Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset about my husband’s reaction to Israel/Palestine

140 replies

Tiredboymum22 · 13/10/2023 13:33

I’m a British Ashkenazi jew with family in Israel. I feel broken. Firstly, I don’t support the Netanyahu government or the ever expanding settlements in the West Bank. But obviously I support Israel’s right to exist. I feel devastated for innocent civilians on both sides.

DH is very left wing/was pro Corbyn. I always knew he supported Palestine but, so far, he has said that the BBC are right NOT to call Hamas terrorists. Asked what Israel did to trigger the attacks on Saturday. Then questioned whether the images were staged/Israeli propaganda. Also commented on a Palestinian having a “jewish nose”. Hasn’t asked about my family but has told me I’m up Israel’s arse. My mum’s friend also compared Hamas to Nelson Mandela and told her she’s shocked at her support for Israel (this was the day after the attacks).

AIBU to feel completely betrayed, depressed and alone? I feel guilty for feeling this way as I genuinely sympathise with the Palestinians and obviously I’m safe in my bed whilst many have nowhere to go, have lost loved ones, etc.

Sorry to start another thread. Just needed to vent.

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 14/10/2023 13:56

Hideous.

The lazy, uncritical, ideological tribalism related to this conflict is unedifying enough but using recognisablly racist, antisemitic tropes in the company of your own wife is another thing entirely.

I'm not sure I could reconcile myself to this. It's a horrible, divisive conflict with far-reaching ripple effects. I'm sorry for those who feel vulnerable and isolated by the groundswell of prejudiced sentiment arising from this, very depressed by the rise in UK antisemitism which has been documented in the news for many years now, and empathetic to all who have loved ones in the region and who must be desperately worried.

Awful times.

LakieLady · 14/10/2023 13:45

I'm on the left, voted for Corbyn for leader, have been opposed to the expansion of Israeli settlements post-1967, and am appalled at the way the Palestinians have been treated, but even I don't try and defend the actions of Hamas, or any other group that attack civilian populations. And the reason I don't try and defend them is because they are indefensible.

I think your DH is being an utter arse, and especially crass not to grasp that for you this really feels personal, because you have family who might be at risk. He needs a massive empathy injection.

My heart goes out to all the ordinary, civilian populations of both countries who are living in fear, and especially to those who are desperately trying to flee Gaza when much of the area has been reduced to rubble and they don't have fuel.

To anyone reading who has family and friends in the area, I hope they are all safe and that they stay safe. ❤

GasPanic · 14/10/2023 13:36

Irrespective of where peoples sympathies lie in this situation, it's possible to take a non confrontational viewpoint while realising others close to you may feel differently about it.

Re the Palestine/Israeli situation, to me there are too many people who want to see it in black and white, and not what the world really is, which is shades of grey.

Your husband should be able to take a different viewpoint to you, whilst still being sensitive to your feelings and why you feel about the situation the way you do. If he can't, it probably doesn't bode well for the future, because in any relationship if you both dig your heels in and take polarised viewpoints on issues there is non common ground for compromise.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 14/10/2023 13:28

Britneyfan · 13/10/2023 15:46

FFS of COURSE Hamas are terrorists! It’s one thing debating whether the BBC need to avoid using this term for anyone but it’s quite another to not have them recognised as such under your own roof in the aftermath of this sort of atrocity when your wife is Jewish! I’m absolutely gobsmacked that 20 percent of voters here think YOU are being unreasonable to feel isolated and betrayed here OP.

Holding different views within a marriage on certain topics is possible but I don’t personally think it’s doable for one person to essentially be racist against the race of the other and have a healthy marriage… Imagine a white person married to a black person with family close to a flashpoint during the Black Lives Matter stuff flaring up initially, and the white person is arguing at the time that using the n-word is fine, supports the “All lives matter” movement, and doesn’t ask after family…. And then when the black person feels upset by it 20 percent of mumsnetters say they are being unreasonable?! By finding it upsetting?!! Come on. In fact it’s worse than that because it’s as if there is actually an environment where much of the rest of society thinks the “All lives matter” brigade are in the right.

This is beyond the pale and ultimately I don’t see how your marriage can survive it. I can see how it’s possible for opinions to change or become more extreme over the years but when it’s something so personal to you as this OP, I don’t think it’s going to work. Being Jewish goes to the core of your identity and he has shown here that he is antisemitic in my opinion as well as just generally lacking in empathy and indeed the love for you that he should have.

I am so so sorry that your husband does not have your back and show love, care and support for you and for your family at such an awful time. And I’m even more sorry that you have to read some of the shit that people are posting on here when you’re already feeling broken and worried for your family. I hope you’re not in an abusive marriage (I do wonder for him to express things the way he has and you still to be in the relationship). Please don’t be gaslighted by your husband or people on here to think this is ok because it really really isn’t. I can’t think of another topic where people would dare to assist him in gaslighting you like this actually. It’s not you, it’s him. And sadly it seems a whole lot of the general public too. But please know that you are not alone. There are plenty of British people who are horrified at what Hamas have done here and who stand with Jewish people at this time.

@Britneyfan , that was an excellent response. I agree with your every word.

Floppyelf · 14/10/2023 13:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

littleburn · 14/10/2023 13:18

YANBU, that's appalling behaviour on his part. I would end it over that.

I'm on the left and am really shocked by the number of people this week saying 'it's terrible but ...' Just that complete inability to acknowledge the horror for even a minute without equivocation. I saw this on Insta earlier (think it's from an article in The Atlantic, and it really resonated:

To feel upset about my husband’s reaction to Israel/Palestine
Patchesofdrizzle · 14/10/2023 13:14

He's being cruel and unsupportive of you, and sounds like his enjoyment of virtue signaling is more important to him than you are.

contactme · 14/10/2023 13:09

To be honest I think you are being U because this isn’t really a situation where you can take sides, atrocities have occurred on both sides. Neither comes out as a pillar of honour frankly

B12B12 · 14/10/2023 13:09

I don’t think this is really about politics at all. Your husband is being a goady arse for the sake of it and trying to wind you up.

Frankly, you don’t deserve abuse in your own home. If he won’t shut his trap knowing he upsets you, show him the door.

I disagree strongly with my DDs about so called trans/GC stuff but we talk around the subject or just avoid it altogether.

GoonieGang · 14/10/2023 13:07

Angrycat2768 · 14/10/2023 11:47

It's not two objective opinions though. One person has an opinion on something happening in the Middle East that has no day to day effect on them. The other one is Jewish with family and friends who have actual links to the situation. Whatever his opinion is, if he had some respect or care for her or her family he would have kept his mouth shut. What benefit does he get from distressing his already distressed wife? By him keeping his trap shut, the benefit would have been a not upset wife.

He is entitled to his opinions which sounds like he is questioning not supporting either side. Suppression of someone’s opinion in a marriage is wrong and maybe they need to split up if one party is not allowed a voice

Lentilweaver · 14/10/2023 13:02

Your husband is a twat. Regardless of his opinions, he should be there for you and ask about your family.

And btw, I think what Israel is doing in Gaza is a war crime. Nevertheless, I can have sympathy for ordinary Israelis, as I have for ordinary Palestinians. The least your husband can do is offer sympathy and a shoulder.

Threemangoes · 14/10/2023 12:54

BIossomtoes · 14/10/2023 12:51

Did you even bother reading that post @Threemangoes? Where does it mention killing anyone?

I said target them in UK. Have you not read my post?
The poster is clearly inciting hate speech by suggesting muslim children are told to hate Jews. And she wants to target them in UK to I doctrine them or something. I have reported her comment to mumsnet.

BIossomtoes · 14/10/2023 12:51

Did you even bother reading that post @Threemangoes? Where does it mention killing anyone?

blanketsmell · 14/10/2023 12:51

How did this not come up before you married?

Threemangoes · 14/10/2023 12:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Threemangoes · 14/10/2023 12:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BIossomtoes · 14/10/2023 12:37

I never thought you and I would agree on anything @Xenia but here we are in total accord.

Xenia · 14/10/2023 12:25

You are certainly not alone. I am Christian and stand with Israel on this, just about the only democracy in that area. I think it is very important those of us who support Israel say so otherwise we may be drowned by a sea of voices of support for Hamas and Palestinians.

I was never a Trump supporter but I was very pleased that he/the USA recognised Jerusalem as Israel's capital in 2017.

Now is the time to root Hamas out, destroy all the tunnels and make Gaza safe for everyone including so it cannot be used to invade Israel again and behead babies on Jewish soil.

Perhaps in the UK we also need more resources going into communities where small children in the UK may be being taught to hate Jews so that we breach a multicultural wall on this issue because it is a teaching that breaches our laws here in the UK.

MrsSlocombesCat · 14/10/2023 12:20

I used to be a left wing Corbyn supporter that somehow believed that the aggression was all coming from Israel. But I have been watching some videos that have changed my view. Hamas ARE terrorists with support from Iran. They refuse to recognise Israel as a legitimate country. So what is the solution? It’s not as simple as Israel withdrawing from Palestine. If they did they would come under attack because Hamas want to destroy Israel.

Therealjudgejudy · 14/10/2023 12:13

Sending you a vitual hug op. Having family in Israel right now is terryfying.

Your husband is an uncaring twat.

P.s im an Arab.

Evaka · 14/10/2023 12:11

Your husband sounds like a basic moron I'm afraid. How utterly cruel not to ask how your friends and family in Israel are. Of course the events of last weekend were acts of terror. They were the very definition. The response amounts to war crimes. Both these things are true. I've never said it before on mumsnet, but I wouldn't stay married to him I'm afraid.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 14/10/2023 12:08

@Tiredboymum22 , in every AIBU thread in connection with this war approximately 20% of respondents fall on the side of the Palestinians. The Metropolitan police report a three fold increase in antisemitic crime since the war began. The BBC have refused to call Hamas terrorists (which they are). Joyful celebrations have occurred across the world including the U.K. unapologetically happy that Jews have been made to suffer. Suggestions have been made on MN that the crimes of Hamas have been exaggerated or that Isreal are asking Palestinians to move southward in order to trap and annihilate them. Posters of kidnapped Israeli children put up in London have been ripped down and put in bins. Jewish schools have shut their doors. I could go on sadly. Antisemitism has never gone away.
I’m sure people will tell you your husband has a right to his opinions which of course he does. It’s possible to criticise the actions of the Israeli government without being antisemitic just as it’s reasonable to criticise the actions of Islamic extremist terrorists without being racist. I do think though that in different circumstances these same people would be telling you that your husband has an appalling lack of respect for your feelings. He is giving his political beliefs a higher priority than you, that would worry me a lot. Obviously you need to point this out to him and then you can gauge by his reaction where you stand.
I stand with the innocent and hope for a two state solution and peace in the Middle East. You are in a difficult situation, I hope you find your peace too; with or without your husband. 🙏🏻

BeginningToLookALotLike · 14/10/2023 12:00

His comments are unsupportive and disrespectful to you at this time. I would not want to be around him any more, tbh.

YDBear · 14/10/2023 11:59

Husband is clearly not just pro-Palestine or anti-Israel but anti-Semitic in general. Talking about “Jewish noses” and staged attacks clearly reveals him to be a conspiracist mired in race hatred.
On a more general note, it’s always worth pointing out that Labour under Corbyn was the most electorally successful anti-Semitic party in western Europe since 1932. Too many “useful idiots” make excuses for that.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/10/2023 11:55

No, yanbu. I'm deeply uneasy about aspects of Israel's response to the terrorist acts by Hamas last weekend, and I'm a bit unnerved by what appears to be the almost unconditional support from Western governments, including our own. What Hamas did in Israel was utterly abhorrent but I don't think innocent Palestinian civilians should be made to pay for it.

So I think there is room for different perspectives in all of this, but frankly, your H just sounds deeply antisemitic. I'm so sorry.