Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Britain should start growing it’s own food again?

206 replies

Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 08:33

The situation in the Ukraine clearly isn’t going to resolve any time soon. The lack of grain from Ukraine is pushing prices higher. Add in further political instability in other parts of the world to the mix. We are always told that IK farming isn’t competitive but with the rising prices, it can be and furthermore; having home grown produce is seeming like it will be more necessary in the future. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
mumda · 15/10/2023 11:38

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/10/2023 08:51

I often wonder why on earth we import so many tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers etc. from the Netherlands - a small country with the same climate as the S of the U.K. Answer, presumably because growing a lot more here would need an awful lot of polytunnels, which are loathed by NIMBYs.

They will have less to sell or it'll cost more.
They use gas heated greenhouses for food production.

ChevyCamaro · 15/10/2023 11:31

I used to grow vegetables, but the climate changes made it much harder. There would be a whole month of rain in February, turning soil in mud. Then no rain at all through April, meaning having to water every day. Excessive heat through July and incredibly wet Autumn. The UK used to have an ideal climate for so many fruits and vegetables - bit of sun, gentle showers all year long. Not anymore.
I might try again, but a more self reliant country would take everyone trying, on every bit of land they have, and I agree with the pp who said most people just turn their outdoor space into sterile rooms with plastic sofas. Or hard standing for parking. Most people have no sense of what it takes to grow food, what is in season, why pollinators are important or how the wonky weather is affecting the availability of food.
I find it very scary.

Maddy70 · 15/10/2023 11:30

Notcookie · 15/10/2023 08:34

Don't vote Labour then as they want to build on farmland.

People also need to be housed!

There are more golf courses than housing per acre

The problem is too big really. We did not have the right climate for many crops so we will always need to trade with other countries

Angrycat2768 · 15/10/2023 11:29

Brenna24 · 15/10/2023 09:04

I live right on the east coast of Scotland, 60 miles north of Edinburgh. The local estate grows oats, wheat and barley in fields that run down to the beach. We can definitely grow wheat in this country.

Yes thats what I thought. Bread was a staple in the Middle Ages. Im not sure how much was made with wheat imported from Ukraine! Itb mush have been able to be grown here. Granted we have a much larger population, so probably didnt produce as much, but the population fed itself with the carb available ( bread here, rice in Asia)

magicmole · 15/10/2023 11:21

Plannersareus · 15/10/2023 10:08

Agricultural land is classified into grades and you can't build on a lot of it. Also not all land you see is agricultural land or fit for growing.

Edited

You can lose it for the next 40 years to a solar farm though. I'm in one England's most productive growing areas and there are some big chunks of growing land that are being given over to solar.

And it's typically land that's ALC Grade 1-3. I'm guessing from your name/comment you already know what that means. For those who don't, it ranges from the very best land that has no limitations on what can be grown on it, down to land that consistently produces moderate to high yields but of a narrower range of crops. In other words, you can grow food on it.

At planning I've repeatedly seen councillors and communities wrestling with the dilemma of needing to produce renewable energy AND needing to produce food. One council near me has now come down on the side of food production after they approved several solar projects one after another but then several more appeared. Other councils have not.

FWIW I've already got some back garden solar and am saving my pennies to cover the roof so I'm not being an anti-renewables NIMBY here. We need solar as part of our energy mix. But we also need food and I don't think we've got the balance right at the moment.

Every hectare of productive arable that goes to energy production could mean more reliance on food imports. And if overseas supplies are disrupted, countries will feed their own people before they feed the UK. Let's not kid ourselves either that all the schemes are about saving the planet: it can be far more lucrative for landowners to produce energy than to grow food. I've also seen some play down land as "only" Grade 3 in applications even though it's land that has been successfully producing tonnes of food for generations.

At least though, there's a chance the land can revert to agri use in a few decades. We can't say the same when the land becomes a housing estate!

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:19

(That was for Random Buttons but I can't c&p on my phone) ^

NetZeroZealot · 15/10/2023 11:19

Pasta is made from durum wheat which is difficult to grow in this country

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:18

Then we try to stop growing crops on the ungrowable and allow nature to return to these areas instead. Sheep are devastating for upland biodiversity, and produce very very little food per acre.

You've heard of Knepp? Even with a lot of capital, they could not make arable farming on their lowland clay estate work, financially speaking. So they chucked in the towel and rewilded, producing a small amount of very high quality beef and pork and creating an ecological success story.

Gallowayan · 15/10/2023 11:17

Nobody likes a smart ass and there is no need to state the obvious. I does supplement the food supply in a small way. I produce 10% of my own food so that means 10% more for someone else.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 15/10/2023 11:16

It's not just the land availability, it's the labour, the processing and the distribution systems.
Much of the wheat we grow is low grade, because of our weather, we can't get decent yield from the high quality varieties which need more sun. So wheat for bread and pasta generally isn't UK grown.
Goodbye to rice too. And a lot of fruit. And veg, apart from roots, in the winter.
A lot of the land we grow grass on isn't much good for growing anything else - too cold, too wet, too steep. But we're very good at growing grass which is why we are good at meat and dairy.
I think our first step needs to be cutting food waste at all points along the chain from farm to fork.

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 15/10/2023 11:16

How does organic farming waste land?

I buy organic and get all sorts of random shaped and sized fruit and veg. I thought this was less wasteful than supermarkets demanding uniform sized produce and discarding the rest. If you buy a supermarket punnet of cherry tomatoes, they're all perfectly round and the same size. The punnet I got last week had a mixture of big ones, little ones and a deformed one that looked like a boobie!

ExtraOnions · 15/10/2023 11:16

Until consumers are prepared to pay the proper cost of production (including wages for farmer / farm staff), we will be stuck with cheap imports, and a domestic industry on its knees.

I am pointing at the Supermarkets, who seem to be in a race to the bottom.

tenbob · 15/10/2023 11:15

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 11:11

It’s 100% fake. I know certified organic farms that have fields next to them that are not organic.

It’s quite eye opening that there are these sorts of rumours about organic farming

It seems like a very strange industry/movement to be taking shots at but several posters on here are talking very negatively about it, to the extent of confidentiality posting fake statements about it to back up the claim that it’s a cause of land wastage and therefore food insecurity

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 11:13

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:00

knittedcardi nearly all beef cattle are fed some kind of supplementary feed- 100% grass fed cows are extremely rare. The issue is also that the fields used to graze cattle could often be used to grow something else- cows are a very land hungry way to produce food!

There is such a thing as 100% regenerative beef. Friends of mine have a hardy, native breed herd that they graze on a national nature reserve all year round, helping to preserve the open heathland habitat. This is not how 99% of the UK's beef is produced!

The issue is lowland clay soil is impossible to grow crops on, but perfect for growing grass and raising cattle. Highlands (sun h as the vast majority of Wales) is impossible to grow crops on but perfect for sheep.

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 11:11

tenbob · 15/10/2023 10:58

I’m not sure the first bit is true

I’ve just had a very quick read of the rules for the UK, and they say you can’t ‘mosaic’ organic and non-organic fields within the same farm, but if you have organic and non-organic production on the same farm, they must be separated by a solid barrier such as a hedge or fence.

And for farms run as separate businesses, the rules don’t apply

I will read that book though, it sounds interesting

It’s 100% fake. I know certified organic farms that have fields next to them that are not organic.

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:10

(Although with a few tweaks we could probably be self sufficient in broad beans. Eat more broad beans, people! Highly nutritious, easy to grow in the UK (even by me) and actually really delicious if you turn them into falafel and burgers. This infomercial was brought to you by the British Broad Bean Marketing Bureau 😆)

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:07

We'd starve to death if we had to rely on my allotment to keep us fed 😆

Gallowayan · 15/10/2023 11:06

We do produce our own food. As we speak I am surrounded by pasture where sheep an cows are grazing.

Not as much land is under the plough though for the production grain and vegetables and you can feed more people pe acre of land from arable crops

In Ireland back in the day a family of six could feed themselves for a year with potatoes grown on an acre of land. As a previous poster has said we would all have to go back to a humbe unvaried diet for this to work.

The "Dig for Victory" effort during WW2 might be something we could do again i.e. digging up our gardens and parks to plant veg? There's a lot of interest in allomenting at the moment.

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:05

Also, our seas are massively overfished so there are a lot of catch quotas. Our fishing fleets are dominated by several large companies with massive boats that exploit loopholes in the law to fish in unsustainable ways, and small boats who usually fish in a more sustainable way don't get a look in.

Unithorn · 15/10/2023 11:01

Theunamedcat · 15/10/2023 10:24

If we have so much fish why can't I afford to buy it?

Because we live in a low wage economy, having cheap food for many years has meant that it hasn't been hugely problematic until now. Fish is still cheaper here than in many countries, but it's a fairer price for those in the supply chain than stuff like veg/eggs/milk in which this country happily fucks farmers over for.

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 11:00

knittedcardi nearly all beef cattle are fed some kind of supplementary feed- 100% grass fed cows are extremely rare. The issue is also that the fields used to graze cattle could often be used to grow something else- cows are a very land hungry way to produce food!

There is such a thing as 100% regenerative beef. Friends of mine have a hardy, native breed herd that they graze on a national nature reserve all year round, helping to preserve the open heathland habitat. This is not how 99% of the UK's beef is produced!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/10/2023 11:00

Spendonsend · 15/10/2023 09:24

We do have a massive green house at Thanet Earth. The produce tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers in the millions. I am sure we could see more of this.
But my understanding is it uses a lot of electricity and water to keep it running. I cant remember if they are sustainable with this yet. Probably.

I agree that Jeremy Clarksons farm was very interesting, despite him. Particularly his bit about how long the soil has left and what we need to do. But the financials of it are bonkers.

Presumably the the Netherlands will have the same issues with electricity/water etc.

I often see Thanet Earth produce and will always buy it (or other U.K. produce) rather than anything imported - if I have that choice.

Suring colder months I do try to rely largely on home grown veg - cabbage, sprouts, carrots, swede, etc., and white cabbage keeps so much better than lettuce and is great in salads, not just in coleslaw.

Why anyone buys those tasteless little baby sweetcorns flown in from e.g. Thailand,I have no idea - even if some daft stir fry recipe includes them. Masses of much more readily available veg - including all sorts of cabbage - is great in a stir fry.

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 11:00

KnittedCardi · 15/10/2023 10:53

I understood that most Beef and Lamb in the UK is grass fed. Obviously in the depths of Winter they need supplemental grain but generally grains grown here are for human consumption unless low grade?

Sheep generally graze grass out on fields all year round. Many dairy farms rent fields to sheep farmers through the winter. Cattle are fed cake (mostly soy/linseed) and silage through the winter. Cattle farmers will have fields they use to make silage.

Chickens eat mostly grain from what I understand.

Zebedee999 · 15/10/2023 10:59

I wish every park was surrounded by a perimeter of fruit trees of all sorts + hazlenuts, walnuts, blackberries/currants etc etc. The same with all hedgerows up and down the land, school playing fields etc.

If you are aware of what can be foraged, then there is a huge amount of free food along virtually every footpath if you know what to look for and how to cook it.

Years ago as kids after school we had to collect a basket full each but these skills are long forgotten and if you suggest foraging on the "save money" threads you're told you're some kind of Nazi as people have a right to supermarket provessed stuff.

This wouldn't feed 50% of the country but would help suplement what we already grow here and will help when the inevitable world wide famine hits one day.

tenbob · 15/10/2023 10:59

I’m still really interested to know how organic farming ‘wastes land’ though

Swipe left for the next trending thread