Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD- damaging friendship over a cot?

392 replies

Honestmummydearest · 15/10/2023 05:50

This is less of a AIBU and more of a WWYD because I genuinely don’t feel I have BU but would appreciate advice.

A few years ago we had our first born and bought a not inexpensive bedside cot, suitable for the early months. Served us well and when LO was ready, we packed it up and stored it away. A few months later DH’s friends got pregnant. Aware money was tight for them (and knowing I would have loved to have been on the receiving end) we lent it to DH’s friends, making it clear we planned for a second so would need it back at some point. They gratefully accepted.

Fast forward to today, the couple know I am now heavily pregnant with DC2 and whilst I have physically only briefly run into them on a few occasions in the interim, we are in touch via text with pleasantries, updates, birthday wishes etc. They have actively acknowledged how far I am along in my second pregnancy and said of course we can have the cot back ‘soon, but not yet’. We felt awkward pushing this and I still had a few weeks to go at that point so let it drop.

In an effort to force the point, we invited ourselves over yesterday and arrived with baby gifts etc even though their LO is now 8 months- this is really the first time we had properly met up. They gave us a tour of the house and I saw they still had the cot (so not sold or damaged) and were still actively using it. They clocked that I’d seen it and again thanked me and said we could have it back for DC2 ‘soon, but not today’.

I subtly dropped into conversation that our first had been out of the cot for several months at their LO’s age and we’d found an age appropriate, larger cot in a second hand shop for £20. They said oh yes, and there are lots of FB marketplace- they would pick one up. Soon, but not today.

I reminded that at this stage in both our respective earlier pregnancies our babies had already been born and I am expecting this one to be early too. Much head nodding and acknowledgment but no offer of when we’ll get the cot back.

I don’t believe there is any malice here- just perhaps a short sightedness on this couple’s part. I am disappointed, though, that we are being taken advantage of and have asked DH to message with an exact date in the coming week when he will be over to pick up the cot. Concerned we’ll get the same response: ‘Soon, but not yet’ and that I’ll go into labour without a cot for our newborn.

I’m not sure how much more direct I can be with them, without being rude. They are DH’s friends really and I am loathe to damage the friendship he has but have told him it’s on him to sort this out now. He needs to have a frank conversation with them, but in his defence, it’s not like either of us have been overly subtle!

AIBU/WWYD?

OP posts:
Sisterpita · 21/10/2023 10:22

@Honestmummydearest hope you have the cot safely back in your possession by the end of today.

Nanaof1 · 18/10/2023 18:43

@321user123

I am so glad it's not just me!

It really does boggle the mind, just boggles the mind!

321user123 · 18/10/2023 18:41

Nanaof1 · 18/10/2023 18:35

Thank you! I admire your patience. Me, I am just SMDH

I mean, I am reading that people kept their baby in it until 9-11 months old because of the "weight limit". It has nothing to do with weight limit. It is the weight limit, OR your child is pulling themselves into a sitting position or worse, a standing position. Unless their child has delayed development, their child was in the bedside cot a lot longer than was safe. These same parents would have wanted the company sued or they'd be all "what did I do wrong?" if their child had fallen out. They were negligent and are extremely lucky nothing happened.

And then telling the OP to go and "do what they would do"--" I’d be getting one of the cheap second hand ones OP is telling them to get off marketplace myself and using that until such time as they were naturally finished with the item." Except that the cot people are talking about the CFers needing to get is the bigger baby/tot cot not a bedside one. Are they trying to say that the OP's newborn should not have a bedside cot if it inconveniences the Cheeky Fers?

Sometimes, I really wonder about people. Is it lack of reading comprehension, lack of thought or just the need to be contrary?

Yh agree, people saying the OP should buy a new cot are insane.

it also really irks me when people don’t read the post, the amount of people saying “you’re unreasonable OP, you shouldn’t have given it at all, now they have to buy one, only used for 8 mo.. bla bla bla” is crazy, surely they can read???
the bloody thing is only safe for 6mo if that. (You may get an extra few weeks but still!)

Nanaof1 · 18/10/2023 18:35

Phoenixfire1988 · 18/10/2023 11:20

It's a bedside crib NOT a cot and they are inly suitable up to a certain age like once baby can roll etc .
She done them a favour now needs it back their lack of preparation is not her problem

Thank you! I admire your patience. Me, I am just SMDH

I mean, I am reading that people kept their baby in it until 9-11 months old because of the "weight limit". It has nothing to do with weight limit. It is the weight limit, OR your child is pulling themselves into a sitting position or worse, a standing position. Unless their child has delayed development, their child was in the bedside cot a lot longer than was safe. These same parents would have wanted the company sued or they'd be all "what did I do wrong?" if their child had fallen out. They were negligent and are extremely lucky nothing happened.

And then telling the OP to go and "do what they would do"--" I’d be getting one of the cheap second hand ones OP is telling them to get off marketplace myself and using that until such time as they were naturally finished with the item." Except that the cot people are talking about the CFers needing to get is the bigger baby/tot cot not a bedside one. Are they trying to say that the OP's newborn should not have a bedside cot if it inconveniences the Cheeky Fers?

Sometimes, I really wonder about people. Is it lack of reading comprehension, lack of thought or just the need to be contrary?

Sa11yCinnamon · 18/10/2023 15:17

I'm really surprised at some of the comments on this. A friend is lending me a bedside cot because she's planning to have a second baby when mine will be into a normal cot - so to me it's completely obvious that I'll give it back at a certain time. Even if she came to me and said "actually it's happened sooner than I thought, we'll need it back early" I'd make arrangements and get it back to her - because it's hers, not mine, and she'd have helped me out. Find it very hard to see how the OP has done anything wrong!

Passepartoute · 18/10/2023 11:35

Solibear · 17/10/2023 20:35

@Ssme92 it’s not 9 months, it’s probably more like 5 months between them announcing the pregnant and now (she isn’t full term yet), and her post says “a few weeks”. Still, I take your point. Maybe they’re delaying giving it back because they’re just not ready to be finished with it yet, and hoping OP will just buy a new one of her own because at the end of the day she’s not going to leave her newborn without a cot. Whatever the reason, they should give it back since OP has asked for it, but personally, if I had lent something like that to someone (financially struggling or not) and then it turned out I actually needed it after all, I wouldn’t ask for it back while they were still using it - I’d be getting one of the cheap second hand ones OP is telling them to get off marketplace myself and using that until such time as they were naturally finished with the item

With every respect, that would be truly nutty. The cot is not suitable or an 8 month old to use, the other parents have had plenty of time to prepare because they took it on the understanding that they would give it back when it was needed.

Passepartoute · 18/10/2023 11:32

QS90 · 17/10/2023 21:33

Perhaps, but in that case the conversation from the borrowers should go "So sorry, but we're having trouble with our LOs sleeping, so are reluctant to change cot atm. However, we appreciate you need a cot now, so please could we buy it off you? That way you can buy another". That is, honestly and fair. Not playing chicken with the due date, hoping the owners of the cot will just give up and pay out of pocket.

On that basis they can go out and buy a similar cot for themselves, rather than expect the 9 months pregnant woman to go out and do it.

Phoenixfire1988 · 18/10/2023 11:27

The entitlement from some people in this thread is astounding tbh !
Why should the op go and buy another crib when there is a perfectly good one there that BELONGS TO THEM they done the friends a favour and now they need the cot back end of story.
I'd message them and say DH will be over to collect the cot on x date this gives you time to sort an alternative .

Phoenixfire1988 · 18/10/2023 11:20

It's a bedside crib NOT a cot and they are inly suitable up to a certain age like once baby can roll etc .
She done them a favour now needs it back their lack of preparation is not her problem

Solibear · 17/10/2023 21:44

@QS90 I agree. I think the whole thing is primarily a communication breakdown on both sides

QS90 · 17/10/2023 21:33

Solibear · 17/10/2023 20:35

@Ssme92 it’s not 9 months, it’s probably more like 5 months between them announcing the pregnant and now (she isn’t full term yet), and her post says “a few weeks”. Still, I take your point. Maybe they’re delaying giving it back because they’re just not ready to be finished with it yet, and hoping OP will just buy a new one of her own because at the end of the day she’s not going to leave her newborn without a cot. Whatever the reason, they should give it back since OP has asked for it, but personally, if I had lent something like that to someone (financially struggling or not) and then it turned out I actually needed it after all, I wouldn’t ask for it back while they were still using it - I’d be getting one of the cheap second hand ones OP is telling them to get off marketplace myself and using that until such time as they were naturally finished with the item

Perhaps, but in that case the conversation from the borrowers should go "So sorry, but we're having trouble with our LOs sleeping, so are reluctant to change cot atm. However, we appreciate you need a cot now, so please could we buy it off you? That way you can buy another". That is, honestly and fair. Not playing chicken with the due date, hoping the owners of the cot will just give up and pay out of pocket.

QS90 · 17/10/2023 21:26

Don't even think about it, or use any emotional energy on it. Just tell then "we're coming over to tomorrow to pick it up because our baby is due". If they choose to be surly about it, you know what sort of people they are!

Sceptre86 · 17/10/2023 20:42

To be honest you've learnt a lesson here that no good deed goes unpunished. You know what they are like and shouldn't be handing them anything to use after you've had your dc2. They can buy off Facebook marketplace and vinted if indeed they are struggling for money. Of course it's your choice if you choose to reuse your mattress from your first child but I would buy new with the money you save on getting your cot back.

Solibear · 17/10/2023 20:35

@Ssme92 it’s not 9 months, it’s probably more like 5 months between them announcing the pregnant and now (she isn’t full term yet), and her post says “a few weeks”. Still, I take your point. Maybe they’re delaying giving it back because they’re just not ready to be finished with it yet, and hoping OP will just buy a new one of her own because at the end of the day she’s not going to leave her newborn without a cot. Whatever the reason, they should give it back since OP has asked for it, but personally, if I had lent something like that to someone (financially struggling or not) and then it turned out I actually needed it after all, I wouldn’t ask for it back while they were still using it - I’d be getting one of the cheap second hand ones OP is telling them to get off marketplace myself and using that until such time as they were naturally finished with the item

Ssme92 · 17/10/2023 20:10

@Solibear I think the 9 months it takes for a woman to grow a baby would be enough of a transition period for them to be honest. It's not like she went over, announced she was pregnant and ready to pop, and demanded it back!

Baba197 · 17/10/2023 20:06

Message and be direct - hi, I’m pleased you’ve had so much use from our cot but as our baby is due imminently we need it back on x date. You can buy new cots fairly cheaply or from marketplace! If you’ve only just met their baby then it can’t be a particularly close friendship and if you loose it would you be all
that bothered?

Solibear · 17/10/2023 19:20

My firstborn was in her bedside cot until she was 11 months old. She didn’t hit the weight limit until then and still fit in it fine, so she just stayed in it. If that’s their baby’s comfortable and familiar sleeping environment and is sleeping well in it, I can absolutely understand why they don’t want to give it back to you “today”. Given that you already have one child, surely you know how hard it is to get a baby to sleep well, and that there needs to be a transition period for something like this? If you were planning on having another one so soon, you really shouldn’t have lent it out in the first place. You need to be firmer with them so that you do get it back soon, but give them some time to manage the change

navigatingmy20s · 17/10/2023 18:27

it’s a bedside cot which should only be used for around 6 months anyway so OP had plenty of time to lend it to them and get it back in time for her LO.

wystful · 17/10/2023 17:22

Good update.
But when are you actually due? You've never answered this question?

momonpurpose · 17/10/2023 15:49

TheOccupier · 17/10/2023 15:45

Very well done OP! Let us know when you have it back.

Yes please ! I am invested in the pickup!

TheOccupier · 17/10/2023 15:45

Very well done OP! Let us know when you have it back.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 17/10/2023 15:37

Its good that you've laid down your terms and insisted. It shouldn't have needed to come to that and that is on them. Who on earth says Soon but not today to an 8 months pregnant woman.. You could hardly say that to the baby could you? You can have your cot baby, soon but not today.

So don't feel bad.

They haven't reciprocated your kindness and I'm guessing that this is extra pressure because you are in that lets get everything ready phase.
But you will find nicer friends.
Wishing you and your lovely newborn a good birth

Jellytot1234 · 17/10/2023 15:02

I kind of agree with a few posts that whilst your intentions were good. Why on earth did you lend them a cot when you knew you were planning another in the near future? If you want it back, you’re going to have to actually say it.. some people don’t take hints.. even seemingly obvious ones. What a to do over a cot..

Beautiful3 · 17/10/2023 15:00

Great message op. Update us when you pick it up. My fingers are crossed for you.

TheBerry · 17/10/2023 12:46

Why are you being so unassertive? You don’t need to be all “oh well the baby might be early”, “our first was out of the cot by this stage”, that is all irrelevant. It’s your cot.

Just say we need cot back back X day, we’ll come round and collect it on X.