Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 17:40

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:49

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

@Rudderneck why does the OP have to take those types of comments as the correct or accurate ones though, have you read the posts by @ALittleTeawithmilk ?

it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democratic principles.

So do British people think that us having greater rights in our own country or being recognised as British people is a bad thing too? What is the big deal with recognising that indigenous people exist and having that being reflected in a constitution?

The OP asked why people would vote this way, and many people have pointed out that there are serious issues, from a law and constitutional POV, that might make people disinclined to have voted yes.

If the OP simply intended to dismiss those answers there was zero point in posting.

Your comment really is an excellent example of what those concerns entail, it was not just a vote about "recognizing" indigenous people, it was potentially about changing the constitutional basis of lawmaking in the country. That's a serious thing, and whether it will even achieve the desired effect will depend on how it is implemented. Mistakes on this kind of thing can destabilize whole governments. Ethnic divisions, once constitutionalized, become concretized in a way that may have unexpected effects, even potentially really negative effects for the people it is meant to help.

That people think it is a good idea to virtue signal with the constitution without working out the details of proposed changes is basically the answer to the OPs question.

HHhiak · 17/10/2023 16:50

What on earth made you think the majority of the population would ever vote for something like this?

There was one area where the Yes vote won, the wealthy privileged and very expensive capital. The fact that the political class were in favour of yes but the population weren’t tells me that those in office so not represent their voters. The solution is for the population to vote for people who share their views and will represent them properly. It doesn’t mean there is anything wrong with the electorate.

HoppingPavlova · 17/10/2023 16:37

Just as a little side-note, the term Aboriginal, while historical is outdated. Whilst always lumped together in the ‘white’ intent of Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islanders generally don’t identify as Aboriginal. Therefore, to be correct you would need to say Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islanders. This then became a mouthful and a half, so the term Indigenous was used as it covers both groups. Lately, First Nations has become popular but with stats we still report data in terms of ‘Indigenous’. On an individual basis, you identify an individual as their country/land/group name, example ‘Linda, a Gamilaroi woman, is 46yo’. So, for those using the term Aboriginal, either add in the Torres or swap to one of the other two terms if wanting to be correct.

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 14:59

"Writer Chris Owen who Authored the book, Every Mothers Son Is Guilty: Policing the Kimberley Frontier of Western Australia feels there is a lot more that needs to be done in order for all Australians to learn about Australia’s brutal past. He has recently decided that he will be working on another book the outlines even more Aboriginal history from the rest of Western Australia.

He is also posting some of his research from W.A and elsewhere across Australia on social media. Some of his posts have been shared several hundred times. In his most recent post, he highlights a diary entry from a young British Settler (Emily Caroline Creaghe) who was passing through Queensland gulf country in 1883. During her stay at Lorne Hills station, she detailed how the station owner (Jack Watson) had around 40 sets of Aboriginal ears nailed around the walls of the homestead"

It’s disturbing how she can write about the weather in one sentence and trophy killings in the next sentence. From her tone, it sounds like she is more disturbed by the weather than the owner of the station where she was staying.

Most of what Chris has posted is information that can be found online. All it takes is a little digging and you will discover the truth about brutal crimes against humanity that took place during Australia’s colonisation.

It seems that Australian’s have a real fear of this truth and so they should. To this day, there has been no justice for these crimes. Some descendants of these killers still occupy the same lands where their forefathers committed these crimes. The world needs to know about Australia’s history that happened at a time when International laws were in place."

Queensland man had 40 sets of Aboriginal ears nailed to walls (welcometocountry.org)

Every Mother's Son is Guilty: Policing the Kimberley Frontier of Western Australia 1882-1905

Chris Owen   In Every Mother’s Son is Guilty, Chris Owen provides a compelling account of policing in the Kimberley district from 1882, when police were established in the district, until 1905 when Dr. Walter Roth’s controversial Royal Commission into...

https://uwap.uwa.edu.au/products/every-mothers-son-is-guilty-policing-the-kimberley-frontier-of-western-australia-1882-1905

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 14:55
Complete communities wiped out by gunfire, herded off cliffs, burned alive and poisonings by the use of strychnine which is widely regarded as one of the most excruciating ways to die.

"The argument that all this happened under Britain’s rule is not true. All of these images are from after 1901 when Australia became a nation. The neck chains were used well up until the 1960’s and only used on our people.

Neck chains were used while Aboriginal men were marched from their homelands into prisons, concentration camps known as missions and lock hospitals or forced into slavery. Women were also forced into slavery as domestic servants.

Many of the following images contain images of Aboriginal men and children in chains who were often chained up by the neck and sent to Aboriginal concentration camps.

The oppression continues today as well. In recent years, the United Nations have handed down multiple scathing reports on Australia’s lack of effort when it comes to improving the shocking rates of suicide, incarceration, health and education. Australia doesn’t even bother responding to these reports any more. There is no pressure for them to do so. They have created the perfect strangle hold on our existence as they try to force us to assimilate into their toxic and destructive society.

And just when you think Australia could do no worse… today, they even choose the date of British invasion (Jan 26) to celebrate ‘Australia Day’. And that is why hundreds of thousands of us hit the streets each year in protest."

Australia's brutal treatment of Aboriginal people (welcometocountry.org)

EDITED: Added quotation marks as taken from a website.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?
OP posts:
Oakbeam · 17/10/2023 14:47

The whole atmosphere of Australia is really different to the UK.

The first time I went there I was glad I visited Malaysia on the way back. Otherwise, I wouldn’t have felt like I had been on holiday at all.

Maybe I’m take-as-you-find-me, selfish, crude and vulgar. I don’t think so though.

CowboyJoanna · 17/10/2023 14:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 14:26

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 10:44

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

It seems to be all about some kind of performative element to you, which you think will somehow help people.

If you look at indigenous populations in countries around the world, you often do see the same two types of approaches. One is something like a reservation approach, where the government is responsible for supporting people. This was often an earlier approach, at a time when it was thought people might carry on living a traditional lifestyle.

Of course time marches on, so no one does live a wholly traditional lifestyle anymore than European-descent people do. But what became clear pretty much anywhere this was tried was that it was very bad for communities. There were a number of things that could influence that, like location and resources, but part of it seems to be that supporting any capable, adult population through the state has detrimental effects.

Which has tended to produce people who think integration might be a better approach. This too has had some serious failures but often because it was conceptualized as requiring a loss of culture.

There are a lot of complicated questions involved in how to approach these things, and it's not at all clear that the idea that giving people special government support will actually be better for them, or that constitutionalizing racial groups is a good idea - it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democatic principles.

That there are problems in aboriginal communities, that there is racism, does not wipe out those kinds of concerns, you have to actually address them.

I have been reading everyone's posts with interest and I don't claim to know all the answers. It was good to read more about the workings of Australian politics and the nuances of what has just happened here.

I am also noting that in 2020 the then Prime Minister claimed Australian slavery had not happened! It is very revealing about what Aboriginal people are facing with these attitudes.

I agree that after everything that has been done to the Aboriginals' society, there is no easy way to fix it. In fact, it's impossible for everything to go back the way it was. Many of their spiritual sites have gone forever. The travesties that were carried out are still within living memory and healing is going to take a long time.

I am not claiming to know the answers, but I thought that voting YES might have been a step in the right direction.

I really do believe they are owed a debt.

EDITED: changed "are going" to "have gone".

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 14:10

HoppingPavlova · 17/10/2023 10:35

I was staying in Maroubra with family. As I am sure you know Maroubra is an Aboriginal word

well, yes, you won’t find a decent Indigenous concentration around Maroubra. You would in other suburbs though, where house prices are, on average, as high as or considerably higher than Maroubra. Still no idea of your point - you didn’t see anyone who looked, to you, Indigenous, while you went shopping in Maroubra (and potentially right in CBD as from your post I can’t tell whether you went there or just Maroubra). So what? You seem to be making out they have all been banished from society, whereas if you went to some other suburbs that are as close to CBD as Maroubra is, you would have seen plenty of Indigenous folk, many of whom would have even looked, to you, obviously Indigenous. Again, your point here is what?

If you actually look at stats, instead of basing everything on a stay in Maroubra, you would know that there is a higher density of Indigenous in cities/metro than there is in rural/remote. They just face very different issues, which was part of the problem with the Voice, with those from rural/remote areas questioning whether they would be represented by city based leaders and whose Voice would be heard? Unfortunately it was all things like this where the government came back with ‘no detail on this but vote for it and we’ll just sort it out later’. That’s not a popular response.

You seem to be making out they have all been banished from society,

Well, they were!

The White Australia policy was only stopped in 1973 and things did not magically become better overnight. They still faced racism. Attitudes had not changed across the board. Why would they? People had grown up seeing them as second class citizens and some would have preferred to keep their free/cheap labour as it was.

Rising up from the wreckage of their lives, mourning their stolen children and land and still facing racism, would have made it very difficult for them to end up in comparable lives with the whites who had got rich off their backs.

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 13:59

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 12:28

The ‘don’t know, vote no’ slogan was shameful. What the opposition party, who led this campaign, should have been saying is ‘if you don’t know, here is where you go to learn.’ Or ‘if don’t know, don’t tick any box because you can’t answer’ This was a referendum question. It was the moral duty of both sides of govt to present the case homestly, not try to fuck it up.

What were the opposition scared of? Nothing. At this point things are so bad for them they could only go up. They are hoping this is a win for them politically. It was turned into a defacto election. Imo, Peter Dutton, opposition leader, sought to raise his abysmally low popularity ratings in the polls. He did not serve the Australian people and he certainly didn’t serve the First Australians. He served himself.

I don’t know about all you, but I’m sick of this sort of politics. It’s going to ruin us. Misinformation rules. Truth is the casualty. Shame no longer exists.

That’s it for me. Bedtime. And time to move on. But I will be supporting the First Nations Peoples in any way i can in future.

There’s a very good campaign, has been running all this time, for some time, ‘raise the age’ look it up. Let’s stop putting our kids into terrible custodial conditions from as young as 10 years of age - First Nationds kids by the way, not because they are ‘badder’ but just because they are much more likely to be given custodial sentences than a child of white heritage, (or any other racial heritage), who commits the same offence.

This post and your others are excellent.

OP posts:
nearlywinteragain · 17/10/2023 12:58

LuisVitton · 17/10/2023 12:35

After Brexit and the Scottish Indyref I’m amazed anyone thinks a referendum is a good idea.

Legally a change to the constitution requires a referendum.
Australian posters have told us this a few times on the thread.

Dutch1e · 17/10/2023 12:56

taybert · 17/10/2023 12:34

I wasn’t talking about this thread though, I was talking about news articles I’d read on it prior to the vote, which is where most people get their information from. As I said in my post, they were British articles and I assumed the lack of detail was because of that, but there are quite a few people from Australia here saying there was a lack of clarity in the reporting of what exactly it meant there and how it would work too.

I'm also Australian and find the "oh gee, so unclear" claim to be complete bullshit.

It was a fear-driven No campaign full of the usual racist drivel and lies

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/oct/12/indigenous-voice-to-parliament-referendum-misinformation-fact-checked

Voice referendum: factchecking the seven biggest pieces of misinformation pushed by the no side

In a brutal referendum campaign, the same debunked claims from the no camp have popped up time and time again. Guardian Australia takes a look

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/oct/12/indigenous-voice-to-parliament-referendum-misinformation-fact-checked

EasternStandard · 17/10/2023 12:50

LuisVitton · 17/10/2023 12:35

After Brexit and the Scottish Indyref I’m amazed anyone thinks a referendum is a good idea.

I think the Aus system means it had to be a referendum

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 17/10/2023 12:45

the referendum was right in that it required more than 50% +1 ( this is good enough for something that can be reversed every 3-6 years depending on what government and where, as term lengths vary) all major irreversible changes should require 60 % of electorate ( not 60% of voters where it is not mandatory) I think this should have applied to brexit, Scottish independance etc, the status quo stays unless a big swing to opposite view.
the problem with 50 % plus one is that side a could win but if you held same vote a week later the reverse could happen. even 490,000 votes versus 510,000 votes is not clear cut enough for major changes just 20,000 out of a million is just 2%,
I think all major changes should require an absolute clear majority no thinking well if the weather was better more people would have voted or if it was a different day more workers would vote at weekends

ComeOutSun · 17/10/2023 12:36

DanceMumTaxi · 17/10/2023 09:05

I’m not at all surprised by this outcome, but it is very sad. I was very shocked when I visited Australia to learn how some people speak about and see aboriginal people. This was a very stark contrast to how neighbouring New Zealand view their Māori heritage.

I have seen racism in NZ. As for the history, Maori children were caned for speaking Maori in the early 20th Century in schools. Colonisation has never been pretty.

LuisVitton · 17/10/2023 12:35

After Brexit and the Scottish Indyref I’m amazed anyone thinks a referendum is a good idea.

taybert · 17/10/2023 12:34

Dutch1e · 17/10/2023 12:09

I have to say, in my reading on this (which has been fairly brief, but still) I have been unable to discern what they are actually voting on. “An indigenous voice” great- how does it actually work?

I'm not trying to sound snappy when I say that if you RTFT this has been answered a couple of times

There were two questions, paraphrasing:

  1. Do you want to officially recognise First Australians?
  2. Do you want to enshrine the right for an advisory board to exist?

Advisory boards have always existed, this just tried to stop the gross habit of every successive Australian gov shutting it down.

If the answer had been yes, the exact structure of that board (called the Voice) would then be decided via legislation, where it could be changed with the times rather than having a particular structure cemented in the Constitution from the get-go.

I wasn’t talking about this thread though, I was talking about news articles I’d read on it prior to the vote, which is where most people get their information from. As I said in my post, they were British articles and I assumed the lack of detail was because of that, but there are quite a few people from Australia here saying there was a lack of clarity in the reporting of what exactly it meant there and how it would work too.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 12:28

The ‘don’t know, vote no’ slogan was shameful. What the opposition party, who led this campaign, should have been saying is ‘if you don’t know, here is where you go to learn.’ Or ‘if don’t know, don’t tick any box because you can’t answer’ This was a referendum question. It was the moral duty of both sides of govt to present the case homestly, not try to fuck it up.

What were the opposition scared of? Nothing. At this point things are so bad for them they could only go up. They are hoping this is a win for them politically. It was turned into a defacto election. Imo, Peter Dutton, opposition leader, sought to raise his abysmally low popularity ratings in the polls. He did not serve the Australian people and he certainly didn’t serve the First Australians. He served himself.

I don’t know about all you, but I’m sick of this sort of politics. It’s going to ruin us. Misinformation rules. Truth is the casualty. Shame no longer exists.

That’s it for me. Bedtime. And time to move on. But I will be supporting the First Nations Peoples in any way i can in future.

There’s a very good campaign, has been running all this time, for some time, ‘raise the age’ look it up. Let’s stop putting our kids into terrible custodial conditions from as young as 10 years of age - First Nationds kids by the way, not because they are ‘badder’ but just because they are much more likely to be given custodial sentences than a child of white heritage, (or any other racial heritage), who commits the same offence.

Dutch1e · 17/10/2023 12:09

taybert · 17/10/2023 11:08

I have to say, in my reading on this (which has been fairly brief, but still) I have been unable to discern what they are actually voting on. “An indigenous voice” great- how does it actually work? I sincerely hoped that the Australian reporting of it would give some clarity on what it actually meant and that the reports I was reading in the British news were short on detail because it wasn’t a British issue. But actually it sounds like that was also the case in Australia too and that there wasn’t really any detail.

It’s easy to say aren’t they racist and isn’t it awful and it might be true, but you can’t expect people to vote to change their constitution without being sure what that means. What if it was all just tokenism anyway and it meant very little- if the indigenous people have a “voice” that no one listens to and which has no power then it can be used a smokescreen, people might feel enough has been done, it could actually prevent progress on the issue.

It sounds like it’s been handled terribly to be honest.

I have to say, in my reading on this (which has been fairly brief, but still) I have been unable to discern what they are actually voting on. “An indigenous voice” great- how does it actually work?

I'm not trying to sound snappy when I say that if you RTFT this has been answered a couple of times

There were two questions, paraphrasing:

  1. Do you want to officially recognise First Australians?
  2. Do you want to enshrine the right for an advisory board to exist?

Advisory boards have always existed, this just tried to stop the gross habit of every successive Australian gov shutting it down.

If the answer had been yes, the exact structure of that board (called the Voice) would then be decided via legislation, where it could be changed with the times rather than having a particular structure cemented in the Constitution from the get-go.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:58

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 11:44

People have to read the information or they could listen to it or watch it: There was so much of it I got tired reading. Govt., First Nations websites, wiki, University constutional professors answering ALL the question re the constitution. you could ring people, there were live web chats , documentaries and so on and so forth. But what no one can do is magically zap the info into someone’s head. its s citizens obligation to inform themselves - from a plethora of sources. It wasn’t hard to do. A person won’t learn it by magical osmosis.

The Uluṟu statement was a one page statement and you can find it now all over the internet. It was in the papers. People read it out loud on tv. It’s a beautiful bit of writing, and I’d recommend you read it because it is history now. The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities have said it’s their intention to pack it up and put it away. It’s done.

There was a model for the Voice, but it’s only a model. Parliament couldn’t legislate on it until after a referendum. So a model of the Voice could not be presented to the people as the definitive one: that is impossible until after the referendum and after Parlt had done its thing:

Same thing happened under a liberal govt in regards to the Republican referendum 25 years ago: - the model coulld not be called the definitive one as that can only go to parliament to be discussed legislated, back and forwards between the house of reps and the senate etc., after a referendum has given the go ahead.

The referendum question had two parts. It was not complicated. I haven’t got a copy but you could find that on line too. A couple of lines and very straightforward . We knew the question before hand.

I find it really frustrating that people said there was not enough info.

The 1967 referendum that passed with a 96 percent or similar ‘yes’vote was to give all Aboriginal People the vote. Everyone understood it, because it had bipartisan support and no one was trying to muddy the waters: And that happened in a very racist political environment eg We still had The White Australia Policy. Bipartisan support was the difference.

I’ve explained earlier how both paries were for the Voice to begin with. One party, the opposition party, politicised this. Unforgivable.

Edited

Its almost like people are ignoring your posts here! Thank you for trying though :)

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

When you wake up, try answering my next response following this where I gave examples of your opinion you're stating as fact.

BobShark · 17/10/2023 11:47

I live in sydney, my area came out with a vote of almost 70% yes, as did most of the city, as well as Melbourne.

PP are right in many things, it was very poorly communicated what it actually meant, the 'don't know, vote no' campaign was very strong, and there's a big difference in education and understanding from the cities and country. Australia is also a very racist country,

It's a disaster and has created appalling divide, however nobody was surprised it didn't pass.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 11:44

People have to read the information or they could listen to it or watch it: There was so much of it I got tired reading. Govt., First Nations websites, wiki, University constutional professors answering ALL the question re the constitution. you could ring people, there were live web chats , documentaries and so on and so forth. But what no one can do is magically zap the info into someone’s head. its s citizens obligation to inform themselves - from a plethora of sources. It wasn’t hard to do. A person won’t learn it by magical osmosis.

The Uluṟu statement was a one page statement and you can find it now all over the internet. It was in the papers. People read it out loud on tv. It’s a beautiful bit of writing, and I’d recommend you read it because it is history now. The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities have said it’s their intention to pack it up and put it away. It’s done.

There was a model for the Voice, but it’s only a model. Parliament couldn’t legislate on it until after a referendum. So a model of the Voice could not be presented to the people as the definitive one: that is impossible until after the referendum and after Parlt had done its thing:

Same thing happened under a liberal govt in regards to the Republican referendum 25 years ago: - the model coulld not be called the definitive one as that can only go to parliament to be discussed legislated, back and forwards between the house of reps and the senate etc., after a referendum has given the go ahead.

The referendum question had two parts. It was not complicated. I haven’t got a copy but you could find that on line too. A couple of lines and very straightforward . We knew the question before hand.

I find it really frustrating that people said there was not enough info.

The 1967 referendum that passed with a 96 percent or similar ‘yes’vote was to give all Aboriginal People the vote. Everyone understood it, because it had bipartisan support and no one was trying to muddy the waters: And that happened in a very racist political environment eg We still had The White Australia Policy. Bipartisan support was the difference.

I’ve explained earlier how both paries were for the Voice to begin with. One party, the opposition party, politicised this. Unforgivable.

Olivesmum78 · 17/10/2023 11:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 11:37

Here's an example:

It's definitely not a bad thing anymore to be Aboriginal.

This is opinion @Olivesmum78 not fact.

They most certainly will not have problems accessing employment or progressing in life.

Also an opinion, from someone who is not aboriginal.

But they most certainly are being accessed by those in the non remote areas, who are no more disadvantaged that anyone else. In fact, they have access to free dental and healthcare, again not means tested.

This is opinion also, and it seems to be based on factually incorrect information as @ALittleTeawithmilk has repsonded to it. The ' they get things I don't get and its not fair' rhetoric is not new to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread