Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some crimes should not be turned into a drama

86 replies

Mtngfres · 13/10/2023 23:07

Flicking through Netflix and came across 'Maxine'. Realised to my horror that it was a true crime drama about Maxine Carr and the Soham murders 20 years ago. Think it was on TV last year but never heard about it.

I actually felt quite sick and no way I would be able to watch it.

I have watched True crime dramas in the past - The Sixth commandment for example was well done and you could tell it had been done with information and consent of families too. It was still hard to watch.

However, Crime dramas about child murder that many of us still remember on the news just feels too much. Not sure what consent was obtained from victim families either but it just feels wrong to dramatise.

I know it's all about viewing figures though and people always watch these programmes so I won't be surprised if they dramatise other terrible crimes that are best left alone.

OP posts:
itsmyp4rty · 15/10/2023 17:35

I watched that Jeffrey Dahmer one on Netflix and I have to say it was crazy but absolutely fascinating - if it hadn't happened then you'd never believe it. It was done as more of a drama than a documentary as it was done from his point of view - and of course they couldn't know exactly what he did when he was alone.

I do think it was done too soon and that it was wrong not to ask people if they were happy to be portrayed in it - or even tell them beforehand that they were including them in it.

PuppyMonkey · 15/10/2023 17:28

What does everyone here think of the cosy type of murder drama/comedy shows that currently seem so big. I’m thinking mainly of Only Murders in the Building but also things like Midsummer Murders and the one where it’s set in the Caribbean, forget the name!

I know they’re not real cases, but I often feel a bit uncomfortable watching stories about people being horribly murdered - usually while the stars are making witty quips or taking the piss.

therealcookiemonster · 15/10/2023 17:20

I am 100% with you OP. disrespectful to the tragic victims and their families to monetise their heartbreak. and some of these are positively ghoulish.

I enjoy crime drama but could never watch something based on real life, can barely manage to read the news coverage.

Gwendimarco · 15/10/2023 17:06

YANBU, I find it ghoulish.
It’s like those horrible memoire paperbacks in the supermarket with titles like “Daddy, no” all about child abuse. Somebody somewhere must enjoy reading them, it’s grim.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 17:04

I'm so sick I named my bearded dragon Ted Bundy.

x2boys · 15/10/2023 16:47

Milarky · 15/10/2023 16:40

So you accidentally watched all.three episodes but have the audacity to call other people who watch true crime sick individuals
What a,Hypocrite

I know a complete hypocrite!! That's what I'm saying! It's really easy to see why people get sucked into them!

Also I suppose in my defence, and admittedly a pretty shit defence, how I can have an opinion on these sort of shows if I've never watched one? Well I have now. It's reinforced my opinion of the people who watch them and the shows who make money out them.

I will never watch another.

Well you could have turned it off after a,few minutes but you watched all.three so.....

Milarky · 15/10/2023 16:40

So you accidentally watched all.three episodes but have the audacity to call other people who watch true crime sick individuals
What a,Hypocrite

I know a complete hypocrite!! That's what I'm saying! It's really easy to see why people get sucked into them!

Also I suppose in my defence, and admittedly a pretty shit defence, how I can have an opinion on these sort of shows if I've never watched one? Well I have now. It's reinforced my opinion of the people who watch them and the shows who make money out them.

I will never watch another.

MyDogSmellsTerrible · 15/10/2023 16:30

I've just really enjoyed watching The Long Shadow about Peter Sutcliffe.

Thought it was brilliantly done. I often wonder why the police today seem so soft. But having watched how utterly incompetent, misogynistic and arrogant they were towards those poor women, it's opened up a whole new perspective to me.

I think if the families of the victims are openly hostile to the idea, then perhaps not - but if they don't object, I can't see why the story shouldn't be televised.

Faircastle · 15/10/2023 16:27

This question is the subject of a Black Mirror episode: Loch Henry.

TumblingTower · 15/10/2023 16:04

Milarky · 15/10/2023 14:58

I have never watched any real-life crime drama or watched/listen to podcasts.

Think the women who watch this shit (I believe it's mostly women) are sick individuals.

Now after being all high and mighty I must admit to coincidently watching Maxine last night. Don't know why, just couldn't find anything else at just let it play. I watched all 3 episodes and I can see why some people get into it. It appears to give a deeper insight into the crime. I'd missed from the original tragedy that Hinley had already been accused of rape of young girls.

Anyway all the way though I was thinking, did the parents agree to this? And the hypocrisy of the show slagging off the red tops when the programme was using those families misery to make money too, blew my mind!

No I'd never watch another true crime drama. But I'm guessing there's going to a lot more. :(

I hate that she's out and has a kid and family. She knew exactly what she was doing when she was cleaning up and lying.

She obviously wasn't that afraid of him if she was snogging other men. Reading some of the abused women's posts on here, and the constant fear they are under, I doesn't compute with me that she would risk doing that.

Are you balancing on a pin head on that moral high ground 😂

LaurieFairyCake · 15/10/2023 15:58

Yep, both Maxine and Saville are too soon for me - will watch them in 20 years

I've just watched the Yorkshire Murderer one with Toby Jones as I was young when it happened

Oblomov23 · 15/10/2023 15:46

"If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. " oh purlease. Hmm There are loads and loads of films, documentaries, programmes, series about crime.

x2boys · 15/10/2023 15:32

Milarky · 15/10/2023 14:58

I have never watched any real-life crime drama or watched/listen to podcasts.

Think the women who watch this shit (I believe it's mostly women) are sick individuals.

Now after being all high and mighty I must admit to coincidently watching Maxine last night. Don't know why, just couldn't find anything else at just let it play. I watched all 3 episodes and I can see why some people get into it. It appears to give a deeper insight into the crime. I'd missed from the original tragedy that Hinley had already been accused of rape of young girls.

Anyway all the way though I was thinking, did the parents agree to this? And the hypocrisy of the show slagging off the red tops when the programme was using those families misery to make money too, blew my mind!

No I'd never watch another true crime drama. But I'm guessing there's going to a lot more. :(

I hate that she's out and has a kid and family. She knew exactly what she was doing when she was cleaning up and lying.

She obviously wasn't that afraid of him if she was snogging other men. Reading some of the abused women's posts on here, and the constant fear they are under, I doesn't compute with me that she would risk doing that.

So you accidentally watched all.three episodes but have the audacity to call other people who watch true crime sick individuals
What a,Hypocrite

Milarky · 15/10/2023 14:58

I have never watched any real-life crime drama or watched/listen to podcasts.

Think the women who watch this shit (I believe it's mostly women) are sick individuals.

Now after being all high and mighty I must admit to coincidently watching Maxine last night. Don't know why, just couldn't find anything else at just let it play. I watched all 3 episodes and I can see why some people get into it. It appears to give a deeper insight into the crime. I'd missed from the original tragedy that Hinley had already been accused of rape of young girls.

Anyway all the way though I was thinking, did the parents agree to this? And the hypocrisy of the show slagging off the red tops when the programme was using those families misery to make money too, blew my mind!

No I'd never watch another true crime drama. But I'm guessing there's going to a lot more. :(

I hate that she's out and has a kid and family. She knew exactly what she was doing when she was cleaning up and lying.

She obviously wasn't that afraid of him if she was snogging other men. Reading some of the abused women's posts on here, and the constant fear they are under, I doesn't compute with me that she would risk doing that.

Passepartoute · 15/10/2023 14:46

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/10/2023 01:00

If you watch any of these you’re a ghoul. You get your jollies from other’s murder. Yes think about that…you can dress it up however you want but someone died for your entertainment. You might as well watch a snuff film.

And no @Mtngfres you don’t get to occupy the moral high ground because you had this epiphany.

