Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most friendships are just situational

83 replies

Corsadrive · 15/10/2023 09:35

I’ve stayed in the same area my entire life, left school 20 years ago never went to uni, been a SAHM a lot of that time and worked very much part time for most of the rest. I’ve not really ‘lost’ friends over the years as I’ve always just had a few mates from school who I stayed friends with and then a few people I met through the school when my own DC were in primary. However, my DC are now 25, 23 and 17 respectively and all three have had a very different experience to me (the two eldest have moved away to uni and now graduated and the youngest still has a year of college left) and therefore have all moved between part time jobs, school to college to Uni, then to grad jobs etc. I was talking to them last night (full house for the weekend) and they all agreed that most friendship’s aren’t real and just ‘situational’ in the sense they only last whilst two people are in the same situation eg two colleagues can superficially be close but as soon as one leaves the job they drift. Anecdotally, my own DC who aren’t that old only still talk to about 2 or 3 people each from their secondary school friendship groups. Aibu to feel sad but agree with my DC that most friendships are situational?

OP posts:
Mummy08m · 15/10/2023 10:00

I think situational friends certainly serve an important purpose and can be celebrated anyway. And looked back on fondly later down the line.

I agree with this 100%.

I used to feel so sad when my friendships faded whenever my situation changed. But I accept it now.

I think, if you want long term friendships (I mean ten years plus) then you have to try hard to maintain a static situation. For example, stay in the same job for many years. Or live in a small village where people know each other for multiple generations. You also have to be prepared to get close to people out of proximity rather than having things in common (like neighbours).

Those options just don't work for me. So I'm resigned that my friendships will come and go, I can still enjoy them while they last. At least I have my husband, and my husband's friends have been quite static.

Warum · 15/10/2023 10:00

Agreed.
I don't actively 'end' many friendships but I've also had situations where we both don't do much to stop them drifting away. The good times were good and the memories are there, but both of us have moved on (physically or in other ways).
I've never needed to be part of a large circle though.

TheaBrandt · 15/10/2023 09:58

Arguably family are situational too as they are in your life as they just happen to be your mother / sister etc?!

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with friendships being situational. It’s great to have people at a similar life stage helping each other out. I really value my local friends we supported each other through toddler years and doing same now they are teens.

QueSyrahSyrah · 15/10/2023 09:55

Most are, but not all. One of my dearest friends dates back to the start of secondary school but we've not lived in the same town since we were 17 (we're now 39).

I have two friends on the other side of the world now that I met in my 20s and while we're not 'speak every day' close we can just pick up where we left off after months, as thick as thieves.

On the other hand, there've been plenty of others who have come and go over the years. Sometimes a Facebook memory will pop up and it'll take me a second to place a name in the comments.

WeightoftheWorld · 15/10/2023 09:54

Yes this is definitely true and one of the reasons I think why DH and I are so family-orientated. We were both brought up like that too, my DF always used to tell me and my siblings as kids that friends come and go but family is forever and encouraged us to be kind and supportive of one another. Obviously that's simplistic and some family members can behave terribly (my DH's own parents for example, and one of my siblings, so it's not that we have no experience of that!). Likewise some friends can be long term and very close, again we have some of these. But in general terms I think he was/is right.

Having said that, I think situational friends certainly serve an important purpose and can be celebrated anyway. And looked back on fondly later down the line.

CobwebsAndCauldrons · 15/10/2023 09:47

Yep I think most are. But not all.

I have two friends who started out that way but who I stay in touch with and visit/see regularly, despite our lives being in very different places - literally and figuratively.

DyslexicPoster · 15/10/2023 09:47

Yes I agree. There's only a few friends who stick around for life and they take effort to keep going from both sides.

I'm finding right now I got fed up of situational friendships after a mum friend dumped me when her child started a new school. She only has one long term friend and the rest are rapidly churned over. I don't want friends like that. I do wonder how she copes now her kids are both in secondary

minipie · 15/10/2023 09:40

My experience is that when you meet a group of people through a new stage of life, there will be one/two/maybe three you really click with and will keep in touch even after the time has passed… and the other 90% are perfectly nice but you wouldn’t bother keeping up if you didn’t see them day to day.

So broadly yes I agree with you