Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset about my husband’s reaction to Israel/Palestine

140 replies

Tiredboymum22 · 13/10/2023 13:33

I’m a British Ashkenazi jew with family in Israel. I feel broken. Firstly, I don’t support the Netanyahu government or the ever expanding settlements in the West Bank. But obviously I support Israel’s right to exist. I feel devastated for innocent civilians on both sides.

DH is very left wing/was pro Corbyn. I always knew he supported Palestine but, so far, he has said that the BBC are right NOT to call Hamas terrorists. Asked what Israel did to trigger the attacks on Saturday. Then questioned whether the images were staged/Israeli propaganda. Also commented on a Palestinian having a “jewish nose”. Hasn’t asked about my family but has told me I’m up Israel’s arse. My mum’s friend also compared Hamas to Nelson Mandela and told her she’s shocked at her support for Israel (this was the day after the attacks).

AIBU to feel completely betrayed, depressed and alone? I feel guilty for feeling this way as I genuinely sympathise with the Palestinians and obviously I’m safe in my bed whilst many have nowhere to go, have lost loved ones, etc.

Sorry to start another thread. Just needed to vent.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kirbykirby · 10/11/2023 20:17

I wonder if he also supported the terrorists of 7/7 or the Ariana Grande concert massacre as a protest against British colonialism?

He sounds deranged and racist.

Mother444 · 10/11/2023 20:04

Hi @Tiredboymum22 . Your post has really interested me because I’m in a similar situation but the other way around. It’s given me an insight into how my husband might be feeling about being married to me!

I’m married to an ashkenazi Jewish man. I have always been pro-Palestine, and “a leftie”. I find the settler occupation in the West Bank deplorable, and the open air prison of Gaza dehumanizing. I felt that Israel needed to be sanctioned by the international community if those situations were ever to be resolved for Palistinians. That was before October 7. I am a human being with a heart, and so cannot do anything other than condemn the attacks by Hamas on Jewish civilians. It was horrific, peaceful innocent people were brutally murdered.

However, I’m finding my husbands difficulty with condemning Israel hard to deal with. In my view, the massacre of civilians in Gaza is not justified. We have agreed to not discuss it, as we both end up hurting each other when we do. He thinks the civilian death in Gaza is unavoidable, I think it’s a calculated massacre. I have not said anything like your husbands comments about Jewish noses as obviously that’s racist and I really am not at all against Jewish people.

I feel like we are on such opposite sides of something which seems so obvious to me. Obviously bombing children is wrong? I’m only 1 year into my marriage, but I also have a 6 month old. I really don’t want to divorce or end it.

Not sure how to proceed.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 25/10/2023 09:22

They're not far different from hard right men. Both think in moral absolutes, both think they're always right and both give greater weight to men's views. What's that saying? The right thinks women are private property, the left thinks women are public property.

Angrycat2768 · 25/10/2023 09:02

Lostcotter · 24/10/2023 21:50

bit ot topic but I’m curious - why do you think they tend to be misogynists? Is this widely known?

I’m wondering because my boyfriend is a big Corbyn fan and while I wouldn’t call him misogynist he did try and talk over me recently when I was explaining why some women have reservations about trans issues. I did shut it down, but I seen it as an amber flag. And there’s some other things I’ve noticed.

I think many misogynists are attracted to the Labour movement, and the more Hard Left element of it. The Hard Left have always been fairly misogynist. They were all concerned about the 'working man' which traditionally meant not women ( less work for the men). My DH tried to mansplain trade unionism to me a few months ago. I quickly shut him down with a list of my Politics degree, Masters in Employment Law and 10 years as a Trades Union Rep (for the place he used to work, so while we were dating, he was so disinterested in politics he didn't realise his own girlfriend was his Trades Union rep!)

Lostcotter · 24/10/2023 21:50

TinyRebel · 24/10/2023 16:12

As a leftie woman who has recently spent four days in the company of fellow lefties, I can confirm from several encounters, that the Corbynista, keffiyeh and rainbow lanyarded men are the most vile, misogynistic and anti-semitic ones of the bunch. You have have a husband problem I’m afraid.

bit ot topic but I’m curious - why do you think they tend to be misogynists? Is this widely known?

I’m wondering because my boyfriend is a big Corbyn fan and while I wouldn’t call him misogynist he did try and talk over me recently when I was explaining why some women have reservations about trans issues. I did shut it down, but I seen it as an amber flag. And there’s some other things I’ve noticed.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 24/10/2023 20:56

he has said that the BBC are right NOT to call Hamas terrorists. Asked what Israel did to trigger the attacks on Saturday. Then questioned whether the images were staged/Israeli propaganda. Also commented on a Palestinian having a “jewish nose”. Hasn’t asked about my family but has told me I’m up Israel’s arse.

None of that is about being pro Palestine. I know Muslims who don't say those things. I'm not Jewish but if my husband said those things, he'd be toast. I won't stomach ridiculous conspiracy theories, racism or anti semitism.

TinyRebel · 24/10/2023 16:12

As a leftie woman who has recently spent four days in the company of fellow lefties, I can confirm from several encounters, that the Corbynista, keffiyeh and rainbow lanyarded men are the most vile, misogynistic and anti-semitic ones of the bunch. You have have a husband problem I’m afraid.

Imagnu1234 · 16/10/2023 20:30

I think your husband is being insensitive and has said some racist things, though I think it stems from his concern for Palestinians, which is a legitimate concern, and being in an echo chamber with others that are pro Palestine and perhaps not realising the anti-Semetic roots of some of the things he is saying.

However, I don't think this is necessarily something that can't be overcome by open honest discussion. In fact, perhaps the only hope for the Israel Palestine situation is if more moderate people can have open honest discussions!

The Jewish nose comment is definitely concerning and I would show him something that explains how it isn't just a characteristic like a Roman nose, but an anti-Semitic trope.

Of course it is very upsetting that he hasn't shown any concern for your family and how frightening it is for them, and that you are not unreasonable to identify with the trauma suffered by your family and fellow Israelis due to Hamas, and that from your point of view, understanding that is an emotional thing, it is not a comment on the rights and wrongs of the situation and to bring the rights and wrongs in is insensitive.

But I can see that from his point of view, when people say they condemn Hamas, but aren't so vocal about condemning the terrible actions by the current Israeli government and the suffering of the Palestinian people, then it can very much seem like taking sides and ignoring the suffering of the Palestinian people.

You say that you obviously don't have an issue with Israel existing. Whereas I don't disagree with your right to hold that view, I do think it isn't obvious. What is obvious to me is that when the international community, with Britain in a key role, decided to give a multicultural area to just one of the cultures that lived there, without the agreement of the other cultural groups that had lived in that area for centuries, and also agreed to settlement of that area by large numbers of people who hadn't previously lived there, it was a recipe for disaster. I absolutely disagree with anti-Semitism and any attempt to discriminate against or persecute Jewish people. But I don't think the formation of Israel was the answer. I can see the logic of a Jewish state as a refuge against antiSemitism, except that it doesn't solve antiSemitism and if anything worsens it outside of Israel. I don't believe that the Jewish people have a promised land as I am an atheist. And I can see that the whole situation is grossly unfair to the other cultural groups living in the area, who have had Zionism literally take over their lives and homes. Though I think it is more complex than that even - apparently Rory Stewart has done a thoughtful Podcast on the history of conflict in the region going back centuries , though I haven't listened to it myself yet, but you might find that useful background if you haven't already got that knowledge.

And unfortunately, such a situation tends to breed extremism - both in terms of Hamas and also the current Israeli government. I think that Hamas is anti Semetic, but I also think the current Israeli government is racist against Palestinians. I do agree that Hamas are not just freedom fighters, as David Baddiel explained in a Podcast the other day (Newscast, might be one for you and your husband to listen to together) that they have an anti-Semitic mission statement, aiming to eradicate Jewish people in the region. I didn't know that. I suspect many Corbynites probably don't know that either. I think until I knew that I might have said that 'one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter', as I don't believe that there are many non violent routes being left open to those who want to end the persecution of Palestine by Prime Minister Netanyahu's government. I heard on the radio today that a hostage negotiator who has worked in the region for years believes that the current situation may have been avoided if the international community had taken more interest in pursuing non violent solutions to the crisis that was building.

So I think although your husband has said some racist things, and you absolutely need to call him out on them and make it clear that it is unacceptable, I think you are both probably coming from good places. And both of you deepening your understanding and having sensitive discussion could be a very good thing.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This is amazing. A reference to a "Jewish nose" isn't disparaging or antisemitic.

No wonder Jews are terrified right now.

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WillyWonkaBlues · 14/10/2023 16:59

I’m sorry you are experiencing this. Is your husband Jewish? It doesn’t like it to me. I can take a difference of opinion but when it comes to putting down my own people, then I’d have to tell him to pack his bags. No one deserves this.

FedUpOfItA · 14/10/2023 16:38

I'm really sorry to hear this OP. I do think it's difficult to be with someone that thinks so differently to you and it transpiring that he has such different values. I think you need to be careful that this hatred doesn't precipitate deeper into your relationship. Just make sure you don't allow yourself to be abused by him.

AmazingSnakeHead · 14/10/2023 16:32

That's awful OP. He is your husband and shouldn't be implying that Israel "deserved" what happened last weekend.

underneaththeash · 14/10/2023 16:28

Corbyn is an anti-Semitic communist. What did you expect his views to be if he was a fan.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 16:28

It's really, really illuminating that so many people literally don't notice the most obvious, clichéd, antisemitic stereotype of them all if it appears during a discussion about Israel and Palestine. It's not as if it's even relevant to the situation. It's just thrown in there, serving no purpose except to reinforce nasty, ancient, ignorant antisemitic tropes for their own sake, and people literally don't see it because it's in this topic.

It's true that criticising Israel isn't antisemitic, of course, but these people clearly can't be trusted to know the difference.

MargotBamborough · 14/10/2023 16:24

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 16:07

If the OP is against what the Israeli government are doing and her husband is against what the Israeli government are doing then aren't they on the same side?

Because her husband hasn't asked after her relatives in Israel and he made an antisemitic comment about noses.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 16:23

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 16:07

If the OP is against what the Israeli government are doing and her husband is against what the Israeli government are doing then aren't they on the same side?

I'm not on the side of anyone who makes disparaging remarks about a "Jewish nose".

sunshinesupermum · 14/10/2023 16:21

I'm so sorry Tiredboymum22 Your DH is being unreasonable insensitive and antisemitic.
Like you I am an Ashkenazi Jew previously married to another Jew and have two daughters and two grandsons who by definition of having Jewish mothers are also Jewish.
My DP is not Jewish but he is very well read on the subject of history and the Middle East. We don't agree but he understands my feelings at this present time. Not sure if I could carry on living with a husband like yours 😢

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 16:07

If the OP is against what the Israeli government are doing and her husband is against what the Israeli government are doing then aren't they on the same side?

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 16:04

Has he though?

Don't most impartial people deplore what has been done and also deplore what is being done?

DdraigGoch · 14/10/2023 15:57

contactme · 14/10/2023 13:09

To be honest I think you are being U because this isn’t really a situation where you can take sides, atrocities have occurred on both sides. Neither comes out as a pillar of honour frankly

But the OP hasn't defended the actions of Netanyahu's government. It's her husband who has taken a side.

verdantverdure · 14/10/2023 14:34

He said The BBC are right not to call Hamas terrorists.

And the BBC's long-standing impartiality policy involving not calling anyone terrorists has been explained earlier on the threat.

Startingagainandagain · 14/10/2023 14:19

This is awful and your husband is a fool...

It is one thing to express sympathy for civilians in Palestine who are endlessly caught in this conflict and are paying the price.

It is unacceptable though to suggest that Hamas are anything other than terrorists (they don't even care about their own civilians and just use them as pawns in their fanatical, vile activities).

It is also unacceptable for your husband to speak to you in that way and to fail to grasp that you are worried for your family and friends in Israel.

Do you have kids with that man? If so doesn't he realise that they are Jewish too as their mum is Jewish?

Frankly it sounds like you need to leave that man and get his toxicity out of your life.

Parker231 · 14/10/2023 14:16

Not all Palestinians are Hamas in the same way as not all Germans were Nazis.
50% of the Palestinian population are children. Israel cutting off their water and electricity is wrong and cannot be supported. Telling them to leave Northern Gaza within 24 hours - where are they meant to go with limited fuel and no safe routes?
No one can take the moral high ground in this tragedy.

SerafinasGoose · 14/10/2023 14:12

There are plenty of British people who are horrified at what Hamas have done here and who stand with Jewish people at this time.

I don't question that antisemitism has been on the rise in Britain for a long time. I wasn't a Corbynista largely because of the stench of antisemitism pervading Labour at that time. Whether you view him as guilty of this form of racism or not, the conditions were such that it was able to flouish under his watch. By the same token, in academia there are now serious repercussions for those studying this region who have questioned the behaviour of Israel and found themselves on the receiving end of accusations of antisemitic racism. People have lost their jobs because of this. Unions have also waded in to protect those people's jobs and been accused of antisemitic campaigns against Jewish students.

I'm horrified by what Hamas have done. I'm also horrified by what the far-right, oppressive Israeli government have done to Palestinian citizens, having seen for myself the terrible conditions under which they are living on the West Bank. No human beings should have to live the lives they live. There are wrongs on many, many sides of this conflict, some of which emanate from far beyond the borders of Israel/Palestine. It's sad to see the flocking toward lazy left/right tribalism without much critical examination of why those distinctions are these days questionable at best. The whole situation is far more nuanced and complex than that.

Whatever the wrongs of the above situations, It's a frightening time in UK history for Jewish people, and this is in no way acceptable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread