Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In questioning a school that makes potential grade 7 GCSE pupils fear inferior

36 replies

Georgianattiude · 13/10/2023 18:08

All the year 11s at my DD's 1 school were called into an assembly this morning and told they were to be split in to two large groups. The first group which DD is in was for pupils who are likely to achieve grade 8 or higher in all their GCSE's. The second grouping was for pupils looking at mostly grade 7 and 8s at GCSE. The room where DDs group were placed had an ex pupil and Cambridge graduate highlighting the virtues of hard work and how all this group had the potential to get into Cambridge or Oxford University.

The second group were DDs best friend was placed had a joint 1 hour talk from the Head of Sixth Form and Head of year 11 berating them for their prospective grades averaging below 6.5 or 52 points over their top 8 subjects. This is the requirement for entry in to her Grammar Schools Sixth form.

The head of year apparently rattled on at them that if they do not achieve 52 points they will have wasted their opportunity given to them by passing the 11+. The head of Sixth Form then said to the girls in the group if you can't get 52 points, you don't deserve to be in the Sixth Form here !

I found this horrible on two fronts firstly denigrating pupils who in most schools would be near the top cohort by making them feel stupid. Secondly and perhaps most importantly talks like this can cause mental issues in bright girls to come to the surface.

If this was supposed to be a pep talk to the two groups concerned, I can see it having a very negative effect on both groups actually.

OP posts:
Catastrophejane · 13/10/2023 18:25

I’m in two minds- done badly it could really knock a kids self esteem.

on the other - if these kids passed 11+ , they are all very bright. They are capable of top grades, so they are underperforming if they aren’t getting it.

having said that, kids sometimes have times when they just aren’t that into school work.

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 18:24

If you don't like the ethos of a competitive grammar school (or competitive private school) don't put your kids in one!

Parents will have specially selected them because they push the kids, and they don't resign themselves to be mediocre.

They all passed the 11+, it's not unreasonable to expect a certain level.

Starrystarryfight · 13/10/2023 18:24

Gosh, my daughter came home yesterday telling me she’d been predicted 6s and I was thrilled!
Not a grammar school though

Bobbybobbins · 13/10/2023 18:23

I'm a secondary teacher and agree with you OP that this is likely to be counter productive. Poor kids.

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2023 18:23

If the second group are looking at grades 7-8, how are they possibly in danger of missing a requirement for an average of 6.5?

Georgianattiude · 13/10/2023 18:19

I wonder if the school is a bit concerned that perhaps quite a few of the girls, due to the issues facing schools after COVID are not at the usual level. The school usually admits around 115 girls out of the 120 year 11 cohort to the Sixth Form. I am wondering if the school is worried that maybe 20-25 girls next year might not make the 52 point cut off.

OP posts:
Cherryana · 13/10/2023 18:17

This kind of ‘motivational’ denigration comes from people who lack both imagination and have huge egos.

They must put all the fear their students - because they are so afraid of being perceived as failing.

Notellinganyone · 13/10/2023 18:14

That’s awful. I’m a teacher and 6th form tutor in a big academic independent day school and think it’s unacceptable. Also nonsense- GCSEs don’t matter that much.

ATailOfTwoKitties · 13/10/2023 18:13

The second grouping was for pupils looking at mostly grade 7 and 8s at GCSE

That would be DD, now in her final year at Oxbridge. Chumps.

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 13/10/2023 18:12

This is quite common in Grammar schools - happened to my daughter last year. From that point on she decided she wasn’t going to stay there for 6th Form. Arguably it’s a counter productive step for the school to take isn’t it. However, some students really do need the wake up call that they’re not on track.

Georgianattiude · 13/10/2023 18:08

Where DD's friend was placed

OP posts: