Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister on holiday with Covid

332 replies

CarlosSainzAKASmoothOperator · 13/10/2023 14:08

Spoke to sister this morning. She and her young child have tested positive for Covid after having a cough for a couple days. They are on a cruise due to disembark tomorrow.
I've told her she should tell the medical team onboard and isolate in cabin. She says I'm being ridiculous, that it's the last day so she will stay onboard on the pool deck in the fresh air. She lap says there's loads of people coughing.

I'm angry at her - she's got a flight back tomorrow - she says she will wear a mask but will enjoy the last day of the holiday.
She only tested as she had an lft in her case which I told her to pack.

Aibu for being annoyed at her?

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 15/10/2023 13:57

@AussieManque

sunglassesonthetable · 15/10/2023 13:57

Just because it's national policy it doesn't mean it's correct. And as a tax payer and voter, I will push back against unscientifically sound government policy, because spreading infection is a waste of my tax funds and a danger to my health and that of my family. Far more effective to invest in HEPA filters, proper FFP2 for NHS staff and awareness raising about airborne infection (handwashing is no use against covid!), and testing and isolation, than to advise healthcare staff to go to work sick to infect patients (the conversation I was in moved on beyond the OP's sister).

OK You have your push back etc. And we all pay taxes. And this gov is an absolute shower agreed.

But in relation to the OP it's really unfair to expect people to go against the national policy over and above normal sickness protocol.

AussieManque · 15/10/2023 13:48

@sunglassesonthetable if you are following the covid inquiry, you'll see that unfortunately while people like Patrick Vallance are very aware, the government doesn't necessarily follow his advice.

Just because it's national policy it doesn't mean it's correct. And as a tax payer and voter, I will push back against unscientifically sound government policy, because spreading infection is a waste of my tax funds and a danger to my health and that of my family. Far more effective to invest in HEPA filters, proper FFP2 for NHS staff and awareness raising about airborne infection (handwashing is no use against covid!), and testing and isolation, than to advise healthcare staff to go to work sick to infect patients (the conversation I was in moved on beyond the OP's sister).

Stroopwaffels · 15/10/2023 13:38

CarlosSainzAKASmoothOperator · 13/10/2023 14:18

@Catza I've never had it (as far as I am aware).
I work with vulnerable people so I still test twice a week. I feel very strong about Covid as I have seen how it has affected people.

You can feel as "strong" as you like about it. You cannot go around requiring that other people feel a particular way, or stick to your own self-declared roolz about isolating and testing etc etc etc.

Topseyt123 · 15/10/2023 13:32

IamRa · 15/10/2023 11:24

@Topseyt123

It is like a cold and fairly mild in a lot of cases. Severe in some others and it is a bit random there. But for most it is mild.

That is exactly how these things work, whether you like it or not. Go and explode about that if you want to!

Well, no. It's not classed as a rhinovirus, is it? It's a novel coronavirus - distinct even from existing coronaviruses. You may experience symptoms that are similar to that of a slight cold, but that is an entirely different statement.

That's why I said it is like a cold. I didn't state that it was one

Also, although Covid isn't classed as a rhinovirus, not all common colds are from the rhinovirus group. A few are from the coronavirus group. Covid 19 is also from the coronavirus group. Covid 19 is still not a cold, but it can be like some of them and there are some similarities. Doesn't mean that they are the same thing at all.

sunglassesonthetable · 15/10/2023 12:52

And as I've said ad infinitum, COVID leads to more conditions, so we are just making things worse for the NHS. COVID is not like flu or other illnesses - it's far far more contagious, and active all year round, so failing to control it means the hospital system never has time to recover.

You talk as if you are the only one to realise this @AussieManque

Do you think the powers that be

A. Are aware and are actively ignoring this. Patrick Vallance et al. ?

B. Unlike you, just haven't realised.

The policy of not testing, and living through Covid is a national policy after all. And the should and should nots debated on here, are only a matter of opinion from individuals who don't make policy.

Whatever anyone says on here DS is only following accepted national policies whilst OP is taking a sort of 'home made' stance.

And we could be having this discussion about , say, flu. Which can be very debilitating.

If she thought she had flu, would you say isolate, inform ship , etc etc.
Granted I don't think you should be out at work or breathing flu onto vulnerable people.
Which most people wouldn't.

Panaa · 15/10/2023 12:49

IamRa · 15/10/2023 11:24

@Topseyt123

It is like a cold and fairly mild in a lot of cases. Severe in some others and it is a bit random there. But for most it is mild.

That is exactly how these things work, whether you like it or not. Go and explode about that if you want to!

Well, no. It's not classed as a rhinovirus, is it? It's a novel coronavirus - distinct even from existing coronaviruses. You may experience symptoms that are similar to that of a slight cold, but that is an entirely different statement.

The poster said it is like a cold, not that it was one.
The statement was correct.

Badbadbunny · 15/10/2023 12:49

Panaa · 15/10/2023 12:40

Again, complete shortsightedness.

The hospital system won't ever recover because covid is here to stay. They can't keep trying to control it because of the knock on effect of staff shortages etc....which makes things worse in the short, medium AND long term for the NHS.

I know you've said it ad infinitum but it's been weighed up and decided that not trying to control it is in the best interests of the NHS and the public in general.

I disagree.

What makes it all worse is the way that infections (covid and others) are allowed to run freely through hospitals because no one cares enough to take even the most basic precautions. That causes patients to become ill and causes them to spend longer in hospital, need more attention/drugs, worsen long term conditions which again mean more hospital interventions etc.

Ever since Aids and HIV, hospital staff don't care about cross infections for anything that isn't red in colour - ALL the emphasis is on blood, and they seem to have completely forgotten (or don't care) about infections that are passed on in the air, droplets or "clear" fluids.

Panaa · 15/10/2023 12:40

AussieManque · 15/10/2023 09:12

@Panaa you seem to have forgotten that we are talking about healthcare. Medical practitioners have a duty to do no harm to their patients. Treating them with an active COVID infection, without even a requirement to wear a surgical mask, let alone a proper respirator, is negligence. COVID remains a notifiable disease though you wouldn't know it given how hospitals have given up. You can't take fresh flowers to hospital but sure, come and spread COVID around, no problem!

We are already seeing in other countries hospitals being sued for failing in their duty of care to prevent COVID transmission. We will see it very soon in the UK, and that's great because finally hospitals will have some accountability.

And as I've said ad infinitum, COVID leads to more conditions, so we are just making things worse for the NHS. COVID is not like flu or other illnesses - it's far far more contagious, and active all year round, so failing to control it means the hospital system never has time to recover.

Again, complete shortsightedness.

The hospital system won't ever recover because covid is here to stay. They can't keep trying to control it because of the knock on effect of staff shortages etc....which makes things worse in the short, medium AND long term for the NHS.

I know you've said it ad infinitum but it's been weighed up and decided that not trying to control it is in the best interests of the NHS and the public in general.

IamRa · 15/10/2023 12:01

Hbh17 · 15/10/2023 11:30

Good for her! Her only mistakes were 1) to pack a test and 2) to use it.

Mmm, terrible 'mistakes' to make on a CRUISE. 🙄

Hbh17 · 15/10/2023 11:30

Good for her! Her only mistakes were 1) to pack a test and 2) to use it.

Nothankyou22 · 15/10/2023 11:28

It’s literally carry on now unless you feel like crap. We can’t isolate forever

IamRa · 15/10/2023 11:24

@Topseyt123

It is like a cold and fairly mild in a lot of cases. Severe in some others and it is a bit random there. But for most it is mild.

That is exactly how these things work, whether you like it or not. Go and explode about that if you want to!

Well, no. It's not classed as a rhinovirus, is it? It's a novel coronavirus - distinct even from existing coronaviruses. You may experience symptoms that are similar to that of a slight cold, but that is an entirely different statement.

43ontherocksporfavor · 15/10/2023 10:30

Yes Covid causes vomiting and diarrhoea especially children. Vertigo is often due to ear fluid issues which is fairly common after any upper respiratory tract infection.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 15/10/2023 10:23

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/10/2023 20:29

I still can’t stand upright 3 months after catching Covid.

I can’t imagine anything less like a cold. And the 2 times l’ve had it I’ve been throwing up with no cold symptoms.

So no, it’s not like a cold.

Edited

It doesn't sound like covid either.

WinterDeWinter · 15/10/2023 09:23

bluetongue · 14/10/2023 22:06

Even if that were true and I agree that there’s lots we don’t know about Covid it’s impossible to avoid. The only way not to get Covid is to isolate yourself and cut off social contact. Not only is that a miserable existence but it’s also bad for your health.

Most of us don’t deny that Covid can be serious for some but we’ve weighed up the impact of letting it run our lives any more than it already has and decided that it’s worth the risk. Just like we drink alcohol and eat processed meats even though quitting them would be healthier.

