Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
twokidsonedog · 17/10/2023 08:48

What did you see?

hamstersarse · 17/10/2023 08:31

I’d wonder about the precedent you set by giving different rights to ‘Original People’ given all the immigration and frankly, racism that exists.

And I mean precedent, not all Original People stories are the same, but the concept could very much be seen as the same. ‘White privileged’ enshrined in the constitution?

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:26

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 03:13

Some misinformation here corrected.

All Australians are entitled to free health care.

All school kids are entitled to free dental care. After that, dental care is means tested. (If you want free health care as an adult (its means tested), then lobby your govt. fight for it: just don’t say ‘it’s not fair, they get all the benefits I do not’ , someone fought for any benefits Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders get and believe me, they aren’t enough. We pay high taxes, insist your govt stop throwing money away on companies like ‘ Price Waterhouse consultancy’ and reinvest in your public service.

If you are a non Aboriginal Australian with school age kids you can access dental care for them. Some parents know that, many are unaware. Usually the parents who know this have had Dept of Health mobile dental services come to their kids’ schools. Many schools don’t have the mobile dental services come around, but you can access the free service.

Ring the Department of Health Dental services (it may have a different name now, as it’s been a while since I accessed it for my kids a few times when I was broke. And I only found out about them because a parent from another school told me about the free dental. WHAT? I said’ FREE DENTAL - WHAAAT? When I had had some money again, I found it easier, more convenient, to access my local dentist that I paid for). The mobile dental van with its free dental services is coming to my grandchild’s school next month so free dental is still available for children. Insist on it.

Demand better of your govt. & be better informed. Always ask about your rights. It’s something Australians generally tend not to do as we aren’t encouraged to. (Australia wash colonised as a penal colony and that thinking then, that a convict had few rights, has filtered down somewhat inter- generationally Be aware, every single govt representative of yours, both federal and state, knows their rights.

First Nations people do get preference for Educational Systems.. How does it work? One example: In my understanding: eg Two students get 50% in their final exams. Both barely scrapped by, and there’s University One place left. One is an Aboriginal teenager, another is not. The University will take the Aboriginal teenager and not the non Aboriginal teenager. Why so? Because there’s recognition that it’s more likely it’s taken a lot more effort for an Aboriginal Teenager to get that far. They face so many roadblocks. (eg a court is much more likely to sentence an Aboriginal child to a custodial sentence than a white child - for exactly the same crime). But, its not to say the non Aboriginal teenager in the example did not face roadblocks, but that generally, in our society, an Aboriginal teenager is likely to face more roadblocks than a Non Aboriginal teenager. It’s not a perfect solution. It’s up to you to demand better from your govts. Voting every 3 or 4 years helps, but becoming activists in your own lives helps that much more. If nothing else, if something unfair pisses you off,!write an email and send it to your MP and every relevant MP. One of the shiftiest shock jocks ever - Alan Jones - used to do that because, it works. Enough letters on the same topic and the MPs stop ignoring you and others. Don’t be put off by those pithy non answer emails they send back in reply. Write again and Organise people to write. Ring their offices, let them know. Find out when your representatives are in their offices and make an appointment to see them. They work for you.

A Pp poster is right - The book is called ‘Dark Emu’ and not ‘emu rising’ but I always mistakenly call it that. Might be the ‘rising’ bit and a connection to the phrase ‘phoenix rising’ some Aboriginal people do question his Aboriginality, some do not. At any rate his research is good.

There is a documentary on Netflix - it was on our ABC but I think it may have moved to Netflix - called ‘in my blood it runs’ about a 10 year old Aboriginal child growing up in Alice Springs. He’s a great kid but goes perilously close to running off the tracks despite a loving, but impoverished, family. He triumphs but over the course of a couple of years the documentary is filmed over, you start to see all the roadblocks faced by Aboriginal children and their parents.

Not to say many white people people don’t face roadblocks. But for Black , and many Brown and Asian people too, the very colour of their skin is a roadblock in our society. Preconceptions abound. Preconceptions abound for poor people, single parent families, disabled people, abused women and their kids, and so on.

