Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this child’s crying outbursts are too much?

287 replies

ForgotTheBiscuits · 14/10/2023 01:23

My DS’s friend, 4, has almighty meltdowns whenever he has to do something he doesn’t want.

For example, I collected both my DS and his friend from a party, and as soon as it was time to go, this kid begins crying, not actually tears but just the sounds, lots of sound. He refused to say thank you to the hosts or wish the kid ‘happy birthday’ before we left. It went on for the entire 20 minutes journey home. It bothers me that I can’t attend to my own child at all when this is happening, as dealing with the meltdown takes all my attention.

There is no consoling, I have tried on many different occasions when this happens (it’s very frequent!) to reassure, comfort, give hugs, distractions, humour - nothing works! He just commits to the crying and won’t engage at all, won’t listen or even make eye contact. And it goes on for a very long time!

When this boy is playing and doing what he wants, he’s has pretty good manners and makes eye contact, is affectionate and talkative.

His mum is incredibly gentle and I don’t think he even gets short shrift at any time from her. I would spontaneously combust if my kid did this all the time, it’s bloody annoying to say the least.

I’m good with kids generally, having worked with hundreds of them over the years, and have always been able to find a way to calm a child down somehow, but this kid has me at a loss and drives me insane!!

Is this Highly Sensitive Personality or something else?

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 14/10/2023 09:22

Maybe it’s being exacerbated by the amount of time he spends away from his mum? Perhaps rather than going on every outing with you, having sleepovers, etc, he only comes a few times? If he needs an iPad to get to sleep, he might be over-tired as well as missing his mum.

As for the screaming,I too find consoling and explaining makes things a lot worse. Give warnings, both before the activity and towards the end about the leaving process, and then be very matter of fact. Ignore the crying. Don’t try to jolly him up, don’t engage him in conversation.

For your DS’s party, I don’t think it’s fair that you let this child spoil it or distract you from your son. Don’t invite him or ask his mum to bring him for a brief time (so he can be removed if screaming). My DC had a friend like this and their mum always stayed with them to ensure nobody else had to divert their attention to the child at parties. She also took said child away from a party when they really kicked off.

overand · 14/10/2023 09:18

@TumblingTower I have seen the looks from other adults when my child is having a meltdown - and they are not compassionate, they are judgemental, just like much of this thread.

When my little one is screaming, hitting, kicking and hurting himself and I'm down at his level trying to comfort him, it makes me sad knowing there are people out there shaking their heads, tutting and thinking he's a brat rather than a struggling child.

Whatafustercluck · 14/10/2023 09:13

This sounds a lot like my dd at that age. In fact, she got to 6.5yo before we could say she'd had a full day without crying. Transitions were always hard, and throw in the assault on all the senses that tends to come with parties and we had frequent behavioural problems. Days out in particular were very hard. Otherwise seemed 'normal' when emotionally regulated. We always felt very judged.

She's currently on a pathway to diagnosis for ND.

This child may well just be an over indulged little darling who gets away with it because his parents are too soft. Most likely the case. But there's a chance all is not as it seems, so I wouldn't be as quick to judge.

Hooplahooping · 14/10/2023 09:10

You don’t need to engage. Once you’ve reassured him that you’re there if he wants a cuddle, just check in with him sporadically and cheerfully get on with it, chatting to him as you go.

some people get gentle parenting and permissive parenting mixed up. Poor kid sounds like he isn’t getting the loving but firm boundaries he needs at home vs a developmental issue.

N4ish · 14/10/2023 09:05

margotrose · 14/10/2023 08:39

I don't think this thread is very kind.

He's only four, he has a mum who is clearly quite unwell and as a result, he is doing a lot of things on his own or with a relative stranger taking him. That must be quite overwhelming for a child who has barely started reception.

I wouldn't be indulging the tantrums and would probably just ignore them but I don't think it's nice to come on and start a thread that will just encourage people to bash his mum and call him a brat.

I agree, it sounds like things are very unsettled in this child’s life and he’s become over sensitive and ‘difficult’ as a result. 4 is very young for a sleepover and he seems to spend a lot of time without his mother.

Think OP can just decide to distance herself from the family or else grit her teeth and put up with it.

Hellenabe · 14/10/2023 09:04

I'd not help anymore personally. Too much hassle.

TumblingTower · 14/10/2023 08:58

Tinybrother · 14/10/2023 08:33

I had one like this. They weren’t “indulged” or given in to or whatever (and I have two other children who behave(d) differently) and nor were they ignored or shamed. No one else was expected to deal with it but us as parents. They grew out of it.

My eldest is definitely more like this but I find he’s an absolute delight with other people. Nursery and school he is an Angel. My second is definitely more of an easy child but he’s consistent with whoever he is with 🤷🏼‍♀️

SoupDragon · 14/10/2023 08:55

There are some really nasty comments on this thread. This child is 4 and struggling with a mother who is ill.

One of mine had huge tantrums when he didn't get his own way. It never got him his own way yet still he did it. He would just erupt and there was no reasoning with him. He wasn't over indulged, or a brat or any of the other nasty things people are saying, he was dealing with a difficult situation. Plus, as it turned out, he has ADHD.

TBH, I just ignored him when he was in one of these moments and we'd talk when he calmed down. Obviously I removed him from the situation and made sure he was safe though!

I remember one occasion promising him something small but desirable if he left a friends house with no fuss. He was out of that house so fast it was almost rude! This might be worth trying (although mine was probably 6 so slightly older than this boy)

Tinybrother · 14/10/2023 08:52

Mrsjayy · 14/10/2023 08:34

So do you think it was just personality/tempremant @Tinybrother

For my child yes

i don’t know about the child in the OP, just noting that some children do need more help than others (or more time) working out how to regulate their emotions

Lovemusic82 · 14/10/2023 08:50

I had to deal with a child like this once, turned out she had a pretty awful life at home. She would get herself into a right state, mainly when we had to leave the park or leave somewhere she liked. It got to a point where I had to just let her cry it out because there was no calming her down or comforting her until she had stopped screaming, once she started calming down I would offer her a drink and then talk calmly to her about how crying will not change the situation (or get her what she want she wants), she would then give me a hug and say sorry for screaming. At home she had no structure, her mother would shout at her but not really parent her, there were no boundaries in place other than getting shouted at when she did something her mother didn’t like. Kids need structure and some kids need more preparation than others to know what’s happening and what’s expected of them.

Gerrataere · 14/10/2023 08:48

TumblingTower · 14/10/2023 08:29

I think they’d see you, as the parent dealing with it as best you can and so realising it’s not a fault of the parent but a sign of something else.

This differs from the OP.

No they wouldn’t. I have an autistic child who is cognitively permanently a toddler, they don’t come with a special sign saying ‘Autistic not a ‘brat’!!’. People on MN love to say ‘oh but we don’t mean your child, of course we wouldn’t judge you’. But the fact is an autistic child having a meltdown is unlikely to look different from a toddler tantrum to the outside view. I’ve had grown adults step over my child as I try and coax them off the ground despite plenty of room to walk around. There is no difference when it comes to judgement, sneering and some odd need for justice and punishment when a young child has not learned to control their emotions.

Rainallnight · 14/10/2023 08:39

ForgotTheBiscuits · 14/10/2023 01:54

I’m not looking forward to my son’s birthday party as I know the end will involve half an hour of crying from this kid, as we have to drive him home. It takes all my self control to not just snap ‘will you pack it in, you annoying little sod!’, especially when driving.

I have tried the firm, authoritative ‘Right, I think that’s enough now/think of other peoples’ and also ignoring. I’ve been unlucky enough to spend rather a lot of time with this kid so have used all the tricks!

I am acutely aware it’s not my place to discipline this child, but how the heck can I tolerate this incessant crying when he doesn’t get his own way?!

It sounds like you’re lovely to the little boy’s mum but for your DS’s party, she’s going to have to come up with another plan so you don’t have to look after him/drive him. Your DS needs your attention

margotrose · 14/10/2023 08:39

I don't think this thread is very kind.

He's only four, he has a mum who is clearly quite unwell and as a result, he is doing a lot of things on his own or with a relative stranger taking him. That must be quite overwhelming for a child who has barely started reception.

I wouldn't be indulging the tantrums and would probably just ignore them but I don't think it's nice to come on and start a thread that will just encourage people to bash his mum and call him a brat.

Mrsjayy · 14/10/2023 08:34

So do you think it was just personality/tempremant @Tinybrother

Tinybrother · 14/10/2023 08:33

I had one like this. They weren’t “indulged” or given in to or whatever (and I have two other children who behave(d) differently) and nor were they ignored or shamed. No one else was expected to deal with it but us as parents. They grew out of it.

DaisyWaldron · 14/10/2023 08:30

Some kids just find transitions hard. Some of those kids also find fun quite hard to deal with. DD was like this, and for a period of a few years, it felt as though most of our fun trips out ended in massive crying fits.

As she got older, she learned to express herself in other ways, and to tell me when things got too much and she needed space, and she learned to anticipate that fun things would come to an end, and she grew out of it.

But until that happened, all I could do was make sure she had some calm time, talk to her in advance about what helped/made things worse when her feelings got too big to handle, prepare her for the transition and then ride out any upsets when they happened.

TumblingTower · 14/10/2023 08:29

overand · 14/10/2023 08:05

I have a nearly four year old who behaves like this and some of the responses on this thread are heartbreaking to read.

My child struggles with all transitions and has epic meltdown that can last for over 30 minutes. I am not a passive parent who overindulges. He's on the waiting list to be assessed for ASD.

It makes me so sad to think that other people (I'm assuming based on this thread women and mothers) would just assume he's a brat that needs ignoring or shaming. I'm broken and exhausted and doing my best to help my child and the judgment on this thread about a very young child struggling is hideous.

I think they’d see you, as the parent dealing with it as best you can and so realising it’s not a fault of the parent but a sign of something else.

This differs from the OP.

Hibiscrubbed · 14/10/2023 08:25

Circumferences · 14/10/2023 01:37

Is this Highly Sensitive Personality or something else?
No. It's highly indulged personality syndrome.

This entirely. That behaviour needs to be totally ignored. Even negative attention is good attention for that kid.

Prinnny · 14/10/2023 08:25

That sounds draining, especially the constant wailing whilst trying to drive. I think you know the child and mother well enough by now to have a short sharp ENOUGH and then dround him out with the radio. I wouldn’t be offering any more lifts or play dates and encouraging other friendships for my child.

olderthanyouthink · 14/10/2023 08:24

Uninformed*

olderthanyouthink · 14/10/2023 08:22

overand · 14/10/2023 08:05

I have a nearly four year old who behaves like this and some of the responses on this thread are heartbreaking to read.

My child struggles with all transitions and has epic meltdown that can last for over 30 minutes. I am not a passive parent who overindulges. He's on the waiting list to be assessed for ASD.

It makes me so sad to think that other people (I'm assuming based on this thread women and mothers) would just assume he's a brat that needs ignoring or shaming. I'm broken and exhausted and doing my best to help my child and the judgment on this thread about a very young child struggling is hideous.

I feel you, DD is autistic and possibly PDA profile. Probably to the uniformed it looks like were very lax/permissive/coddling but it's just ableist to hold everyone to the same standards

Donotshushme · 14/10/2023 08:22

JennyJenny8675309 · 14/10/2023 06:59

@Donotshushme
So would you ask another parent to bring your child home from a party knowing they would behave that way? Why should this woman be expected to figure out why they are behaving this way”?

Sounds like the op offered.

I said if she's not willing to work out what's going on with this boy, she should stop looking after him. At the very least, a bit of empathy.

User478 · 14/10/2023 08:21

Do you pick him up too?

Spend the way there explaining what is going to happen. (You can get a social story for this if you think it would help -have a google for "going to a party social story")
Explain that at the end of the party it will be time to go home. Tell him you will warn him 10 minutes, 5 minutes and 2 minutes before it's time to leave. Remind him you might feel sad when it's time to leave, but it's not safe to shout in the car, what does he think the answer is?
Choose to listen to Paw patrol or Thomas (or whatever) music in the car and/or fidget with (whatever) or have his party bag (if you're ok with that?) Listen to his solutions.

Try and head the crying off before it starts.

Nonplusultra · 14/10/2023 08:18

Loop earplugs or similar might help with the noise aspect op.

In terms of transitions, one of the best techniques I’ve found is to talk, in very general terms, about what’s happening later (I wonder what your dad is cooking for tea tonight, or I wonder what you’ll play on your iPad later) no direct question, or demand. But it gently helps direct thoughts past the transition.

If you can arrive a few minutes early, send them back in for their last go/last two minutes etc so that it’s not an abrupt transition. I used to do a countdown with my dc, showing 5 fingers for 5 minutes, all the way down to one.

kezzyleah · 14/10/2023 08:17

This sounds quite normal to me? Particularly with an unsettled home life and a sick mum. In each of my children's classes there has been at least one child like this who has been quite sensitive and emotionally developmentally slow and seems to cry at everything. One child used to cry and tantrum at every school drop off for two years. A sleepover for a 4 year old sounds very young too, I get it's probably out of necessity but even my very well behaved and calm children would struggle with one at that age. If you're struggling though can't you see if others from the class can help a bit more or just be honest with the mum that you're finding it too much.