Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry with teacher about commenting on pupil appearance

136 replies

Drizzlydrizzle12 · 13/10/2023 19:58

What do you think about what this teacher said today. He's a supply until Xmas.

Recently when the children line up for assembly he's been saying about them being smart and commenting on their appearance saying they don't look smart enough.

Today he gave a reward point to a girl because she had really shiny shoes. They are that shiny leather material and some of the other children will never have shoes that material so I feel its unfair. They are yr6 so beginning to become aware of their appearance. I just think personally he shouldn't be doing this.

Also what about the children in the class who I know live in difficult circumstances and its not their fault that their uniform is messy. It just places more anxiety to them and points out the gap between the well looked after children and those who aren't. Aibu to be mad at the teacher?

OP posts:
Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 08:36

WASZPy · 13/10/2023 20:34

Asking kids to straighten their skirts and ties, tuck their shirts in, pull their socks up, tidy their hair etc before assembly is absolutely standard practise. I should imagine by 'messy' he was referring to this sort of thing, not whether their polo shirts were from Harrods or not.

Clearly he was doing more than that if he was rewarding children for the shoes their parents choose to pay for.

Teaching children to make a big thing about appearance rather than hard work and attainment shows a weird sense of priorities for a teacher.

Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 08:33

Underneaththestars · 13/10/2023 20:12

You are being very unreasonable. It's completely normal for teachers to comment on the smartness and check uniform/shoes before assembly. Sounds like he's doing his job to me.

It really isn't. Teachers have much better things to do with their time.

Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 08:32

cansu · 13/10/2023 20:08

Teacher praises shiny shoes. Are you seriously cross about this?? Maybe you need to relax a bit.

Giving a reward point to a child for something that their parents have done is just stupid, and it's not fair to other pupils whose parents can't afford the same.

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/10/2023 08:09

CosyFluffBooBoo · 14/10/2023 07:50

I don't think primary school children need to look smart, just clean, rested, fed, comfy and ready to learn and socialise.

Very much this. Tbh the anachronistic clinging to uniform and 'smartness' in UK schools (primary and secondary alike) boggles me more every year. Almost every other country in large parts of the world seems to turn out successful educational outcomes and people able to dress and act appropriately in a range of scenarios without insisting that schoolchildren don't wear trainers. I wish an academic study would measure the time and energy that goes into policing this stuff and convert it into the progress in attainment that could be made it if went on actual teaching and learning.

Anyway - I'd be uncomfortable with this and perhaps have a quiet word (with the teacher himself in the first instance), asking him what his pedagogical aim is in making the comments and mentioning your concern about children in difficult circumstances. I'd also be looking at it in the round - what is he like otherwise, do the children like him, are they learning? It may just be a hobby horse of his.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 14/10/2023 08:09

As long as he’s not punishing the ones without shiny shoes, I don’t see the problem. He’s still teaching everyone what smart looks like. As adults, they’ll all know to polish their shoes.

MrsNandortheRelentless · 14/10/2023 08:06

This thread has transported me right back to being that scruffy hungry child feeling utterly utterly ashamed, trying to stretch down the sleeves of my too small cardigan and hide the holes. Trying to avoid the puddles with my unshiny shoes because of the holes and feeling scruffy and conspicuous and judged by adults, teachers, other kids.

But that was the fucking 1970’s. I am damaged from that, kids will be damaged from it still happening in the year 2023. FFS. It’s another form of abusing kids who have NO control over this. And it is abuse.

Drizzlydrizzle12 · 14/10/2023 08:05

Tamuchly · 14/10/2023 07:37

I’m a TA in a year 6 class and I make a lot of comments to children about their appearance every day. I notice new hairstyles, remind them about the make up rule discreetly, ask them to wash their hands, notice muddy trousers, ask about cuts and grazes, remind them to wear or not wear their jumper for certain activities and comment also if they are looking really smart. I also notice when someone in the class doesn’t look as together as they normally do and try to get to the bottom of it. Our uniform is non compulsory but almost everyone wears it. When these children go to the local secondary schools their uniform will be compulsory and it will be checked every morning. My informal comments about their appearance reminds them that I see them, that I notice them as individuals and that I care.

Yes I do the same as in our you've got a new haircut that's nice and obviously no makeup as that's the school rules. Or if they need their jumper for p.e. What I wouldn't do is make them line up ready for p.e and loudly comment on things in front of the whole class.
A few of them actually said oh that's not fair when he said about point for shiny shoes. You shouldn't need to point certain children out in a line for the way their appearance is.
I'm also a new TA at the school and he's new too

OP posts:
MeinKraft · 14/10/2023 07:59

I grew up in one of those deprived and neglected type of homes. Teachers making comments around that age (well maybe a year or two older) did me a favour really, if I hadn't had teachers pointing out that I was scruffy the other kids would have done it for me eventually. That was how the penny dropped and I started talking myself off for regular showers and washing my own uniform. There were some things that I couldn't help, like having the cheap polyester blazer instead of the expensive woollen one most kids had but there are things children can do themselves.

cansu · 14/10/2023 07:56

You clearly don't like him. Are you the class TA? Tbh I have seen some very unsupportive and sneery TAs with new or supply staff.

DinnaeFashYersel · 14/10/2023 07:54

Never ceased to be amazed about the things that parents get worked up about.

Jeezo let the child get a bit of praise for something.

CosyFluffBooBoo · 14/10/2023 07:50

I don't think primary school children need to look smart, just clean, rested, fed, comfy and ready to learn and socialise.

DrFosterWentToGloucester23 · 14/10/2023 07:48

I gave a reward point the other day to a kid for having a glue stick and a ruler. You’d hate me.

Maddy70 · 14/10/2023 07:43

AlfredaTheGrape · 13/10/2023 23:51

I think that teachers should stop commenting excessively on children's clothing and appearance. And male teachers in particular need to think very carefully about what messages they are sending when commenting on girls' clothing or appearance. It's getting very weird indeed. This bizarre overly-controlling cult of uniform in the majority of British schools is making us look ridiculous, and is not helping to improve educational outcomes.

Don't be ridiculous, tuck your shirt in , put your tie straight is teaching basic manners and reinforcing standards nothing sexual

Maddy70 · 14/10/2023 07:43

AlfredaTheGrape · 13/10/2023 23:51

I think that teachers should stop commenting excessively on children's clothing and appearance. And male teachers in particular need to think very carefully about what messages they are sending when commenting on girls' clothing or appearance. It's getting very weird indeed. This bizarre overly-controlling cult of uniform in the majority of British schools is making us look ridiculous, and is not helping to improve educational outcomes.

Don't be ridiculous, tuck your shirt in , put your tie straight is teaching basic manners and reinforcing standards nothing sexual

Tamuchly · 14/10/2023 07:37

I’m a TA in a year 6 class and I make a lot of comments to children about their appearance every day. I notice new hairstyles, remind them about the make up rule discreetly, ask them to wash their hands, notice muddy trousers, ask about cuts and grazes, remind them to wear or not wear their jumper for certain activities and comment also if they are looking really smart. I also notice when someone in the class doesn’t look as together as they normally do and try to get to the bottom of it. Our uniform is non compulsory but almost everyone wears it. When these children go to the local secondary schools their uniform will be compulsory and it will be checked every morning. My informal comments about their appearance reminds them that I see them, that I notice them as individuals and that I care.

Redditchcycler · 14/10/2023 06:35

And what did you do about this dreadful occurrence? I mean you are there. In the classroom. An adult. Why not blooming say something if you don't think it is appropriate. You are the best one to advocate for this poor children you think are being humiliated.

MintJulia · 14/10/2023 06:30

These are 10 & 11yos. They are perfectly capable of cleaning the mud off their shoes, tucking in their shirts etc.

If he was making those comments to reception, then I'd object but by year 6, they should at least start thinking about whether they are tidy or not.

I'd be pretty relaxed about this, but object if he strays into comments about weight, acne, brands etc.

Ggttl · 14/10/2023 06:23

Children get praise and rewards for good behaviour, neat handwriting, good homework, reading lots, good manners, doing well in class, listening to the teacher, putting rubbish in the bin etc. the list is pretty endless. The ones with inadequate parents are going to find all this stuff harder. Also the fact that they start school 2yrs behind their peers is going to be tough for them. What would be a completely fair thing to praise children for? Or are you suggesting there should be no praise in school?

Ilovelurchers · 14/10/2023 02:26

OP if you work in this teacher's class I am guessing you are the TA perhaps? If his conduct in awarding these points goes against your school's policy and ethos, then I would suggest the kindest and most humane thing to do would be to tell him this in a friendly way, as he is probably just doing something he was encouraged to do at other schools:

"Bob, I know you are trying to do a nice thing and build relationships with the kids, but here we don't reward things like smart uniform, due to the levels of deprivation. Giving them points for......(insert appropriate school focus) might be a better way .....Not criticising at all, I know all schools are different so I just wanted to give you a heads up"

Or similar.

If this fails and he persists and you feel strongly enough about it I guess you need to mention it to SLT. It would be decent of you to give him a chance to adjust first.

You should only do this if he is going against school policy though. As we've established on here, some schools have a policy and ethos where smart uniform is rewarded, others don't. There are arguments for and against, of course - as any KS3 child who has been made to write an argumentative speech or essay for or against school uniform could tell you! (It's a popular choice of essay still as the arguments on both sides are so easy to grasp). But if it's just your personal view/preference you can't reasonably insist that he agrees. Some do, some don't - just the way it has always been.

Maddy70 · 14/10/2023 01:24

What's wrong with praising pride in appearance ?

5foot5 · 14/10/2023 00:54

iovebread · 14/10/2023 00:35

was this your education. shoe shining? kids don't know basic math today but their shiny shoes are of more concern?

Oh FFS. Did you not read the OP? She mentioned that a child had been given a reward for shiny shoes and implied that this was because the child had been bought a pair of shoes that were naturally shiny. My point was that clean shoes are within everyone's reach whatever their income.

But oh, yes of course, all I was taught at school was shoe shining! No my parents taught me that because we were not well off and needed to look after whatever we had.

A phrase I see an awful lot on mumsnet is "It's not a race to the bottom." So why doesn't this apply here. Some children unfortunately are in circumstances which compromise their ability to appear smart and clean at school. Does this mean that any expectation of clean and tidy appearance should be abandoned for all pupils? Obviously do not victimise the pupils in difficult circumstances. But is it really so unreasonable to suggest pupils of 10 or 11, with no known problems, should be able to turn up reasonably tidy, shirts tucked in, shoes clean, etc.

StarlightLime · 14/10/2023 00:37

iovebread · 14/10/2023 00:35

was this your education. shoe shining? kids don't know basic math today but their shiny shoes are of more concern?

What a strange response, @iovebread ??

iovebread · 14/10/2023 00:37

jannier · 14/10/2023 00:10

Hey kid you get extra credit for having wealthy parents whilst scruff boy at the back with the charity box hand me downs no watch and needing a haircut what do your parents do buy food and electric rather than new clothes???? Demerit for you poor boy.

exactly this and also, some parents are shit. they don't always take care of their children properly or at all. so judging a kid by some stupid standard reflects poorly on that pathetic teacher. don't expect every child to be in school coming from a good home. fucking teachers, i can't stand them.

iovebread · 14/10/2023 00:35

5foot5 · 14/10/2023 00:30

Do people not clean shoes anymore?

I was taught how to do this at about 7 or 8.it then became one of my regular chores, clean school shoes before bed.

As an added incentive Brownies also had shoe inspection. We were far from well off, but I think clean shoes should be within everyone's reach and therefore worth praising and rewarding.

was this your education. shoe shining? kids don't know basic math today but their shiny shoes are of more concern?

iovebread · 14/10/2023 00:34

I can't stand a lot of teachers today