Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok to tell her to hit them back?

167 replies

Comeonthenproperautumn · 13/10/2023 12:40

Is it ok to tell my 5 year old Dd that if someone hits her, to hit them back?
Ive been saying this to my Dd, but part of me feels strange saying it.
I can’t protect my child when I’m not there and can’t 100% trust other adults are fully protecting her, is it ok to start building this resilience in her?

OP posts:
SkyTree · 13/10/2023 13:26

No. Violence isn’t the answer. They should tell an adult.

I’m sure you’d be the first on the phone to the school if she got in trouble for being in a fight which started because someone hit her first and she hit them back!

DisquietintheRanks · 13/10/2023 13:26

Icedlatteplease · 13/10/2023 13:18

It's fine until she hits the wrong person back and gets beaten up.

Oh this. If the other kid isn't particularly aggressive, then hitting back isnt necessary. If the other kid is particularly aggressive, hitting back will likey lose you your teeth.

@Comeonthenproperautumn try asking your dd what is happening just before the hitting starts.

CampsieGlamper · 13/10/2023 13:21

Try talking it down

If you have spoken to the school and they have done nothing or given mealy mouthed replies "tarquin sometimes punches, but he's from a poor family, is speshul" - escalate.

Dont throw the first punch, throw the last one.

saveforthat · 13/10/2023 13:18

Stompythedinosaur · 13/10/2023 13:05

If course it isn't ok! That's a terrible message to give!

How about telling her to tell the teacher?

I've always told my kids there are only two reasons anyone is allowed to use violence - to protect themself or to protect someone else. Teaching them to retaliate violently, or to be violent in revenge is absolutely not the right message.

But self defence is protecting yourself

Icedlatteplease · 13/10/2023 13:18

It's fine until she hits the wrong person back and gets beaten up.

JaneyGee · 13/10/2023 13:16

It works sometimes. But real life isn’t like a Hollywood movie, where the bully falls down and learns her lesson. I remember someone on this forum saying their son had stood up to the school bully after he hit a friend. Their son pushed the bully over. And what happened? The bully just got straight back up and punched her son three times in the face.

caringcarer · 13/10/2023 13:16

I think in the first instance tell the teacher or TA. Hopefully the bully will be made to stop but if it doesn't get sorted and she's being hit a lot then I'd say hot back very hard. The bully will likely back off and decide she's no longer an easy target. My.older used to be bullied by 2 older boys at break and lunch time. He told the teacher. I spoke to the teacher but he kept coming home with bruises where he had been pushed over or pushed into a wall as he walked along. His Dad showed him how to punch putting in the rotation from the hip. He hit one of the bullies back and knocked him over. They stopped picking on him after that. It just took one good punch.

saveforthat · 13/10/2023 13:14

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 12:56

🙄

Honestly.

Of course it's not ok to tell her to hit back. For a few reasons: it's not dealing with the underlying issue of her being hurt by others; it is likely to lead to her being more hurt, as the physical attacks increase.

If the teacher isn't listening to her, you go into school and discuss it.

You talk to your DD about the situations it's happening, and strategies to protect herself.

The trouble with the tell an adult approach is that children can get hurt in the time it takes to do this and the bully could hit them every day. Let's face it teachers do not have eyes in the back of their head. If she hits back hard, it might stop the bully hitting her in the future

Fogwisp · 13/10/2023 13:14

The problem is, it works until there's someone bigger and stronger. I was taught to hit them back as a child and I was good at it, protected my siblings from bullies, defended myself. But I was and am a small female and once past primary age we small females are at risk if we fight back (I'm sure martial arts skills help, but it's not enough against big men). I think it's better to teach other ways of managing conflict, although letting your a child know it's fine and good to stand up for themselves is important too.

IgnoranceNotOk · 13/10/2023 13:14

I do get all the messages about hitting back to get them to stop however if the child hitting back was then internally excluded in another class for the rest of the day because they were the one caught hitting and the perpetrator who started it denied hitting first, would you all let that go as that’s all the teacher has to go off of?

On the other hand, we had issues at the end of nursery with a child with SEN repeatedly hitting my child - I tried all the learning differently talks and he might take longer to learn the rules etc and did tell the staff and then it continued and the staff seemed to want my child to play with him even though this was happening so it got to the point I told mine not to play with him as he doesn’t have to play with someone who hits - I was then livid when staff told my child that he’s hitting because he wants to be your friend! I had a meeting and told them if they didn’t keep them apart and prevent the hitting then I’d be telling my child to hit back.

I’m a teacher so I know both sides.

Divebar2021 · 13/10/2023 13:09

I don’t know why anyone would say it’s a terrible idea - the potential for your child to be the victim for the rest of their life is very real. There are times when going to an adult is possible and advisable and times when it’s not. In those situations then yes hit back. “ Self defence” is a right enshrined in law and I have no problem in supporting my child if she chooses to exercise her RIGHTs not to be hit.

cushioncovers · 13/10/2023 13:08

Mine were told don't start the fight but make sure you finish it. They always had my permission to hit the kid back and I would sort it out with their teacher and the other parents. As a child I always walloped a kid back if they hit me. I was never bullied at school.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 13/10/2023 13:08

I would tell her to shout 'stop hitting me X!' If it continues, she tells an adult, and then if it happens again, hit back.

My sister was often bullied at junior school after we moved into a village as 'outsiders', back in the 1960's. The gang of bigger girls would pretend they wanted to be friends with her, encourage her to go out of sight of the teachers and then start hitting her, pulling her hair, etc. One day this happened, and I saw this girl who was much bigger than my sister, pulling her hair, I looked around for help (I was only 5), but there was no one to be seen, so I grabbed the bigger girl's pony tail, and swung on it! Surprise, surprise, they never picked on her again after that, and no one even thought about trying it on with me. So while in general I don't believe in violence, if it's continual bullying, I would definitely tell a child to hit back good and hard!

IgnoranceNotOk · 13/10/2023 13:06

This shouldn’t be necessary at 5. Is this the end of tether because you’ve told the teacher every time it’s happened (you need to be doing this if your daughter reports to you) and then it’s still ongoing?

If not, then you need to report it every time so they can keep a record - even if this is emailing the school office every time so they know there is an issue not being dealt with properly.

If this has all happened already then I’d be looking to change schools.

I went to rough schools and only needed the ‘if someone hits you, hit them twice as hard’ advice my dad gave me at secondary school when everyone was doing the ‘you alright?’ Half playful hit on the arm - people didn’t hit me on the arm anymore.

Screamingabdabz · 13/10/2023 13:06

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 12:56

This.

What bollocks. It’s actually worse parenting to psychologically take away their only line of defence.

‘Telling a grown up’ results in accusations of being a tell-tale or worse, they end up up in some pathetic restorative justice namby-pamby meeting keeping a lid on their justifiable hurt because they’re suppose to sympathise and collude with their own victimhood.

A short sharp retaliation is sometimes the only language punchy little bullies understand.

Stompythedinosaur · 13/10/2023 13:05

If course it isn't ok! That's a terrible message to give!

How about telling her to tell the teacher?

I've always told my kids there are only two reasons anyone is allowed to use violence - to protect themself or to protect someone else. Teaching them to retaliate violently, or to be violent in revenge is absolutely not the right message.

ObsessedWithZach · 13/10/2023 13:04

Have you been into the school and spoken with the teacher if this is happening quite frequently?

If not then do so. At least if you're child does hit back, there will be a record of you going in and asking for something to be done. The school should be doing something but b if they don't know it's happening, they can't.

If you have been in and they're not dealing with your child being quite frequently hit, I'd look at escalating the issue.

skgnome · 13/10/2023 13:03

only If all the other avenues have been exhausted
tell an adult, shout no and then tell an adult
i know some schools would not act on it
also, unless they do know how to hit they are more likely to injure themselves and just get caught in a fight
i do know sometimes it will have to be done, but all the other avenues need to be exploded before you get there, don’t do it just in case

LadybirdLover · 13/10/2023 13:01

No, that’s an awful message to teach your child. It’s never okay to assault someone.

eandz13 · 13/10/2023 13:00

Absolutely.
Mine know they can never EVER hit first, but if they get hit they can take the other kid to pound town.

Flamingogirl08 · 13/10/2023 12:59

In MN world no she should go and find an adult who fix it and she will have no issues because the adult saved her.

In the real world sometimes kids need to hit back and stick up for themselves against bullies.

ChickpeaPie · 13/10/2023 12:59

I’ve always taught my children to walk away and tell an adult.
But recently I’ve heard other adults telling their children to hit back, and harder. It makes me really uncomfortable

Noshowlomo · 13/10/2023 12:58

My dad (an old valleys man who gives no shits) always said never hit first, ever. But if hit or bullied then punch them in the nose, and hit upwards. My friend was being picked on by this absolute dick head every day on the way home, so I grabbed him and smacked him. Didn’t happen again. Only time it ever happened and I am not a violent person as people above are saying will happen.
My son is 4.5 and if /when the time comes I will be telling him the same. At the moment I say to tell the teacher and me and his dad when he gets home from school. Bullies only know one way…

Marblessolveeverything · 13/10/2023 12:58

I am assuming that this is her peers? so they are 5 years old?
The problem you will have by telling her to hit back is it conflicts with the school message and she will get into trouble for hitting.

The first step is say in a her "strong voice" that is not nice/stop hitting me etc, and tell a teacher.

The teacher will deal with the perpetrator who could be reacting to your DD/anything else/ not as mature/ frustration etc. By her telling the teacher you are allowing the teacher to correct / put in interventions to sort the issue.

Violence only begets violence and is never the answer. However, I did ensure mine learnt self - defence from an early age - it teaches de-escalation, how to get out of situations and where absolutely necessary how to safely engage appropriately - a valuable life skill.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 12:56

ASCCM · 13/10/2023 12:49

Nope. Unless you want your kid to grow up thinking that violence is the only option.

this is not good parenting at all.

This.