Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most friendships are just situational

83 replies

Corsadrive · 15/10/2023 09:35

I’ve stayed in the same area my entire life, left school 20 years ago never went to uni, been a SAHM a lot of that time and worked very much part time for most of the rest. I’ve not really ‘lost’ friends over the years as I’ve always just had a few mates from school who I stayed friends with and then a few people I met through the school when my own DC were in primary. However, my DC are now 25, 23 and 17 respectively and all three have had a very different experience to me (the two eldest have moved away to uni and now graduated and the youngest still has a year of college left) and therefore have all moved between part time jobs, school to college to Uni, then to grad jobs etc. I was talking to them last night (full house for the weekend) and they all agreed that most friendship’s aren’t real and just ‘situational’ in the sense they only last whilst two people are in the same situation eg two colleagues can superficially be close but as soon as one leaves the job they drift. Anecdotally, my own DC who aren’t that old only still talk to about 2 or 3 people each from their secondary school friendship groups. Aibu to feel sad but agree with my DC that most friendships are situational?

OP posts:
Strawberriesandpears · 30/10/2023 22:28

I'm facing a future (especially in old age) without any family at all (only child, probably too late to have children of my own as I am 36) so I really hope I can develop some close friendships, but threads like this make me doubtful.

I am terrified of being all alone in my older years.

Celia24 · 30/10/2023 22:27

Yes and no. I left another European country four years ago and have kept up two friendships. I worried they wouldn't be bothered after I left but both have visited me/kept in touch and I do likewise a couple of times a year. We have hobbies, values and many shared memories in common.

I'm lucky enough to be able to travel and also work remotely so I can split my time to an extent between where I am now and my former country.

I've had plenty of situational friendships die out and am fine with it mostly. Others I wanted to keep in touch with but they saw our friendship as situational.

PegasusReturns · 30/10/2023 22:23

Most friends come and go but a minority are around forever and are far more than situational. But you have to put the effort in and work at them.

If I think of attendees at my teen/adult birthdays/events over the past three decades 60% are acquaintances that I broadly stay in touch with, 20% are friends who are there decade after decade and 20% are colleagues/neighbours/parents of DC who might be around a year or two.

MsCactus · 30/10/2023 22:18

I have a group of about 8 uni friends I still see fairly regular (graduated 12 years ago). I also have two school friends I'm close with - three/four friends from my first job, five from my second (was at each company for five years).

So yes, lots are situational, but usually there's one or two from each sphere of life that I keep long term. I like situational friends though - I have plenty of "real" friends too. And tbh I really value both types - they make life more fun!

NineteenOhEight · 30/10/2023 22:15

Respectfully, OP, a lot of Mners are just not very good at making or maintaining friendships, so it’s not really the place to come to get a variety of opinions on friendship types or duration.

JamSandle · 30/10/2023 22:14

People move around so much I think. But friendship is so important.

theduchessofspork · 30/10/2023 22:11

Yes but I don’t think it’s sad - you can only have a few v close friends, but it will be dull if there weren’t lots of people moving through your life.

There is a saying that friends are with you for a reason, a season or a lifetime. I’d also say that some brief friendships can still have a long term impact on you.

jlpth · 30/10/2023 22:06

Well, I’m a bit on the fence. It’s hard, in terms of time and practicalities (particularly when you have kids) to keep up with friendships when you move situation. That’s why they drift IMO.

tunainatin · 30/10/2023 22:02

I don't think my friendships are like this, partly as i like being alone a lot so I don't really need people to just hang out with. I tend to make strong heart connections with certain people and maintain those, so I have very long friendships with people from many places. But might not see them very often.

SoIRejoined · 30/10/2023 21:53

There's nothing wrong with friendships bring situational though. You would be worn out if you stayed friends with everyone from school, work etc who no longer moves in your circles. It's nice to get on with people you see often and enjoy fun times together. It's also nice to have a few special friends who you stick with for life wherever they are, but you can only have a small number of those.

Dedicated11 · 30/10/2023 21:44

Sadly OP I agree. It’s sad but it’s life.

MooncakeConnoisseur · 15/10/2023 13:27

I’d say 90% of friendships are situational. My definition of friendship is perhaps a bit stricter though as what many call “friends” I’d call “acquaintances”.

For me I’d say I have 3 genuine lifelong friends. One I talk to daily, even if it is just via text, and two I talk to once a week at least. I feel completely comfortable around these people and I know they’ll have my back whenever and vice versa.

As for the rest they’re often friendships of convenience. It’s not something deliberate but it’s just how it goes if we no longer work together or play the same sport together. It takes an incredibly amount of effort to maintain a friendship and we’re still friendly, don’t get me wrong, but I wouldn’t necessarily consider us friends after that.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 15/10/2023 13:19

I´m 30 and still very close to friend from first grade.

We have lived in different towns since we were (young) teens, went to different schools, unis, different careers etc. and still remain very close friends.

But most friendships are situational ime, yes.

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2023 13:13

Yes, as you go through the various stages of life you will make lots of friends but only a small number from each situation will endure, I think. But that's OK!

And if you do meet someone you really like you need to put the work in - making the effort to keep in touch and arrange meet-ups which might not always be totally convenient, or what you feel like doing at the time.

Keep your friendships in good repair is a motto someone told me, and I agree. They will wither and die if you don't feed them and take the trouble. Good friends are like gold-dust.

Goldfish41 · 15/10/2023 12:59

This makes me so sad!!! No I don’t think that at all. I have had friendships that I consider situational, but they make up a very very small percentage of my friendships. I have a lot of deep friendships dating back decades (to childhood, to uni, to various other “situations”, that I have taken on with me through the years and make an effort to keep up despite the fact that we’re in completely different situations now. The shallower acquaintances haven’t lasted but those aren’t the relationships I’ve spent time cultivating.

I guess this may not be the case for everyone, reading this, so perhaps I am very lucky. I am somewhat of an introvert so I’ve never been a social butterfly but instead focused on individual bonds, maybe that’s something to do with it. But no I think YABU, gently, because it certainly doesn’t have to be that way if you find the right friendships.

YokoOnosBigHat · 15/10/2023 12:59

margotrose · 15/10/2023 11:55

I don't disagree but thinking about this, how does that "one" friendship most of us have from school work?

I know very, very few people who are still in close contact with people they went to school with. All my school friendships faded/disappeared once we went off to university and moved to different parts of the country.

We're still vaguely in touch via social media but I wouldn't describe any of us as close anymore.

@margotrose Isn't that weird- I can't think of many people I know/have known where that wasn't the case. I wonder if you and I are in wildly different social/class groups or something.

Burgundylover · 15/10/2023 12:57

I am a pensioner and have friends going back to school days. You could still call these friends situational. Looking back, I can see that generally we were very close at school, drifted when setting up home, getting married, pursuing careers etc. We became close again when we were SAHMs, as we had more time. Closeness has also depended on how near or far we move to. As the DC grew up and we returned to work and busier lives, we drifted again. Now we are retired, we see each other more often.

Tiredalwaystired · 15/10/2023 12:52

In part but I don’t think that’s something to feel sad about. I’ve met loads of lovely people over the years through work for example, but once I’ve moved on from a job there are very few that have remained friends forever.

Same with education and hobbies. A few stick, most don’t. But my life has been richer for all of them. And the ones that have stuck are gold.

SallyWD · 15/10/2023 12:17

Not my experience. I tend to have a few quality friendships rather than lots of superficial friendships (sorry if that sounds smug! But I'm a introvert so it's how my relationships are). I've moved around a lot and my friendships do last. I have close friends from every place I've lived. Of course, I've lost track with some acquaintances, old colleagues etc but I suppose they were never close friends in the first place.

ComeOnThenFanny · 15/10/2023 12:13

I was told once that people come into your life for "a reason, a season, or a lifetime" and I think that's very true.

I'm 53 now, and although I stay in touch with close friends from school or previous jobs etc, we're not close, and we don't see each other. But I moved 200 miles away from my hometown almost 20 years ago, so that makes a difference too.

NineteenOhEight · 15/10/2023 12:13

cremona · 15/10/2023 11:02

Well if you make the decision that you’re going to invest in/prioritise family relationships most, and treat friendships as less important, then you’ve sort of stacked the decks as to which relationships in your life are going to last, haven’t you?

Agreed. The OP is giving her children a script about what relationships are prioritised and enduring, which becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

I grew up with some very odd scripts about friendships from my mother, a socially-anxious people-pleaser, but actively worked to shed them in young adulthood. To this day, she’s baffled by my enduring friendships, because in her view I do everything ‘wrong’ (I don’t people-please, I refuse some invitations that don’t work for me, I don’t pretend to agree with beliefs I don’t share, I’m not an endlessly available suffering sponge, I don’t befriend everyone who wants to befriend me etc etc.)

SaracensMavericks · 15/10/2023 12:06

I disagree. I'm nearly 50 and I still have school friends, university friends and friends from a job I left 18 years ago, despite the fact that I no longer live in the cities I went to school / uni / worked in.

margotrose · 15/10/2023 11:55

I don't disagree but thinking about this, how does that "one" friendship most of us have from school work?

I know very, very few people who are still in close contact with people they went to school with. All my school friendships faded/disappeared once we went off to university and moved to different parts of the country.

We're still vaguely in touch via social media but I wouldn't describe any of us as close anymore.

TheaBrandt · 15/10/2023 11:50

And frankly when you have a toddler and a baby you want a lovely pal round the corner in the same boat to go to the park with. The lovely mum in your old city who now requires a big effort and a whole weekend stay to see is less appealing …so don’t think people can be blamed really.

User0000009 · 15/10/2023 11:50

I think it depends on who you meet and how you feel about that person in the “situation”. I don’t have a group of friends. It’s not something I crave but I do have two special people; one I’ve known 50 years and the other 40. People I know really well and not ships that pass in the night.