Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
IamRa · 17/10/2023 01:12

Photographsandmemories · 16/10/2023 13:19

I'm no fan of Australia, but I do find it funny that a lot of British people here are blithely branding Australia racist / xenophobic.

Pot, kettle...

Indeed. It was the British who colonised Australia. It was the British that called the native population - the First People - fauna. It was the British that then enslaved them, put them in chains, and branded them. It was the British that introduced them to strange illnesses. It was the British that brought alcohol to these shores. It was the British that denied them any opportunity.

It was the British that slaughtered them in genocidal numbers.

And we are a member of the Commonwealth, are we not?

tpxqi · 17/10/2023 00:38

The lack of understanding about the detail and nuances of foreign politics, international relations and economics never ceases to amaze.

All these people commenting about how shocking it is that Aus voted no have made no effort to understand the story and regurgitated and few soundbites to signal their quota of virtues for the day.

BlinkyBulldozer · 17/10/2023 00:35

It’s Dark Emu, just FYI in case anyone wants to Google for it. And many indigenous people have expressed concerns about Pasco’s identity and research. Michael Mansell, for instance, from the Tasmanian Aboriginal Land Council who is no right-winger has said emphatically that Pascoe is a white man co-opting aboriginal identity. There have also been serious scholarly objections to his research and conclusions - not slander - summarised here: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/25/bruce-pascoe-has-welcomed-the-dark-emu-debate-and-so-should-australia

The issue of treaty is also more complicated than you represented. Britain commonly signed treaties with indigenous groups - New Zealand, Canada etc. In Australia, indigenous peoples appeared to the British to be a tiny number without a structured society. We know this to be untrue now but the two cultures - were so hugely different from each other that the British simply didn’t understand what they were encountering. It was also completely different from what the British had encountered with other indigenous peoples in the US or New Zealand that they saw no need to make a treaty. A few decades after colonisation began, they had recognised that they erred. Governor George Arthur called it a fatal mistake.

We need to be able to discuss these issues with nuance not culture war stuff. The voice campaign failed to do that and settled for calling people dickheads and racists instead.

Bruce Pascoe has welcomed the Dark Emu debate – and so should Australia | Mark McKenna

The culture wars make it difficult to see what this moment is: an opportunity to deepen our knowledge of Indigenous people

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/25/bruce-pascoe-has-welcomed-the-dark-emu-debate-and-so-should-australia

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 23:55

Apologies for any typos in my post above, I have a disabling illness that causes amongst other things, vision problems at times.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 23:53

In my opinion there is a lot of racism in Australia: Only 235 years ago Australia was colonised by Britain as a Penal Colony. When the First Fleet arrived in Australia the British govt had decreed this Terra Nullius - which essentially means no person owns it/no person lives there. Complete bullshit of course but that tells us something.

No treaties were ever allowed by the British Government. If there had been a TREATY it would have been recognition that people did live there and were the traditional owners of the land. No treaties meant the British Govt did not have to admit the Truth, that this was land already owned by People, as it turns out a land owned by more than 500 different nations of people for over 60,000 years. Oldest living cultures in the world

The different 500 Nations interacted, they traded. If nomadic (and plenty weren’t - they were farmers and had villages) they would have to seek permission to cross another nation’s land. They warred on each other at times. Different Peoples traded with the countries to the north of Australia. Spain had interacted with the Peoples.

As a matter of fact one reason why Britain chose to colonise Australia was because it wanted a trade route here, and to prevent Spain doing the same.

At any rate British Colonidsation meant that First Nations people were pushed off their lands, dispossessed , massacred, were forced to be free labour, children were stolen, families separated, diseases for which the people had no immunity introduced. Rape also, mixed race children as a result) (hence the beginning of arguments of who is white who is a First Australian leading to removal of children. Devastation. There were wars between three British, the colonials and First Nations People. This has been largely hidden by history deliberately, but we know about the Australia Wars now (Henry Reynolds is the first non Aboriginal historian to write about them,! so you can stsrt there if interested) and Bruce Pascoe (Emu Rising) details farming, fish farming practices, the villages etc.Bruce Pascoe was met with lots of slander and questioning if he was ‘really Aboriginal’ .- this is common, there seems to be a need for People who have successfully beaten the odds to prove their Aboriginslity etc.( that’s racism in another form). More archeological evidence of settled life was uncovered during the huge fires of 2019-2020 when dense bush land burned away - I saw a couple of articles about it.in the news but then nothing more.

Anyway, things continued on in this way until Federation in 1901, where things then continued on this way - same day, different boss. White Australians have proved no better than the British from whom most they are descended. For a second example look how Australia is treating its refugees who come by boat. (And Britain is not clean in this)

It’s been a slow and tortuous route for First Nations People to get recognition in Australia. Yet again, they were denied it on Saturday . I believe they will not ask for a Voice again but, it’s my opinion they will demand Truth and Treaty now. I’ll be there as an ally, as will many millions of Australians who voted yes.

This has irrevocably changed Australia as we know it.

For those arguing which is the most racist country you need to cut it out, and look to evidence of disparities in income, health, education, the legal system etc.. and listen to the people who are experiencing it. Australia’s evidence of equality is not good although people will pick out examples of those who have succeeded despite the odds. Same in the UK.

We are both racists countries. But Australia just exposed itself to the World on Saturday. “Not everyone who voted no is a racist, but every racist voted no” - a singled out selective quote. I truly believe people voted no because they were misinformed, misled and lied to, but I think some also voted no because they are racist.