Recognise though, that that Original People, the First Australians, are the ones whose lands were colonised. We to come here or most of our ancestors wanted to come here. First Nations People - they are owed a chance to improve their lives. They are owed a debt. (Despite the popular bullshit, theybaren’t asking for handouts.). On average, First Nations people are still living at levels of Great Depression Era Poverty. And they are amongst the most roadblocked people in the world. We should not get to take nearly everything of theirs and then say ‘okay, now we are all equal.’

Recognise though, that that Original People, the First Australians, are the ones whose lands were colonised. We to come here or most of our ancestors wanted to come here. First Nations People - they are owed a chance to improve their lives. They are owed a debt. (Despite the popular bullshit, they aren’t asking for handouts.). On average, First Nations people are still living at levels of Great Depression Era Poverty. And they are amongst the most roadblocked people in the world. We should not get to take nearly everything of theirs and then say ‘okay, now we are all equal.’

Yes, I believe they are owed a debt.

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:17

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 03:31

I see, so a thread about something which has taken place in Australia is allowed to be commented on by a bunch of people in the UK, who haven't the faintest idea of what was actually happening, and they are throwing "racist" insults about Australia all around the place, but no-one is allowed to point out that the utopia which supposedly the UK is can be just as racist. Thanks for enlightening me.

This is very topical at the moment. All over the news.

But I would welcome a thread about racism in the UK.

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

The majority of people who identify as Aboriginals are whiter than me

Perhaps I should amend my post to say that I didn't see anyone who looked obviously Aboriginal.

I am sure those who are very white must experience less racism as a result. I have white nieces and nephews and a mixed race Islander niece. All born and bred in Oz. They tell me their very different experiences of life.

My brother who is white lives with Aboriginals and tried to get one of his young friends a job and the boss gave him a mouthful of abuse full of racial slurs for suggesting such a thing. My brother had an Aboriginal girlfriend for years and being with her he saw how she could be treated. Also, by extension, he was often shunned by people because he was with her.

I know this is all anecdotal, but when you hear lots of stories like this it does make an impression.

OP posts:
Wonkasworld · 17/10/2023 07:39

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 03:31

I see, so a thread about something which has taken place in Australia is allowed to be commented on by a bunch of people in the UK, who haven't the faintest idea of what was actually happening, and they are throwing "racist" insults about Australia all around the place, but no-one is allowed to point out that the utopia which supposedly the UK is can be just as racist. Thanks for enlightening me.

It is the virtue signallers from the UK, bringing the UK into it. I've said that throughout the thread. It's not necessary. Once again, I have defended Australia. These people thrive on division and do nothing but stir up trouble. As your post suggests, it's worked.

Mystro202 · 17/10/2023 06:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

5YearsLeft · 17/10/2023 05:37

I’m sorry I haven’t read the entire thread but OP asked if they were U to be “shocked.” I voted YABU, simply because in the entire history of Australia, no referendum has ever passed without bipartisan support. This referendum didn’t have bipartisan support, and it didn’t pass. It shouldn’t shock anyone who has studied Australian politics. There are nations that have referendums practically every other Tuesday as part of their political system (like Switzerland). But this is the first referendum Australia has had in 25 years and they rejected the last one too (no bipartisan support). They have only passed 44 referendums since 1901.

The last one they rejected was about Australia becoming a republic, another referendum that would have had long historical effects. I suspect the issue may have been that people who voted “no” were against adding anything to their constitution, probably affected by the “no” campaign’s “whataboutery” that if they started adding things to a 122-year old document, what about when X group wants to be in the constitution? And Y group? I’m not saying that’s a fair argument at all (the group asking for this change has been there LONGER than the constitution), but it can be effective in swaying a lot of on-the-fence or even slightly conservative voters.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 05:32

“Please read the official information that Australians had access to before voting in the voice referendum, and you will have a better understanding of why people voted the way they did.
**
Yes, of course there would have been an element of racism. However, racism wasn’t the only reason why people chose to vote no.”

Just to add to this pp link about AEC info: Please note the AEC information provided
by both yes and no campaigns was not fact checked. (I’ve NRFT so apologies if this info is being repeated)

The AEC do not fact check info they send out for a referendum. I know, my head still hasn’t stopped spinning from this revelation.

There are now calls for fact checking to be legislated.

The Guardian fact checked both - and they yes side was correct in information, and no side had misleading information and was therefore incorrect. The AEC have acknowledged it was not fact checked.

So, this AEC pamphlet comes to peoples’ homes. People read it; and believe it all and, misinformed, then vote according to what they’ve read.

Misinformation was absolutely rife but the AEC form was not the only source of misinformation. We had misleading politicians, misleading media, and the thing many of us are going to read the most - social media - plenty of misinformation on social media:

https://www.aec.gov.au/referendums/files/pamphlet/your-official-yes-no-referendum-pamphlet.pdf?=v1.0
https://www.aec.gov.au/referendums/files/pamphlet/your-official-yes-no-referendum-pamphlet.pdf?=

https://www.aec.gov.au/referendums/files/pamphlet/your-official-yes-no-referendum-pamphlet.pdf?=v1.0

user1492757084 · 17/10/2023 05:19

I've been listening to lots of talk back radio and it is certainly true that some people who voted NO were definitely not racist and were actual Aboriginals themselves and the largest populations who voted YES came from the inner city areas of the largest cities.
There were two parts to the referendum put up ..

  • an acknowledgement of first peoples and
  • a VOICE to advise Parliament and committees.

It has been interesting to hear the many reasons why people voted Yes or NO.
Some remote Aboriginal areas voted 75% YES, other Aboriginal regions voted NO though I suspect that the over all the Aboriginal vote was YES. There were respected Aboriginal people leading both sides.
NO voters gave their many reasons, some ..
not enough detail, they did not approve of a racial difference in the Constituation set for all time but prefer each Australian to be equal under the Constitution, the poor performance of similar VOICES ie ATSIC (which became corrupt with some Aboriginal leaders taking advantage of others), a need for the bulk of money to support better specific problems and actual outcomes rather than setting up a beaurocracy, not feeling like a VOICE set up in Canberra would accurately represent the Aboriginals in regions and many other reasons.

Aboriginal Australia is made up of hundreds of tribes not just one. Every area has unique circumstances.

YES voters were obviously disappointed (and many NO voters) as the whole ordeal has been challenging and quite divisive.
Ultimately the YES voters thought the inclusion of the extra words were the right way and the NO voters thought the chosen words should have been different.
Over all the result was about a 40% - 60% split.

Powerful Aboriginal leaders who expressed views were Jacinta Price, Warren Mundine, Linda Burney, Marcia Langton, Lidia Thorpe and others - all of whom are deeply respected and include Parliamentarians and schollars of note.
It is a very complex issue.

I think it likely that a simplified change to the Constitution could have succeeded - one that acknowledged the fact that Australia, though written as being Terra Nullius, was, as noted by written records of those who came in ships, occupied by dark skinned people who, it transpired, were members of many neighbouring tribes and who had been living sustainably on their land for thousands and thousands of years.
To acknowledge the truth that because the people seemed primitive they were dismissed as occupants and that violence between settlers and the Aboriginals (and huge deaths by transmissable diseases) resulted in the demise of the many peoples, cultures and languages with whom no treaties were made.
New Australians prevailed - over took the ancient cultures - to form the Australia of today. To acknowledge the survival of fragments of the oldest culture and the oldest peoples and to support conservation of language and ancient artworks, culture and preservation of the health and well being of the people would have, I think, been voted in a clear YES.

There are many marginalised groups in Australia, not all being Aboriginal of course. So to entrench a VOICE to Parliament in the Constitution would have set a racial division that some voters did not think right.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 04:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

user1477391263 · 17/10/2023 03:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

The whole “aboriginal people can be white too” hints at one of the problems to me.

I mean….bluntly? If someone does not “look” Aboriginal and did not grow up on a protected area or similarly disadvantaged place, it’s hard to see how the fact that they are [insert percentage here] Aboriginal or whatever is supposed to be a disadvantage or source of discrimination for them. And if that is the case, any sort of legal change that could potentially bring advantages to them becomes highly dubious - it can all start to look like a way for the more sharp-elbowed, good-at-working-the-system type of white person to gain special status for themselves.

I don’t know enough about this particular piece of legislation to know how I would have voted. But stuff like this makes me suspect that it’s a bit more complex than “IF YOU VOTED NO YOU ARE RAY-SISSED” etc.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/10/2023 03:53

FWIW I do think that this referendum and the proposed changes to the constitution were not adequately discussed in a rational, factual, straightforward or informative way.

There seemed to be a lot of heated emotional arguments, misinformation and scaremongering.

It was an important referendum that needed the facts to be presented in an unbiased way in order to fully inform the people.

People cannot be expected to make good decisions when they are misinformed and manipulated.

People will lack trust if they feel that important details are withheld.

And lastly, most people are either reluctant to embrace change or struggle with it in one way or another. Introducing change needs to be done right or it will be rejected and fail.

IamRa · 17/10/2023 03:43

I did find this though. Try and guess when this was published. (Apologies for its formatting.)

THE FUTURE OF THE ABORIGINES.
Of late years little has been done to
ameliorate the condition of the abori-
gines, and although I believe that
between the years xxxx and xxxx
large sums of money were expended in
protectorates in New South Wales, very
little good was effected. That our
present position with reference to the
original owners of this colony is not
an equitable one is beyond dispute.
We have taken from them a country
where, after their own fashion, they
were contented and happy ; and, in
return, we have bestowed on them a
civilisation which destroys them. I
do not say that this could altogether
have been avoided, for experience
everywhere proves that races in a
state of savagery, and even those races
which have passed from savagery to
barbarism, are unable to withstand the
advance of European civilization.
It is a very difficult matter to sug-
gest measures that would effectually
improve their condition.
Five or six protectors might be ap-
pointed throughout the colony, care
being taken that the positions were
filled by men who understood the
characters of their charges and took an
interest in the welfares of those whom
they were appointed to protect.
Depots could be established in
different localities from which food
and clothing could be obtained in
reasonable quantities. For this pur-
pose the different police stations could
be used.

IamRa · 17/10/2023 03:41

BlinkyBulldozer · 17/10/2023 01:30

Aboriginal Australians were never classified as fauna. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flora_and_Fauna_Act_myth

Thank you for correcting me there. I thought I'd read it in an old newspaper - perhaps thankfully not!

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/10/2023 03:41

To clarify, the above link is the official pamphlet representing both the yes and no vote. It was available at the polling venues for anyone who hadn’t already done their research previously or who were still undecided.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/10/2023 03:38

I haven’t RTFT so, apologies if this has already linked.

Please read the official information that Australians had access to before voting in the voice referendum, and you will have a better understanding of why people voted the way they did.

Yes, of course there would have been an element of racism. However, racism wasn’t the only reason why people chose to vote no.

https://www.aec.gov.au/referendums/files/pamphlet/your-official-yes-no-referendum-pamphlet.pdf?=v1.0

https://www.aec.gov.au/referendums/files/pamphlet/your-official-yes-no-referendum-pamphlet.pdf?=v1.0

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 03:31

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 14:18

A thread about Australia but there's still plenty bringing the UK into it. Really pathetic the way the UK is always kicked around like a political football. Why do you even need to make a comparison between the two countries?

I see, so a thread about something which has taken place in Australia is allowed to be commented on by a bunch of people in the UK, who haven't the faintest idea of what was actually happening, and they are throwing "racist" insults about Australia all around the place, but no-one is allowed to point out that the utopia which supposedly the UK is can be just as racist. Thanks for enlightening me.

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 03:14

wandawaves · 16/10/2023 10:32

I was there 20 years ago and visited Sydney and Perth and did not see one indigenous person my whole time there.

Umm... ok? What's your point?
Also... what does an Indigenous Australian look like? Seems you're doing a bit of racist stereotyping there yourself.

Well said!! Does that poster imagine that Indigenous Australians go around with a sign on their foreheads? Because if they don't I would like to know how they "did not see one", how would they actually know?

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 03:13

Some misinformation here corrected.

All Australians are entitled to free health care.

All school kids are entitled to free dental care. After that, dental care is means tested. (If you want free health care as an adult (its means tested), then lobby your govt. fight for it: just don’t say ‘it’s not fair, they get all the benefits I do not’ , someone fought for any benefits Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders get and believe me, they aren’t enough. We pay high taxes, insist your govt stop throwing money away on companies like ‘ Price Waterhouse consultancy’ and reinvest in your public service.

If you are a non Aboriginal Australian with school age kids you can access dental care for them. Some parents know that, many are unaware. Usually the parents who know this have had Dept of Health mobile dental services come to their kids’ schools. Many schools don’t have the mobile dental services come around, but you can access the free service.

Ring the Department of Health Dental services (it may have a different name now, as it’s been a while since I accessed it for my kids a few times when I was broke. And I only found out about them because a parent from another school told me about the free dental. WHAT? I said’ FREE DENTAL - WHAAAT? When I had had some money again, I found it easier, more convenient, to access my local dentist that I paid for). The mobile dental van with its free dental services is coming to my grandchild’s school next month so free dental is still available for children. Insist on it.

Demand better of your govt. & be better informed. Always ask about your rights. It’s something Australians generally tend not to do as we aren’t encouraged to. (Australia wash colonised as a penal colony and that thinking then, that a convict had few rights, has filtered down somewhat inter- generationally Be aware, every single govt representative of yours, both federal and state, knows their rights.

First Nations people do get preference for Educational Systems.. How does it work? One example: In my understanding: eg Two students get 50% in their final exams. Both barely scrapped by, and there’s University One place left. One is an Aboriginal teenager, another is not. The University will take the Aboriginal teenager and not the non Aboriginal teenager. Why so? Because there’s recognition that it’s more likely it’s taken a lot more effort for an Aboriginal Teenager to get that far. They face so many roadblocks. (eg a court is much more likely to sentence an Aboriginal child to a custodial sentence than a white child - for exactly the same crime). But, its not to say the non Aboriginal teenager in the example did not face roadblocks, but that generally, in our society, an Aboriginal teenager is likely to face more roadblocks than a Non Aboriginal teenager. It’s not a perfect solution. It’s up to you to demand better from your govts. Voting every 3 or 4 years helps, but becoming activists in your own lives helps that much more. If nothing else, if something unfair pisses you off,!write an email and send it to your MP and every relevant MP. One of the shiftiest shock jocks ever - Alan Jones - used to do that because, it works. Enough letters on the same topic and the MPs stop ignoring you and others. Don’t be put off by those pithy non answer emails they send back in reply. Write again and Organise people to write. Ring their offices, let them know. Find out when your representatives are in their offices and make an appointment to see them. They work for you.

A Pp poster is right - The book is called ‘Dark Emu’ and not ‘emu rising’ but I always mistakenly call it that. Might be the ‘rising’ bit and a connection to the phrase ‘phoenix rising’ some Aboriginal people do question his Aboriginality, some do not. At any rate his research is good.

There is a documentary on Netflix - it was on our ABC but I think it may have moved to Netflix - called ‘in my blood it runs’ about a 10 year old Aboriginal child growing up in Alice Springs. He’s a great kid but goes perilously close to running off the tracks despite a loving, but impoverished, family. He triumphs but over the course of a couple of years the documentary is filmed over, you start to see all the roadblocks faced by Aboriginal children and their parents.

Not to say many white people people don’t face roadblocks. But for Black , and many Brown and Asian people too, the very colour of their skin is a roadblock in our society. Preconceptions abound. Preconceptions abound for poor people, single parent families, disabled people, abused women and their kids, and so on.

Recognise though, that that Original People, the First Australians, are the ones whose lands were colonised. We to come here or most of our ancestors wanted to come here. First Nations People - they are owed a chance to improve their lives. They are owed a debt. (Despite the popular bullshit, theybaren’t asking for handouts.). On average, First Nations people are still living at levels of Great Depression Era Poverty. And they are amongst the most roadblocked people in the world. We should not get to take nearly everything of theirs and then say ‘okay, now we are all equal.’

RantyAnty · 17/10/2023 02:49

I wasn't surprised. Australia is racist and openly so.

I did vote yes, not that it matters now.

This was big for Albo as he campaigned on the promise for first nation, but of course racist Aussies let everyone down.

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 02:08

HunkyRory · 16/10/2023 09:30

I saw this and it apparently failed due to the poor way it was presented with little facts or information for voters to make a decision. The failure for this is not on the voters as I saw that indigenous citizens also criticised the terrible campaign

It wasn't just "presented" poorly. That would imply the policy was well crafted but poorly explained.

You cannot handwave constitutional structures. Maintaining an effective democratic structure is not a game. The idea that anyone would vote for a poorly crafted amendment because they are worried that it is racist not to is so fucking crazy I don't know what to say.

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 01:59

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

They wanted people to vote for a constitutional change - this is a big deal OP, you can't just switch it off - without giving any significant details about how the proposal would actually work.

Just because a proposal seems like the sort of nice thing to do doesn't mean it would be good law or policy. It would be crazy to vote to make something a constitutional obligation without a clear idea of what it would entail. This approach has produced some incredibly shit laws, in a number of countries, in the last 10 or 15 years.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 01:55

South Australia /Treaty /“Fatal Error”

“What is the history of Treaty in South Australia?
**
No formal treaty has ever been signed between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and the British or Australian governments. It could have been different in South Australia.

In 1832, George Arthur, the Governor of Van Diemen’s’ Land (now Tasmania) noted that it was ‘a fatal error ... that a treaty was not entered into with the natives’ in the colony.

Arthur recommended a treaty be signed before a colony was set up in South Australia.”
**
“ Unlike other areas of Australia, British colonisation of the area that is now known as South Australia was meticulously planned. The South Australia Act 1834 legislated for the establishment of a settlement in South Australia. In 1836, Letters Patent establishing the Province of South Australia were issued. Significantly, the Letters Patent included recognition of the rights of the ‘Aboriginal Natives’ to live within the lands of the new Province.

‘Provided Always that nothing in those our Letters Patent contained shall affect or be construed to affect the rights of any Aboriginal Natives of the said Province to the actual occupation or enjoyment in their own Persons or in the Persons of their Descendants of any Lands therein now actually occupied or enjoyed by such Natives.’

Despite the existence of the Letters Patent, the rights of Aboriginal people were ignored. Like the rest of the continent, no treaties were signed.

We are talking now 1836 - ‘settlement’ SA, 48 years after colonisation of the east coast of Australia. A bit more than a few decades.

The argument that the existing culture was unrecognisable to the British in 1788 holds some weight, imo. But nearly 50 years later, I think it should well and truly have been ‘recognisable’ by then. No Treaty at any point.

The Voice Campaign included people like, Constitutional Lawyer Megan Davies, Noel Pearson, Aunty Pat Dodson and many more. MP Julian Leeser - who was Shadow Minister for the Indigenous Peoples, resigned his shadow minister to campaign for yes. These people, and so many others, was not part of a ‘yes campaign calling others ‘dickheads and racists’. ‘

it did happen of course as the yes campaign had official and unofficial campaigners. Just like some of the ‘no campaign’ threw around words like ‘woke - (appropriated and used disparagingly) bleeding hearts and ‘elites’, and ‘culture warriors’ etc..

Basically, what Australian govt been doing for decades to improve the lives of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders has not worked. Only 4 of the 19 close the gap initiatives have shown success. This was an attempt to try something new.

The Close the Gap initiatives cost a lot of money. But most of benefits of that is supposed to accrue from money never reaches the people that it’s supposed to. They receive only minimum or no benefit from it, minimum or no improved services / health education - housing etc etc.. Most of the money goes to consultancy firms, business organisations that deliver programs etc etc., who are, generally, not First Nations People.

This was an attempt to change that. By giving a Voice to Parliament - an advisory board of First Nations People - non legislative - no power - simply advising the govt on how to more effectively spend the money, in regard to their own people only.

. South Australia /Treaty /“ Fatal Error”

https://antar.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Treaty-in-SA-Factsheet.pdf

twokidsonedog · 17/10/2023 01:50

it was a constructional amendment- in Australia, this needs to be done by referendum.