Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
ClaribelLowLieth · 16/10/2023 10:26

DiabolicalFinial · 16/10/2023 10:21

Fuck some of you are rude and condescending.

The basic question in the referendum was double-barrelled- which is absolutely ridiculous to put into a referendum.

Many Australians absolutely want First Nations Peoples acknowledged and respected in the constitution BECAUSE THEY AREN’T RACIST.

It was the second part - enshrining a Voice to Parliament in the constitution, and without detail, definition or transparency, that resulted in many people voting no.

Perhaps it is viewed differently elsewhere, but changing the constitution is a fucking big deal, and there was no reason for the Voice to be embedded into our constitution when it could have been legislated.

One state is already introducing their own version of the Voice to Parliament, and everyone I know hopes it is a success, and a springboard for similar to be introduced throughout Australia and at all levels.

Although it may not fit the narrative that “Australia is so completely racist and we are so superior” that is being posted here, most Australian people detest racism and want First Nations Peoples to be empowered, celebrated and actually have the ‘gap’ closed and the funding/money that is needed directed into achieving the results the communities themselves determine is required.

Yes - this!

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 10:26

Dutiful · 16/10/2023 10:14

Take a look at Jacinta Nampijinpa Price's speech to The Press Club.
https://www.youtube.com/live/hrinfhtFDlc?si=BEi2YFcAkIEV6dhX
It would have persuaded many, unfortunately.

I am watching this now. Thank you.

OP posts:
Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 10:25

Dutiful · 16/10/2023 10:14

Take a look at Jacinta Nampijinpa Price's speech to The Press Club.
https://www.youtube.com/live/hrinfhtFDlc?si=BEi2YFcAkIEV6dhX
It would have persuaded many, unfortunately.

Thanks for posting that. It gives somewhat balanced reasoning. I learnt a lot about the situation from that.

Gingerbee · 16/10/2023 10:25

I was saddened by the vote but sadly not shocked.
I have spent a lot of time in Australia and found it to be very racist in general.
I find it amazing the language used against the Indigenous People and new immigrants. The worst are the children of the 'Ten Piound Poms'
It was one of the main reasons we decided not to stay despite the better work life balance..

wandawaves · 16/10/2023 10:25

Simonjt · 16/10/2023 08:45

I don’t find this shocking, after all the word P*ki is very popular, not just people in everyday life, but its commonly used on TV to describe us.

There should not have been a vote, the right thing to do was to include automatically.

In Australia? Where? When?

Lateliein · 16/10/2023 10:24

Deeply racist country. Would not want my kids raised there.

ManonDe · 16/10/2023 10:21

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 09:14

Far be it from me to interrupt Mumsnet when it's in full "Australians are all stupid, racist colonials" mode but (a) the voice could have been legislated without a referendum, the government chose to try and place it within the constitution despite refusing to explain how it would work, (b) even placing it in the constitution didn't mean anything given that a future government could introduce legislation changing the voice to one bloke in Ulla Dulla if they had a mind to, (c) the yes campaign failed to engage with voters in working class areas or those with English as a second language and instead produced a top-down, corporation-heavy campaign that made people who were always going to vote yes feel good about themselves but didn't do anything elsewhere (d) there is a not insignificant Blak Sovereignty movement that doesn't want the voice, they want a treaty instead, (e) the no campaign was led by two indigenous politicians - whatever anyone thinks of Jacinta Price she has a skill for speaking plainly to the electorate, and (f) the yes campaign knew from very early on that the referendum was likely to fail but they brought the enabling legislating to parliament unchanged anyway and the government abandoned the idea of local and regional voices.

Now please do carry on explaining that your Aunt Beryl went to Sydney for three days in 1997 and was appalled at all the racism she saw and the terrible lack of nice civilised history like medieval castles.

This is exactly what my parents who live in Australia (one who voted yes and one who voted no say) and agree on.

Added to the fact that the yes campaign received tax breaks and funding to the tune of millions and the no campaign did not, despite electoral laws. Including the yes campaign getting free flights all around the country to campaign. Added also to the fact that the Government REFUSED to say what yes would mean.... when ever they were asked it was all 'just leave the details to us you bigots'.

The feeling as I understand it was that the metropolitan elite were treating the electorate with crushing disrespect and so the feeling was that if the 'Government does not want to explain what this means then what are they hiding?'.

DiabolicalFinial · 16/10/2023 10:21

Fuck some of you are rude and condescending.

The basic question in the referendum was double-barrelled- which is absolutely ridiculous to put into a referendum.

Many Australians absolutely want First Nations Peoples acknowledged and respected in the constitution BECAUSE THEY AREN’T RACIST.

It was the second part - enshrining a Voice to Parliament in the constitution, and without detail, definition or transparency, that resulted in many people voting no.

Perhaps it is viewed differently elsewhere, but changing the constitution is a fucking big deal, and there was no reason for the Voice to be embedded into our constitution when it could have been legislated.

One state is already introducing their own version of the Voice to Parliament, and everyone I know hopes it is a success, and a springboard for similar to be introduced throughout Australia and at all levels.

Although it may not fit the narrative that “Australia is so completely racist and we are so superior” that is being posted here, most Australian people detest racism and want First Nations Peoples to be empowered, celebrated and actually have the ‘gap’ closed and the funding/money that is needed directed into achieving the results the communities themselves determine is required.

kinkytoes · 16/10/2023 10:17

@Teddleshon although this particular incident was definitely not meant as humour, misplaced or otherwise. Having the piss taken out of me is absolutely fine!

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 10:16

CrazyHamsterLady · 16/10/2023 10:07

YABU. Just because people don’t think the same way as you it doesn’t mean they’re wrong. That’s the entire reason most countries have a democracy, so people can have their voices heard. Would you rather live in a dictatorship?

...and the reason we have free speech is so I can share my opinion!

OP posts:
Rewis · 16/10/2023 10:16

I don't know many Australians but all of them have talked about the indigenous community with such a hate that I'm not surprised at all

Libertass · 16/10/2023 10:16

No, I’m not shocked by the result.

This isn’t the first time an issue championed by progressive metropolitan liberals has been rejected by the overwhelming majority of ordinary people who live work & think outside the ‘woke’ bubble, and it won’t be the last.

kinkytoes · 16/10/2023 10:15

@Teddleshon yeh you're right it's not the right word at all. Apologies.

Dutiful · 16/10/2023 10:14

Take a look at Jacinta Nampijinpa Price's speech to The Press Club.
https://www.youtube.com/live/hrinfhtFDlc?si=BEi2YFcAkIEV6dhX
It would have persuaded many, unfortunately.

Before you continue to YouTube

https://www.youtube.com/live/hrinfhtFDlc?si=k6GyTb6TYTgNAraO

MaggieFS · 16/10/2023 10:13

From an outsider observer's opinion, with a long term interest in studying politics and political systems:

  • it seems like the proposed solution of 'The Voice' wasn't going to fix the issues. Wrong answer to the problem
  • mandatory voting is a good thing, IMHO, when choosing people (MPs, councillors) to represent you. It's not good when making people vote on something they don't know anything about/don't care enough about
  • in this case it was hard to work out what it would mean in practice, as pp have said, but it did feel like it would constitutionality segregate the population and confer different rights, and purely from a theoretical standpoint, that feels odd for any country to adopt

I hope it gives momentum to people who were on both sides to find another way because I think the objectives behind it are important, there just needs to be a different way to address them.

OP posts:
Dotjones · 16/10/2023 10:10

It was inevitable that the Australians would vote this down, their referendums usually fail and the aboriginal people only make up a tiny fraction of the population - most people don't think about them much or really care either way. The other main issue was that it wasn't clear what voting "yes" actually meant. Generally people vote for what they think is best for them, not what's best for a group of people that they themselves will never be.

Just because a law or constitutional change sounds like its something right-thinking people would support, it doesn't mean that right-thinking people should support it if it's not clearly defined what the likely outcome will be. As with that MP guy who blocked the "on the nod" upskirting vote in the UK parliament - he wasn't pro-upskirting, he just felt that a law which could result in a prison sentence and placement on the sex offenders' register ought to at least have a discussion before being voted through.

LaBaDeeLaBaDa · 16/10/2023 10:08

I'm really disappointed at the result and definitely agree Australia has issues with racism, but polling showed a (pretty big) majority of people supported the idea of The Voice before the referendum campaign actually began (attached a screenshot of the graph below). That instinctive majority for "yes we should probably support this" went off a cliff, for all the reasons with the campaigns some pp have mentioned above. So I don't think it's right to attribute it just to straightforward racism - the instinct was to support, then it fell apart.

That's not to deny the racism that does exist, but handled differently this could have been a real moment for healing, and it has just made everything worse

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?
LovelaceBiggWither · 16/10/2023 10:07

I voted Yes but my idealist self would have preferred to vote No as I didn't want a Voice to parliament, I want a Treaty.

CrazyHamsterLady · 16/10/2023 10:07

YABU. Just because people don’t think the same way as you it doesn’t mean they’re wrong. That’s the entire reason most countries have a democracy, so people can have their voices heard. Would you rather live in a dictatorship?

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 10:05

@kinkytoes I'm an Australian and when I first moved to the UK in the 1990's every time I spoke in the office morning meeting it was repeated back to me by the boss in an exaggerated Aussie "Ocker" accent. I would never in a million years call this racism, just misplaced humour verging on bullying.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 10:04

Porridgeislife · 16/10/2023 10:02

No. It’s similar to the Brexit vote.

Brexit happened because people hated the status quo and the “yes” campaign spun a tale of nonsense convincing them that Brexit would make everything better.

In Australian, most voters are happy with the status quo and the “no” team spun a tale about having your land rights taken away and all sorts of nonsense.

Also, the voting threshold for a referendum is much higher in Australia. 4/6 states need to have a majority yes vote (not 50% overall).

I knew the B word would find its way on here.

MyCircumference · 16/10/2023 10:03

i think i read there population of indigenous people in Australia is 3% so very small

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 10:03

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 10:00

When the Australian soap opera Neighbours introduced its first non-white family in 1993 – the Lims from Hong Kong – their first major storyline was to be accused of eating another neighbour’s dog.

Admittedly, the person doing the accusing was Julie Martin, a character known for being obnoxious, and described by the official Neighbours book as “unbearable”. Eventually, in a triumph for race relations, they were vindicated. After six weeks, they were written out. The dog, Holly, stayed around for five more years.

Australian television – both scripted and not – has been overwhelmingly white and Anglo-Saxon, more so than the population.

Whitewashed: why does Australian TV have such a problem with race? | Australian television | The Guardian

Awww, that storyline was horrible. So blatantly racist as well.

Porridgeislife · 16/10/2023 10:02

No. It’s similar to the Brexit vote.

Brexit happened because people hated the status quo and the “yes” campaign spun a tale of nonsense convincing them that Brexit would make everything better.

In Australian, most voters are happy with the status quo and the “no” team spun a tale about having your land rights taken away and all sorts of nonsense.

Also, the voting threshold for a referendum is much higher in Australia. 4/6 states need to have a majority yes vote (not 50% overall).