Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and flying

113 replies

cruelladepoppins · 13/10/2023 17:59

First world problems, but here goes.

I have a big birthday next year. For my last big birthday ten years ago, we rented a villa with pool abroad with extended family staying for a fortnight. It was great. This time, I'd quite like to do something similar, as would both DCs (now adults). Maybe just the 4 of us, or with a friend for each DC.

The sticking point is that DH is v much against flying, for environmental reasons. His attitude has hardened in recent years. I totally respect that. But I soooo want to go. It's not like I fly often - maybe once a year, usually to take DM on holiday. DCs are champing at the bit and I am torn.

DH suggests we rent a house in Scotland where we live and have extended family to stay, but (a) crap weather, no pool (b) I can't imagine extended family would want to come (c) it very much feels like second-best and (d) he doesn't drive so I would have to schlep us all the way there.

DM suggests I set up what I want, without him, but that makes me feel sad.

Any advice? Are there nice places within easy reach of (say) Edinburgh? Anyone experienced anything similar?

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 13/10/2023 19:44

There’s a fast train to Avignon and Provence is beautiful. Under 6 hrs from St Pancras on the fastest service I believe.

Edit - sorry just seen your update about Trains being just as bad, who knew!

RandomUsernameHere · 13/10/2023 19:41

YANBU, you should arrange whatever you want. He can choose to fly, travel by alternative means or not go at all.

Catopia · 13/10/2023 19:40

I may have missed it somewhere, but what time of year/month is your birthday? Might impact on the recommendation!

LazJaz · 13/10/2023 19:38

On some airlines you can opt to “buy saf” in the same way that with octopus energy you “but renewable wneegy” (basically you sponsor more of the renewable into the grid - but an electron is an electron)
you can offset (though obv not the answer, and not iron clad)
or you can take more control (and expense) and plant your own trees or in other ways finance CCUS technologies
would any of these induce him to come with you?

i work in sustainability, and my view is that we still need to be able to live - even if it’s more expensive/less convenient/less frequent we can’t just ban things that people enjoy. What way to live is that?

LumpyPumpkin · 13/10/2023 19:33

It seems he isn't willing to compromise in any way, so you shouldn't either. Book your dream trip and go without him.

Tell him that the carbon footprint that will be generated when you divorce him and have to have to run separate households will far outweigh an occasional flight.

TheYear2000 · 13/10/2023 19:31

Rent a villa or find a nice hotel in a town accessible by Eurostar in south of France. You and children fly, he can get the train. As others have said, he's full of shit saying train as bad- it's not.
You don't have to drive for a holiday in France!

Babysharkdoodoodood · 13/10/2023 19:30

cruelladepoppins · 13/10/2023 18:16

Btw he has looked at train travel and says it's not all that different from air travel in terms of CO2 over a big distance - that distance is part of the problem.

We go on lots of UK breaks, which I enjoy v much, but I would like to do something a bit special for this birthday.

Have a look at Byway. Amazing traintrips. Cobblers about trains using as much as planes.

www.byway.travel/inspiration/trips-of-a-lifetime

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 13/10/2023 19:29

Nope. I'd make the plans I want and stick to them. If he feels that strongly he can find another way to get there or not go. Up to him.

I don't know why so many people are suggesting rubbish alternatives. Book the villa.

saraclara · 13/10/2023 19:29

My dad wouldn't fly for different reasons - very severe claustrophobia. This was a long time ago (he'd be over a hundred now) so flying off on holiday wasn't such a usual thing. But all the same my mum reached the point in the early 1980s where she realised that she was missing out, so she went on holiday to Malaysia and Thailand with a friend for three weeks. So she really went for it, given Long haul holidays weren't such a thing either!

So yep, your situation is a bit different, but also it involves your kids and extended family. So do it for all of you. It's a lengthy enough holiday for your DH to travel the slow way and join you for part of it if he's determined to.

Daffodilsandbagels · 13/10/2023 19:24

Get the train to the south of France - I've done this several times from Edinburgh and it's LOVELY. I would do Edinburgh to London and then stay overnight somewhere, then get the 9.30am Eurostar to Paris the next morning. You arrive in Paris for lunch, change over, and you're in the south of France by the early evening. If you book in advance it's not loads more expensive than flying and the whole experience is really lovely.

EDIT: I've just seen he won't take the train either – that's bananas, sorry you're having to put up with that OP.

FloweryName · 13/10/2023 19:23

He’s being selfish wanting his principles to take priority for the whole family when it’s someone else’s special occasion.

Tell him if he’s that bothered he can pay the extra to do carbon offsetting.

GrumpyPanda · 13/10/2023 19:20

cruelladepoppins · 13/10/2023 18:16

Btw he has looked at train travel and says it's not all that different from air travel in terms of CO2 over a big distance - that distance is part of the problem.

We go on lots of UK breaks, which I enjoy v much, but I would like to do something a bit special for this birthday.

So he gets his way something like 19 times out of 20? Point that out to him and tell him it's his turn to compromise else you might reconsider the UK breaks next time it comes to it.

PinkiOcelot · 13/10/2023 19:18

My DH doesn’t fly anymore. Not for the same reason as your DH, but I just leave him at home and go. Don’t feel sad about going without him, you’d be more sad at home watching the raindrops running down the window pain.

Densol57 · 13/10/2023 19:11

Oh god to be stuck with a DH like yours is my idea of hell
personally Id leave it - there would be no future with it with me

LovedmyRaleighChopper · 13/10/2023 19:11

I’d probably just organise for myself, close family and kids then and leave him out of it. I’ll bet his principles crumble when he sees everyone going without him, he’s just trying to control you. I can’t imagine someone so obtuse, puritanical and joyless bringing much to the party anyway, let him stay home saving up for his heat pump.

Tinkerbyebye · 13/10/2023 19:08

Bit hypocritical of him to go on lots of uk breaks, that’s just as bad for the environment as well. Tell him he can do without those next year instead

go without him, I would and you and your kids and anyone else you invite can have fun

SquishyGloopyBum · 13/10/2023 19:04

If he was really environmentally conscious, he wouldn't have had children.

I don't tho l it's about that anyway if he's saying that about train travel.

ChesapeakeBay · 13/10/2023 18:59

cruelladepoppins · 13/10/2023 18:16

Btw he has looked at train travel and says it's not all that different from air travel in terms of CO2 over a big distance - that distance is part of the problem.

We go on lots of UK breaks, which I enjoy v much, but I would like to do something a bit special for this birthday.

But surely if you add up the emissions of all your U.K. breaks is similar to one long journey by train?!

saraclara · 13/10/2023 18:59

This is your birthday, not your husband's.

That.

Why are so many posters providing ways for him to control what OP does for her own birthday? His environmental principles are his own, and he doesn't get to dictate that anyone else abide by them.

It's not like I fly often - maybe once a year, usually to take DM on holiday. DCs are champing at the bit

So you go. If you're planning two weeks away, he can just use a few days at the beginning and end, to get there under his own steam. Everyone else can make their own decisions about how they travel.

Seriously, you have a right to the holiday you want.

disappearingfish · 13/10/2023 18:57

Leave him behind then 🤷🏻‍♀️

cakehoover123 · 13/10/2023 18:53

Two suggestions from me.

Firstly: summer 2024 will probably be hot, because of El Nino. So if your birthday's in summer, booking a place in Scotland with a pool (if any exist?) might not be a terrible idea.

Secondly: It's easy to take the train to Avignon, Aix-en-Provence, Annecy, or Spain, and rent somewhere within a short hop? Just book somewhere in a nice village with a couple of bars, and take an Uber from station to villa.

https://www.sawdays.co.uk/france/provence-alps-riviera/?term=Provence%20-%20Alps%20-%20Riviera&guests%5Badults%5D=2&guests%5Bbabies%5D=0&guests%5Bchildren%5D=0&guests%5Bpets%5D=0&rooms=0&accommodation_type%5B%5D=self-catering&t=1697219194792

As others have said: the CO2 difference between flights and trains is HUGE. So YANBU at all to insist he takes a train. (And also - YANBU to say that going abroad for a special occasion would be important to you, and you'd like him to set his principles aside.)

Special places to stay in Provence - Alps - Riviera | Sawday's

Explore our special places to stay in Provence - Alps - Riviera. Sawday's has over 25 years' experience visiting the best gites, b&bs and hotels for a holiday!

https://www.sawdays.co.uk/france/provence-alps-riviera?accommodation_type%5B%5D=self-catering&guests%5Badults%5D=2&guests%5Bbabies%5D=0&guests%5Bchildren%5D=0&guests%5Bpets%5D=0&rooms=0&t=1697219194792&term=Provence+-+Alps+-+Riviera

Universalsnail · 13/10/2023 18:53

I would go, and fly and expect him to join us via an over the land route like the train

Gypsum5 · 13/10/2023 18:46

Do not do what he wants on your birthday, Scotland or Cornwall my arse 🙄 Leave him home to moan & book yourself a great trip.

ohdamnitjanet · 13/10/2023 18:43

Pleatherandlace · 13/10/2023 18:11

You and the kids fly and he meets you there by train/boat whatever.

Absolutely - he shouldn’t be able to spoil it for everyone else. Or just leave him at home and have a fabulous holiday. Does he never want to go abroad again, unless YOU drive?

FusionChefGeoff · 13/10/2023 18:42

www.seat61.com/CO2flights.htm