Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
User893432374902zzx · 16/10/2023 11:01

Should not be surprised if you are British. After all, members of the royal family did openly question how dark prince Harry's children would be.

K1nga23 · 16/10/2023 11:01

I think it’s sad but not surprising

bombastix · 16/10/2023 11:01

@enchantedsquirrelwood / well, I think even if you took the compensation aspect out, I think it would be no. The tendency in liberal circles is to imagine their views extend across the board. I don't think that is true at all. And I am a liberal person

MaggieFS · 16/10/2023 10:59

Lateliein · 16/10/2023 10:24

Deeply racist country. Would not want my kids raised there.

Biscuit
Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 10:59

Sorry but a lot of you are showing your ignorance on this thread, the proposed changes meant changing the Australian Constitution which required a referendum. It also reads as though a number of posters don't actually understand what the proposed changes were.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 10:58

SaySomethingMan · 16/10/2023 10:54

What’s the point of using popular vote for this? They didn’t really want to change things, did they?
I can only imagine what America would still be like if the civil rights acts was decided on by popular vote.

I feel so sad for the Aboriginals. To be treated so badly in the land of one’s ancestors . For others to come and steal someone’s land mainly for their criminals, but refuse to give them the same Rights then and down the line? They’re staying true to their roots, I guess

The referendum was held because the Uluru Statement From the Heart requested the voice be permanently placed within the constitution. There is no other way to change the constitution.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders or Indigenous Australians are better terms than "the Aboriginals".

StoneWashJeansWithAMatchingJacket · 16/10/2023 10:56

I think it’s massively unreasonable that they felt the need to hold a referendum on this rather than just do the decent thing and make necessary changes. Instead it’s made Australia look like a backwards, bigoted country that doesn’t care about its own indigenous people.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 16/10/2023 10:55

bombastix · 16/10/2023 10:41

I'm surprised that you are surprised.

I'm pretty sure if you held a referendum in the U.K. about recognition of slavery and reparations you would get a similar rejection.

Warm words are free.

That is very different, as it would involve money - and a lot of it - and also blaming the current population for something that happened over 200 years ago.

Although referendums are divisive, it's nice to see one that doesn't just depend on a simple majority of votes and also needed a majority in each state (cough, Brexit, Scotland).

SaySomethingMan · 16/10/2023 10:54

What’s the point of using popular vote for this? They didn’t really want to change things, did they?
I can only imagine what America would still be like if the civil rights acts was decided on by popular vote.

I feel so sad for the Aboriginals. To be treated so badly in the land of one’s ancestors . For others to come and steal someone’s land mainly for their criminals, but refuse to give them the same Rights then and down the line? They’re staying true to their roots, I guess

Verbena17 · 16/10/2023 10:51

It’s not baffling/surprising - there is still a huge amount of racism in Australia and anyone who tells you there isn’t, is lying.

IveHadItUpToHere · 16/10/2023 10:51

I understand the flaws but is there not a suspicion that the government deliberately had a referendum and was vague about the outcomes so it would fail and then it will not be replaced with something better?
Because not everyone will see that voting 'no' was an anti-racist decision but will instead exploit it as a tacit endorsement of racism and discrimination. There are PPs on here - saying they're Australian - and already doing exactly that.
It looks a bit as though there was the opportunity for something that was flawed or a nebulous nothing that could be filled with any fantasy future perfect scheme. Isn't something better than nothing? Couldn't that something have pushed for legislation to be implemented that breached the gaps in the referendum?

seishonagon · 16/10/2023 10:50

Teddleshon · 16/10/2023 10:05

@kinkytoes I'm an Australian and when I first moved to the UK in the 1990's every time I spoke in the office morning meeting it was repeated back to me by the boss in an exaggerated Aussie "Ocker" accent. I would never in a million years call this racism, just misplaced humour verging on bullying.

My ex used to do this all the time to me. Some Brits (usually posh men) think that the 'Orstralian' accent is inherently ridiculous. It's not racism, but if it happens repeatedly, even when you ask someone to stop, it's bullying.
FYI my accent is so low-key these days that Australians often assume I'm English.

SaturdayGiraffe · 16/10/2023 10:46

OssieShowman · 16/10/2023 10:30

$450 million the Referendum has cost.

That’s a lot of money.
Which budget did it come from?

Reminds me of the Republic referendum in 1999, but that was far closer.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_Australian_republic_referendum

1999 Australian republic referendum - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_Australian_republic_referendum

ManonDe · 16/10/2023 10:43

I am not sure people know how referenda work in Australia. You have to get a majority of votes in a majority of states. Plus a national majority of voters. So referenda are notoriously difficult to 'win'. There have been 45 referenda since federation and only 8 have been 'won'.

Painting 'Australia and Australians are racist racist RACIST!!!!'' is a bit of a massive and offensive generalisation one would think. Not sure the proof of a Neighbours episode really cuts as studied research either.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 16/10/2023 10:43

I’m stunned that people are stunned by the result. It was very predictable. I can only think that Albanese was surrounded by advisors pushing for the Voice and didn’t hear arguments against it.

As the campaign was run, it was destined to fail.

In addition to points other posters have made about the poorly worded question, the lousy campaigning, the demands of the black sovereignty movement which contradicted themselves, mandatory voting etc…

Approximately 30% of Australian voters were born overseas. 3.5% are of Aboriginal descent. There are many races in Australia. There is also a lot of racism in Australia, not all of which is directed at Aboriginals. But saying a no vote is racist is ridiculous.

But I think the key thing was withholding the detail of the voice. How would it’s members be elected? One per mob, or per mob population? Indigenous people are not uniform in their needs. Aboriginals in Redfern (Sydney) live very differently to those in Tenant Creek. What works for one group doesn’t work for another,

I could go on but I really can’t be bothered now.

bombastix · 16/10/2023 10:41

I'm surprised that you are surprised.

I'm pretty sure if you held a referendum in the U.K. about recognition of slavery and reparations you would get a similar rejection.

Warm words are free.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 10:38

mintbiscuit · 16/10/2023 10:34

This. Having lived there for a number of years I left deeply disappointed with the level of racism, sexism and misogyny that went on.

Well that let's the UK, off the hook for all of 5 minutes. Oh the drama.

Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 10:34

Not sure it's correct that Australians are racist in their entirety. My experience in watching many Eng v Australian cricket matches and vice versa is that Australians' banter could be interpreted as hostile when it's meant to be hard banter/sledging. The English respond with their own banter. I'm not meaning to simplify the matter.

Upon further reading, I don't think the results of this vote are clear cut.

mintbiscuit · 16/10/2023 10:34

Coffeerum · 16/10/2023 08:46

I'm not overly surprised, Australia is actually quite a racist country.

This. Having lived there for a number of years I left deeply disappointed with the level of racism, sexism and misogyny that went on.

Neriah · 16/10/2023 10:33

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:44

A member of my family has some very close indigenous friends.

He was working somewhere and tried to get one of the young adults a job there and was told in no uncertain terms "no way, I'm not employing a *". I won't type in full the term used.

It is absolutely shocking the way they have been treated in their own country. I can't believe in 2023 the Australians voted NO to them having a say.

I can believe it.

Whilst I think that recognising First Nation status and rights is important in any country, the way in which First Nations across the world are treated goes a long way to explaining why you couldn't expect a bunch of "immigrants" to respect either.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?
wandawaves · 16/10/2023 10:32

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 09:11

So disappointing isn't it.

I foolishly thought maybe things were going to improve for the indigenous people. My family member telling me about the racist incident I mentioned earlier, well I thought that was just how you get racists everywhere. However, it seems that this is something much more deep rooted in the fabric of Australia than I thought.

I was there 20 years ago and visited Sydney and Perth and did not see one indigenous person my whole time there.

I was there 20 years ago and visited Sydney and Perth and did not see one indigenous person my whole time there.

Umm... ok? What's your point?
Also... what does an Indigenous Australian look like? Seems you're doing a bit of racist stereotyping there yourself.

BlackSwan · 16/10/2023 10:30

The Australia I grew up in during the 80's & 90's was supremely racist, sexist and homophobic. I won't repeat the slurs here, but they abounded for anyone Aboriginal, European, Asian, homosexual...
I don't believe much has changed, but people are perhaps more careful to hide their prejudices in public & immigration has continued to bring more diversity to the local population.
Money spent on the referendum would have been better spent directly on supporting Aboriginal communities. The referendum was a cynical exercise to give the appearance of fairness and inclusivity.

OssieShowman · 16/10/2023 10:30

$450 million the Referendum has cost.

MerryMarigold · 16/10/2023 10:28

I have a view that Australia is more racist than the UK. My grandmother was Anglo Indian. As with racially mixed people there was a range of browner to lighter amongst her siblings. The 'whiter' ones were able to emigrate to Australia (2 out of 6) but my grandmother was at the browner end and rejected. It was nothing to do with qualifications. She was a qualified teacher and her sister had no qualifications. They seemed to value skin colour over education. I'm not sure if they told her the reason or if she guessed it but she was a lot darker.

Yes, it was a long time ago (the 1950s!) but it shows the UK were more progressive then, which is saying something, and I'm afraid it's left an impression on me regarding Australia so many years later.

EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 10:27

ManonDe · 16/10/2023 10:21

This is exactly what my parents who live in Australia (one who voted yes and one who voted no say) and agree on.

Added to the fact that the yes campaign received tax breaks and funding to the tune of millions and the no campaign did not, despite electoral laws. Including the yes campaign getting free flights all around the country to campaign. Added also to the fact that the Government REFUSED to say what yes would mean.... when ever they were asked it was all 'just leave the details to us you bigots'.

The feeling as I understand it was that the metropolitan elite were treating the electorate with crushing disrespect and so the feeling was that if the 'Government does not want to explain what this means then what are they hiding?'.

Underestimating people gets you nowhere in a referendum

I agree with pp it was a big deal, enough to be a referendum