How far do you take that? Can we not watch, say, any of Shakespeare's history plays because they feature actual deaths and murders? If we can watch those, how do you define the cut-off point?

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 14:31

x2boys · 15/10/2023 12:24

I.assume they will.have.to.ask.the families permission?
About 30/years ago.there was an horrific murder local to me it went unsolved for many years and the killer was only caught by chance
Earlier this year it was dramatized on how they caught the killer
Lots of people including me watch true crime programs
Clearly there is a fascination shared by many hence all crime channels etc.

They did ask permission but the mum and step dad said no but the girl's real dad agreed despite not having much involvement in her life.

TumblingTower · 15/10/2023 13:11

Pigeonqueen · 13/10/2023 23:49

If you actually watched it you might feel differently. I found it really interesting and not gory or glorifying things at all.

No. It doesn’t cover the actual murder at all.

SuperFi · 15/10/2023 13:10

YANBU Op, I think the BBC has a brass neck producing this Savile drama for content when they turned a blind eye to his antics for years. Not watching it, surely everyone knows enough about him already?

@Rosiem2808 yes I know what you mean about the Long Shadow too, the family of murdered victim Yvonne Pearson refused to cooperate/ objected to the show, so she was not featured and replaced with a fictional character.
However as@Hereinthismoment says I do agree that some crimes are pivotal sociological moments, and history in action . I think many young people now would struggle to comprehend the level of sexism and misogyny in the UK in the 70s, and the Long Shadow portrays this well imo. Aldo Police detecting operations were radically overhauled follow the conviction of Peter Sutcliffe
It is a difficult area though, especially when the artistic licence muddies the waters, and some people take these dramas as entirely factual.

Vocaladvocaat · 15/10/2023 12:32

Yanbu

Hereinthismoment · 15/10/2023 12:32

I do think at least part of the fascination with crime is this guilty shifty sense that we ‘shouldn’t’ be enjoying it (or entertained by it) yet we are.

Many crimes are pivotal in sociological terms. The Soham murders were in terms of child protection and were probably the start of seeing teens in relationships with older men as victims of sexual abuse and not sluts, although it wasn’t until the late 2010s that really changed. If you look at what happened to Arlene Arkinson in NI in the 90s and Hannah Williams in Kent it shows pretty starkly what attitudes were once.

Crime is history in action. I don’t think there’s anything as raw and real as crime for showing what things were like once, especially for women and girls.

x2boys · 15/10/2023 12:24

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 12:07

There was a documentary focusing on a 16 year old girl from my area who got murdered by her aunt's boyfriend. The murder was in 2020, and the TV programme is on Netflix called 'A Killer In My Village'.

It caused all sorts of drama on our local Facebook page about whether to watch it or not out of respect for the family.

I.assume they will.have.to.ask.the families permission?
About 30/years ago.there was an horrific murder local to me it went unsolved for many years and the killer was only caught by chance
Earlier this year it was dramatized on how they caught the killer
Lots of people including me watch true crime programs
Clearly there is a fascination shared by many hence all crime channels etc.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 12:07

There was a documentary focusing on a 16 year old girl from my area who got murdered by her aunt's boyfriend. The murder was in 2020, and the TV programme is on Netflix called 'A Killer In My Village'.

It caused all sorts of drama on our local Facebook page about whether to watch it or not out of respect for the family.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 12:04

Well I expect they'll be very many viewers tuning in to watch a Lucy Letby documentary in the future.

I like to watch true crime but I'm an insensitive soul anyway. I don't get shocked or upset over things.

CesareBorgia · 15/10/2023 11:13

There was a thread here about the Maxine drama at the time it came out, peppered with posters telling others they were disgusting for watching it.

RhymesWithTangerine · 15/10/2023 11:10

You are all on a thread about a true crime drama. You’re interested! It’s no good primly calling other people ‘ghouls’ - we are fascinated by crime.

And that’s rightly so because it has a huge impact on us emotionally and socially, tapping into deep instincts.