Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Gremlinsateit · 18/10/2023 04:25

BlinkyBulldozer · 17/10/2023 00:35

It’s Dark Emu, just FYI in case anyone wants to Google for it. And many indigenous people have expressed concerns about Pasco’s identity and research. Michael Mansell, for instance, from the Tasmanian Aboriginal Land Council who is no right-winger has said emphatically that Pascoe is a white man co-opting aboriginal identity. There have also been serious scholarly objections to his research and conclusions - not slander - summarised here: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/25/bruce-pascoe-has-welcomed-the-dark-emu-debate-and-so-should-australia

The issue of treaty is also more complicated than you represented. Britain commonly signed treaties with indigenous groups - New Zealand, Canada etc. In Australia, indigenous peoples appeared to the British to be a tiny number without a structured society. We know this to be untrue now but the two cultures - were so hugely different from each other that the British simply didn’t understand what they were encountering. It was also completely different from what the British had encountered with other indigenous peoples in the US or New Zealand that they saw no need to make a treaty. A few decades after colonisation began, they had recognised that they erred. Governor George Arthur called it a fatal mistake.

We need to be able to discuss these issues with nuance not culture war stuff. The voice campaign failed to do that and settled for calling people dickheads and racists instead.

Bruce Pascoe is very nuanced about his Aboriginality. He is clear that his ancestry is at least mostly from the UK, and, if you understand the history of genocide, rape, child removal, and “breeding out the colour”, it is very clear that someone in Pascoe’s position is perfectly likely to have Aboriginal ancestry. That’s why it is disgraceful that right wing commentators bore on with the “whiter than me” rubbish.

Most attacks on Pascoe are on the basis of his Aboriginality, not his scholarship. If you actually read Dark Emu you can see that his claims are modest, and mostly based on historical documents of Europeans.

It’s a fascinating book for those of us who grew up in the Australian school system. A friend of mine remembers being quite literally taught that Captain Cook was the first man in Australia, while sitting in a classroom with Aboriginal kids.

PS I think you’ll find that the Yes campaign didn’t call anyone stupid or racist. Some individuals outside the campaign did, and some more individuals were misquoted by good old Murdoch media.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 18/10/2023 02:52

Gremlinsateit · 18/10/2023 02:43

There were a lot of untruths promoted about the Voice, many of which are repeated on this thread.

The Voice was constitutionally sound, supported by a wide range of Indigenous groups who had been extensively consulted, and was rejected by conservatives due to racism (including some internalised racism) and hopes for political gain.

It was never going to succeed without bipartisan support, so the process has inevitably caused a lot of grief and heartache for Indigenous people.

The only positive is that we now know millions of Australians genuinely want to make progress towards recognition and closing the gap. Otherwise, it’s a pretty sad outcome for the country.

Really good post. Clear and concise 👍

I agree with all of your points.

Gremlinsateit · 18/10/2023 02:43

There were a lot of untruths promoted about the Voice, many of which are repeated on this thread.

The Voice was constitutionally sound, supported by a wide range of Indigenous groups who had been extensively consulted, and was rejected by conservatives due to racism (including some internalised racism) and hopes for political gain.

It was never going to succeed without bipartisan support, so the process has inevitably caused a lot of grief and heartache for Indigenous people.

The only positive is that we now know millions of Australians genuinely want to make progress towards recognition and closing the gap. Otherwise, it’s a pretty sad outcome for the country.

Catsmere · 18/10/2023 02:22

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/10/2023 02:16

To be fair. And to correct myself from pp. They did outline the wording for the proposed changes to the constitution:

2 After Chapter VIII
Insert:
Chapter IX—Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples

129 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice
In recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia:
(i) there shall be a body, to be called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice;
(ii) the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice may make representations to the Parliament and the Executive Government of the Commonwealth on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples;
(iii) the Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws with respect to matters relating to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice, including its composition, functions, powers and procedures.

—————————————————

However, they didn’t outline or explain who this body would be or how they would be truly representative of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. How would the Voice differ from the existing advisory bodies that represent the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people? Would it replace the existing advisory bodies?

FWIW I voted yes because I really do think that we should recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia. And I hoped that it would achieve Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people being listened to, taken seriously and consulted on matters that directly affect them.

I almost voted no because I think it is a bit ambiguous, open to interpretation and I am not entirely convinced that it would make the difference that many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander’s hope for. And I still feel that I don’t have enough detail on how it works or how it would be implemented.

As Gary Foley said in the Overland interview posted upthread, it wouldn't have been any use anyway. Governments have ignored the numerous advisory committees ever since they started, and enshrining one in the Constitution would have meant we (the country) were saddled with it.

ETA I also appreciated his dubiousness (or outright scorn) for the whole Uluru Voice from the Heart business. They were far from representative, and how could they be, when Indigenous groups around the country have such different needs and wishes?

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/10/2023 02:16

To be fair. And to correct myself from pp. They did outline the wording for the proposed changes to the constitution:

2 After Chapter VIII
Insert:
Chapter IX—Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples

129 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice
In recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia:
(i) there shall be a body, to be called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice;
(ii) the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice may make representations to the Parliament and the Executive Government of the Commonwealth on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples;
(iii) the Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws with respect to matters relating to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice, including its composition, functions, powers and procedures.

—————————————————

However, they didn’t outline or explain who this body would be or how they would be truly representative of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. How would the Voice differ from the existing advisory bodies that represent the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people? Would it replace the existing advisory bodies?

FWIW I voted yes because I really do think that we should recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of Australia. And I hoped that it would achieve Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people being listened to, taken seriously and consulted on matters that directly affect them.

I almost voted no because I think it is a bit ambiguous, open to interpretation and I am not entirely convinced that it would make the difference that many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander’s hope for. And I still feel that I don’t have enough detail on how it works or how it would be implemented.

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/10/2023 01:19

IamRa · 18/10/2023 00:46

@ImustLearn2Cook

This is a vote to change the constitution in some way. We should know, in order to make an informed decision, what exactly is that change, the wording and the legal ramifications.

Every single person over the age of 18 must vote in a referendum.

They cannot be all be asked to wade through reams of information - including legal ramifications - that many simply won't understand. Referendum questions are kept concise and simple for this very reason. Any constitutional change arising from a referendum is also concise and clear. It is only after the referendum, when devising any governmental body arising from the constitutional change, does any complexity arise. (This may not be negative complexity; simply the sorting out of commonplace bureaucratic issues, ie, who does what.)

You might be able to make an informed decision given the tools and information, but a good amount of people would not.

@IamRa Yes, I know. I have been voting since the age of 18 myself. And it really isn’t that hard to make informed decisions.

It doesn’t take reams of information - including legal ramifications - that many simply won't understand to outline the precise changes (including the wording) to the constitution that are being proposed.

It is not impossible to explain these legal ramifications concisely and in layman’s terms so that the vast majority can understand.

It is not impossible to have intelligent, factual debate that avoids insults, misinformation and propaganda.

And it is absolutely vital that we don’t treat the majority of the population as unintelligent and far too dense to understand.

We are autonomous (self governing) individuals part of a collective whole. We absolutely do have the ability to make informed decisions.

BlinkyBulldozer · 18/10/2023 00:51

This is what we had during the campaign for the voice this year:

Federal Minister for Indigenous Australians: if Australia had the voice, we wouldn't have all the problems we've seen in Alice Springs and other places.

Australians: How would it fix them?

Government: We're not telling you. Just vote yes. We'll sort all that out later.

Australians: But what exactly is it going to be? Who'll be on it? What will they do?

Government: Christ. Go read the work we've put out on this already. Do some googling you lazy bigots.

Australians: Okay. So that's how it's going to work?

Government: We didn't say that. Maybe, maybe not. We'll sort it out later. Look! Qantas repainted a plane! It says yes! Everything's fine. Just vote yes.

Australians: I still don't understand so I'm going to vote no.

The media: The referendum didn't pass because everyone except us is stupid and racist. There can be no other reason.

IamRa · 18/10/2023 00:46

@ImustLearn2Cook

This is a vote to change the constitution in some way. We should know, in order to make an informed decision, what exactly is that change, the wording and the legal ramifications.

Every single person over the age of 18 must vote in a referendum.

They cannot be all be asked to wade through reams of information - including legal ramifications - that many simply won't understand. Referendum questions are kept concise and simple for this very reason. Any constitutional change arising from a referendum is also concise and clear. It is only after the referendum, when devising any governmental body arising from the constitutional change, does any complexity arise. (This may not be negative complexity; simply the sorting out of commonplace bureaucratic issues, ie, who does what.)

You might be able to make an informed decision given the tools and information, but a good amount of people would not.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/10/2023 23:47

taybert · 17/10/2023 11:08

I have to say, in my reading on this (which has been fairly brief, but still) I have been unable to discern what they are actually voting on. “An indigenous voice” great- how does it actually work? I sincerely hoped that the Australian reporting of it would give some clarity on what it actually meant and that the reports I was reading in the British news were short on detail because it wasn’t a British issue. But actually it sounds like that was also the case in Australia too and that there wasn’t really any detail.

It’s easy to say aren’t they racist and isn’t it awful and it might be true, but you can’t expect people to vote to change their constitution without being sure what that means. What if it was all just tokenism anyway and it meant very little- if the indigenous people have a “voice” that no one listens to and which has no power then it can be used a smokescreen, people might feel enough has been done, it could actually prevent progress on the issue.

It sounds like it’s been handled terribly to be honest.

As an Australian who voted in the referendum I can say this was a big part of it. We were given vague information and told that more specific information would be given after the vote (if majority voted yes).

This is a vote to change the constitution in some way. We should know, in order to make an informed decision, what exactly is that change, the wording and the legal ramifications.

To vote yes it involved a leap of faith that the yes campaign was all good and the no campaign was merely manipulative and deceitful and scaremongering.

The no campaign’s slogan: “If you don’t know, vote no,” was highly successful in tapping into people’s doubts and lack of trust in the government.

Most people don’t want to take that leap of faith, blindly trusting any of our politicians.

Bubblesoffun · 17/10/2023 23:47

Well it’s quite clear by this thread that no one in the world is more informed about global events and politics than a bunch of MNters. Clearly you know more about the whole referendum than we did. It must be wonderful to live in a world that’s so black and white and clear cut.
(I say all this as someone who voted yes)
In case I’m not being clear enough I was being sarcastic.

Photographsandmemories · 17/10/2023 23:24

Hush, we don't want any indigenous rights activists, investigative journalists, constitutional lawyers or what have you quoted here. We want the uninformed kneejerk opinion of mumsnet, which believes that Monty Python's Bruce sketch is a fully accurate and up-to-date representation of the Australian voting populace.

Catsmere · 17/10/2023 23:20

The very phrase "on the right side of history" sets off all my alarm bells these days.

octaurpus · 17/10/2023 23:07

For anyone interesting in the 'No' perspective articulated by legendary Indigenous rights activist - and founder of the Tent Embassy in Canberra - here is a fascinating interview he gave a week before the vote. https://overland.org.au/2023/10/the-use-and-abuse-of-history-in-the-voice-referendum-debate-an-interview-with-professor-gary-foley/

The interview was tweeted by John Pilger, who wrote, produced and presented the devastating documentary 'Utopia' in 2013. 'A 'yes' vote is said to be 'on the right side of history'? But is it? And what does it really mean?'

The use and abuse of History in the Voice referendum debate: an interview with Professor Gary Foley - Overland literary journal

I can see the failure of the referendum making a whole lot of Blackfellas sit up and think and realise again, what we realised back in ’67, that our best efforts to achieve our aims are always at our own behest, under our own control. A whole new gener...

https://overland.org.au/2023/10/the-use-and-abuse-of-history-in-the-voice-referendum-debate-an-interview-with-professor-gary-foley

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 22:40

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 19:11

and many people have pointed out that there are serious issues, from a law and constitutional POV

I don't see that here, can you briefly explain what these serious legal and constitutional issues would be in recognising that indigenous people exist and that there should be an advisory group?

This has already been outlined quite a lot on the thread, but just to name few:

The number one issue is that governance structures are complicated and work together in synergies. If you add a whole new element, the idea that you would somehow leave it to later, to even talk about how it would be consituted, is just incredibly foolish.

