Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Estate Agents have no real loyalty?

65 replies

chatenoire · 13/10/2023 13:54

I'm trying to sell a property and no matter what, the EA is doing voodoo maths to get me to accept an offer.

I had an initial offer (which I rejected) and counter offered for £10k on top. The buyer isn't moving, so I told the EA that there was no deal.

I've been clear to the EA that it's not that I want the full amount of the counter offer, but that I should see some "good will" from the buyer (so even a gesture of £2k would be enough).

Then the EA came back saying that the slow months are coming and she wouldn't be able to sell it and that her contract would expire.. then I said "maybe then try harder?"

BTW my counter offer is what she valued the house on.

I'm in no rush to sell. It's an inheritance from my uncle, so my mother obviously has an opinion and I don't want to end up fighting with her either.

OP posts:
Ohmylovejune · 13/10/2023 17:13

Just seen the drip.feed.

Make sure its being done properly and legally.

Ohmylovejune · 13/10/2023 17:11

Don't make a complete matter more complicated. It's business.

Whatever the current final figure on the table is, present to your mother and discuss. Let your Mum know the EAs view of the market. Choose to accept or not accept. Let the EA know.

Remember if this money was in yours and your Mumss bank account now you could probably be getting 5 percent easily in interest (albeit taxable). Depending on the value of the property it might not take long to get that 2k you want back, a different way.

Boundoverbyacat · 13/10/2023 17:10

But you have no other offers.

chatenoire · 13/10/2023 17:04

Seas164 · 13/10/2023 17:01

It sounds like your EA has more than earned their commission already getting to this point, their loyalty is only to getting their completions over the line and to their sales figures. Not to your family dynamic unfortunately.

Selling houses is stressful enough without making it entirely more complicated than it needs to be by marketing it way over the valuation, and expecting good will gestures from buyers.

Yes, but I've never bought (nor sold) a house on the first offer.

This would be like my 4th/5th

OP posts:
chatenoire · 13/10/2023 17:03

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:54

It sounds like you need more legal advice than some strangers opinion on your EA, who doesn't really own you any loyalty.

My accountant said to stay away from dodgy deals. My lawyer said that the EA was being very odd for being so stubborn

OP posts:
Seas164 · 13/10/2023 17:01

It sounds like your EA has more than earned their commission already getting to this point, their loyalty is only to getting their completions over the line and to their sales figures. Not to your family dynamic unfortunately.

Selling houses is stressful enough without making it entirely more complicated than it needs to be by marketing it way over the valuation, and expecting good will gestures from buyers.

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:54

It sounds like you need more legal advice than some strangers opinion on your EA, who doesn't really own you any loyalty.

chatenoire · 13/10/2023 16:51

BristolBlueGlasses · 13/10/2023 16:30

Jeepers, this is a complicated (and tedious) drip feed. If I was you I'd just talk to your agent and try to come to some legal and sensible conclusion.

Crying because the valuation doesn't meet an unrealistic expectation kinda sets the tone.

I only want it to be legal! And to meet me somewhere in the middle for the purchase price.
Having it to comply with the law shouldn't be seen as a compromise

OP posts:
Cleethorpes · 13/10/2023 16:36

Your mother being greedy and tearful is not the EA’s problem!

GasPanic · 13/10/2023 16:31

TBH this sounds like less of an EA problem and more of a mother and buyer problem.

Even if you do agree terms, I would not be betting the farm on this transaction going smoothly.

BristolBlueGlasses · 13/10/2023 16:30

Jeepers, this is a complicated (and tedious) drip feed. If I was you I'd just talk to your agent and try to come to some legal and sensible conclusion.

Crying because the valuation doesn't meet an unrealistic expectation kinda sets the tone.

chatenoire · 13/10/2023 16:19

Testina · 13/10/2023 16:01

There’s a strong vibe here that the stress and difficulty here is coming from you.

Why are you quibbling over a “goodwill” gesture? They’re supposed to mind read that you don’t mean you want £10K, you want £2k more because it’s not about the money but about… some weird thing in your head! Sorry, but you sound like a PITA vendor who isn’t treating it like a simple business transaction. Which links with the loyalty oddness: she’s not your friend. You should expect professionalism, not loyalty.

Your EA gives you an honest warning about the well known winter slow period, and instead of being pleased she isn’t bullshitting you that she can sell - to keep your business - you rudely tell her to try harder then?

In what way did her numbers not make sense?

This is not in the UK but the down low is:

*EA valued at £290k (my DM cried because she thought it was too low by the by)

*Was advertised for £325k, then reduced to £305k which is the current price

*One cash offer of £250k

*Current offer of £280k

The offer was final, but that wasn't clear from the EA.

However, they want to pay £80k in cash and the legal limit in that country is £40k (money laundering regulations).

Apparently their "willing to negotiate" is to actually follow the anti-money laundering law, and not do what they originally proposed which is against the law.

I'm completely against doing it outside of those regulations, however I'm OK with paying the EA commission in cash as a middle ground.

The buyer has not moved in price nor in his original position to go against the money laundering regulations.

However I have been open to move my goalpost slightly.

EA tried to manipulate the numbers by showing me that there's little difference between:

a) paying the full amount and paying all my taxes - including her commission as a bank transfer (at an agreed price of £290k)

b) not follow anti money laundering regulations and paying her in cash (at an agreed price of £280k)

My point being that I should have to accept a lower offer just because I want to ACTUALLY follow the law.

OP posts:
kweeble · 13/10/2023 16:08

Let your ego go and consider your mother in this too - it’s much better to sell now than leave it over winter in this kind of declining market.

Testina · 13/10/2023 16:04

chatenoire · 13/10/2023 14:56

That's what I mean. The EA failed to communicate it was final. She made it sound that there would be room to negotiate

Uh? But you said there was room to negotiate. What is the £2K “goodwill” if not a negotiation?

Like I said above, the problem here is you, not the EA.

Testina · 13/10/2023 16:01

There’s a strong vibe here that the stress and difficulty here is coming from you.

Why are you quibbling over a “goodwill” gesture? They’re supposed to mind read that you don’t mean you want £10K, you want £2k more because it’s not about the money but about… some weird thing in your head! Sorry, but you sound like a PITA vendor who isn’t treating it like a simple business transaction. Which links with the loyalty oddness: she’s not your friend. You should expect professionalism, not loyalty.

Your EA gives you an honest warning about the well known winter slow period, and instead of being pleased she isn’t bullshitting you that she can sell - to keep your business - you rudely tell her to try harder then?

In what way did her numbers not make sense?

megletthesecond · 13/10/2023 15:54

They're loyal to money.

BristolBlueGlasses · 13/10/2023 15:50

If it were me I'd stop expecting the niceties of a courtly dance and get the deal done and dusted. After all, it's not s though it's a property you've invested money in is it. It's an inheritance....a gift. Every single penny is profit to you and your mum/other benefactors.

You can expect politeness and loyalty or you can bank the money and move on. That's, quite rightly, what the estate agent is doing.

GasPanic · 13/10/2023 15:45

A lot of people will tell you to remember that an EAs loyalty is to the seller (person who employs/contracts the EA).

In fact their primary loyalty is to themselves.

It's worth remembering. It's also worth not blaming them for that.

I am not sure how your description constitutes "voodoo maths", in the respect the maths involved seem like the sort of stuff a 6 year old could do, it's just that you don't like the outcome ?

thaisweetchill · 13/10/2023 15:45

I work in the housing industry and closely with estate agents, the market is SLOW, there is not a lot of buyers out there so she's trying to sell your house before it gets stale and sits on the market (god forbid she does her job).

If you're not in a rush then that's fine but don't be surprised when you struggle to sell in months to come.

Boundoverbyacat · 13/10/2023 15:44

How bizarre? A good will gesture? Have you ever done a business transaction before. You sound clueless and probably therefore a nightmare client. And ‘try harder’ is just rude. If my clients said that to me they wouldn’t be my clients anymore

Thebigblueballoon · 13/10/2023 15:42

It’s a business transaction. They aren’t a golden Labrador.
Now that you know the buyers are standing firm on their final offer, decide whether you want to go back to them and accept. If you don’t, I suspect you may regret it a couple of months down the line.

ErcolSofa · 13/10/2023 15:41

Why did you put it for sale above what they valued it at?

LindorDoubleChoc · 13/10/2023 15:38

The arguments between you and your mother are not your EA's problem!

Coffeerum · 13/10/2023 15:37

Why would they have loyalty? Essentially you’ve employed them to complete a job. If they don’t think the job is reasonable within the parameters you are trying to set why would they do it?
They don’t think it’s likely to get the price you’re holding out for and they are trying to advise you.

Spendonsend · 13/10/2023 15:33

I'm not sure there is much incentive for an estate agent to negotiate a small increase like that. There incentive is to turn over lots of properties quickly for roughly market value. That 2k to you is like £30 to them for a lot of effort.