Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this child’s crying outbursts are too much?

287 replies

ForgotTheBiscuits · 14/10/2023 01:23

My DS’s friend, 4, has almighty meltdowns whenever he has to do something he doesn’t want.

For example, I collected both my DS and his friend from a party, and as soon as it was time to go, this kid begins crying, not actually tears but just the sounds, lots of sound. He refused to say thank you to the hosts or wish the kid ‘happy birthday’ before we left. It went on for the entire 20 minutes journey home. It bothers me that I can’t attend to my own child at all when this is happening, as dealing with the meltdown takes all my attention.

There is no consoling, I have tried on many different occasions when this happens (it’s very frequent!) to reassure, comfort, give hugs, distractions, humour - nothing works! He just commits to the crying and won’t engage at all, won’t listen or even make eye contact. And it goes on for a very long time!

When this boy is playing and doing what he wants, he’s has pretty good manners and makes eye contact, is affectionate and talkative.

His mum is incredibly gentle and I don’t think he even gets short shrift at any time from her. I would spontaneously combust if my kid did this all the time, it’s bloody annoying to say the least.

I’m good with kids generally, having worked with hundreds of them over the years, and have always been able to find a way to calm a child down somehow, but this kid has me at a loss and drives me insane!!

Is this Highly Sensitive Personality or something else?

OP posts:
RoseAdagio · 17/10/2023 17:38

mowly77 · 14/10/2023 03:35

⬆️

Agree that if parents are stressed (illness) maybe they give in more. But in general this thread is mean-spirited, abelist & horrible.

In what way is it ableist? She isn't discriminating against the Mum, who has health problems, she is actively trying to help her out. She is finding it difficult dealing with someone else's frequently histrionic child on a regular basis, which hardly seems unreasonable...

MeinKraft · 17/10/2023 17:24

concertgoer · 17/10/2023 08:05

If the child is exclusively in your care, in your car, and is distracting you, I believe it is your place to discipline the child!

car crash … dangerous driving charge …. I was distracted by my friends child screaming in the car Your Honour, but I didn’t feel it was my place to discipline him, so I carried on driving with him distracting me.
….. not gonna wash!!

also tell the child’s parents he’s a little sh1t ! - they may well no & stop him! He could just be trying to get a reaction from you.

He is 4 years old. He's not a little shit, he's struggling with transitions. Neither we nor the OP know why. There may be SEN, he might just be maturing a bit more slowly than his peers, he might not want to go home and the end of an activity because it's not a happy place to be. I'd love to know how you expect his parents to stop it because once a child has gone into that place interventions only make it worse.

Jellytot1234 · 17/10/2023 16:56

Prevention is key with children with behavioural struggles. Damage control is useless once the child has began to explode.. especially if you’re dealing with a neurodiverse child.

my son has asd and he had awful meltdowns- (not just tantrums) Prior to a diagnosis; I just decided to implement strategies that would benefit a child on the spectrum- to be honest, a lot of the strategies are good for ALL children anyway! Warnings and timers are excellent for allowing the child to come to terms with the fact a certain activity is ending soon. Mini sand timers are a good visual way of showing a child that it’s time to go. Having a visual or clear explanation of Now and Then and forced choices.

Youre obviously being very kind to help out but I think it would be absolutely okay for you to mention the child’s behaviour to their parent- you’re spending loads of time dealing with him after all! Perhaps mum will be relieved you’ve mentioned it and then you can run by some ideas for next time.. but you’re also completely reasonable to stop taking him too, he’s not your child and if it’s ruining your time with your own then that’s okay and who you put first!

olderthanyouthink · 17/10/2023 16:52

@Truthbomb maybe autistic, a lot of girls don't really show it more obviously till puberty ish but some do earlier. Worth looking into and keeping in mind.

JustAMinutePleass · 17/10/2023 16:42

Truthbomb · 17/10/2023 10:11

My daughter is 4 and has almighty meltdowns. We never give in to her, she used manners too and meltdowns do not get her her own way. This hasn’t stopped them happening unfortunately. She had one yesterday because I said no to going to the park after school (it was cold and windy and I needed to get home and feed my 3 month old).

A meltdown began, she attacked me, punched, kicked, hit, screamed and was completely inconsolable. At one point she tried to dart in to the road and I had to restrain her to get her in the car. This lasted for 20 minutes until I got her in the car. All the school parents were witnessing this and likely assuming I lack parenting skills and spoil her, all the usual tripe. It can be really hard to hear people saying ‘over indulged child’. My child receives a lot of love from me but I implement firm boundaries. Despite these almighty meltdowns and the judgement people show towards me I do not give in and I do not go back on my word.

Not every case of extreme behaviour is to do with being over indulged. Unfortunately there is absolutely no reasoning when she reaches this point as you have said. Nothing works. Nothing. It has had me in tears many times and I am now at the point where I avoid play dates because of it.

I have reached out for a professional opinion and been told this is normal behaviour. I disagree but it’s hard when she excels in all other areas of life. She is happy in school, she enjoys learning, not a fussy eater, her speech is fantastic and her eye contact is fine.

The point of my post is to say that I appreciate this may seem abnormal to you but just because you haven’t experienced this with your own child doesn’t mean the boys parents are failing or not bothering with boundaries/consequences.

DS does this too so I got a psychologist to see him (I know someone and was fast tracked a private appointment). Apparently it isn’t ‘normal’ - it’s something only highly intelligent & driven children do and often tantrumns / stubbornness etc between 2-4 results in children being highly motivated / doing very well /taking on leadership positions in adulthood.

Seaside3 · 17/10/2023 16:27

Not saying this child is being, but, children can be manipulative. They literally manipulate you into feeding them and looking after them from a tiny age. So there's every chance a 4 year old can be. He might just need some boundaries in place to feel secure.

BagForLifer · 17/10/2023 15:33

greenhydrangea · 14/10/2023 23:48

He is ululating. Not crying. If he was anxious, he would be actually weeping, shedding tears.

Nonsense.

Cabincat · 17/10/2023 14:27

Maybe this child is letting out there emotions. If his mum is not well
maybe they can’t play or interact much at home with him so he’s bored and lonely at home , so he is so disappointed that he’s got to go home this is the only way he knows how to it as he can’t explain his emotions in words just like a lot of normal children do when they have to leave the park after a particularly wonderful time there , either that or he may well have autism etc as he has been with you enough times now to know a tantrum won’t get him what he wants so I doubt it is solely that .

Daisyblue77 · 17/10/2023 10:38

Can the mum find someone else to collect? I know you want to support your freind

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 17/10/2023 10:36

Sounds like he may have ASD; my son was similar at that age. We give him a warning when it was close to the time for something to end/to leave somewhere. He was diagnosed with ASD at 6.

Truthbomb · 17/10/2023 10:11

My daughter is 4 and has almighty meltdowns. We never give in to her, she used manners too and meltdowns do not get her her own way. This hasn’t stopped them happening unfortunately. She had one yesterday because I said no to going to the park after school (it was cold and windy and I needed to get home and feed my 3 month old).

A meltdown began, she attacked me, punched, kicked, hit, screamed and was completely inconsolable. At one point she tried to dart in to the road and I had to restrain her to get her in the car. This lasted for 20 minutes until I got her in the car. All the school parents were witnessing this and likely assuming I lack parenting skills and spoil her, all the usual tripe. It can be really hard to hear people saying ‘over indulged child’. My child receives a lot of love from me but I implement firm boundaries. Despite these almighty meltdowns and the judgement people show towards me I do not give in and I do not go back on my word.

Not every case of extreme behaviour is to do with being over indulged. Unfortunately there is absolutely no reasoning when she reaches this point as you have said. Nothing works. Nothing. It has had me in tears many times and I am now at the point where I avoid play dates because of it.

I have reached out for a professional opinion and been told this is normal behaviour. I disagree but it’s hard when she excels in all other areas of life. She is happy in school, she enjoys learning, not a fussy eater, her speech is fantastic and her eye contact is fine.

The point of my post is to say that I appreciate this may seem abnormal to you but just because you haven’t experienced this with your own child doesn’t mean the boys parents are failing or not bothering with boundaries/consequences.

Ffion21 · 17/10/2023 09:34

Wow some of these replies are mean. If the child is not perfect, then god forbid you should engage (yes this is dripping in sarcasm).

He sounds insanely annoying but you’re doing the right thing stepping in and helping because he is your sons friend but also the poor kid is going through a lot more than the vast majority of kids will ever know. Helping the mum out like you are is a really kind thing for you to do - for her and him. All mums worry about whether their kids have friends, aren’t missing out etc so no doubt your help will be a big source of comfort to her.

However I do think gently raising the issue with her is worthwhile. Can’t you have a word when they’re not in ear shot and Just explain you’ve noticed that he does have quite significant meltdowns during a period of transition and are after some advice on how you can manage that to make it easier for him. This will do two things:

  1. let her know the kids a challenge for you
  2. if she isn’t aware he has issues (whatever the cause) this gently makes her aware

You’re asking her from a place of asking advice then and not a critical and judgemental way, making her feel embarrassed.

ChillysWaterBottle · 17/10/2023 08:43

Some of the posters here are absolutely psychopathic. Calling a distressed little 4 year old boy with a mum too sick to take him to parties a brat, little shit, spoiled, manipulative etc. Some of you need to go to therapy before you start trying to give parenting advice to anyone else. Fucking weirdos.

OP what you're doing is lovely and kind, and no wonder you're getting stressed and overwhelmed yourself. I agree with the countdown/talking through what will happen in advance technique may help here. Would it be possible to video call mum on a phone in the car back from places too so he can see her and tell her all about the event? I feel so sorry for him.

I think for your son's birthday you should ask his mum to come and ask her what she needs to accommodate/support her being there. It's perfectly reasonable to say that as the host you will have your hands full that day.

You're doing a great job OP and the poor little boy and his mum are lucky to have you in their lives x x x

ToadOnTheHill · 17/10/2023 08:21

If you're going to carry on woh the arrangement I'd handle it by acknowledging it and appearing nice but not getting sucked in to the drama whilst drawing a very firm boundary that you and your child wont engage with the behaviour and the world wont stop for it.

Get down to his level making eye contact and acknowledging him and give him a choice: Hey XX, I'm so sorry you're upset that were leaving, I understand that that's upsetting and that you feel like you need to get your feelings out, so cry as much as you need to. XXX (My child) and I will be carrying on as normal and we would love you to join in with us when you have calmed down.

Then start and forcibly hold a cheerful conversation with your own child and give them positive attention, even if that means elevating your voice to do so.

Snowinjulyy · 17/10/2023 08:06

My child has sen and struggles with transitions. Saying 10/20 minutes before the party ends "we have to go home soon, not now but in 10 mins" helps a lot and has done since around the age of 3/4. At the park it's something along the lines of "you can choose a last go on three things before we go home"
Might be worth a go for next time.

(I'm not saying that this child has sen but the strategy might still work.)

concertgoer · 17/10/2023 08:05

If the child is exclusively in your care, in your car, and is distracting you, I believe it is your place to discipline the child!

car crash … dangerous driving charge …. I was distracted by my friends child screaming in the car Your Honour, but I didn’t feel it was my place to discipline him, so I carried on driving with him distracting me.
….. not gonna wash!!

also tell the child’s parents he’s a little sh1t ! - they may well no & stop him! He could just be trying to get a reaction from you.

Letsbekindplease · 17/10/2023 08:04

Hard work not jade work I meant

Letsbekindplease · 17/10/2023 08:03

4 year olds are jade work. I have one and he is so sensitive and emotional. Especially after nursery and when he’s asked to do something he doesn’t want to do. I think there’s a leap at this age called the limbec leap ? Something like that. Emotions can be high and very sensitive

concertgoer · 17/10/2023 08:00

I would pull the car over and tell him to shut up before you are completely distracted and kill you all !! (I’d probably shout! 1, in frustration, 2, to be heard)

probably not the “right” advice. But it’s what I do to my own children if they’re sounding off without reason.

has he ever actually been told to just shut up??? He might just be seeing how far he can push you. Mum might be calm, but she might nip that nonsense in the bud pretty quick either with what he wants, or with a look!!

special needs or not, life is about him & others learning to manage those needs. … staying alive driving a car is pretty fundamental to that!!

Brefugee · 17/10/2023 07:56

ForgotTheBiscuits · 14/10/2023 01:54

I’m not looking forward to my son’s birthday party as I know the end will involve half an hour of crying from this kid, as we have to drive him home. It takes all my self control to not just snap ‘will you pack it in, you annoying little sod!’, especially when driving.

I have tried the firm, authoritative ‘Right, I think that’s enough now/think of other peoples’ and also ignoring. I’ve been unlucky enough to spend rather a lot of time with this kid so have used all the tricks!

I am acutely aware it’s not my place to discipline this child, but how the heck can I tolerate this incessant crying when he doesn’t get his own way?!

So tell his mum that she has to be there and take him out and take charge of him if he behaves like this?
Or tell his mum that if he can't behave he can't come?
or that she has to make other arrangements to get him home?

Newhorizons8 · 17/10/2023 07:55

Nobody is diagnosing him but just saying it could be based on our experiences. Obviously, that is just one part but its really common for ND children to have meltdowns at the end of preferred activities.

Instead, you would rather accuse a 4year old of using his emotional distress to be manipulative and question his mothers parenting skills.

It's only offensive if you think there is something wrong with being ND.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 16/10/2023 20:50

Kazzybingbong · 16/10/2023 18:45

Could be ND and overstimulated so hence the meltdown. It’s really nothing to do with you and if you find neurodivergence so annoying, then find someone else to hang around with.

You go from could be ND to if you can't handle ND child find someone else to hang out with???

How do some of you get through the day?

It's offensive to diagnose someone's child who you know nothing about or met. His father walked out on them and sees him when he wants mum is struggling to give him the attention he craves. It can't be the fucking obvious let's all pile on and say he's got ND. Fuck it

Pertangyangkipperbang · 16/10/2023 20:41

Four Grandsons with ASD.
This child needs to be assessed.. all points to ASD.

Newhorizons8 · 16/10/2023 20:11

As others have said do a countdown, "We're leaving in 30mins, we're leaving in 25 mins, we're leaving in 20mins", also tell in advance we will be at the party for 1 hour and then it's time to go home.

My son was diagnosed ASD at 2yo and this technique really helped him (not saying this child has ASD) with the ending of a preferred activity. I started with reminding 30mins before the end and reminding him every 5mins, now I don't have to prepare him as much in advance.

Sennelier1 · 16/10/2023 18:50

At the age of 4 children understand the meaning of agreeing on something, making a promiss. Maybe you ask that child in advance he will not cry or make a scene when it's time to leave. Make him promis, shake hands on it or pinky-swear or something. Repeat what you agreed on : no theater, no crying, when it's time we just go. I have a 4 year old grandson and he's pretty good at brokering a deal and - important - stick to it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread