Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Messages. AIBU or is he?

339 replies

welshprincess1975 · 15/10/2023 14:13

Hello all.

Posted here for traffic.

Long time lurker.

Married for 12 years to H with 2 girls.

Went on his phone last night to check banking and found messages between him and a mutual friend.

Backstory
She is 17 years younger than us and has been a friend for over a decade. She is married and all are part of a larger friend group.

These messages seem to have been going on for over 2 years.
Lots of "xxx" on messages. Flirting, sex talk, photos (underwear etc from both) and everyday talk as well as more intimate deeper conversations. Even going as far as to say that he thinks they are more than friends and that they are each others person.
Every day and multiple times a day. Always starts with good morning and ends with night night.

He says it's friend talk and I'm overreacting and I think it's inappropriate and want him to block her.

OP posts:
Pinkshoppingbag · 15/10/2023 21:06

What would he say if you were messaging a male friend talking about being on your knees? Ask him that.

Angrywife · 15/10/2023 21:05

Ask him if he would be happy for his son in law to behave like he has, treat his daughters as he is treating you.

momtoboys · 15/10/2023 21:02

Come on. You know you are not being unreasonable. Where there is smoke, there is usually fire!

Optionyougot · 15/10/2023 21:00

Why and how does a marriage come to the point where one person in it is invested in someone else?

It gets to that point when the person you refuse to cast "moral judgement" on decides a flirtation is worth more than his vows, the trust of his wife and the feelings of all those who love him.

OrangesLemonsLimes · 15/10/2023 20:58

Yes, keep a dignified silence on the WhatsApp group and initiate no communication with her husband. You can keep this amongst yourselves - it won’t need to come out into general knowledge because she won’t leave her husband for yours, she’s just toying with him. And if it does somehow come out, believe me when I say that it does not reflect badly on you! Focus on your own welfare and that of your children. From your username I think you live in Wales - are prenups a thing there? In England they are not really binding which is why I ask.

ErniesGhostlyGoldTops · 15/10/2023 20:58

Your marriage is so over.

See a lawyer. Let her have him and the pleasure of being with a cheater.

SpudleyLass · 15/10/2023 20:54

Nimello · 15/10/2023 20:48

I wouldn't give a single second's thought to any group WhatsApp (but I am too old for that shit, thank God).

The only thing that matters, @welshprincess1975, is your own family.

I disagree with PP who say you should contact the woman's partner. He relationship with her partner is for her to sort out. She is irrelevant - all this crap from him about her being 'the one' is bollocks, and I would guess that if it hadn't been her, it would have been someone else. Your focus should be on your daughters and yourself.

What is best for them, and for you?

I am not going to cast moral judgement on your husband, as relationships are complicated and the only people who know what's going on are the two people who are actually in the primary relationship. Why and how does a marriage come to the point where one person in it is invested in someone else?

But you need to think with your head about what's best for the three of you, and act accordingly.

''I am not going to cast moral judgement on your husband''

I mean....the man is telling this other woman who I actually don't think has much interest in him beyond the attention she is currently getting, that he thinks about her during sex and that OP can't make him maintain an erection.

People who cheat physically put their partners at risk of venereal diseases. I don't think this ''friend' would go there, but it appears he would. He would have such disregard for his own wife, that he would actively choose this risk for her.

I'm judging. Hard.

Nimello · 15/10/2023 20:49

Blinkingbonkers · 15/10/2023 20:47

“Hi WhatsApp group, we’re away at the moment but I’ve found a large number of messages between dh & X including underwear photos and discussions of dh picturing X whilst being intimate with me, I’m being told this is normal - please may I ask if any of you indulge in this behaviour with other peoples husbands/wives on the group so I can gauge whether my reaction is justified? Ta, @welshprincess1975
💐💐💐OP

And please don't do this. You are better than that. Dignified silence is the only thing you need while you work out what is best for you and your daughters.

Nimello · 15/10/2023 20:48

I wouldn't give a single second's thought to any group WhatsApp (but I am too old for that shit, thank God).

The only thing that matters, @welshprincess1975, is your own family.

I disagree with PP who say you should contact the woman's partner. He relationship with her partner is for her to sort out. She is irrelevant - all this crap from him about her being 'the one' is bollocks, and I would guess that if it hadn't been her, it would have been someone else. Your focus should be on your daughters and yourself.

What is best for them, and for you?

I am not going to cast moral judgement on your husband, as relationships are complicated and the only people who know what's going on are the two people who are actually in the primary relationship. Why and how does a marriage come to the point where one person in it is invested in someone else?

But you need to think with your head about what's best for the three of you, and act accordingly.

Blinkingbonkers · 15/10/2023 20:47

“Hi WhatsApp group, we’re away at the moment but I’ve found a large number of messages between dh & X including underwear photos and discussions of dh picturing X whilst being intimate with me, I’m being told this is normal - please may I ask if any of you indulge in this behaviour with other peoples husbands/wives on the group so I can gauge whether my reaction is justified? Ta, @welshprincess1975
💐💐💐OP

WowOK · 15/10/2023 20:44

@welshprincess1975 this is not how friends talk to each other. I would never talk in sexual way to my best friend (who is male). I wouldn't even think about him in a sexual way. I don't view him like that.

If a man ever approached me in this manner I would immediately tell him that its inappropriate and distance myself from that friendship. Your H and this woman haven't don't that. They have engaged in sex talk and building an intimate relationship. It's disrespectful. I would view it as cheating. I would view the secret sharing and intimacy as worse than a onenoff shag because its deeper on more heartfelt. I would guess that they have been having sex because no one talks about this shit for years without doing something.

You need to take legal advice. I personally would divorce him. I know your worried about him using your bipolar against you. I know your worried about him fighting and winning custody of the girls. Ultimately, I don't see the alternative of leaving him. He'll just continue cheating which will ruin your mental health and self esteem. He's not taking responsibility on recognising his behaviour is wrong so he'll just continue and blow smoke up your arse and act like your crazy and irrational. Honestly, he will use the kids, money and your mental health to manipulate you but realistically you can't trust him, he doest respect you and he only has his own interests and dick at the forefront of his mind.

welshprincess1975 · 15/10/2023 20:37

As we are still away it's difficult to do anything.
But he hasn't spoken and is on his phone.

Our group WhatsApp is going off wondering where we're have vanished to

OP posts:
welshprincess1975 · 15/10/2023 20:36

She has commented about whether I know and what I would think. And that if he isn't happy to leave. It seemed at the beginning she was on my side. But he made me sound almost abusive

OP posts:
CleaningAngel · 15/10/2023 20:35

I should be speaking to her if I were you, that's not normal. Is her husband/partner aware of what she's doing?

itsmyp4rty · 15/10/2023 20:33

Suggest all the messages are shared with the large friendship group to see if they agree that it is just friendly banter. What a fucking arsehole, I'm so sorry OP.

Goldbar31 · 15/10/2023 20:33

Block her?
Why are you not packing his bags!
I’m sorry that you are going through this.

Solonge · 15/10/2023 20:27

It doesnt matter whats in his name alone, you are married and have chikdren, you would get probably half or not much under. A pre nup not appkicable after kids and he would be required to provide child support, though you would need to get a job. Tell him you have decided to ask the couple round to discuss the messages, so its all out in the open and her husband knows too.

SpudleyLass · 15/10/2023 20:24

She ultimately does not matter. He has shown time and time again in those messages and now he is denying it all to your face despite the evidence of your own eyes, that he has no respect for you.

I don't think a marriage can survive that, even if you want it to.

This is clear cut to me. I'd be getting out of Dodge, sending the evidence to her husband too and probably to the family/friends Whatsapp groups so nothing can be twisted and seeking legal advice with a view to divorce.

As for your daughters being Daddy girls, I can only say that as a child of divorce, I found the toxic parent always outed themselves in one way or another. Its a matter of time before they discover his true character.

Livelovebehappy · 15/10/2023 20:23

He’s gas lighting you definitely. And I know you are trying to talk yourself into believing him, because he’s always been the perfect husband and you don’t want to lose that, so your head is trying to justify what he was doing because you really want to believe what he’s telling you. Say to him that if he thinks you’re over reacting, that he won’t mind then if you share the messages with her dh, as clearly he too will think it’s fine. I bet he will go into panic if he thinks his messages will be shown to her partner, as he knows they’re not appropriate, and he will be as shocked as you. If he actually apologises to you and admits to having an emotional affair, at least you have something to work on and can both sit down to discuss what he intends to do to make things up to you and put things right. If he doesn’t even admit to behaving badly and continues to gaslight you, it’s going to be very difficult to resolve it.

Solonge · 15/10/2023 20:18

Absolutely unreasonable of him! Ask him how he would feel if it were you exchanging underwear photos and sex talk with another man on the phone….or suggest the four of you go for drinks and share the phone conversations with you and her husband….i would be looking to asking him to leave.

MrsMarzetti · 15/10/2023 20:15

If they are just friends, is your Husband happy enough to go round and see her Husband and show him the messages ? I bet bloody not. Hope you sent the messages to yourself and have the sense to divorce him.

Joeylove88 · 15/10/2023 20:12

I'm sorry you are going through this, but your H is completely taking the piss out of you. He's basically having an emotional affair and should be ashamed of himself for even trying to pass this off as just a friendship. To say that he thinks her and him are eachothers person?! That's not a friendship OP. Oh and he won't delete her from his life so does he expect to continue this 'friendship' even though you now know and are hurt by all of this? The choice is yours but I personally wouldn't trust him one bit after this! You can choose to stay but you will be setting yourself up for misery and paranoia. You would be better off chucking him out on his ass he doesn't deserve you.

Nimello · 15/10/2023 20:10

NettleTea · 15/10/2023 17:23

the pre-nup will be meaningless, because youve been married a long time and have had children.

Do you work, or have you been a SAHP? apart from 'fun dad' stuff, is he involved in all the day to day boring parts of being a parent? ie does he take parental leave if they are sick, make hospital appointments, keep on top of homework/buying presents for other kids parties , keeping an eye on and replacing outgrown clothes/shoes etc

Would he realistically be able to parent even 50-50 with his big paying job - and that doesnt mean bringing in paid childcare to cover things that you would be willing and able to do.

In divorce its the one time that the unpaid labour that women do with children actually has some financial acknowledgement. The starting point is 50-50 for all assets/pensions/savings/property if the marriage is well established, and 50-50 for custody. Realistically most men dont go for this, which gives the woman less future earning capacity, so some of those assets get reallocated to balance things up a bit - plus they like to keep the status quo as far as their lives go.

Id not worry about the 'I came in with nothing' and pre-nup situation. Prenups done, I believe, hold water in the UK

Obviously a solicitor would need to know more of the actual details of this specific situation - but this is a very sound post (it's a 'child arrangement order' rather than 'custody' if you're in the UK, but it means the same in effect).

The needs of the children from the marriage are paramount, and they override any pre-existing financial agreement with your husband. If you have been more involved in the children's day-to-day care, you would be likely to end up with a slightly larger share of the assets as the children would be spending more time with you.

Even if you don't read anything else, @welshprincess1975, read this one.

Your alternative, obviously, is for your husband to admit that he has crossed a line here, and for you both to have counselling in an attempt to save your marriage. He would, however, have to accept responsibility and would have to be entirely committed to rectifying things. As he's denying there's a problem, that could be difficult.

The third option is to switch your feelings off and carry on anyway, so that your daughters' lives remain unchanged on the face of it. You wouldn't be the first woman to overlook her husband's "indiscretion" if you did that. But it's a risky game, as it would take a massive toll on your mental health and wellbeing, and you would also always be looking over your shoulder wondering if he was still wanting her - or if there was someone else in the picture.

I would personally try to save the marriage, if he's willing to engage properly with this, because divorce is hell on earth even if you end up with a fair settlement.

Letitgonowgr · 15/10/2023 20:10

Not sure how you could even ask who is BU! It’s clearly him. He’s having an affair telling his ‘friend’ he wants to have sex with her etc and you’re not sure if he’s in the wrong?!

TolkiensFallow · 15/10/2023 20:08

He said “he has to think of her to make it stay up” … horrific