Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you're being undertook, you might be driving wrong.

193 replies

theundertakersmate · 14/10/2023 01:41

NC for unpopular opinion.

I don't undertake on the motorway, for a disclaimer. But I do drive long distance on a smart motorway where there are 4 open lanes. I find it insanely frustrating the amount of people who do not move to the left. I understand it's hard when there are no hard shoulders but as I don't undertake, I fully go round people in overtaking and get back into the left lane, as we are meant to.

A colleague does a similar route and instead of my problems, he constantly complains about people repeatedly undertaking him. He says it always happens.

AIBU to think that, while undertaking is dangerous and not my way of driving, if you are ALWAYS being undertaken, to the point you rant about it always happening in your workplace... maybe you are the problem and are sitting middle lane??

Surely, if a person can physically undertake you, you aren't using the lanes appropriately?

OP posts:
marshmallowfinder · 14/10/2023 08:01

It's undertaken, not undertook!

WrongSwanson · 14/10/2023 07:57

I do think having motorway driving lessons should be mandatory before people are allowed to drive on them

I was so glad I did some after I passed my test (I had a toddler already and felt a huge responsibility to be a safe driver for him)

WrongSwanson · 14/10/2023 07:56

Middle lane hogging is awful, it makes the whole motorway more dangerous

SuprisingHorse · 14/10/2023 07:54

These threads never fail to surprise me on the number of people who
A) boast about something that is against the Highway Code or illegal
b) seem adamant something is fact when it provably not.

But I always feel drawn into comment as hopefully they’ll take something from the thread and make the roads a bit safer for everyone.

Before we talk about undertaking it seems some people on the thread need reminding of the very basics:

  1. there is no such as a ‘fast lane’
  2. there is no such thing as a ‘slow lane’ (there are crawler lanes, but that is different)

If you disagree, you shouldn’t be driving until you’ve had a chance to read the Highway Code.

If you drive in lane 2 as you ‘don’t like’ using lane 1 or 3 then you should hand your driving license back and make the roads permanently a safer place for yourselves, competent drivers and their passengers.

Graciebobcat · 14/10/2023 07:49

EBearhug · 14/10/2023 02:55

I think some sort of exception needs to be made for the eastbound M25 at J5 because the two exit lanes are on the right, which is totally not like any other motorway junction I've come across, and very confusing the first time you have to use it as i did in May.

But I agree that drivers sometimes don't seem to know about keeping left except when overtaking.

I'd also like to ban lorries from overtaking each other on dual carriageways going uphill like that bit of the northbound A34, where they seem to wait till then to do it just in front of me.

Clearly you have to be in the correct lane to exit. The M25 also often has two lanes chock full of lorries and two lanes of everything else, as no-one wants to get stuck between them. Not the least because you can miss things like being in the correct lane at a junction. It's also often so busy that it's unsafe to keep changing lanes and you just carry on maintaining the correct speed and trying to maintain a good stopping distance.

SirCharlesRainier · 14/10/2023 07:49

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/10/2023 01:46

Agree. I hate going in the fast lane so I do sometimes resort to undertaking cars. I do usually drive alongside them, occasionally glaring, having flashed my lights at them first.

Please hand your licence back.

Maddy70 · 14/10/2023 07:47

Its as much of an offence to middle lane hog as it is to undertake. Undertaking is very dangerous though

Sisterpita · 14/10/2023 07:40

I undertake regularly on the M25 as frequently cars are sat in the 3rd lane with nothing in lanes 1 and 2. Undertaking by driving in lane 1 means there is a whole lane between me and the car in lane 3. My rationale is the whole empty lane between us is sufficient to not be dangerous or careless driving and the person in lane 3 is clearly driving without due care and attention as they can’t see the 2 empty lanes.

bonzaitree · 14/10/2023 07:38

I have a teeny tiny car with a 1 litre engine. Lots of smart motorways around me.

When people are middle lane hogging I am faced with either undertaking or changing lanes 5 times, going in the 4th lane with really fast cars with big engines who can speed up quickly.

Neither choice is really great!

I look at people going at 55-60 in the second lane sometimes. They’re in a world of their own. Not one solitary care in the world. La la la 🙉

ButterMyParsnip · 14/10/2023 07:35

Globules · 14/10/2023 06:57

I'm going cross country in an hour. This thread has just reminded me what I've got to put up with on the motorways

ARGH.

BLOODY MIDDLE LANE HOGGERS.

I always find it interesting when this comes up on MN, as no one ever admits to doing it!

I'll admit to it. I did it the first time I went on a motorway. I was approaching a busy slip road so moved over to the middle but then everyone who was joining filed over to the middle too. There were no vehicles in the left lane at all. I worried that I'd missed a sign and the lane shouldn't be used so I stayed there. I spent a good 5 minutes (felt like an eternity) eyeing up the left lane and wondering why we couldn't use it. Eventually I saw a few cars using the left lane in the distance so I moved over and stayed there until I got off. I felt like an idiot after that.

Saschka · 14/10/2023 07:31

Circumferences · 14/10/2023 01:51

Surely everyone should just drive up to the speed limit to facilitate the flow of traffic but go no faster, and no one should need to dramatically speed past another driver. I don't understand the need to undertake on motorways unless you actually want to speed or drive dangerously.

The problem is people driving at 55-60 in the middle lane and refusing to pull in. Anyone doing anywhere near 70 will want to get past them, and if the outside lane is full of people doing 75+, you are going to get undertaking.

This thread is making me glad I no longer need to do any regular motorway driving!

rocknrollaa · 14/10/2023 07:29

No one should undertake.

But also, no one should be in the middle lane for a prolonged period if the left lane is free.

Obviously the former is more dangerous and causes more accidents. So undertakers are more in the wrong... but both are against the highway code.

Almondandhoney · 14/10/2023 07:26

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/10/2023 01:46

Agree. I hate going in the fast lane so I do sometimes resort to undertaking cars. I do usually drive alongside them, occasionally glaring, having flashed my lights at them first.

Jesus Christ. Don't drive on the motorway then!

LuisVitton · 14/10/2023 07:26

I would say your friend is not looking in his mirrors. Few people seeing a radiator gril speeding into their r v mirror will just ignore.

Thisismynewusernamedoyoulikeit · 14/10/2023 07:22

What gets me is when there's a wall of middle lane traffic and a couple of massively spaced out lorries in the left lane. I tend to move into the left lane because:
A) It what Highway Code tells you to do
B) I can maintain a safe braking distance in the left lane but not the middle or right lane. If I do maintain a safe distance in these lanes, someone cuts into it.

But then I'm stuck in the left lane, going at lorry speed eternally.

I don't know what would happen if everyone followed the highway Code in this situation, but I can't help but think it would be better and safer.

bozzabollix · 14/10/2023 07:14

PS again with driving instructor hat on, if you’re on a test, the limit is 70 in good conditions you have to demonstrate that you can drive at 70. This is to show that a) you can do it to not hold traffic up and b) you know the speed limit of the road you are on. Anyone thinking they’re being good at 55 is not being good, they’ve adapted rules in their head to suit the levels of their competence.

@SunsetsAndSandwiches my qualifications mean I can tell you you’re wrong, you need to revisit the Highway Code. It’s never ok to undertake unless you have ‘stay in lane’ signs and flashing lights is only to show that you’re there, not to express annoyance. Getting annoyed in a car has an awful effect on your quality of driving. Take the emotion out of it. Yes frustrating for someone not to be using the correct lane discipline to drive too slowly in the middle lane, but use effective observations and move out to overtake them before returning to the left hand lane. It might even remind them to return to the lane they should be in (that does work sometimes).

NoMor · 14/10/2023 07:13

Pipsquiggle · 14/10/2023 07:08

Yes, he is the issue. He needs to move over to the left

I do wish we were more like Germany. I think they are taught how to drive on motorway and are strict on lane management

I've found that they move over too fast after overtaking, right into your stopping distance! And as soon as there's a middle lane rather than just two, plenty of people start middle laning. I've also noticed that if someone is going extra fast they stay in the 'fast' lane the entire time, they do not move over as they know they're going too fast to safely change lane.

Thisismynewusernamedoyoulikeit · 14/10/2023 07:12

daisychain01 · 14/10/2023 05:19

Undertaking is 100% illegal in the context described. People flippantly saying "oh I undertake" are breaking the law. Frightening that you don't know the Highway Code.

No it's not.

If a driver is inappropriately in the middle lane and I am travelling at 70mph in the left lane, I could undertake. It would not be illegal.

If I screeched up the back of the driver in the middle lane, flashed my lights and then snuck around them between two lories in the left lane, yes of course that's dangerous driving and I could be prosecuted.

Pipsquiggle · 14/10/2023 07:08

Yes, he is the issue. He needs to move over to the left

I do wish we were more like Germany. I think they are taught how to drive on motorway and are strict on lane management

NoMor · 14/10/2023 07:04

I don't undertake people as it's dangerous but if there is somebody in the lane to the right of me who is going slower than I am, I will continue at my current speed even if it means I go past them. That is not undertaking, it is staying in your lane until you need to overtake. I'm not moving two lanes to go round them, that is dangerous. People need to stay in the left lane until they overtake I agree.

bozzabollix · 14/10/2023 07:04

Driving instructor here. Your colleague would fail his driving test with that. You’ve got to be in the left lane unless overtaking. But people once pass effectively write their own rules to cope with their driving shortfalls. With him it’s probably a reluctance to change lanes which is probably down to bad observation skills.

NotGettingIt · 14/10/2023 07:02

Undertaking is both illegal and dangerous, because it is unexpected. If a driver is not driving as fast as the undertaking driver requires they may then perfectly legally move into the left hand lane and then the two cars are on a collision course. Irritating though drivers not keeping up with the flow of traffic in the middle lane may be, usually there is usually space for the faster driver to make the legal manoeuvre of overtaking. They are the ones who are in the wrong.

Fizbosshoes · 14/10/2023 07:01

I find it really annoying when the motorway is almost clear, .....but the most left hand lane is almost empty. Then you are driving in that lane and then come across someone in the next lane tootling along at about 55mph when there is no good reason why they can't simply move left ....and then you have to go 2 lanes across to overtake!

Globules · 14/10/2023 06:57

I'm going cross country in an hour. This thread has just reminded me what I've got to put up with on the motorways

ARGH.

BLOODY MIDDLE LANE HOGGERS.

I always find it interesting when this comes up on MN, as no one ever admits to doing it!