Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Britain should start growing it’s own food again?

206 replies

Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 08:33

The situation in the Ukraine clearly isn’t going to resolve any time soon. The lack of grain from Ukraine is pushing prices higher. Add in further political instability in other parts of the world to the mix. We are always told that IK farming isn’t competitive but with the rising prices, it can be and furthermore; having home grown produce is seeming like it will be more necessary in the future. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Polis · 15/10/2023 15:22

Farmland isn't being built on ffs.

It is around here.

Havanananana · 15/10/2023 15:05

"Don't vote Labour then as they want to build on farmland."

Don't vote Conservative either as they have already signed trade deals with Australia and New Zealand that will allow the import of cheap meat that does not meet current British/EU standards and is from animals fed on feed that does not meet UK/EU standards and that have been treated with drugs that do not meet UK/EU standards. Trade deals that will put many British farmers out of business, and will have a negative impact on the businesses and communities that depend on farming for their prosperity (feedstuff suppliers, vets, agricultural machinery dealers, transport companies, food processing companies etc.).

NetZeroZealot · 15/10/2023 14:21

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 12:54

Pasta isn’t generally made in this county. It’s mostly imported ready made from Italy, from wheat grown in Italy. Italy seems very happy to keep selling it to us so I’m not entirely sure what your point is.

I was clarifying in response the post at 10.35 which quoted my earlier post re eating pasta imported from abroad.

Lots of grumpy people on MN today!

NetZeroZealot · 15/10/2023 14:14

magicmole · 15/10/2023 11:21

You can lose it for the next 40 years to a solar farm though. I'm in one England's most productive growing areas and there are some big chunks of growing land that are being given over to solar.

And it's typically land that's ALC Grade 1-3. I'm guessing from your name/comment you already know what that means. For those who don't, it ranges from the very best land that has no limitations on what can be grown on it, down to land that consistently produces moderate to high yields but of a narrower range of crops. In other words, you can grow food on it.

At planning I've repeatedly seen councillors and communities wrestling with the dilemma of needing to produce renewable energy AND needing to produce food. One council near me has now come down on the side of food production after they approved several solar projects one after another but then several more appeared. Other councils have not.

FWIW I've already got some back garden solar and am saving my pennies to cover the roof so I'm not being an anti-renewables NIMBY here. We need solar as part of our energy mix. But we also need food and I don't think we've got the balance right at the moment.

Every hectare of productive arable that goes to energy production could mean more reliance on food imports. And if overseas supplies are disrupted, countries will feed their own people before they feed the UK. Let's not kid ourselves either that all the schemes are about saving the planet: it can be far more lucrative for landowners to produce energy than to grow food. I've also seen some play down land as "only" Grade 3 in applications even though it's land that has been successfully producing tonnes of food for generations.

At least though, there's a chance the land can revert to agri use in a few decades. We can't say the same when the land becomes a housing estate!

Actually most solar farms are on lower grade land, because planning guidance is clear that there is a preference for land that is 3b or below. Would people rather that we are reliant on Putin for imported gas to generate electricity?
What about all the other non-food uses of farmland? Energy crops? Campsites? Horses? Golf courses? Should they all be stopped as well?
Solar panels currently take up about 0.1% of farmland. And they help farmers stay in business so they can continue to produce food on the rest of their land.

Emmalin · 15/10/2023 14:12

Sloth66 · 15/10/2023 08:55

This country hasn’t been self sufficient in food for well over a 100 years. Farmland is increasingly being built on with new housing estates

Farmland isn't being built on ffs. And only a very small proportion of our land is built on at all.

We lost a lot of our farmland centuries ago. It became country estates for gentry to introduce deer and pheasants for shooting purposes, and ride their bloody ponies on.

caringcarer · 15/10/2023 14:05

If you have a garden or allotment you can grow a lot of your own fruit and veg. During lockdown I started growing food in my back garden. Prior to that I just grew flowers. I've got apple and plum trees, raspberries, runner beans, potatoes, onions, carrots, rhubarb, salad leaves, tomatoes, strawberries peppers and chillis. My sister with no garden grows tomatoes and salad leaves in a grow bag on the edge of her back door. You can grow herbs in a patio pot or on your window sill.

caringcarer · 15/10/2023 13:59

Notcookie · 15/10/2023 08:34

Don't vote Labour then as they want to build on farmland.

They want to build on green belt not necessarily farm land. They want to reclassify some current green belt to brown belt.

OldPerson · 15/10/2023 13:37

Of course you're not being unreasonable. Under the good old EU farmers were paid huge subsidies (2.4 billion a year) for not producing food. Because all the food waste and disposing of the food waste in the 1970's and 80's was an embarrassment. No farming competition. No needs to invest in the future of farming. Laziness and corruption. Feeding cows sub-standard food that led to the "mad cows disease" CJV scandal in 1980's. Time all farmers started farming, and not just owning land they're paid to do nothing productive with. Not tarnishing the hard-working farmers, just the idle ones who lived off the EU non-productivity rewards and now want to sell their land to a Labour Government for housing.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 15/10/2023 13:15

I think the seafood/fish is a cultural thing. It's been generations since we've had the dietary habits & shopping time & culinary skills to make the most of our coastal resources. And our seas are still massively over-fished in an industrial fashion, so it's not something that we want to build back up to be honest.

What we need is a cross-party consensus on a long term sustainable land use framework.
And a serious move into producing alternative protein sources in an industrial fashion - urban fish farming, insects, yeast products. To supplement regenerative farming production.

CurlewKate · 15/10/2023 13:05

It'd be nice if we ate our own fish, to be honest. The fish that was such a big deal during Brexit but we won't buy?

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 15/10/2023 13:05

Most consumers apparently don't know that our shit already fertilises fields - with lots of testing & monitoring & rotation & harvest intervals.
Our sewerage infrastructure would be in an even more dire situation if disposal to land wasn't used.

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 12:58

Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 12:01

Lots of great points and interesting views on this thread:-
might be worth saying I was alluding to rising prices generally, which has been caused by a variety of factors.

Interesting that if I said this in France or Spain I would get a very different reaction to the mostly negative one here. I get they have different values, weather etc. As I said before, it’s a complex subject but the problems can be overcome.

Firmly tongue in cheek here but rather than dumping sewage in rivers and sea, maybe the Tories could add some nutrients to soil with it instead?

There have been in depth studies into using sewage as fertiliser. Killing bacteria can be a problem but it can be done. But the problem is basically consumers are mortified at the thought of it.

RosaGallica · 15/10/2023 12:55

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/10/2023 12:25

Saying organic farming wastes land isn’t very helpful language, but it’s certainly a less efficient use of land as the crops grown organically generally yield less output per hectare. For example wheat grown conventionally will yield around 8 tonnes per hectare, but wheat grown organically will barely make 5 tonnes. So you need almost twice as much land to grow the equivalent quantity. One could see that as wasteful, but either way it’s less efficient.

Efficiency can be measured in the short or long term, and organic farming may yet prove to be more efficient in the long term as soils are damaged and nutrients are depleted.

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 12:54

Pleaseme · 15/10/2023 12:37

Often the varieties of wheat grown in Scotland are destined for biscuit making or animal feed. There isn't enough sunshine to grow the kinds of wheat to make decent bread. Overall we grow more than 80% of our wheat which isn't bad atall.

And most our bread wheat is imported from Canada.

RandomButtons · 15/10/2023 12:54

NetZeroZealot · 15/10/2023 11:19

Pasta is made from durum wheat which is difficult to grow in this country

Pasta isn’t generally made in this county. It’s mostly imported ready made from Italy, from wheat grown in Italy. Italy seems very happy to keep selling it to us so I’m not entirely sure what your point is.

crackofdoom · 15/10/2023 12:43

Pleaseme time to go back to bannocks??

Pleaseme · 15/10/2023 12:37

Brenna24 · 15/10/2023 09:04

I live right on the east coast of Scotland, 60 miles north of Edinburgh. The local estate grows oats, wheat and barley in fields that run down to the beach. We can definitely grow wheat in this country.

Often the varieties of wheat grown in Scotland are destined for biscuit making or animal feed. There isn't enough sunshine to grow the kinds of wheat to make decent bread. Overall we grow more than 80% of our wheat which isn't bad atall.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/10/2023 12:25

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 15/10/2023 11:16

How does organic farming waste land?

I buy organic and get all sorts of random shaped and sized fruit and veg. I thought this was less wasteful than supermarkets demanding uniform sized produce and discarding the rest. If you buy a supermarket punnet of cherry tomatoes, they're all perfectly round and the same size. The punnet I got last week had a mixture of big ones, little ones and a deformed one that looked like a boobie!

Saying organic farming wastes land isn’t very helpful language, but it’s certainly a less efficient use of land as the crops grown organically generally yield less output per hectare. For example wheat grown conventionally will yield around 8 tonnes per hectare, but wheat grown organically will barely make 5 tonnes. So you need almost twice as much land to grow the equivalent quantity. One could see that as wasteful, but either way it’s less efficient.

Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 12:24

Magpiecomplex · 15/10/2023 12:08

@Vocaladvocaat Using sewage sludge cake as a soil amendment and fertiliser is standard practice.

Thanks, that’s really interesting!

OP posts:
Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 12:22

I am sure the interest in allotments etc is because people are struggling to feed their families. Have friends who constantly get food from their gardens (albeit limited choice) there is no question that you can grow a fair amount of food in a smallish area if you want to

OP posts:
RosaGallica · 15/10/2023 12:13

May be of interest:

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/united-kingdom-food-security-report-2021/united-kingdom-food-security-report-2021-theme-2-uk-food-supply-sources

We are in a fairly good situation re grains, wheat, barley and oats. As for ‘wasting’ land on organically grown food, or what our grandparents would have known as ‘food’, the real waste is on golf courses. More allotments would help too.

United Kingdom Food Security Report 2021: Theme 2: UK Food Supply Sources

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/united-kingdom-food-security-report-2021/united-kingdom-food-security-report-2021-theme-2-uk-food-supply-sources

Magpiecomplex · 15/10/2023 12:08

@Vocaladvocaat Using sewage sludge cake as a soil amendment and fertiliser is standard practice.

To think Britain should start growing it’s own food again?
Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 12:01

Lots of great points and interesting views on this thread:-
might be worth saying I was alluding to rising prices generally, which has been caused by a variety of factors.

Interesting that if I said this in France or Spain I would get a very different reaction to the mostly negative one here. I get they have different values, weather etc. As I said before, it’s a complex subject but the problems can be overcome.

Firmly tongue in cheek here but rather than dumping sewage in rivers and sea, maybe the Tories could add some nutrients to soil with it instead?

OP posts:
BlackForestCake · 15/10/2023 12:00

Sure we can be self-sufficient, if we all learn to be content with a diet of oats, turnips and herring. I don't think many people would agree to do that.

Havanananana · 15/10/2023 11:52

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/10/2023 08:51

I often wonder why on earth we import so many tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers etc. from the Netherlands - a small country with the same climate as the S of the U.K. Answer, presumably because growing a lot more here would need an awful lot of polytunnels, which are loathed by NIMBYs.

As anyone who has ever taken the ferry to the Hook of Holland and seen the farms located near the port will attest, produce in the Netherlands is grown in huge greenhouses, not in polytunnels.

This is possible because much of the land used for the greenhouses is reclaimed land, so it is flat and easy to site greenhouses on - try building these on a hillside. There is also a ready and clean supply of water, which is vital for these greenhouse crops. By contrast, much of the south of England has a shortage of water and is not particularly flat.