There is a strong tendency do this in legislation in recent years, and people make this argument that it is just about "recognition" or support and it will all come out in the wash because after all we all want things to work out right. But it very often ends up with bad policy that has bad effects. If the people proposing this weren't prepared to do the work to show what kind of body they were proposing, with some significant detail, there is no reason anyone should have trusted them to do the work later.

There is nothing to say, either, that once this was constitutionalized, it would be accomplished through legislation, rather than through some other means.

In particular, it would have been important to define what is meant by "advisory" body. This could mean what is in the end a totally ineffective waste of money and air, all the way through to a body that has some kind of ability to propose policy, to some kind of veto power, who knows?

The other element that is going to be very concerning to many is the institutionalization of ethnicity as defining how much, or what kind of influence, people have on government policy. That's a pretty direct over-turning of the principles western democracies have worked under. The same principles, by the way, that said that actually, it was illegitimate to restrict voting by racial group.

And to take that thought a little further, it's not only directly concerning that it might mean you now have some citizens with more avenues than others, it's concerning because you have set a precedent that political rights, at the constitutional level, can be tied to ethnicity. Constitutions are long term documents, meant to last hundreds of years. Where could a precedent like that take people in 200 years? What if the public mood changed, could other group's right be defined based on things like ethnicity, or how long their ancestors had been there?

With those kinds of considerations at stake, it's pretty natural that in order to vote yes, people would want some clear information about what they were voting for.

You have to wonder on what basis people think it would convince anyone to say, "aw, no, we don't need to have any clear outline of what this would look like or how it would function." If they believe it's a good idea with substance they should be keen to talk about those things.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 17/10/2023 22:15

HHhiak · 17/10/2023 16:50

What on earth made you think the majority of the population would ever vote for something like this?

There was one area where the Yes vote won, the wealthy privileged and very expensive capital. The fact that the political class were in favour of yes but the population weren’t tells me that those in office so not represent their voters. The solution is for the population to vote for people who share their views and will represent them properly. It doesn’t mean there is anything wrong with the electorate.

This is an excellent but undermentioned point. The Australian Capital Territory was the only one of the states and territories to vote yes. Talk about the ‘Canberra Bubble’!

For those that don’t know, that is like the UK asking the referendum question - do you support the formation of a group to advise government of policy made up only of people who can trace their ancestry back to the Domesday Book? Yes or No.

And the only constituency to vote ‘yes’ is Islington.

Canberra has a well educated and well paid population primarily employed by the public sector. If a referendum was held on the subject ‘Is Canberra representative of Australia as a whole’, I think we can guarantee another no vote.

Dutiful · 17/10/2023 22:06

ALittleTeawithmilk · 17/10/2023 12:28

The ‘don’t know, vote no’ slogan was shameful. What the opposition party, who led this campaign, should have been saying is ‘if you don’t know, here is where you go to learn.’ Or ‘if don’t know, don’t tick any box because you can’t answer’ This was a referendum question. It was the moral duty of both sides of govt to present the case homestly, not try to fuck it up.

What were the opposition scared of? Nothing. At this point things are so bad for them they could only go up. They are hoping this is a win for them politically. It was turned into a defacto election. Imo, Peter Dutton, opposition leader, sought to raise his abysmally low popularity ratings in the polls. He did not serve the Australian people and he certainly didn’t serve the First Australians. He served himself.

I don’t know about all you, but I’m sick of this sort of politics. It’s going to ruin us. Misinformation rules. Truth is the casualty. Shame no longer exists.

That’s it for me. Bedtime. And time to move on. But I will be supporting the First Nations Peoples in any way i can in future.

There’s a very good campaign, has been running all this time, for some time, ‘raise the age’ look it up. Let’s stop putting our kids into terrible custodial conditions from as young as 10 years of age - First Nationds kids by the way, not because they are ‘badder’ but just because they are much more likely to be given custodial sentences than a child of white heritage, (or any other racial heritage), who commits the same offence.

And now we have Peter Dutton (opposition leader) backing away from his promise that he'd hold a second referendum when he and the Liberal party get in Government.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/oct/16/peter-dutton-second-referendum-australian-indigenous-voice-to-parliament-poll

Peter Dutton walks back offer of second referendum after voice poll

Asked about another referendum on Indigenous recognition, opposition leader says Australians won’t want that ‘for some time’

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/oct/16/peter-dutton-second-referendum-australian-indigenous-voice-to-parliament-poll

Catsmere · 17/10/2023 22:04

HHhiak · 17/10/2023 21:42

This reads a bit like ‘how dare people not vote in the way, I think they should. I’m so morally virtuous and those who disagree with me are morally defective in someways.’

With lashings of “look at these brutish colonials and my superior ability to google documentaries!”

Not to mention the obtuse failure to take on the repeated points that referenda in Australia, regardless of topic, do not succeed without bipartisan support; that only eight of 45 have ever passed; that plenty of Indigenous people were against ithis one; and that the YES case made a complete bollocks of presenting their case in any sort of detail. But apparently we’re supposed to vote for changes to our constitution without knowing what they are, and trust politicians who say “Trust me!” or else we’re nasty bigots who hate Indigenous people.

EasternStandard · 17/10/2023 21:45

HHhiak · 17/10/2023 21:42

This reads a bit like ‘how dare people not vote in the way, I think they should. I’m so morally virtuous and those who disagree with me are morally defective in someways.’

Could be the tagline of mn ;

HHhiak · 17/10/2023 21:42

This reads a bit like ‘how dare people not vote in the way, I think they should. I’m so morally virtuous and those who disagree with me are morally defective in someways.’

Teddleshon · 17/10/2023 21:12

Social media is not the whole world.

Bluebellst · 17/10/2023 20:15

ManonDe · 17/10/2023 19:57

I would add arguing about the rights and wrong of a decision that happens in a country they do not live in, does not effect them and where the posters both demonstrably and repeatedly do not understand the political procedural issues at play vis a vis how referenda actually work is pointless.

TBH alot of the comments feel very colonial in themselves- look at those awful racist backward people who did something we don't 'get'. How awful and uncivilised of them.

You realize it’s the whole world saying this, not just British people. On my social media, a lot of the people talking about how racist Australia is are Australian!

ManonDe · 17/10/2023 19:57

I would add arguing about the rights and wrong of a decision that happens in a country they do not live in, does not effect them and where the posters both demonstrably and repeatedly do not understand the political procedural issues at play vis a vis how referenda actually work is pointless.

TBH alot of the comments feel very colonial in themselves- look at those awful racist backward people who did something we don't 'get'. How awful and uncivilised of them.

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 19:45

koalaknickers · 17/10/2023 08:17

This is very topical at the moment. All over the news.

But I would welcome a thread about racism in the UK.

There are a lot of news items about things which happen in Britain, all the time. I never comment on them because I don't live there so don't feel qualified to discuss them. However, it does surprise me how MNers who don't live in a country feel they need to give their (quite frankly unwanted) view. There is nothing wrong btw with passing a randon comment, but this arguing about rights and wrongs of a decision made in a country posters don't live in and which doesn't affect them at all is pointless. "Having family out there" isn't enough.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 19:11

and many people have pointed out that there are serious issues, from a law and constitutional POV

I don't see that here, can you briefly explain what these serious legal and constitutional issues would be in recognising that indigenous people exist and that there should be an advisory group?

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 17:42

Iwantcakeeveryday · 17/10/2023 10:49

I have to wonder OP if you are really interested in this issue, as you have basically ignored all the posts that talk about why this kind of change is controversial.

@Rudderneck why does the OP have to take those types of comments as the correct or accurate ones though, have you read the posts by @ALittleTeawithmilk ?

it runs very close to ideas about race essentialism, and giving special related to ethnicity it's a huge departure from liberal democratic principles.

So do British people think that us having greater rights in our own country or being recognised as British people is a bad thing too? What is the big deal with recognising that indigenous people exist and having that being reflected in a constitution?

PS - are you suggesting that you think that people whose ancestors hail from the UK should have more rights than those whose claim to citizenship is more recent??!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread