Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child lost soft toy. Should I get another and fake it?

107 replies

Teddybear87 · 13/10/2023 12:06

My DS is almost seven. This summer, he lost his beloved jellycat soft toy. I’m considering getting a new one, and faking it. I would need to take its arm off and stitch it back on again a bit wonky and put it through the wash a lot of times to make it look “loved”!

I don’t know if that’s not a good thing to do. It’s lying, isn’t it?

And what if he can tell the difference?

He’s still devastated about it, and I’m heartbroken for him so am v tempted to do it. Because maybe he really needs that soft toy?

What would you do?

OP posts:
StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 22:09

HowdidIgethereblownaway · 13/10/2023 21:33

I heard once from a mum she bougt a couple of new ones and even found a smaller one in the shops. It was a few months after. And she told her child the toy had to go find a mate and they had a baby, now it came back to find him! Child was so happy.
You can make up something like it went to the doctor to get a new arm, came back for him all new and better.

Aw!

Teddybear87 · 13/10/2023 22:07

happytobee · 13/10/2023 18:15

which is it? i’m in some jellycat groups as an avid collector myself and could ask for you

It’s the black and white dog - you can still get it from JL etc I’ve seen!

OP posts:
HowdidIgethereblownaway · 13/10/2023 21:33

I heard once from a mum she bougt a couple of new ones and even found a smaller one in the shops. It was a few months after. And she told her child the toy had to go find a mate and they had a baby, now it came back to find him! Child was so happy.
You can make up something like it went to the doctor to get a new arm, came back for him all new and better.

BogRollBOGOF · 13/10/2023 19:35

Last year DS 9's little cuddly got bundled up in some bedding on holiday and we had to come back without it. DS was gutted, he'd bought it himself on camp. It really upset him for weeks and fortunately the site was local enough to contact and buy a replacement. I bought one in the other colour too- he'd originally bought that and lost that while on camp then had to buy the other colour.

He walked home from school and found the pair of them sitting outside on the doorstep waiting for him to let them in when he got home. He cried with happiness.

I left it open to him about whether these were new or had "come home". He knows, but it feels more like a continuation for him this way.

I wouldn't try and fake years of use, but if I could get away with something like sleeping with them to make them smell right, I'd consider that.

DS12's cuddly would be a total disaster to lose after 12 years of love and surgery. He sticks to safe things like sitting in my car while he's at school.

Danikm151 · 13/10/2023 19:09

You can try. My son lost one of his backups(3 of the same little lamb) so I got a new one. Now he declares he wants grubby lamby not the clean one. He’s 3… he knows 😂

Catopia · 13/10/2023 19:03

Todaysproblem · 13/10/2023 12:17

we had this happening when mine was about 5. I half faked it, I pretended the toy went on a holiday and came back beautiful, refreshed and looking like new (must’ve gone to Turkey)! She then found the old one somewhere, looked puzzled at both and I had to pretend it was the toy’s cousin visiting, it was a whole thing. 🙄

She’s 9 and still sleeps with the original toy and the ‘cousin’.

Thank you for sharing this, this did make me laugh!!

theculture · 13/10/2023 18:57

One child has 3 of her favourite toy after she realised we had two on a washing rotation that had begun to age differently and got another when on holiday and we thought we had lost one!

The other lost hers and after many tears we found a new replacement that arrived on DCs bed one night (a la the tooth fairy) with a message from the original asking DC to look after the new one . . .

seymourhoffwoman · 13/10/2023 18:54

Read the Knuffle bunny books by Mo Willems. Made for this situation

fearfuloffluff · 13/10/2023 18:40

DD lost a special little mouse toy, we got a different one (I'm an eBay fiend) and told her the mouse had gone away go uni and then came back, so that's why she was different.

Could his bunny have gone to a health spa or salon or something, and come back with appropriate things?

Brendabigbaps · 13/10/2023 18:37

We’ve sent a few away to be “juzzed”
basically they get lost/eaten by the dog, we buy a new one and it turns up, we then tell DD that they’ve been away to be juzzed. A bit like a spa fir teddies. It gives a reason why they come back looking like new! She still believes now at 10!

wouldthatbeworse · 13/10/2023 18:32

I rotate my 7 yo’s bunny with the 3 we have in a drawer. She kind of knows (saw a spare once) and she will comment on the fur feeling different or the holes having come back but overall she is accepting. I think I’d do it. Can you get a “pre loved” one to save all the washing.

happytobee · 13/10/2023 18:15

which is it? i’m in some jellycat groups as an avid collector myself and could ask for you

zingally · 13/10/2023 17:04

I'd just take him to pick out a new one.

toadasoda · 13/10/2023 16:24

We got a 'new' second hand one on ebay. DD called it 'new mouse', to this day we wonder where 'old' mouse went. She was delighted and understood it was a replacement but that was OK. She was 4, at 7 I think he wouldn't be fooled by pretending

trevthecat · 13/10/2023 14:48

We've done this, with two children actually. The face of utter joy and relief when they got the new toy was absolutely worth it. 1st one we said he had been cheeky and gone to the North Pole and told santa what he wants for Christmas! He was about 7 at the time. Second we just said we had found him but he was younger at about 4

PurplePanther1 · 13/10/2023 14:40

I echo what others have said - that he'll know. My granddaughter had a favourite cuddly toy. Her mum bought two more of the same, but it didn't stop her having a preferred one of the three. She knew every last detail such as three missing stitches and she was only 3 when it went missing, so a 7 year old will definitely know the difference.

Thebigblueballoon · 13/10/2023 14:31

Do it. Absolutely no harm in this and it’ll bring joy to your son.

Mothership4two · 13/10/2023 14:29

@Spencer0220

I don't agree with everyone saying he's 7 and it shouldn't be a big deal.

No-one on here has actually said that.

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/10/2023 14:26

Always good to have several of a fab toy and Rotate them but obv to late for that

I would ask ds if he would like a replacement till other one turned up

Or buy a different one

Going forward - either a fav toy stays in the house

Or

Put your phone number on toy on label etx so if found they can ring you

VineRipened · 13/10/2023 14:19

I would do it.

And say he has been travelling / on holiday / visiting relatives and got a bit lost but is home now, and has had a good bath.

It is likely that he will know what happened but telling himself this will allow him to move forwards with new cuddly.

Children this age can (and do) live an imaginary / emotional life alongside their rational understanding. That is how he, and other children, feel so strongly about him being ‘lost and alone’, and all the other adventures toys have.

Also how they understand Father Christmas etc.

Beamur · 13/10/2023 14:19

Every home with little children needs a copy of Tatty Ratty by Helen Cooper - deals with this perfectly.
I think at 7 your DS is not going to be conned by a deliberately dishevelled toy. Sadly honesty is the best way - beloved toy is lost and may not come back. I would offer a new toy to love and sympathy and understanding for the loss of the other.
We had to impose a no special toys out of the house after the loss of one!

musicforthesoul · 13/10/2023 14:14

At 7 he's most likely going to realise if you try and fake the old one, it's not going to work and could make him feel worse if he realises later you've lied.

I'd offer to get him a new exact replacement if he wants but let that be his choice.

Spencer0220 · 13/10/2023 14:13

Sprogonthetyne · 13/10/2023 14:03

I have 3 of my 4oy's special toy, I rotate every few months, when the current one needs a wash, so they all look roughly equally loved. Luckily non of them have required surgery yet, so haven't had to maim the others to match.

I love this idea

Sprogonthetyne · 13/10/2023 14:03

I have 3 of my 4oy's special toy, I rotate every few months, when the current one needs a wash, so they all look roughly equally loved. Luckily non of them have required surgery yet, so haven't had to maim the others to match.

CoalCraft · 13/10/2023 13:50

Don't try and fake it. You'll almost certainly fail. My DD instantly recognised her replacement was a different one and she was 2.5. I hadn't been trying to pass it off as the old one but even if I had I'd have failed instantly.

Ask him if he'd like another one, and if yes, buy him one. Be honest about it.

Obviously not quite the same but I was so hurt as a kid that my mum tried to pass off a new pet as an old one that had passed away while I was in school. I noticed straight away and was then gutted, not only that my pet had died but that my mum had planned not to tell me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread