Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok to tell her to hit them back?

167 replies

Comeonthenproperautumn · 13/10/2023 12:40

Is it ok to tell my 5 year old Dd that if someone hits her, to hit them back?
Ive been saying this to my Dd, but part of me feels strange saying it.
I can’t protect my child when I’m not there and can’t 100% trust other adults are fully protecting her, is it ok to start building this resilience in her?

OP posts:
Goldfish41 · 13/10/2023 17:30

I don’t think it’s generally the right response, no. If there’s literally no other self defence option in the face of an unremitting bully then ok, but I don’t think general tit for tat violence (especially in the case of a small thump from a young child) is the right approach and often leads to it spiralling.

Examples in a couple of threads on here right now - one where a kid at school hit back after a bully kept going at him and had him up against something, fair enough, he was disciplined by the school wrongly IMO.

There’s another thread on here at the moment where a parent told their child to push a child back and it escalated massively to violence involving the parents.

Violence should be a last resort, not the standard response.

BoohooWoohoo · 13/10/2023 17:25

Yes but don't hit first.
Tell her that if she gets told off to explain that she hit them back and if the adult still doesn't understand then you will explain to them.
I agree that sometimes the adults don't do anything or are ineffective because they didn't witness things.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 17:24

If she hits back hard, it might stop the bully hitting her in the future

It won't.

If you are a bully who is happy to hit, you'll hit more. And harder.

If you are a normally peaceable child, who only hits back in defence, you'll be hit harder & be hurt more.

You'll still get into trouble. The hitting wing stop.

You do have to tell a person in authority. It won't stop that incident but handled correctly, it stops in the future. If not, the parent acts as a parent & deals with it.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 13/10/2023 17:24

In that case TheCunctator, you've had a very lucky and privileged life. Perhaps your children went to private school? Or maybe they WERE the bullies??

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 17:22

It’s actually worse parenting to psychologically take away their only line of defence.

@Screamingabdabz
I think this is much more likely to be bollocks.

Of course hitting someone back isn't 'their only line of defence'. Not only isn't it, it's going to escalate it for them.

And solves nothing.

The rest of your post is even more idiotic.

Vocaladvocaat · 13/10/2023 17:18

It’s all very well saying violence is wrong. Obviously it is. So is being the victim of repeated attacks and not getting any validation or support from teachers.

Nobody is condoning violence they are condoning self defence when normal methods of preventing violence fail. Sometimes a thump in the face will make the worst bully think twice.

TheCunctator · 13/10/2023 17:17

UpaladderwatchingTV · 13/10/2023 16:59

Where do you live Cunctator, a desert island perhaps?

Don't be ridiculous. There are plenty of places in the UK where people know how to behave themselves and don't go round hitting one another. I've had three children at a total of six schools, and there was not one single instance of pupils having punch-ups. Bullying was dealt with very effectively by the staff in all cases. I don't socialise with the kinds of people who advise their children to punch back. Obviously these things go on, but not everyone has personally experienced them.

Ididivfama · 13/10/2023 17:05

I personally don’t think you should respond to violence with violence. Then you take it throughout your life into adulthood. Two wrongs don’t make a right. Also once hitting is ‘ok’ to some level it gets difficult.
Defending yourself is getting out of a bad situation or protecting your own face/body.
Whether or not the adults are helpful, it’s not a child’s place to deal with this.

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2023 17:03

ConsuelaHammock · 13/10/2023 12:53

No I want my child to grow up knowing they have the right to protect themselves from children who haven’t been parented well. Big difference.

Telling a 5 year old to use physical aggression IS bad parenting!
A 5 year old cannot use logic to determine if she is defending herself or just getting the first punch in. If she learns to hit, she will soon learn that her actions will have consequences in school.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 13/10/2023 16:59

TheCunctator · 13/10/2023 14:21

I also noticed the false equivalence between violence and resilience.

Resilience is something very different indeed.

I suspect some of the people on here who tell their child to hit the bully harder live in the kinds of homes or have had the kinds of upbringings where abuse is not uncommon.

People who advocate hitting back also say it's part of the "real world". I've been in the real world for over 50 years and I don't know anyone who has ever hit anyone.

Where do you live Cunctator, a desert island perhaps?

Screamingabdabz · 13/10/2023 16:52

ASCCM · 13/10/2023 14:28

That's fine. You are not my kind of person OP. Fighting is trashy and unnecessary, parents who endorse these behaviours are not parents I want to be like or have any respect for. (likewise, their fighting kids)

…Missing the whole point 🙄

Bunglemom · 13/10/2023 15:12

My daughter was bullied by little sh*ts and kept telling the teacher and the teachers refusal to do nothing (regardless of how many times i went through the correct processes ending up with the head teacher) so one day she snaps and floors this girl after being pushed about for too long. The other girls gave her no grief afterwards and to be honest with my youngest now ive always said 'you dont start it but you finish it'... sometimes a little bit of violence goes a long way.

Kendodd · 13/10/2023 15:07

I would say no, but, sometimes all the other strategies fail and you are left with nothing else. Also, if somebody is hitting you, and continues to hit you, you have the right to hit them back to defend yourself, everybody does and the law recognises that right.

skippy67 · 13/10/2023 14:58

ASCCM · 13/10/2023 14:50

Neither you or OP are my kind of person. I will never encourage violence ( used or not)

Okie dokes!

itsmyp4rty · 13/10/2023 14:56

ehb102 · 13/10/2023 14:46

I got into my work (trauma resolution) through looking at how bullying causes PTSD.

My view is that if the systems aren't working to protect a child you need to make sure they have agency to protect themselves. Disempowering them and expecting them to be the pinch point between someone trying to hurt them and a malfunctioning system is unfair.

The psychology of bullying is about power. A child needs to be able to reclaim their power.

Really? In your work of trauma resolution you tell children to hit other kids back? If systems aren't working to protect your child then the systems are crap and you move your child to somewhere where the systems are good. If a school can't keep your child safe then you leave and find a school that can - why would you have your child at a school where they are in constant fear of being hit and nobody cares?

Expecting children to sort out a situation where someone is trying to hurt them is what is unfair. They shouldn't have to reclaim anything - what if they don't want to lamp another child? What then?

SouthLondonMum22 · 13/10/2023 14:56

At 5? No, especially as a general rule with little to no issues.

A 5 year old doesn't have the greatest judgement, I'd be concerned they'd feel they have permission to whack someone if they bumped into them by accident etc.

Cowlover89 · 13/10/2023 14:50

Yes but never throw the first punch

ASCCM · 13/10/2023 14:50

skippy67 · 13/10/2023 14:41

Not sure why you quoted me, then referenced the OP... Anyhow, My dc are in their 20s now. Neither of them have ever hit anyone. I've never hit anyone either, let alone had a fight😅
For what it's worth I don't think you're my sort of person either. Bit too judgemental.

Neither you or OP are my kind of person. I will never encourage violence ( used or not)

itsmyp4rty · 13/10/2023 14:49

If kids are hitting each other frequently at this school then I don't think telling her to hit back is the answer at all, is she going to hit back at all these different kids? Honestly adults need to be dealing with this, not kids being expected to know what constitutes acceptable violence and then expected to stay within those boundaries.

If your child is being hit a lot then you need to be talking to the teacher about how they are going to keep your child safe and if they are disinterested take it to the head, if they're not interested go to the governors. If you still have no joy then this is obviously a pretty crappy school and I think you need to be looking at other schools where this isn't happening or where it is dealt with swiftly if it does happen. ,

TheCunctator · 13/10/2023 14:48

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 13/10/2023 14:34

What do those who are having the horrors with regards to hitting back suggest work?
Or is it that its your dc who are striking first and you don't want them hit back?

Nice try. I just don't inhabit a world where people go around hitting one another, and neither do my children.

ehb102 · 13/10/2023 14:46

I got into my work (trauma resolution) through looking at how bullying causes PTSD.

My view is that if the systems aren't working to protect a child you need to make sure they have agency to protect themselves. Disempowering them and expecting them to be the pinch point between someone trying to hurt them and a malfunctioning system is unfair.

The psychology of bullying is about power. A child needs to be able to reclaim their power.

Orphlids · 13/10/2023 14:44

Icedlatteplease · 13/10/2023 14:26

Most likely way our daughters will be attacked is In a domestic violence situation. Hitting back is the quickest way to escalate the violence and unlikely to be terribly effective. Worse case scenario it might get her killed.

Freezing is often an instinctive self preservation mechanism.

Best way to avoid violence is to avoid those who are violent entirely.

Indeed, I wouldn’t advise her to hit back in a domestic violence related situation. We occasionally have an in depth discussion about what she should do if she ever finds herself in an abusive relationship, and how she could escape with her life. I wasn’t referring to domestic violence in my earlier post.

skippy67 · 13/10/2023 14:41

ASCCM · 13/10/2023 14:28

That's fine. You are not my kind of person OP. Fighting is trashy and unnecessary, parents who endorse these behaviours are not parents I want to be like or have any respect for. (likewise, their fighting kids)

Not sure why you quoted me, then referenced the OP... Anyhow, My dc are in their 20s now. Neither of them have ever hit anyone. I've never hit anyone either, let alone had a fight😅
For what it's worth I don't think you're my sort of person either. Bit too judgemental.

SummerDawn2000 · 13/10/2023 14:41

Same @Comeonthenproperautumn same

ideally I’d say don’t hit back as if they hitter stumbles and hits the back of their head or something awful happens on the other hand some children only learn by having the same done to them.

sometimes telling an adult gets you labelled a wimp or a grass or a snitch.

kick up a stink at the school about this, call safe guarding and the governors. Don’t put your little Dd in a position where she could hurt another child and herself. Bullies are also children and breakable as well. Sometimes fighting fire with fire doesn’t work

HunterBidensBurnerPhone · 13/10/2023 14:38

I tell them they're allowed to hit back in self defence.

When I was at school it was all 'turn the other cheek', 'sticks and stones', and worst of all: 'if he pushes you over/ pulls your hair/ hits you, it just means he likes you'.

Fuck that.

Three years ago when my son was in reception, the class bully punched him in the stomach at a birthday party. Without missing a beat, my son punched him right back in the face. The mum wasn't happy but I didn't care. Since the the bully has been in trouble for picking on other boys - even holding them up against the wall by their neck. But my son has had absolutely no bother from anyone and has never been violent again.