Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you're being undertook, you might be driving wrong.

193 replies

theundertakersmate · 14/10/2023 01:41

NC for unpopular opinion.

I don't undertake on the motorway, for a disclaimer. But I do drive long distance on a smart motorway where there are 4 open lanes. I find it insanely frustrating the amount of people who do not move to the left. I understand it's hard when there are no hard shoulders but as I don't undertake, I fully go round people in overtaking and get back into the left lane, as we are meant to.

A colleague does a similar route and instead of my problems, he constantly complains about people repeatedly undertaking him. He says it always happens.

AIBU to think that, while undertaking is dangerous and not my way of driving, if you are ALWAYS being undertaken, to the point you rant about it always happening in your workplace... maybe you are the problem and are sitting middle lane??

Surely, if a person can physically undertake you, you aren't using the lanes appropriately?

OP posts:
ReturnOfTheRainMac · 14/10/2023 20:18

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 14/10/2023 15:35

Also remember this idiot killed this pregnant mum on the hard shoulder due to undertaking. Ok so he was speeding and filming himself but still Driver who killed pregnant mum in M66 crash has sentence increased www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-67099209

That is horrific. I see this all the time. You can always tell when someone is on their phone as they're all over the road. I'm on the road most of the day and see that numerous times. I've also seen very near misses where people have gone fully into the other lane as someone passes regularly. I wish they would do more to stop this.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 14/10/2023 15:35

Also remember this idiot killed this pregnant mum on the hard shoulder due to undertaking. Ok so he was speeding and filming himself but still Driver who killed pregnant mum in M66 crash has sentence increased www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-67099209

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 14/10/2023 15:32

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/10/2023 01:46

Agree. I hate going in the fast lane so I do sometimes resort to undertaking cars. I do usually drive alongside them, occasionally glaring, having flashed my lights at them first.

If someone flashes their lights at me and there are mother lanes to my right I refuse to move

TooDrunkToDust · 14/10/2023 15:22

I'm moving to Dorset.

ActDottie · 14/10/2023 15:17

I’m with you. If you’re constantly being undertook then you’re very likely in the wrong lane for your speed.

NashEnquirer · 14/10/2023 15:07

NerrSnerr · 14/10/2023 14:29

Nope, you have to slow down or overtake. The middle lane hoggers are dangerous and irritating but undertaking is also bad.

I do think some people are frightened to change lanes on the motorway and that's why they hog the middle lane and why others can't overtake them

@MockneyReject I'm instinctively inclined to agree with you, as that seems to me the safest option overall, but I think @NerrSnerr is actually right, even though it sort of makes no sense!

Topofthemountain · 14/10/2023 15:04

IMustDoMoreExercise · 14/10/2023 12:35

Why do you think it is dangerous? The potholes?

No, the fact that there might be a broken down car in that lane, which in other circumstances would at least be on the hard shoulder not in a live lane. This is one of the very many incidents.

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/05/deaths-of-two-pensioners-on-m1-spurs-calls-for-end-to-smart-motorways

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:55

Middle lane hoggers, who should get very heavily fined in this country too, are not an excuse to undertake.

If you undertake, you should get fined too.

Br1ocheToast · 14/10/2023 14:54

It depends. I have people overtaking me going over the speed limit.

Waspie · 14/10/2023 14:49

My local motorways all have 4 lanes now but people just sit in the third lane (second overtaking lane) and force everyone to go round them in the outside lane. They are total and complete arseholes who can't drive.

It's better on weekdays but weekends just make me want to lose the will to live. If you can't drive on a motorway, find a different route.

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 14/10/2023 14:46

smooththecat · 14/10/2023 14:38

You know what’s worse than middle lane hogging? Aggressive drivers who cut in and out of lanes, crossing over 2/3/4 lanes of traffic, undertaking on slip roads and cutting people up. I know everyone is really riled up about this here, but this second behaviour is much worse and you are more likely to kill someone, or yourself. And no, the fault does not transfer to the original middle lane hogger, you’re responsible for your own driving and your own aggression. Don’t be that person who I referred to up thread who likely killed himself by undertaking up a slip road and cutting in.

Ignore what I had written previously here. I can’t work out how to delete my post and realised I had forgotten what the OP was about.

smooththecat · 14/10/2023 14:38

You know what’s worse than middle lane hogging? Aggressive drivers who cut in and out of lanes, crossing over 2/3/4 lanes of traffic, undertaking on slip roads and cutting people up. I know everyone is really riled up about this here, but this second behaviour is much worse and you are more likely to kill someone, or yourself. And no, the fault does not transfer to the original middle lane hogger, you’re responsible for your own driving and your own aggression. Don’t be that person who I referred to up thread who likely killed himself by undertaking up a slip road and cutting in.

NerrSnerr · 14/10/2023 14:29

MockneyReject · 14/10/2023 05:15

Surely, if I'm undertaking you, you're in the wrong lane?
If I'm minding my own business, driving at 60/70mph, down a motorway, or dual carriageway, in the left hand lane, as is correct, and you're driving more slowly than me, in any other lane, then you're the problem.
Why would I increase my speed, and go all the way out to the third lane, when there's no-one in front of me? It's not that I want to overtake you. I'm just maintaining the correct speed, in the correct lane.
Why would I, alternatively, slow down to 50, in the left hand lane, just because you're in the wrong lane? If you're not overtaking me, then you shouldn't be in the overtaking lane.

Nope, you have to slow down or overtake. The middle lane hoggers are dangerous and irritating but undertaking is also bad.

I do think some people are frightened to change lanes on the motorway and that's why they hog the middle lane and why others can't overtake them

EBearhug · 14/10/2023 14:23

I learnt to drive in Dorset, where there aren't any motorways (not that you're allowed on them as a learner anyway.) There are dual carriage ways, though, which have mostly the same rules.

When I got my first car, and by then living in Bournemouth, about 7 years after I passed my test, I took a motorway lesson. So you can get motirway lesson if you want (isn't there Pass Plus or something?) We went out to Southampton - and then she told me to drive back through the Forest on the A roads, because they're actually more dangerous.

Motorways can be challenging because of the speed and volume of traffic, and of course weather conditions cam make any journey more difficult, but I find they are usually easier to drive on than smaller roads. They were actually designed for driving, whereas some roads I grew up with, some were largely unchanged since the Iron Age or Saxons (and Romans, but they were good at roads, and believed in straight lines more than geographical features,) except for being tarmacked. I know drivers who would be freaked out by having to reverse down a narrow lane with high sided banks to make space for an on-coming herd of cattle or a tractor.

I am, according to passengers*, a good driver. But even good drivers have bad days, and while middle lane hoggers may be annoying, they're far from the worst thing I have to deal with in many journeys. The driver who undertook me and then over took the next lane at speed on a busy M3 last week was far more dangerous than someone consistently driving too slowly in a middle lane. (I wasn't lane hogging - I was avoiding traffic queing to turn off to Farnborough and slowing down in my lane because it wouldn't have been safe for me to try and get into the third lane,. I didn't stay in that lane once the road was clearer.)

If middle lane hoggers are the most annoying thing you encounter on a drive, it's probably been a good day.

*including my mother, who was a nervous passenger, who never gave us praise about anything; I actually spoke to my sister about it, because it was so unusual!

IMustDoMoreExercise · 14/10/2023 12:35

Mintyy2 · 14/10/2023 05:55

I can forgive people for not wanting to use lane 1 on a smart motorway. It's just so fricking dangerous.

Why do you think it is dangerous? The potholes?

NotGettingIt · 14/10/2023 11:49

@SunsetsAndSandwiches You seriously can’t see that not only are you driving dangerously but you are actively trying to distract the other motorist with your shaky moral high ground???

Suffrajitsu · 14/10/2023 11:46

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/10/2023 01:46

Agree. I hate going in the fast lane so I do sometimes resort to undertaking cars. I do usually drive alongside them, occasionally glaring, having flashed my lights at them first.

This is appalling. You really think you are justified in glaring at someone when you are driving dangerously yourself? If you don't want to use the overtaking lanes, do us all a favour and please don't drive on motorways.

BIossomtoes · 14/10/2023 11:11

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/10/2023 01:46

Agree. I hate going in the fast lane so I do sometimes resort to undertaking cars. I do usually drive alongside them, occasionally glaring, having flashed my lights at them first.

Well done. You’re making dangerous driving doubly dangerous. Hope you’re proud of yourself. If you’re incapable of overtaking you shouldn’t be on the motorway at all.

CountTo10 · 14/10/2023 11:00

CingsKross · 14/10/2023 10:42

We have a very bad stretch of motorway near me for middle lane hogging.

I drive the speed limit in the left lane, which is usually completely clear, while all other cars sit in the middle lane, driving below the speed limit. This then blocks up the third lane as their is no room for those overtaking, to pull back in left.

I therefore undertake both right lanes as they are so over crowded, while my lane remains clear because for some stupid reason, no one seems to use the left lane!

I know it's illegal to undertake but until people learn to drive properly, I will continue to do so.

I've also noticed learner drivers are being taught to sit in the middle lane even when the left lane is completely clear, why is this?

I agree with this and it's not actually illegal to undertake depending on the circumstances.

Middle lane hogging is rife to the point there are times when the middle lane and overtaking lane are so full it would be impossible for me in the nearside lane to move out and overtake anyone.

Sometimes you have no choice anyway but to stay in the nearside lane because you need to come off at the next exit. Happened to me the other day. I was actually travelling at 60 in an almost clear nearside lane in attempt to avoid undertaking because I needed to come off at the exit. No time to overtake and impossible due to the volume of traffic in the middle & overtaking lanes.

Despite this I still ended up undertaking whilst the middle lane hoggers remained oblivious.

CingsKross · 14/10/2023 10:42

We have a very bad stretch of motorway near me for middle lane hogging.

I drive the speed limit in the left lane, which is usually completely clear, while all other cars sit in the middle lane, driving below the speed limit. This then blocks up the third lane as their is no room for those overtaking, to pull back in left.

I therefore undertake both right lanes as they are so over crowded, while my lane remains clear because for some stupid reason, no one seems to use the left lane!

I know it's illegal to undertake but until people learn to drive properly, I will continue to do so.

I've also noticed learner drivers are being taught to sit in the middle lane even when the left lane is completely clear, why is this?

Wonkasworld · 14/10/2023 10:22

theundertakersmate · 14/10/2023 02:41

@Chronicallyknackered

Totally agree. If you're too nervous to change lanes, then at best stay left. If you can't do that, don't motorway. I find it infuriating. And I'm not a wuss about it either, a close family member openly admits to middle lane driving as she 'cant be arsed getting stuck in the slow lane' ... my explanation that if everyone drove in the left when not overtaking fell on deaf ears.

That really means she is a driver, who is not confident. Unfortunately, her lack of confidence causes problems for other drivers. Drivers should automatically go with the flow of traffic. Non confident driver equals poor driver. That also goes for the person who doesn't like the 'fast' Lane.

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 14/10/2023 10:16

MockneyReject · 14/10/2023 05:15

Surely, if I'm undertaking you, you're in the wrong lane?
If I'm minding my own business, driving at 60/70mph, down a motorway, or dual carriageway, in the left hand lane, as is correct, and you're driving more slowly than me, in any other lane, then you're the problem.
Why would I increase my speed, and go all the way out to the third lane, when there's no-one in front of me? It's not that I want to overtake you. I'm just maintaining the correct speed, in the correct lane.
Why would I, alternatively, slow down to 50, in the left hand lane, just because you're in the wrong lane? If you're not overtaking me, then you shouldn't be in the overtaking lane.

This is also true, but I think what OP and most other people are talking about are the people who weave in and out of traffic at speed.

If you’re constantly being undertaken by people driving at a reasonable speed, then you are definitely the problem, I agree!

Two types of idiot drivers on the motorway: lane hoggers and lane weavers.

LlynTegid · 14/10/2023 10:15

Middle lane hoggers should be banned from driving for a period. Dashcam or passenger filmed instances should be admissible as evidence, and the means to report widely publicised. The usual reticence to report others I expect would not happen.

Undertaking is not acceptable either.

Thisismynewusernamedoyoulikeit · 14/10/2023 10:10

Not necessarily. Drivers should be at least 2 seconds behind the car in front, or 4 if it's wet. 2s gap is more than enough space for a car to squeeze into inappropriately.

I have been in a middle lane at 65, behind another car at 65, leaving a safe 2 second gap. It was the appropriate lane because I was overtaking a lorry that was at the time just in front of the car in front.

The car behind me didn't believe in 2s gaps. Perhaps he was too important to leave a gap. So he went into the left lane to undertake, acceleration dangerously to the back of the lorry and then pulled back out into my braking gap.

He was undertaking dangerously.

Not all undertaking is dangerous. But some is.

Pertangyangkipperbang · 14/10/2023 10:09

I used to work for Road Safety.
There is NO such thing as slow Lane..fast lane etc.
So annoys me people just aimlessly driving or tooting along in the middle lane.
When you enter the motorway, the left hand lane, lane one, is for routine driving. Lanes two and three are for overtaking only. You should aim to keep to lane one unless there's a build-up of slow-moving vehicles in that lane; in which case, you can move across to the next lane to overtake.