Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some crimes should not be turned into a drama

86 replies

Mtngfres · 13/10/2023 23:07

Flicking through Netflix and came across 'Maxine'. Realised to my horror that it was a true crime drama about Maxine Carr and the Soham murders 20 years ago. Think it was on TV last year but never heard about it.

I actually felt quite sick and no way I would be able to watch it.

I have watched True crime dramas in the past - The Sixth commandment for example was well done and you could tell it had been done with information and consent of families too. It was still hard to watch.

However, Crime dramas about child murder that many of us still remember on the news just feels too much. Not sure what consent was obtained from victim families either but it just feels wrong to dramatise.

I know it's all about viewing figures though and people always watch these programmes so I won't be surprised if they dramatise other terrible crimes that are best left alone.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 14/10/2023 13:21

"On a very basic level we are looking to stop the same things from happening to ourselves and our families and we do that by gathering as much information as possible and educating ourselves on the warning signs."
Really? I don't actually agree with this. I think this is just post hoc justification.

duchiebun · 14/10/2023 11:41

On a very basic level we are looking to stop the same things from happening to ourselves and our families and we do that by gathering as much information as possible and educating ourselves on the warning signs.

Im not convinced about this or at least the argument you can learn from it. What can you learn? dont get into cars with strangers, don’t wear an expensive watch, etc are all things most people know without watching a TC doc.
Most people are murdered by someone they know for one.

Rosiem2808 · 14/10/2023 11:29

I am in a similar mind regarding the drama 'The Long Shadow'. Many of the facts are being scotched over and the real truth is in there somewhere but maybe it just does not make good telly (the truth) so they improvise and make the victims look weak when they were real people who deserve better than a dramatical twist on the actual facts.
What that man did and the way the police dealt with it compounding the misogyny was almost a double act in itself. Dramas like this reduce people to nothing and people tend to look upon these TV re-enactments as gospel when they are far removed from any truth that I can see here.

ZellyFitzgerald · 14/10/2023 11:10

Shows not shoes!

ZellyFitzgerald · 14/10/2023 11:09

It's human nature to be interested in True Crime.

From a purely evolutionary perspective, we learn from these situations, so to admonish someone and make them feel ashamed of having an interest in them is so wrong.

There's a reason True Crime podcasts, shoes and books are so popular, and it's not because the vast majority are 'ghoulish', it's because we are curious and for good reason.

On a very basic level we are looking to stop the same things from happening to ourselves and our families and we do that by gathering as much information as possible and educating ourselves on the warning signs.

Pigeonqueen · 14/10/2023 09:50

My dd is studying Criminology at university as are many other people. If people weren’t interested in these sorts of things our justice system wouldn’t have people wanting to work in it, which wouldn’t be good for society. Ultimately people want to understand these events, the people behind them. It’s actually really normal to be interested in true crime. Mumsnet seems to have some weird attitude about it all.

x2boys · 14/10/2023 09:15

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/10/2023 01:00

If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. You get your jollies from other’s murder. Yes think about that…you can dress it up however you want but someone died for your entertainment. You might as well watch a snuff film.

And no @Mtngfres you don’t get to occupy the moral high ground because you had this epiphany.

And yet there are whole channels dedicated to true crime so there must be an awful lot of ghouls out there.

x2boys · 14/10/2023 09:10

Mtngfres · 13/10/2023 23:07

Flicking through Netflix and came across 'Maxine'. Realised to my horror that it was a true crime drama about Maxine Carr and the Soham murders 20 years ago. Think it was on TV last year but never heard about it.

I actually felt quite sick and no way I would be able to watch it.

I have watched True crime dramas in the past - The Sixth commandment for example was well done and you could tell it had been done with information and consent of families too. It was still hard to watch.

However, Crime dramas about child murder that many of us still remember on the news just feels too much. Not sure what consent was obtained from victim families either but it just feels wrong to dramatise.

I know it's all about viewing figures though and people always watch these programmes so I won't be surprised if they dramatise other terrible crimes that are best left alone.

It actually focused on Maxine Carr and her involvement ,it wasn't in anyway glamorous I watch a lot of true crime and thought it was well done
There are already lots of documentaries about the Soham murders .
I have also recently watched the long Shadow and The Reckoning and thought they were well done too ,these types of programs are always going to.be sensitive because of the nature of them.

ilovesooty · 14/10/2023 09:02

"Maxine" did a good job of portraying Huntley as the coercive lying scum he was. It certainly didn't glorify him.

sashagabadon · 14/10/2023 08:59

I don’t listen to any true crime now or I try very hard not too. It’s a morally dubious genre imo. Imagine thinking milly dowlers murder is a great subject for a podcast 😥

Whatafustercluck · 14/10/2023 08:59

Maxine Carr didn't kill those children. Unlike someone like, say Myra Hindley, she had no hand in their actual murders. She was in a coercively controlling relationship with Huntley and I would expect that the drama is focused on her perspective of Ian Huntley and what happened. Their jail terms reflected their respective levels of involvement.

And i say that as someone who was professionally involved in the case.

LakeTiticaca · 14/10/2023 08:52

CeeceeBloomingdale · 14/10/2023 00:25

It's a good watch, you're making assumptions. Also remember Maxine was in an abusive relationship and her crime was giving a false alibi yet the public treated her akin to Myra Hindley and she was granted life long anonymity due to the public's reaction.

Spot on. She was obviously terrified of him, nasty piece of work that he is .
I always felt a small pang of sympathy for her and I hope she has managed to rebuild her life, wherever she is x

Zebedee55 · 14/10/2023 08:39

Catalwaysasleep · 14/10/2023 07:50

Yes I agree. Like the Saville programme. I feel like the idea glorifies the person who commits the crime. And I don't think entertainment should be made of such suffering. Either it will be gory or it isn't the whole truth, so that's misleading.

I wouldn't watch such a thing.

It didn't glorify him, and Coogan played the part well. It made him the creep he was.

Many of the child victims, adults now, had cameo "clips" in it, so that people heard from them. They were happy about it being shown.

Programmes on TV are a choice, and no one has to watch anything.

BethDuttonsTwin · 14/10/2023 08:15

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/10/2023 01:00

If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. You get your jollies from other’s murder. Yes think about that…you can dress it up however you want but someone died for your entertainment. You might as well watch a snuff film.

And no @Mtngfres you don’t get to occupy the moral high ground because you had this epiphany.

What a ridiculous post 🙄

Witchcraftandhokum · 14/10/2023 08:05

saltinesandcoffeecups·

If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. You get your jollies from other’s murder. Yes think about that…you can dress it up however you want but someone died for your entertainment. You might as well watch a snuff film.

And (having actually seen some)I think anyone who is entertained by soaps or reality shows is as thick as mince.

Neriah · 14/10/2023 08:01

I haven't watched it so I can't comment on the content. Neither have you, so neither can you. Like anything else on TV, you can choose to watch it or not. But you are being unreasonable if you think your choices should dicatte other people's available content. I hate films/ programmes about wars. I generally don't watch them. That doesn't mean that I have a right to tell others that they aren't allowed that content. Yes, there should be sensitivity shown, and programmes should not set out to glorify perpetrators (my main objection to all things "war" being that they often do glorify war), but I cannot see how it is realistically possible to ban such things.

Catalwaysasleep · 14/10/2023 07:54

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/10/2023 01:00

If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. You get your jollies from other’s murder. Yes think about that…you can dress it up however you want but someone died for your entertainment. You might as well watch a snuff film.

And no @Mtngfres you don’t get to occupy the moral high ground because you had this epiphany.

I don't watch them but I don't agree with this.

I got obsessed with reading news of celebrities splitting up - a bit sad I know. I wasn't happy it happened - I was curious.

We get a lot thrown at us in the news. I think people can get obsessively curious or interested in something they'd prefer didn't happen. Also some people want answers and hope the TV drama will help. Though I fear this could be misleading.

Beargrumps22 · 14/10/2023 07:53

If it is done more as a documentary style programme which will educate people to the warning signs or red flags then that is acceptable. it is important that society learns about how these people got away with crimes and how to stop it happening again.
on the other hand if it is done just as a ghoulish entertainment that is wrong.

Catalwaysasleep · 14/10/2023 07:50

Yes I agree. Like the Saville programme. I feel like the idea glorifies the person who commits the crime. And I don't think entertainment should be made of such suffering. Either it will be gory or it isn't the whole truth, so that's misleading.

I wouldn't watch such a thing.

koalaknickers · 14/10/2023 07:47

I have watched some true crime which isn't really my nature. Wish I hadn't! BTK, particularly.

duchiebun · 14/10/2023 07:44

You only have to look at the armchair detectives and psychiatrists that swarm round any ongoing incident that's publicised on the TV.

Good point, the Nicola Bully threads were shocking imo. So many seemed to want her to be a murder victim & thought there were amateur sleuths.

duchiebun · 14/10/2023 07:42

I would be devastated if my loved one's murder ended up on Netflix as someone's Saturday night entertainment. Imagine if it were your child that was murdered and their murder was turned into a "good" and entertaining watch on TV.

Thsts what I struggle with. I think if victims families are involved & the story is focused on them it’s different. Many don’t & aren’t always 100% factually.

CurlewKate · 14/10/2023 04:41

I agree. I've already been told of on another thread for objecting to the Saville drama. A well researched documentary is fine if there is a danger of a case being forgotten. A drama with "made up bits" is simply prurience. You only have to look at the armchair detectives and psychiatrists that swarm round any ongoing incident that's publicised on the TV.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/10/2023 01:12

XenoBitch · 14/10/2023 01:03

FFS, a snuff film is made for entertainment. A dramatization of a real life case is not the same. Someone has to be interested in such things or no one would want to work in policing or forensics.

Yeah.. fuck the victims…screw the families. Other people have ‘interest’

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/jeffrey-dahmer-netflix-tv-show-victim-family-speaks-out-1235228196/

Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story

Jeffrey Dahmer Victim’s Family Speaks Out About Netflix Series

Rita Isbell, who is portrayed in 'Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story,' writes in an Insider essay: "It's sad that they're just making money off of this tragedy."

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/jeffrey-dahmer-netflix-tv-show-victim-family-speaks-out-1235228196/

starray · 14/10/2023 01:06

I would be devastated if my loved one's murder ended up on Netflix as someone's Saturday night entertainment. Imagine if it were your child that was murdered and their murder was turned into a "good" and entertaining watch on TV.