BUT, not everyone who voted yes is not a racist. Some are. They just don’t recognise how they are racist. It’s something all people of the dominant culture in our societies have to look at and sort out. As quick as we can. Denial gets us nowhere: and causes suffering:

HoppingPavlova · 16/10/2023 23:03

@koalaknickers They didn't seem to be represented in Sydney's CBD area, for instance working or shopping. Perhaps because too many of them had to live in places like this when I was there

???? Well, how many Govnt departments/service centres did you visit in the CBD? The Govnt has a very strong positive recruitment strategy for Indigenous (which is a positive thing, and as it should be), and they are more likely to be working in a Govnt office than a shop. Also they are more likely to be shopping in suburbs where they are concentrated, most of which are quite near the city for work purposes but you would not have to go to the CBD to shop, we do all have shopping malls. Traditionally social housing for Indigenous were concentrated in these areas, and for many it has now become their ‘on country’ situation where they choose to remain due to close family/community ties. If you visited these places you would have seen many Indigenous folk. Your time in the CBD is not at all representative of anything other than that CBD specifically. But sure, sprout your knowledge on that. Seriously.

Olivesmum78 · 16/10/2023 22:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Catsmere · 16/10/2023 21:05

Australia has had 44 referenda and only passed eight. Proposing constitutional change is never popular and the Yes side made a right hash of presenting their argument.

JethroTullandhishorse · 16/10/2023 21:00

Not surprised in the fucking slightest. One more reason to not visit the damn place.

TWmover · 16/10/2023 20:50

I know indigenous people in Australia who were voting no because they felt it was the wrong solution. That those on the government advisory boards/think tanks are completely out of touch with what indigenous communities need and are essentially fatcats spending grants/charging fees. They voted no because they want a community-led approach.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 20:33

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 20:01

Off topic but I found the footage of David Lammy (shadow foreign Secretary) and James Cleverly (Foreign Secretary) and both black, bumping into each other in the Sky Newsroom today and embracing very moving.

I like Lammy. 👍 keeping you off topic when I should be steering you back 😉 x

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 20:01

Off topic but I found the footage of David Lammy (shadow foreign Secretary) and James Cleverly (Foreign Secretary) and both black, bumping into each other in the Sky Newsroom today and embracing very moving.

Theunamedcat · 16/10/2023 16:54

Coveescapee · 16/10/2023 09:41

Interpretation- ignore anything the elites don't like. How unifying that would be. I give up with people like you, so arrogant and ignorant.

Yes because voting no to a minority whose country you took over and whose rights you ignore is the epitome of humble and educated

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 16:27

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2023 16:23

I'm referring to the bizarre haters of their own country (UK). They just like to shit stir. I'm a UK citizen too, but difference is I defend my own country

Criticising your own countries manifest faults, is not "hating" it.

I'm not playing your game. It's too tedious. You know exactly what i mean.

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2023 16:23

I'm referring to the bizarre haters of their own country (UK). They just like to shit stir. I'm a UK citizen too, but difference is I defend my own country

Criticising your own countries manifest faults, is not "hating" it.

SaySomethingMan · 16/10/2023 16:22

obviously those people you’ve mentioned in your examples are mixed race and are going to have completely different experiences to whichever of their parents were fully aboriginal. Why deny the truth in the post you’re responding to?

The positions they hold, they’re very very unlikely to have reached , if they were not mixed race and their outward appearances were immediately reflective of their aboriginal roots.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 16:22

SaySomethingMan · 16/10/2023 16:14

You should never ask people who experience racism to give you evidence of racism, unless you’re a court, police, etc. They should’ve have to be traumatised to appease you.
If you are even slightly, the onus is on you to educate yourself.

The exception to that is when you're dealing with race baiters. The person, whose quote you have responded to, was talking to one such race baiter..

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 16:20

Photographsandmemories · 16/10/2023 15:57

Because people in glass houses really shouldn't throw stones. It makes you look daft.

Better to focus on Britain's own manifold constitutional and democratic problems, you'd think.

It cetainly doesnt make me look daft. I'm referring to the bizarre haters of their own country (UK). They just like to shit stir. I'm a UK citizen too, but difference is I defend my own country, as well as I've defended Australia, on this thread.

SaySomethingMan · 16/10/2023 16:14

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:20

Pleas provide evidence of that word being used in sports shows and on the news.

You should never ask people who experience racism to give you evidence of racism, unless you’re a court, police, etc. They should’ve have to be traumatised to appease you.
If you are even slightly, the onus is on you to educate yourself.

Photographsandmemories · 16/10/2023 15:57

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 14:18

A thread about Australia but there's still plenty bringing the UK into it. Really pathetic the way the UK is always kicked around like a political football. Why do you even need to make a comparison between the two countries?

Because people in glass houses really shouldn't throw stones. It makes you look daft.

Better to focus on Britain's own manifold constitutional and democratic problems, you'd think.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 15:12

ManonDe · 16/10/2023 11:43

Fine. Can you please explain exactly what the referendum was about and what a yes vote would have meant going forwards. What the plan was. How that plan (whatever it was) would be implemented.

Bullet points will suffice.

😜😂pmsl

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 14:38

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 14:26

I was agreeing with @Wonkasworld that it is irrelevant!

Oops sorry, I misread 😊

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 14:26

Oops I mean @Fifireee . I think racism is largely irrelevant to the Voice too.

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 14:26

I was agreeing with @Wonkasworld that it is irrelevant!

Swipe left for the next trending thread