Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some crimes should not be turned into a drama

86 replies

Mtngfres · 13/10/2023 23:07

Flicking through Netflix and came across 'Maxine'. Realised to my horror that it was a true crime drama about Maxine Carr and the Soham murders 20 years ago. Think it was on TV last year but never heard about it.

I actually felt quite sick and no way I would be able to watch it.

I have watched True crime dramas in the past - The Sixth commandment for example was well done and you could tell it had been done with information and consent of families too. It was still hard to watch.

However, Crime dramas about child murder that many of us still remember on the news just feels too much. Not sure what consent was obtained from victim families either but it just feels wrong to dramatise.

I know it's all about viewing figures though and people always watch these programmes so I won't be surprised if they dramatise other terrible crimes that are best left alone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/10/2023 17:19

I think many young people now would struggle to comprehend the level of sexism and misogyny in the UK in the 70s, and the Long Shadow portrays this well imo

This. I was born in the mid 70s so didn't really know what it was like then. My heart broke for Marcella Claxton and the awful way she was treated

Hereinthismoment · 18/10/2023 16:36

Why?

I don’t consider myself to be lacking a sense of humour and I certainly have an (unhealthy, according to some!) interest in true crime. But mockery is different.

Universalsnail · 18/10/2023 10:23

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 17:04

I'm so sick I named my bearded dragon Ted Bundy.

This made me laugh far to much 😂

Nazzywish · 18/10/2023 09:44

I've just come across this series and shocked its there, it's just still seems too recent and must be so hard for the girls families to see this advertised etc too. RIP always to those two beautiful angels.

Tutufruiti29 · 16/10/2023 20:48

I watched Maxine the other night. I was interested because I worked for the police years after on the bichard enquiry. I do know where you are coming from though

SammyScrounge · 16/10/2023 19:51

Pigeonqueen · 13/10/2023 23:49

If you actually watched it you might feel differently. I found it really interesting and not gory or glorifying things at all.

I felt the same. The programme showed how audacious and nauseating Savile was as a person. I thought too that the reactions of his victims was very well done. There was no salaciousness only a tormented child's reaction

groohad · 16/10/2023 16:01

Savile was the first of these true crime things I've watched. I thought it was informative (I had no idea about the details, including necrophilia rumours) and would be useful in educating those people who said they had doubts.

TumblingTower · 16/10/2023 15:32

silvercurtainpoles · 16/10/2023 08:41

I disagree but I think it's important to tell the story accurately and sensitively. I think the Saville series is an example of how to do it well. They're telling the story but interspersing it with testimony from the victims - people who up until this point never had a voice.

If the series is sensationalised or gratuitous then that's different but in the case of Holly and Jessica, there will be many who've never heard of this case and in a way it's reminding people these poor girls did exist and their lives counted. If the families strongly objected, then I might be inclined to think differently but sometimes if they're fine well, these programmes can honour the victims plus help others come to terms with the horrific things that happened to them.

I totally agree with your first paragraph. As someone who was sexually abused as a child I can say that being believed gives you a lot of closure. When the man that abused me was spared prison it was so comforting when he was finally convicted a few years after (for crimes against others).

Dramatic · 16/10/2023 09:29

CeeceeBloomingdale · 14/10/2023 00:25

It's a good watch, you're making assumptions. Also remember Maxine was in an abusive relationship and her crime was giving a false alibi yet the public treated her akin to Myra Hindley and she was granted life long anonymity due to the public's reaction.

This always bothered me, as someone who has been in an abusive relationship I can completely see why she thought she had no choice. Plus she wasn't there when he commited the crime, she could never have changed the outcome of what happened. Obviously she should have told the police from the outset but I don't think she deserved anywhere near the hate that he deserved, yet they were pretty much equally vilified

RhymesWithTangerine · 16/10/2023 09:25

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/10/2023 01:57

That’s an odd take. Are all the people posting in the Israel/Hamas threads warmongers who have their popcorn out watching footage of death and destruction?

The people on the Hamas/Israel thread are interested in Hamas/Israel. The people on the True Crime on Telly thread are interested in Trues Crime on Telly.

It’s not difficult.

silvercurtainpoles · 16/10/2023 08:41

I disagree but I think it's important to tell the story accurately and sensitively. I think the Saville series is an example of how to do it well. They're telling the story but interspersing it with testimony from the victims - people who up until this point never had a voice.

If the series is sensationalised or gratuitous then that's different but in the case of Holly and Jessica, there will be many who've never heard of this case and in a way it's reminding people these poor girls did exist and their lives counted. If the families strongly objected, then I might be inclined to think differently but sometimes if they're fine well, these programmes can honour the victims plus help others come to terms with the horrific things that happened to them.

StasisMom · 16/10/2023 07:53

Surely it's more your feelings when watching something like this, which count more? I watch a lot of crime programmes, I never "enjoy" them specifically but I find them interesting. And my overall feeling is sympathy for the victims and families, and anger/hatred for the perpetrators.

Jewelspun · 16/10/2023 07:42

Code of a killer is an excellent film/mini series and deals with the victims and their families very well.

IsThatTheTimeAlready · 16/10/2023 07:34

I thought The Reckoning was very well done. Steve Coogan played Savile brilliantly.
It showed Savile for the creepy, lying, egoistic, paedophilic sex offender that he was.
If anything, it made me feel even more sympathetic towards his victims.
Call me what you like, but I love a true crime / murder, be it a book or on TV.

Tambatamba · 16/10/2023 07:27

CeeceeBloomingdale · 14/10/2023 00:25

It's a good watch, you're making assumptions. Also remember Maxine was in an abusive relationship and her crime was giving a false alibi yet the public treated her akin to Myra Hindley and she was granted life long anonymity due to the public's reaction.

I agree with this.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/10/2023 07:15

InterFactual · 15/10/2023 18:17

YANBU. I was really shocked to see Steve Coogan playing Jimmy Saville. I'm sure it was a well made production but how utterly vile to give that man any more air time. The worst punishment for him is to be forgotten, he so loved the attention that it seems fitting to exile him to the history books and never speak his name again. He is an insignificant nobody, he doesn't deserve a dramatisation even if it's a negative one.

He wasn't an insignificant nobody, and how he was feted and promoted despite serious concerns being known is one of the key learning points.

His victims were involved in that piece, which is an important feature - not only in the dramatisation but speaking as the people they are now.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/10/2023 07:08

There are an awful lot. There were many who went to watch executions!

I think the interest is in some ways natural, as a way of trying to understand a frightening feature of human society.

However some of the tone in discussions gets distasteful. I feel like consumption of true crime as though it were entertainment isn't healthy.

I worry about the adaptations and podcasts that don't have family input.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/10/2023 01:57

RhymesWithTangerine · 15/10/2023 11:10

You are all on a thread about a true crime drama. You’re interested! It’s no good primly calling other people ‘ghouls’ - we are fascinated by crime.

And that’s rightly so because it has a huge impact on us emotionally and socially, tapping into deep instincts.

That’s an odd take. Are all the people posting in the Israel/Hamas threads warmongers who have their popcorn out watching footage of death and destruction?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/10/2023 01:49

LetsPlayShadowlands · 16/10/2023 01:14

Is "ghoulish" the true crime equivalent of "unhinged" 😂

Would you like to watch a dramatization of yourself giving a witness impact statement in your brothers killer’s sentencing hearing?

You’re right she should be happy that everyone got some entertainment for a few minutes…what is she bitching about wanting to be consulted.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 16/10/2023 01:14

Is "ghoulish" the true crime equivalent of "unhinged" 😂

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/10/2023 23:59

Passepartoute · 15/10/2023 14:46

How far do you take that? Can we not watch, say, any of Shakespeare's history plays because they feature actual deaths and murders? If we can watch those, how do you define the cut-off point?

Nice try at the straw man…but it’s pretty easy… Are the relatives going to see depictions of themselves or their murdered love one be turned into entertainment?

That’s my line. You really should read what it was like for someone to be victimized again. The below bit is just a snippet

https://www.insider.com/rita-isbell-sister-jeffrey-dahmer-victim-talks-about-netflix-show-2022-9

When I saw some of the show, it bothered me, especially when I saw myself — when I saw my name come across the screen and this lady saying verbatim exactly what I said.
If I didn't know any better, I would've thought it was me. Her hair was like mine, she had on the same clothes. That's why it felt like reliving it all over again. It brought back all the emotions I was feeling back then.
I was never contacted about the show. I feel like Netflix should've asked if we mind or how we felt about making it. They didn't ask me anything. They just did it.
But I'm not money hungry, and that's what this show is about, Netflix trying to get paid.
I could even understand it if they gave some of the money to the victims' children. Not necessarily their families. I mean, I'm old. I'm very, very comfortable. But the victims have children and grandchildren. If the show benefited them in some way, it wouldn't feel so harsh and careless.
It's sad that they're just making money off of this tragedy. That's just greed.

My brother was murdered by Jeffrey Dahmer. Here's what it was like watching the Netflix show that recreated the emotional statement I gave in court.

Rita Isbell told Insider what it was like to watch Netflix's "Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story" and the recreation of her emotional court statement.

https://www.insider.com/rita-isbell-sister-jeffrey-dahmer-victim-talks-about-netflix-show-2022-9

Americano75 · 15/10/2023 18:18

I thought the Savile programme was very well done, I felt so angry for those victims and had found it hard to understand just how he had managed to get away with it for so long. It made me feel furious. But the victims interviewed have stated that this is as close as they'll get to any kind of justice.

InterFactual · 15/10/2023 18:17

YANBU. I was really shocked to see Steve Coogan playing Jimmy Saville. I'm sure it was a well made production but how utterly vile to give that man any more air time. The worst punishment for him is to be forgotten, he so loved the attention that it seems fitting to exile him to the history books and never speak his name again. He is an insignificant nobody, he doesn't deserve a dramatisation even if it's a negative one.

x2boys · 15/10/2023 18:13

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/10/2023 17:04

I'm so sick I named my bearded dragon Ted Bundy.

😂

LakieLady · 15/10/2023 18:11

Catalwaysasleep · 14/10/2023 07:50

Yes I agree. Like the Saville programme. I feel like the idea glorifies the person who commits the crime. And I don't think entertainment should be made of such suffering. Either it will be gory or it isn't the whole truth, so that's misleading.

I wouldn't watch such a thing.

The Savile programme does anything but glorify him. It shows him for the vile, lying, manipulative, child-abusing pos that he was.

Steve Coogan's acting in it is breathtakingly good, an absolute masterclass in how an ostensibly low-key performance can be incredibly compelling.