We’re not talking about the risk to ourselves. We’re talking about a country who’s state health service takes no action to protect vulnerable patients who have no choice to be in hospital.

AussieManque · 15/10/2023 09:13

@Peterpiperspickledpepper

AussieManque · 15/10/2023 09:12

@Panaa you seem to have forgotten that we are talking about healthcare. Medical practitioners have a duty to do no harm to their patients. Treating them with an active COVID infection, without even a requirement to wear a surgical mask, let alone a proper respirator, is negligence. COVID remains a notifiable disease though you wouldn't know it given how hospitals have given up. You can't take fresh flowers to hospital but sure, come and spread COVID around, no problem!

We are already seeing in other countries hospitals being sued for failing in their duty of care to prevent COVID transmission. We will see it very soon in the UK, and that's great because finally hospitals will have some accountability.

And as I've said ad infinitum, COVID leads to more conditions, so we are just making things worse for the NHS. COVID is not like flu or other illnesses - it's far far more contagious, and active all year round, so failing to control it means the hospital system never has time to recover.

Carseatdilema · 15/10/2023 08:34

Atleast her other sister isn't daft.

Letitgonowgr · 15/10/2023 07:28

Badbadbunny · 14/10/2023 19:42

It tells me the NHS doesn't give a stuff about hospital acquired infections, hence why so many people catch covid, norovirus, and other infections IN hospital. Hospitals should be a place where patients are safe from infection, but they're not. Then the NHS whinges when so many patients stay in hospital longer than necessary -hardly surprising!

If drs and nurses aren’t bothering then members of the public going about their daily life aren’t going to either. They’ll also not be paid if they decide to take time off work to isolate and when most can’t afford to, they won’t.

bluetongue · 14/10/2023 22:06

WinterDeWinter · 13/10/2023 16:18

I'm not talking about vulnerable people - that's a different issue (to you, anyway).

The people impacted by long covid, with irreversible damage in many cases, are people just like you. Non-vulnerable people.

We don't yet understand why or even the full extent of how, but it's clear that there is a post-viral syndrome which is doing terrible damage. It's quite possible that, like some other post-viral syndromes, the full damage won't be clear for years when the virus has a kind of sudden second life. Google Covid and Parkinsons for eg.

You should read more.

Even if that were true and I agree that there’s lots we don’t know about Covid it’s impossible to avoid. The only way not to get Covid is to isolate yourself and cut off social contact. Not only is that a miserable existence but it’s also bad for your health.

Most of us don’t deny that Covid can be serious for some but we’ve weighed up the impact of letting it run our lives any more than it already has and decided that it’s worth the risk. Just like we drink alcohol and eat processed meats even though quitting them would be healthier.

WinterDeWinter · 14/10/2023 21:11

BluebellsForest · 14/10/2023 20:51

I work in a hospital. No one is required to test or isolate or wear a mask. What does that tell you?!

It tells me that there has been a total breakdown in infection control and failure of duty of care. Plus a severe lack of common sense, @Letitgonowgr

Edited

This.

it feels in line with all the many other ways Britain is undeveloping.

Teder · 14/10/2023 21:10

BluebellsForest · 14/10/2023 18:52

Jesus, that was an unfortunate post to come directly after yours, @MariaVT65. Puts your selfish prickdom into perspective.

Would you expect someone to risk isolating and losing their job and home? What if they had children?

I have an immune deficiency. I don’t expect the world to run around me and my needs. I wouldn’t go on a cruise either. Floating germ dish! Where do you draw the line? Do you isolate for 48 hours an after a bit of vomiting or diarrhoea? I work with someone who had a bit of an upset stomach and assumed they ate something rich. It was norovirus and I caught it full blown and ended up in hospital.

BluebellsForest · 14/10/2023 20:51

I work in a hospital. No one is required to test or isolate or wear a mask. What does that tell you?!

It tells me that there has been a total breakdown in infection control and failure of duty of care. Plus a severe lack of common sense, @Letitgonowgr

Cosyblankets · 14/10/2023 20:02

Mindymomo · 13/10/2023 14:41

She needs to speak to the medical centre on cruise ship, they will advise her what she should do. Yes, it’s all around, but personally I wouldn’t want to fly home knowing I had Covid. That’s what having insurance with Covid cover will help with.

What does it cover?
Extra accommodation?
Missed flight?
Lost earnings?
Extra kennel or cattery fees?
Extra airport parking?
Missed airport transfer?
Extra food?