Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

War is just so...stupid.

113 replies

SundayAnon · 15/10/2023 23:27

I'd love to say I'm being light-hearted, but I'm not really.

Isn't war just about the stupidest thing? I just don't get why leaders have to be so ridiculous. Don't they realise that if they stopped fighting they could have nice things?

Things like...maybe a Selfridges, a farmer's market, tapas restaurants, art exhibitions, and picnics.

Religious zealots aren't born zealots, and dictators are born dictators, what the fuck went wrong with those guys (always guys) to make them think they ruining everyone else's days/lives was more important than just rubbing along nicely together and having a decent time?

OP posts:
AmazingSnakeHead · 16/10/2023 14:33

I think that the "women 27% more likely to start a war" stat is misleading, because it omits the reasons why a woman is in charge to begin with, and how those reasons play into the likelihood of war.

AmazingSnakeHead · 16/10/2023 14:31

user1497207191 · 16/10/2023 14:11

The troubles had started before Thatcher so you can't blame her for that either!

I didn't say that she started it. Although she did wage the Falklands war.

sekift · 16/10/2023 14:30

(I don't just mean as heads of state)

sekift · 16/10/2023 14:29

I believe with every fibre of my being that if there were more women in positions of power there would be less war.

toadasoda · 16/10/2023 14:28

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/10/2023 13:28

What is it good for

Absolutely nothing!! 😁

Tortugaa · 16/10/2023 14:26

The problem is if somebody had just slaughtered your family you wouldn’t give a shit about selfridges. You would remember it, want revenge and it would impact your family for generations to come.

Similarly if you oppress people for long enough they’re going to fight back hard in whatever way they can.

toadasoda · 16/10/2023 14:25

SecretAgent00777 · 16/10/2023 13:18

Surely a lot of wars like the current Israeli/Palestine war and the war/troubles in Northern Ireland are caused because one group has power, dominance and control over another group and treat them like shit.

Eventually those being treated like shit will lash out in a violent manner because the dominant group have ignored their pleas for equality and fairness.

Exactly. And the people who are oppressed for generations and generations develop a deep seated hatred the likes of which anyone from a free nation cannot begin to comprehend. They try and fail for a peaceful agreement and sadly, a few generations on this turns into extremism, violence, terrorism and total lack of respect for human life, especially of the dominant nation. Meanwhile the innocent people of the oppressor's country / race are bewildered as to why this happens and why these people are so evil and angry. Its textbook, IRA, Hamas and a thousand other examples. Almost all wars could be avoided by peaceful means if the ones in power wanted it to be so. We can't comprehend it now because we don't get it. For some war, however brutal is better than the alternative (I mean from their narrow perspective).

ketchup07070 · 16/10/2023 14:22

I think violence is also observable in primates. I vaguely remember a documentary years ago which concluded female Bonobos averted violence in the group by having sex with the males. Not sure if anyone else remembers it? It suggested the males were naturally more aggressive and that the females tried to prevent it, though I suspect there are other ways one could interpret their findings.

greglet · 16/10/2023 14:21

@onlytea interesting statistic! I suspect that many female rulers throughout history have had to work hard to establish their power within a patriarchal system, which can mean deliberately presenting oneself as more aggressive or masculine in order to stave off opposition (cf Elizabeth I with her 'I may have the body of a weak and feeble woman, but I have the heart and stomach of a man'). I imagine a lot of wars started by queens were started partly to prove that they weren't pushovers!

greglet · 16/10/2023 14:15

@user1478172746 It's a common but idealistic misconception that hunter gatherer societies are/were more peaceful and egalitarian than settled or farming societies. There are plenty of tribes in e.g. Papúa New Guinea and the Amazonian rainforest who live predominantly by hunting and gathering but who experience high levels of inter- and intra-tribal violence. There's a mass grave dating from about 10,000 years ago in Kenya which seems to provide proof of interpersonal violence too.

Farming and the growth of settled 'states' absolutely enabled larger-scale conflict as capitalism meant resources (including people to serve as soldiers) were concentrated in the hands of a few individuals, but violence is very much an innate part of humanity.

spookehtooth · 16/10/2023 14:13

@TheaBrandt that thing about leaders being people who don't want to be, I'm pretty sure that idea is lifted out of Plato's philosophical text/book republic

user1497207191 · 16/10/2023 14:11

AmazingSnakeHead · 16/10/2023 13:54

Also the person saying that women over 50 would never wage war clearly do not recall that Thatcher was prime minister during the Troubles.

The troubles had started before Thatcher so you can't blame her for that either!

onlytea · 16/10/2023 14:09

User5646382910 posted the answer to that on page 1. The full article is paywalled but there is a key bit of detail in the summary at the top;

They studied how often European rulers went to war between 1480 and 1913. Over 193 reigns, they found that states ruled by queens were 27% more likely to wage war than those ruled by kings

Siameasy · 16/10/2023 14:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BronwenFrideswide · 16/10/2023 14:02

TeenLifeMum · 15/10/2023 23:36

Out of interest, has a female leader ever started a war?

There haven't been that many female leaders in the world over the centuries have there?

Of those that there have been some didn't shy away from war, whether they 'officially' started it or not - Elizabeth I, Queen Anne, Isabella of Castille (led armies against the Muslims in Spain to drive them out , did so successfully and was described as the very epitome of a war leader), Margaret Thatcher (The Falklands War) to name a few off the top of my head.

Whatafustercluck · 16/10/2023 14:01

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/10/2023 13:28

What is it good for

Absolutely nothing.

AmazingSnakeHead · 16/10/2023 13:54

Also the person saying that women over 50 would never wage war clearly do not recall that Thatcher was prime minister during the Troubles.

TheaBrandt · 16/10/2023 13:53

I think it’s true though. The wrong people end up being the ones power. Putin? Hitler ? Stalin? Hitchhikers Guide to the galaxy had it right the best person to be in power is the one that really doesn’t want to be.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 13:51

If countries were led by a committee of 12 normal women in their 50s I bet there would be no war.

Not in my family, I'm sorry to say!

AmazingSnakeHead · 16/10/2023 13:51

Are you fucking kidding me? Have you seen a single photo of Gaza from before the bombing? They are very far away from having "nice things" like Selfridges, a farmer's market, tapas restaurants. What the fuck even is that list? I guess you're trying to be funny, but implying that people who are currently having bombs dropped on them would be fine if they just had a farmer's market to go to is insensitive at best. The people there want clean water, enough food and a safe homeland. The people of Israel also want a safe homeland.

And for the people of Israel, the participation of some countries in at least one war saved the lives of the entire country, and of every Jewish person who lives outside of Israel too. What should Israel (or Palestine for that matter) do in response to attacks, just bury their dead and go and eat some tapas?

Also look at America. They wage lots of wars, and have lots of nice things.

DistrictAndCircle · 16/10/2023 13:50

“Let’s not have wars” is fine. Until someone invades your country. And then what? You either let them have it, or you fight back and there is a war.

The problem isn’t war, it’s aggression.

daytriptovulcan · 16/10/2023 13:47

We live in the age of stupidity, and the older folks who connected us to the horror of WW2 are fewer and fewer.
Ultimately they 'll just have to find a way to live together (you know who you are). May as well start now or soon, rather than wait another 70 years

therealcookiemonster · 16/10/2023 13:38

@RainbowRuby you are probably right... the people I know had parents who immigrated in the 60s/70s from rural areas so they probably haven't engaged with these more recent discussions. my friend's dad actually sat me down and told me everything I know is wrong because 'he knew people in the army'. he is the sweetest, loveliest man so I just smiled and nodded.

tbh each nation has its dark secrets. its not like the various 'leaders' of Pakistan have treated their own people very well!

SilverCatStripes · 16/10/2023 13:34

SecretAgent00777 · 16/10/2023 13:18

Surely a lot of wars like the current Israeli/Palestine war and the war/troubles in Northern Ireland are caused because one group has power, dominance and control over another group and treat them like shit.

Eventually those being treated like shit will lash out in a violent manner because the dominant group have ignored their pleas for equality and fairness.

This analogy doesn’t work though because the other side aren’t calling for ‘equality and fairness’ they are calling the annihilation of the dominant group.

Hamas are no different to Daesh , they would see every single non Sunni Muslim wiped from the Earth and consider that equality and fairness - so how do you propose a peaceful co existence with people who wish you dead?

frustratedinlaw · 16/10/2023 13:31

@Caketothemilk careful with statements like that, they err exceptionally close to “Jewish conspiracy” ideology, and we all know who else pushed that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread