Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 09:34

I don’t have a strong view on the decision but I did look at polling before it happened. The downward slide from high to low was very marked

I also think by referendum was actually a good way to go

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 09:34

The whole issue is far more nuanced than is being presented here (as a number of posters have intelligently pointed out). A lot of Indigenous people were on the "No". Yes historically Australia has has a problem with racism but I do not believe that this is the case any more, certainly in comparison to comparable countries.

It is frankly ridiculous and ignorant to just put the "No" vote down to racism.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 09:33

I read this because I wanted to learn more about Jacinta Price and her thinking on this. She is the Shadow Minister for Indigenous Australians.

Her background: Her father is Anglo-Celtic and her mother is indigenous (Warlpiri, to be precise).

Jacinta Nampijinpa Price - Wikipedia

Price has highlighted the high rates of domestic and other violence in Aboriginal communities. She advocates for law and order, and racial equality before the law.[38] She rejects the "white privilege" narrative and has criticised left-wing public discourse around Indigenous deaths due to violence and, in particular Aboriginal deaths in custody.[41] In her maiden speech, Price rejected the idea of racism causing Aboriginal deaths in custody as a "false narrative", and told Parliament: "We cannot support legislation that prioritises freedom of the perpetrator over justice for the victim, in an attempt to reduce rates of incarceration."[32]
Price rejects claims of systemic racism in the Australian prison system against Aboriginal people, citing the finding of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (1987–1991) that there was no evidence that proportionately more Aboriginal Australians die in custody than non-Indigenous Australians.[42] In her maiden speech, Price said "Our greatest problem lies with the fact that in the [30 years after the Royal Commission], over 750 Indigenous Australians were murdered at the hands of other Indigenous Australians — yet there is little concern or acknowledgment that this is why Indigenous Australians are incarcerated at such high rates."[32]
Following a June 2020 Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne, Price accused protesters of being ignorant and uncaring, stating: "70 percent of Aboriginal men and women incarcerated are incarcerated for acts of violence against their loved ones. [The Left] don't care because the perpetrators are also black, people only care if there is seen to be a white perpetrator. It's not racism that is killing our people, it is the actions of our own people".[41] She argued that Black Lives Matter activists have been "ignoring the real crisis" facing Indigenous people.[43]

Law and order (politics) - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_and_order

OP posts:
HunkyRory · 16/10/2023 09:30

I saw this and it apparently failed due to the poor way it was presented with little facts or information for voters to make a decision. The failure for this is not on the voters as I saw that indigenous citizens also criticised the terrible campaign

Coveescapee · 16/10/2023 09:28

CuppaJoeJojo · 16/10/2023 09:26

Some things shouldn’t be left to referendums. Going by opinion polls apparently the U.K. would vote to bring back the death penalty if it went to referendum…

Oh no how ghastly Tarquin. The lower orders who live in crime ridden streets want to have a say. Let them eat cake.

MrsDanversChickenSandwich · 16/10/2023 09:27

I’ve never thought that the mandatory voting they have in place in Australia seemed like a good idea. All it does is force people to tick a box, but you can’t force someone to engage properly with an issue. And surely if it’s a democratic right to vote, people should also have a democratic right to not vote.

Neodymium · 16/10/2023 09:27

I am Australian. I consider myself quite well educated and read, and I didn’t get what the voice would entail or mean exactly. I voted yes as from what I could gather it was largely a symbolic thing. The no campaign was quite strong and sadly yes, there was lots of overly racist ‘no’ posts I saw. Interestingly the fb friends and family who were most vocal about no sharing dire predictions about homes being taken away ect are the same people who shared Covid conspiracy theories. My mum voted no because she saw an interview with some aboriginal people who said they were voting no. She just didn’t know enough about it and thought if they didn’t want it then she would vote no. I’m not surprised qld (where i live) voted no the strongest. Qld is typically about 20 years behind the rest of the country in terms of progressive thinking. I feel very sad about the whole thing as I think it’s just made the entire country divided and look like a bunch of racists idiots to the world. Please remember the 40% of Australians that voted yes aren’t like that!

CuppaJoeJojo · 16/10/2023 09:26

Some things shouldn’t be left to referendums. Going by opinion polls apparently the U.K. would vote to bring back the death penalty if it went to referendum…

CasperGutman · 16/10/2023 09:25

I'm not remotely surprised.

Problem: indigenous aboriginal Australians are not well served by the democratic institutions of the country they live in, because they represent only a small minority of the electorate and consequently their voices aren't heard in parliament and elsewhere.

Proposed solution (headline): introduce specific representatives to give that small minority a voice, separate from the representatives which the majority of the electorate choose to vote for.

Sounds reasonable, tell me more.

Proposed solution (small print): the aboriginal minority can only have this is it's voted for by the mainstream majority. You know, the majority who have been consistently voting for representatives and policies which fail to serve the needs of the minority and result in their being dispossessed and condemned to poverty for generation after generation.

Hmm, what could possibly go wrong? 🤔

Coveescapee · 16/10/2023 09:24

Thank you @BlinkyBulldozer for explaining the issues in an intelligent way. Some of the posters on here remind me of the arrogant, smug remainders who derided the racist working class while not having a clue about any of the issues. When did people get so stupid?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 16/10/2023 09:23

Compulsory voting is one of those things that sounds a great idea, but I think it's actually the opposite.

I always used to think the Ask the Audience lifeline in WWTBAM would have been much more effective if they'd also had option E: 'not a clue', or just allowed people to abstain - so that you wouldn't have 19% of absolute certain correct answers drowned out by 72 of complete guesses - and actual voting is way more important than that.

I think there's a lot to be said for allowing people to voluntarily opt out if they neither care, understand nor have a preference one way or the other. People happily do it in other areas of life: leave things to the experts/people who know what they're doing.

Dramatic · 16/10/2023 09:22

You only have to look at "Australia Day" and how angry a lot of white Australian's get if someone mentions the indigenous population on that day to know what a lot of people's attitudes are like.

CuppaJoeJojo · 16/10/2023 09:22

‘We’re not racist but…’

Lanoisette · 16/10/2023 09:22

I don’t doubt there is plenty of racism in Australia, but it’s hugely arrogant to say that racism is the only reason someone might disagree with a proposal like this. The failure of the Yes campaign to engage with people who disagree is actually what creates division.

Dulra · 16/10/2023 09:22

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 09:14

Far be it from me to interrupt Mumsnet when it's in full "Australians are all stupid, racist colonials" mode but (a) the voice could have been legislated without a referendum, the government chose to try and place it within the constitution despite refusing to explain how it would work, (b) even placing it in the constitution didn't mean anything given that a future government could introduce legislation changing the voice to one bloke in Ulla Dulla if they had a mind to, (c) the yes campaign failed to engage with voters in working class areas or those with English as a second language and instead produced a top-down, corporation-heavy campaign that made people who were always going to vote yes feel good about themselves but didn't do anything elsewhere (d) there is a not insignificant Blak Sovereignty movement that doesn't want the voice, they want a treaty instead, (e) the no campaign was led by two indigenous politicians - whatever anyone thinks of Jacinta Price she has a skill for speaking plainly to the electorate, and (f) the yes campaign knew from very early on that the referendum was likely to fail but they brought the enabling legislating to parliament unchanged anyway and the government abandoned the idea of local and regional voices.

Now please do carry on explaining that your Aunt Beryl went to Sydney for three days in 1997 and was appalled at all the racism she saw and the terrible lack of nice civilised history like medieval castles.

Read my earlier posts about why it is crucial referendums are run properly, sounds like this was a mess and you have explained clearly why people voted no. A real own goal for Australia that has damaged your reputation overseas. What a failure by your government no winners here.

For what it is worth my bil is born and bred Australian to Indian parents, he has received more racist comments living in Dublin then his years growing up in Sydney

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 16/10/2023 09:19

I have family in South Australia. The racism in particular against aborigines is breathtaking. But as pp probably similar to travellers here.
I'm not surprised.

disappearingfish · 16/10/2023 09:17

@sashagabadon has summarised it well. I think the Left in a lot of countries are alienating people by labelling them as racist/xenophobic/bigoted/ignorant when an alleged "progressive" proposal is not popular.

That creates a space for the far right. Left leaning politicians need to wise up because we're all worse off as a result.

Conkersinautumn · 16/10/2023 09:16

Aus has cemented its not for ethical travel status.

MaybeSmaller · 16/10/2023 09:16

I don't think labelling all no voters as racist is particularly accurate or helpful.

This, especially if you don't live in Australia and have no idea about the issues being voted on.

It's also worth bearing in mind (as PPs have mentioned) Australia has compulsory voting - you don't get to abstain in a referendum, you have to pick Yes or No. So No automatically gets a boost given it's the "keep things as they are" option.

Bansheed · 16/10/2023 09:14

When the result came in, i was hugely disappointed in my fellow Australians. I did think, i wonder if this will make to MN as, over the years, i have seen many other Australians absolutely refuting that it is a racist country on here.

That was never my experience. Sadly, this result is.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 09:14

Far be it from me to interrupt Mumsnet when it's in full "Australians are all stupid, racist colonials" mode but (a) the voice could have been legislated without a referendum, the government chose to try and place it within the constitution despite refusing to explain how it would work, (b) even placing it in the constitution didn't mean anything given that a future government could introduce legislation changing the voice to one bloke in Ulla Dulla if they had a mind to, (c) the yes campaign failed to engage with voters in working class areas or those with English as a second language and instead produced a top-down, corporation-heavy campaign that made people who were always going to vote yes feel good about themselves but didn't do anything elsewhere (d) there is a not insignificant Blak Sovereignty movement that doesn't want the voice, they want a treaty instead, (e) the no campaign was led by two indigenous politicians - whatever anyone thinks of Jacinta Price she has a skill for speaking plainly to the electorate, and (f) the yes campaign knew from very early on that the referendum was likely to fail but they brought the enabling legislating to parliament unchanged anyway and the government abandoned the idea of local and regional voices.

Now please do carry on explaining that your Aunt Beryl went to Sydney for three days in 1997 and was appalled at all the racism she saw and the terrible lack of nice civilised history like medieval castles.

phoenixrosehere · 16/10/2023 09:14

Wordsworse · 16/10/2023 08:45

I too was very surprised. From the little I have read it wasn’t giving the indigenous people any particular power, just recognition.

Unfortunately to some, just being recognised is giving power. They want recognition then they’ll want something else.

sashagabadon · 16/10/2023 09:12

From what I have gathered it was because

  1. no one could say what form the voice would take, who would be on the “ commitee” and what power they would have exactly
  2. people thought it was hiding a bigger agenda involving reparations and land
  3. people didn’t think one racial group should be given more power in the constitution over other groups
  4. people didn’t like the negative yes campaign calling no voters racist
  5. it had a catchy slogan “if you don’t know , vote no” not dissimilar to the simple but effective brexit no slogan “ take back control “

I think they are some of the reasons reading a few articles

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 16/10/2023 09:11

Half of my Aussie cousins are embarrassed but half are ‘ why do they think they’re better than us, getting ALL the special treatment.’

That sounds what I read - that a lot of Aussies who voted No viewed it as a way of giving more rights to the Aboriginal people, which they believed to be very unfair.

Maybe like people countering Black Lives Matter with "But ALL lives matter" - even though the importance of white lives has never been in question or under threat.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 09:11

Frozenone · 16/10/2023 09:07

Not surprised in the result in the slightest.

I’ve visited Australia many times, and one side of my family have lived there since the 1960s, and even the younger generations in the family are racist towards all non-white people but especially to their own indigenous people. I’m originally from NZ (but live in the UK) so both countries have fairly close ties but it’s one strong reason why I would never move there. I don’t like my family’s attitudes either so better to keep my distance from such small-minded horrid people.

I can’t imagine how the Aboriginal people must be feeling right now.

So disappointing isn't it.

I foolishly thought maybe things were going to improve for the indigenous people. My family member telling me about the racist incident I mentioned earlier, well I thought that was just how you get racists everywhere. However, it seems that this is something much more deep rooted in the fabric of Australia than I thought.

I was there 20 years ago and visited Sydney and Perth and did not see one indigenous person my whole time there.

OP posts: