Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok to tell her to hit them back?

167 replies

Comeonthenproperautumn · 13/10/2023 12:40

Is it ok to tell my 5 year old Dd that if someone hits her, to hit them back?
Ive been saying this to my Dd, but part of me feels strange saying it.
I can’t protect my child when I’m not there and can’t 100% trust other adults are fully protecting her, is it ok to start building this resilience in her?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 23:46

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 13/10/2023 23:42

All those teaching your child to hit back "for self defence", you do realise that is the EXACT argument 99% of knife carrying youths give? They carry a blade to protect themselves from others carrying.

Where did that notion come from I wonder?

In self defence classes, you are ALWAYS taught 1. To walk away and 2. To shout back off or similar before 3. Blocking and only as an absolute last resort if you can't get away, fight back.

Exactly this.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 23:45

UndercoverCop · 13/10/2023 23:20

We teach DS to use your words not your fists. You can stand up for yourself without thumping someone.

👏

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 23:45

i often think parents against such use of retaliation are the parents of the bullies

What an idiotic assumption.

Perhaps we are parents who recognise that endorsing physical attacks solves nothing, and can make it worse?

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 13/10/2023 23:42

All those teaching your child to hit back "for self defence", you do realise that is the EXACT argument 99% of knife carrying youths give? They carry a blade to protect themselves from others carrying.

Where did that notion come from I wonder?

In self defence classes, you are ALWAYS taught 1. To walk away and 2. To shout back off or similar before 3. Blocking and only as an absolute last resort if you can't get away, fight back.

justasking111 · 13/10/2023 23:39

There's a horrible family at my grandchildren school, the school just wring their hands because they're from a deprived background. They'd been picking on my grand daughters friend one day. My granddaughter absolutely lamped the ring leader who was two years older than her. Teacher did have a word after school but nothing more. It was the gang versus one child.

The school are short staffed so playground cover is scant and bullies getting away with a lot.

Zerrin13 · 13/10/2023 23:29

My daughter has never hit anyone first. She would never have wanted to but she was always told to stick up for herself if anyone touched her. When she was 17 and at college a social media spat with another girl resulted in this girl deciding she was going to attack my daughter in the canteen. Glad to say the other girl may have started it but my daughter finished it. The college saw it all on CCTV and my daughter was in no trouble at all as she acted in self defence.

UndercoverCop · 13/10/2023 23:20

We teach DS to use your words not your fists. You can stand up for yourself without thumping someone.

Banderbear · 13/10/2023 23:19

Some people on hear sound horrendously privileged. If you’ve never been in a situation where you’ve had to defend yourself, consider yourself lucky, rather than judging parents who have been in those situations and don’t wish their children to be victims.

As a 13 year old I was put through a table in the middle of a classroom by a vicious bully who then proceeded to strangle me whilst the teacher shouted ‘stop’ but did nothing to intervene. As I was blacking out I gave her two good punches to the face and she jumped off me and ran out of the classroom. I’m guessing I should’ve just spoken to a teacher. I will certainly be teaching my children that they have every right to defend themselves from a physical attack even if they have to ‘hit back’.

duchiebun · 13/10/2023 23:17

Or send them to self defence/boxing etc as in a lot of circumstances if you hit back then the bully will just hit you harder.

duchiebun · 13/10/2023 23:15

I teach my dc to access the situation as I was taught. As an adult are you going to want them to hit back without weighing things up?

Fionaville · 13/10/2023 23:01

I always told my kids when they were primary aged, that if anybody hits or tries to hit them, to shout "Noooo! Stop hitting me" and if that doesn't stop them or a grown up doesn't come, to hit them back.

MollyMarples · 13/10/2023 22:58

No

Mydogmybestfriend · 13/10/2023 22:55

Hit but not to hurt, just to say don't play with me

DameEdna1 · 13/10/2023 22:52

The problem with this IMO is that small children don't have the judgement to decide when hitting back is proportionate. I used to teach this age group, and they're A) clumsy and B) not good at telling the difference between 'on purpose' and 'by accident'. I've dealt with numerous situations where child A thinks child B has hit/pushed/kicked them on purpose intending to hurt them and actually, child B wasn't looking where they were going and bumped into child A/accidentally biffed them with their book bag etc. It would be a bloody nightmare if all these kids had been told to hit back.

Plus, I don't think it's necessarily a good idea to put the idea in her head that she needs to be worried about people hitting her at school. It hasn't happened yet and may well not happen at all. If she's telling you that deliberate hitting is happening a lot between other children, I'd raise that with the teacher. By age 5, kids deliberately attacking each other should be an unusual occurrence!

Alwaysanotherwine · 13/10/2023 22:49

I absolutely fell my child to hit back

why should my child put up with 2/3/4 hits to protect the fact some other shit parent harden taught their kids well

not my problem

not my child’s responsibility

why should my child put up with it? I make sure my child hits back a lot harder

if people did this more we wouldn’t have nasty bullies who’s parents think their angels

i often think parents against such use of retaliation are the parents of the bullies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 13/10/2023 22:46

I don’t tell my child to hit back, but I do say if someone is hurting him that he should do whatever he thinks he needs to do to keep himself safe. That might mean hitting or it might mean running or it might mean negotiating.

Thing is with hitting back is that it will either solve the problem (If the other kid backs off) or escalate it (if the other kid hits back even harder then bullies them more etc).

Id like to think my son would hit back if need be, but truth is I think people either have the umph in them or they don’t, and he doesn’t. I think in some ways it’s best to play with your strength and read the situation.

AT345 · 13/10/2023 22:42

Teaching children to hit back and hit back hard makes me feel uncomfortable. If this is the way they learn to respond at a young age and is the go to strategy then what happens as they grow older and stronger? I know it's rare but one punch in the wrong place can kill or change someone's life forever (sadly I have seen this on 2 different occasions involving people I know). There are many other strategies to teach first before the 'hit them back' gets taught. They also need to be aware that if they hit back, they may well get hit again or others getting involved too- it's not some magic thing to do that solves everything like some seem to imply it is.

jackstini · 13/10/2023 22:39

We always told ours - first time say very loudly 'no, don't hit me' and tell a teacher

If it happens again, shout same but hit back

Never start it - always finish it
Don't get pushed around

IgnoranceNotOk · 13/10/2023 22:18

OhcantthInkofaname · 13/10/2023 21:37

I have the problem with 1 of my children. I finally told him to scream every time he was hit. It got attention and those children learned if he screamed it would call attention to them.

This is what is so, so hard as kids get older! If they say they didn’t do it and we didn’t see then we’re at a stalemate and there’s nothing we can do other than try and impress upon them the importance in telling the truth, being able to trust them and thinking about the other person’s feelings if they have hurt them or their feelings as well as trying to admit to mistakes and actions.

I wish we had more power and control but also if we punished everyone without seeing or it being admitted then there would be times it was a lie and someone would be punished who didn’t do anything wrong.

I don’t know what the answer is but 10 years ago more pupils owned up whereas now they are adamant they didn’t do it. I’ve had kids outraged and arguing back at me that they weren’t talking when I’ve seen them myself chatting and then there are consequences because I’ve seen myself but we’re completely powerless if we don’t and they lie and say they did nothing!

One of the reasons we’re losing so many teachers - behaviour is appalling.

OhcantthInkofaname · 13/10/2023 21:37

I have the problem with 1 of my children. I finally told him to scream every time he was hit. It got attention and those children learned if he screamed it would call attention to them.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 13/10/2023 21:34

Sadly I'd always been 'don't hit back, violence doesn't solve things, tell a teacher'
Then found the schools were great at 'if an adult didn't see, it didn't happen' 'oh well she needs to move away from Timmy' 'we can't confirm it's the same child hitting her, but she needs to be kind'
Nope my child getting hit school weren't prepared to do anything about. So she's now been told if pushing him or hitting back will help her or.stop him then as defence its fine.
Being pushed off her into a puddle has surprisingly stopped the targeting!

anareen · 13/10/2023 21:23

Following as I am on the fence about how I feel about it myself. Gaining other perspectives would be wonderful!

MuchTooTired · 13/10/2023 21:18

I tried teaching mine to tell a teacher, tell a teacher. Had several conversations where I told the teacher myself too about this one little shit who kept hurting both of my DTs but dead slyly so he never got caught. After a fair old while, I told them that telling the teacher clearly isn’t working, so as long as he hits you first, you’re free to smack him one back. Funnily enough, we never had a problem with this kid again.

I do still try to encourage both of my children to tell a teacher, and tell the teachers myself as well, but (given it seems they’re largely unsupervised at break times in school) as long as they’re hit first I support them in fighting back as hard as they can, because it’s what would happen in real life.

I hate having to say it to them, but I don’t want either of my kids being bullied by some little shit in school. If they were at a small school or at private school I’d probably give different advice, but then it would probably not arise because it would be dealt with.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 21:13

We need to adjust that message from “It’s not nice to hit, but if you have been hit you can hit back”. I don’t think that’s unreasonable

Of course it's unreasonable!

How does that help either child regulate their emotions?

In adult life, we can't just do back to others what they do to us (not just hitting) and use the argument, 'well they did it first!'

EarringsandLipstick · 13/10/2023 21:11

If you have spoken with the school and the issues aren't resolved, reasonable force should be used.

If she had spoken to the school & it's still an issue - she needs to remove her child or escalate the issue.

Anyway, OP didn't return and her initial posts just spoke of collective children having hit, which sounds nothing like targeted bullying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread