Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

My opinions are based on facts and experiences

No they're not. They're just your opinions. You have opinions I find offensive to poc. I shall continue to answer them if you continue to make them.

But you don't seem to appreciate it when it is you being challenged.

You've not challenged anything I've said about this vote or Australia, just my responses about your posts on indigenous people being offensive. All you've done, repeatedly, is reiterate your opinions are facts, which they're not.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 11:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:15

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 12:56

I’m Not reading any further or I’ll end up tearing my hair out in frustration.

The acknowledgement of First Nations Peoples as the First Australians could not be legislated. It’s a constitutional matter, a changing of the constitution. This demands a referendum. Australia is the only former British colony that does not acknowledge it’s First Peoples.

I’d like to say here that referendums in Australia do not have the same rules as referendums in the UK.

  1. legislating a Voice to Parliament - could be done. But the following govt, any following govt, could dismantle it if it wanted to. There would be nothing to stop dismantling it - which is exactly what we’ve seen happen at least 7 times now by successive governments. The voice needed to be entered into the constiution - (therefore necessitating a referendum) so it would always be there. Once it had got a yes vote, it would have gone to Parliament to be legislated; and been batted around by the two houses until a suitable form for it was agreed upon by both houses. Then, the form of the Voice could be changed by legislation, but the Voice itself, a non legislative body to parliament to advise government on matters pertaining to only Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People always had to exist. The, form itself could be changed. It would have no legislative power and could only advise on things pertaining to First Nations people.

Instead, we will go in as we have before, massive amounts of money spent trying to close the gap between living standards and life spans. eg A First Nations child, on average, will not live as long as the child she is sitting next to in school. I believe the life span gap is at least 8 years. At any rate, it’s too great and not getting smaller. This is terrible. Shameful. Heartbreaking.

I’d just like to add, As the votes come in we are seeing that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait islanders who live in the remote areas have voted overwhelmingly in favour of the Voice. This contradicts the ‘no’ campaign, which misinformed the country and said the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples did not want the Voice - At least Two opposition MPs were very vocal about this. (btw, the oppositions Shadow Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs resigned from his ministry because he did not agree with the way his own party was going. He’s a leading proponent of the yes campaign.

Now, very disturbingly, we have those two MPs, the ones who were very vocal about the First People not wanting the Voice saying that the voting system in these remote communities were not adhered to/interfered with (I think they are trying to say voters were coerced. They are casting doubt on the Australian Electorial Sustem. Who does that remind you of? It’s very Trump -Ian. And bullshit. Up until these figures started returning there was no questioning of our voting system by them. Btw, it’s an excellent system /never been questioned before.

This is the new world we’ve entered where lying is winning, and fuck truth and honesty.

It looks as though, wevare starting to see the Brexit Version of ‘buyers remorse’ - it’s been reported that a number of ‘no voters’ have posted on social media complaining of being lied to and regretting voting no. We shall see.

Please remember that many millions of Australians voted yes. They chose to believe what they were told by the First Nations Voice leaders - that more than 80% of First Nations People wanted the Voice:. This was also confirmed by numerous polls.. It’s looking like that was exactly correct.

Why did ‘no’ win? Partly Because of lies and misinformation - the media had not corrected during the campaign btw - although they have started writing and talking about it now - please note that Murdoch’s media controls about 70 percent of news media in Australia, and that he was not supporting constitutional acknowledgement nor the Voice.

Why else didn’t the referendum pass?

Also because there has not been a referendum passed in Aus that did not have bipartisan support of the two major parties. And at the beginning of all this, there was every indication that it would be bipartisan. It was the Opposition party that had, when in government, asked the First Nations people to design a form
of advisory body that became the Voice.

When the new govt was elected, this was one of the platforms on which they ran - a promise to hold this referendum. And things were looking pretty good. There was majority support for Yhe Voice until April this year. But you see it drop away from April on.

What happened in April? The opposition saw a political opportunity to increase their abysmal popularity numbers. The Leader of the Opposition, Peter Dutton’s popularity rating was in the 20 - 30 percent range. Extremely low. In April Dutton and his fellow MPs politicised the Voice and ceased any support for it, and started arguing against it. At first he said ‘no’ to both parts of the referendum question, but then, realising that Australians weren’t responding overly much to this, he changed tack a little and proposed that when in government he would hold a referendum to acknowledge First Nations People in the Constitution - (a referendum for the first part of the question). Many Australians were more happy with that, but also many were not, and wanted to see First Nations people get the non legislative Voice that had been requested by the former PM of the Previous government of which Peter Dutton had been a prominent member. Minister for Defence at one point. Minister for something else at another: He’s been a pollie or trying to be one, all his working life: He held important ministries.

Since April much misinformation and many lies went unchallenged by media, it was overwhelming. And on Saturday the majority of Australians voted no.

But many millions voted yes. We are divided.

To top this off Peter Dutton has already walked back his promise he made, for the last 5 or so months, to hold a referendum to acknowledge The First Nations People on the constitution when (if) he wins government. There will be now be no referendum should he win office.

This has divided the nation. I’ve seen nothing like it in Australia in my lifetime. I’m nearer 70 than 60. Historically, the WW1 years saw something that was perhaps as equally divisive. I’ve never lived through a time like this in Australia.

Take this away: if it had been a bipartisan agreement all along then it would have very likely have gotten through. And we had little reason, no reason really, to believe it wouldn’t be bipartisan when the process began about 5 years ago - I’m a bit hazy on that timing but it was many years, and a different government (the party that is now in opposition) . In April of this year it changed its mind / 180. I do think it’s going to backfire on the opposition and their leader Dutton, but the damage it’s caused? Where to begin?

I thought this excellent post needed highlighting again for those that are confused.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

No your rudeness about my 'abilities' offended me, and your comments on the skin colour of indigenous people and views with what they would have experienced based on that. You can challenge me all you like, but you said I should scroll on by, that you had the ability to do so but then keep responding to me. make up your mind. You have not just provided facts on this thread at all, but your own opinions on the life experiences of indigenous people and then you've questioned why they should be owed anything after all that has been done to them. As I said, you represent a lot of what is wrong with Australia to me, ignorance and a lack of concern for what colonisation did to the people whose land you inhabit.

taybert · 17/10/2023 11:08

I have to say, in my reading on this (which has been fairly brief, but still) I have been unable to discern what they are actually voting on. “An indigenous voice” great- how does it actually work? I sincerely hoped that the Australian reporting of it would give some clarity on what it actually meant and that the reports I was reading in the British news were short on detail because it wasn’t a British issue. But actually it sounds like that was also the case in Australia too and that there wasn’t really any detail.

It’s easy to say aren’t they racist and isn’t it awful and it might be true, but you can’t expect people to vote to change their constitution without being sure what that means. What if it was all just tokenism anyway and it meant very little- if the indigenous people have a “voice” that no one listens to and which has no power then it can be used a smokescreen, people might feel enough has been done, it could actually prevent progress on the issue.

It sounds like it’s been handled terribly to be honest.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 11:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Bubblesoffun · 17/10/2023 11:02

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:49

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

@Rudderneck why does the OP have to take those types of comments as the correct or accurate ones though, have you read the posts by @ALittleTeawithmilk ?

it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democratic principles.

So do British people think that us having greater rights in our own country or being recognised as British people is a bad thing too? What is the big deal with recognising that indigenous people exist and having that being reflected in a constitution?

The issue was not about constitutional recognition. Everyone I know including those who voted no all agree that constitutional recognition should happen. The issue was with the poorly thought out question with little to no detail on how it would all work. with even the First Nations People divided it was never going to work.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:49

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

@Rudderneck why does the OP have to take those types of comments as the correct or accurate ones though, have you read the posts by @ALittleTeawithmilk ?

it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democratic principles.

So do British people think that us having greater rights in our own country or being recognised as British people is a bad thing too? What is the big deal with recognising that indigenous people exist and having that being reflected in a constitution?

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 10:44

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

It seems to be all about some kind of performative element to you, which you think will somehow help people.

If you look at indigenous populations in countries around the world, you often do see the same two types of approaches. One is something like a reservation approach, where the government is responsible for supporting people. This was often an earlier approach, at a time when it was thought people might carry on living a traditional lifestyle.

Of course time marches on, so no one does live a wholly traditional lifestyle anymore than European-descent people do. But what became clear pretty much anywhere this was tried was that it was very bad for communities. There were a number of things that could influence that, like location and resources, but part of it seems to be that supporting any capable, adult population through the state has detrimental effects.

Which has tended to produce people who think integration might be a better approach. This too has had some serious failures but often because it was conceptualized as requiring a loss of culture.

There are a lot of complicated questions involved in how to approach these things, and it's not at all clear that the idea that giving people special government support will actually be better for them, or that constitutionalizing racial groups is a good idea - it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democatic principles.

That there are problems in aboriginal communities, that there is racism, does not wipe out those kinds of concerns, you have to actually address them.

HoppingPavlova · 17/10/2023 10:35

I was staying in Maroubra with family. As I am sure you know Maroubra is an Aboriginal word

well, yes, you won’t find a decent Indigenous concentration around Maroubra. You would in other suburbs though, where house prices are, on average, as high as or considerably higher than Maroubra. Still no idea of your point - you didn’t see anyone who looked, to you, Indigenous, while you went shopping in Maroubra (and potentially right in CBD as from your post I can’t tell whether you went there or just Maroubra). So what? You seem to be making out they have all been banished from society, whereas if you went to some other suburbs that are as close to CBD as Maroubra is, you would have seen plenty of Indigenous folk, many of whom would have even looked, to you, obviously Indigenous. Again, your point here is what?

If you actually look at stats, instead of basing everything on a stay in Maroubra, you would know that there is a higher density of Indigenous in cities/metro than there is in rural/remote. They just face very different issues, which was part of the problem with the Voice, with those from rural/remote areas questioning whether they would be represented by city based leaders and whose Voice would be heard? Unfortunately it was all things like this where the government came back with ‘no detail on this but vote for it and we’ll just sort it out later’. That’s not a popular response.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I thought you had the ability to just scroll on by? If you're going to write the stuff you have, not actual facts most of it btw, then expect to be challenged on it. Scroll by if you don't like being challenged. I think your posts about aboriginal people are incredibly offensive and ignorant.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 10:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

IamRa · 17/10/2023 10:30

@Olivesmum78

Why are they owed a debt?

Aboriginals who live in remote areas have a very different lifestyle to those who do not live in remote areas. All people who live in remote areas of Australia are at a huge disadvantage, not just Aboriginals.

Are you Australian? Your language leads me to think you're not.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

where have I said I don't accept you can have a different opinion? Don;t be rude to me. I could be a LOT ruder to you and the disgusting things you've written. I have 'the ability' to read what you've written and respond as I wish to. You're entitled to write what you want, and I am entitled to respond to it. Just because its your opinion, doesn't mean people can't disagree with it, thats how a forum works. I think your opinion typifies the problems in Australia, and the way you've written about mixed race people and their colour shows your extreme ignorance of the experiences of mixed race people in colonies like Australia.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 10:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 09:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Why are they owed a debt?

because they were colonised! including having their children taken! Honestly your contributions to this thread are really offensive.

Thanks again to @ALittleTeawithmilk for all the information you're providing and corrections you're making. This thread is awful and shows what indigenous people are up against.

EveryKneeShallBow · 17/10/2023 09:32

Rousblouse · 16/10/2023 08:38

I saw that and I think it was a travesty holding a referendum like that if it didn’t have popular support. Imagine being an aboriginal waking up in Australia after that result. It is horrible. I live in Ireland and if we had a referendum on traveller’s rights we might get the same outcome for example and further alienate an already massively alienated section of our population.

This sort of thing needs to be done in the legislature not by popular vote.

Exactly this.

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 09:25

The following is from a free site, but you need to register. I have picked out parts rather than paste a big wall of text:

The 'Aboriginal Problem'
After colonisation, it was commonly thought that First Nations people in Australia would inevitably die out. However, the growing number of people of mixed race (at that time referred to by the derogatory term ‘half-cast’) soon made it clear that the ‘Aboriginal problem’ wasn’t going to disappear.

The government’s solution was to discontinue its policy of protection, which separated First Nations people from white society by placing First Nations people on reserves and missions, and to instead adopt an assimilation approach. Assimilation policies proposed that ‘full-blood’ First Nations people should be allowed to ‘die out’ through a process of natural elimination, while people of mixed race were encouraged to assimilate into the white community.

During the assimilation era, many First Nations people were forced to leave reserves, which were often reclaimed by governments for housing and mining. Although life on the reserves was oppressive, it was also difficult for First Nations people to find work in the towns and cities due to the prevalent racism in wider society. First Nations people were often refused access to community venues and services, including hospitals and swimming pools. As a result, rather than being assimilated, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people were often forced to live in poverty on the fringes of town

Stolen children
Assimilation policies focused primarily on children, who were considered more adaptable to white society than adults. Consequently, one of the main features of the assimilation era was the forcible removal of First Nations children from their families.

Between 1910 and the early 1970s, generations of First Nations children were removed under these policies, and have become known as the Stolen Generations. Children of mixed race were particularly vulnerable to removal, as it was thought they could be more easily assimilated into the white community due to their lighter skin colour. The policies of child removal left a legacy of trauma and loss that continues to affect First Nations communities, families and individuals

Contradictory logic
Assimilation, including child removal policies, failed its aim of improving the life of First Nations people. One of the main reasons for this was the contradictory logic behind assimilation – it expected First Nations people to take responsibility for becoming the same as white people, yet never gave First Nations people the same rights or opportunities to do so.

Regardless of their efforts, First Nations people weren’t accepted as equals in society, and were still considered an inferior race. This essential belief in the inferiority of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and cultures undermined the objectives of assimilation policy and led to its failure.

The devastating impact of assimilation policies on families and cultures continue to affect First Nations communities today.

Careers Page | Australians Together

Careers Page | Australians Together

Join our team and make a difference in the lives of Indigenous peoples in Australia by working with Australianstogether.org.au. Explore career opportunities and apply today to be a part of our mission to promote understanding and support for Indigenous...

https://australianstogether.org.au/about-us/careers/

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 09:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I think that because their land was taken from them, their children (The Stolen Generation), they were placed in chains and used as slave labour to build the railways, they were promised pay they never received, their cherished spiritual sites that held great meaning for them were built over, the White Australia Policy which only stopped in 1973, their families, community and whole way of life were torn apart, even today their life expectancy is a lot lower than non-Indigenous people,

OP posts:
Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 09:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 09:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

DanceMumTaxi · 17/10/2023 09:05

I’m not at all surprised by this outcome, but it is very sad. I was very shocked when I visited Australia to learn how some people speak about and see aboriginal people. This was a very stark contrast to how neighbouring New Zealand view their Māori heritage.

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:57

I know from my brother's experiences living in Aboriginal communities, that there is a great lack of trust towards many white people and authority figures. That doesn't surprise me.

OP posts:
OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:48

HoppingPavlova · 16/10/2023 23:03

@koalaknickers They didn't seem to be represented in Sydney's CBD area, for instance working or shopping. Perhaps because too many of them had to live in places like this when I was there

???? Well, how many Govnt departments/service centres did you visit in the CBD? The Govnt has a very strong positive recruitment strategy for Indigenous (which is a positive thing, and as it should be), and they are more likely to be working in a Govnt office than a shop. Also they are more likely to be shopping in suburbs where they are concentrated, most of which are quite near the city for work purposes but you would not have to go to the CBD to shop, we do all have shopping malls. Traditionally social housing for Indigenous were concentrated in these areas, and for many it has now become their ‘on country’ situation where they choose to remain due to close family/community ties. If you visited these places you would have seen many Indigenous folk. Your time in the CBD is not at all representative of anything other than that CBD specifically. But sure, sprout your knowledge on that. Seriously.

I was staying in Maroubra with family. As I am sure you know Maroubra is an Aboriginal word.

Traditionally, Aboriginals did live in what is now called Sydney, until they were displaced. Now they have social housing which is often unfit habitation.

I know the past cannot be undone, but the Aboriginals are living where they are allowed to live, not where they would have traditionally lived.

"Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples living in social housing face common social housing challenges of low income, higher incidence of mental health issues and poorer health along with specific challenges due to the impacts of colonisation and its ongoing manifestations in racism and inequity. "

Social and emotional wellbeing of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in Aboriginal controlled social housing | BMC Public Health | Full Text (biomedcentral.com)

Social and emotional wellbeing of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in Aboriginal controlled social housing - BMC Public Health

Background Little is known about the wellbeing and aspirations of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples living in social housing. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples living in social housing face common social housing challenges of lo...

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-023-16817-y

OP posts: