Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child lost soft toy. Should I get another and fake it?

107 replies

Teddybear87 · 13/10/2023 12:06

My DS is almost seven. This summer, he lost his beloved jellycat soft toy. I’m considering getting a new one, and faking it. I would need to take its arm off and stitch it back on again a bit wonky and put it through the wash a lot of times to make it look “loved”!

I don’t know if that’s not a good thing to do. It’s lying, isn’t it?

And what if he can tell the difference?

He’s still devastated about it, and I’m heartbroken for him so am v tempted to do it. Because maybe he really needs that soft toy?

What would you do?

OP posts:
Fruitbatdancer · 16/10/2023 01:50

yes. Do whatever it takes.

my 60 year old husband cried big soppy tears when he spotted a toy in an antique shop window that he lost when he was 6. Different toy obviously but same (and now a dinky toy worth $$$) but I ran straight in to buy it for him. F@ck the cost. Worth. Every. Penny.

do whatever it takes to fix his heart so you don’t have to let his wife do it when he’s 60!!!

Fionaville · 16/10/2023 00:58

I would absolutely fake it. I'd take it a step further and 'find him' in the washing machine with your DS. To explain where its been and why it might look a bit different, because it's been washed.
Everything doesn't have to be a lesson in life. He's only young, let him have his favourite Teddy back.

novocaine4thesoul · 16/10/2023 00:55

Absolutely agree with @Dita73 My daughter (aged about 8) was bought a cat toy from the Rainbow cafe in London by her Auntie. Lost it on the way home. Heart-rending posters were put up in the street, I called everywhere we had been - nothing. I called Rainbow cafe and bought a new one and my daughter was beyond overjoyed to have him back with a story that someone had handed it in from the train. Now I know that the first toy was newish to start with, so didn't have the badges of "love" that some toys have, but I think, as a parent, this is time for a white lie, whatever that might be, "he doesn't smell the same as the people who found him thought he needed a wash" - "he has been to the toy hospital and they have mended his stitches and made him look like new, what a great job they have done, isn't it great to have him back". And for all those who insist that lying is not a great lesson to teach, put your child and their feelings first, then cope with your own. You will have to be economical with the truth sometimes, and for lots of different things as they grow up. There does come a time for "brutal truth" I agree, but it is not when your child is missing a toy or comforter at an early-ish age.

MummyPig21 · 16/10/2023 00:22

I'd not lie to him but buy a preloved one the same, don't worry about the arm and say this is its brother/cousin as the original decided to take a trip. Maybe a preloved over a new one would be more acceptable for him?

Bobbi730 · 16/10/2023 00:12

My son loved his jellycat teddy so much that I bought two more abd used to rotate them but when he got to about 5 or 6, he would only sleep with the original one, he knew the difference. He named all three of them different names and whilst he liked the others, he wouldn't sleep with them. He just knew they weren't the same.
I wouldn't try to fake it at his age but I feel for you as its heartbreaking when they lose something so loved. I hope he comes to terms with it.

Dita73 · 16/10/2023 00:06

Yes do it. I did and it worked a treat. My parents took my daughters to Disney and my youngest had a little cuddly dog she adored. Of course she left it accidentally at the airport in Paris and was devastated. I tried calling the airport but they hadn’t found it and looking around endless shops to find a replacement with no luck. A couple of months later I was in a little gift shop and they had the toy. I bought two (one for back up should it happen again!). I put it in a padded envelope and got some French stamps from my post office and addressed it to my daughter. I pretended the Postie had delivered it and gave it to her. She was just ecstatic. To see her so happy was totally worth the lie. I told her the truth eventually (probably in her teens) but she thought it was lovely that we’d done it. She still has the toy and she’s 27 and I still have the spare!

Potofteaplease · 16/10/2023 00:00

I think he could know the difference even with a second hand one, BUT you could try having the replacement sitting on the doorstep one morning. Then you could feign surprise and leave it to him to make the decision as to whether it is the real one come home, or whether he wants to suspend disbelief and accept it anyway. It must be awful as 7 year olds are still very young and to them that toy is a real friend which has been with them through thick and thin. I definitely DO NOT see this as lying! And anyway we lie all the time so as not to hurt people's feelings and with children it's all about creating magic for them. All positive imo. Good Luck.

WheekWheekWheek · 15/10/2023 23:40

@nutsnutspistachionuts that's a good solution. I wouldn't want to lie because lies usually get found out sooner or later.

LisaJ68 · 15/10/2023 23:35

Yes, do this! My daughter lost her Floppy at 7 and didn't get over it for months, especially during emotional moments. I found a secondhand one on Ebay and told her her uncle had found it at her grandparents' cottage. She's 20 now and still takes Floppy everywhere and has no idea that he is Floppy #2.

MercyIsEliminated · 15/10/2023 22:10

There was a lovely thread many years ago about a little girl who lost her toy mouse. I think she was also about 7 years old. With the help of other MNers, the OP managed to acquire a replacement. Several MNers also sent postcards from the mouse to the child. It was a truly heartwarming story and the OP described how happy the little girl was when her beloved replacement mouse came home.

So I would say why not give it a try? It sounds as though your DS would be thrilled and relieved.

Dancingqueen2023 · 15/10/2023 20:43

Oh blimey, nothing worse is there. Going through this at the moment with a nearly eight year old. We know where it was lost and have let him send a message through to see if it can be found. TBH I don't think we could replace it without him realizing, he still buries his face in them for comfort x

Spencer0220 · 15/10/2023 20:30

Sjh15 · 15/10/2023 19:53

This made me sob reading it. Your mum is an angel

Thank you. She tries.

hadrianswallsycamore · 15/10/2023 20:00

@Teddybear87 I lost a precious toy at 10. I was devastated but he wasn't replaced. I tracked one down on eBay and got bought him for my 42 birthday. I cried like a baby when I saw and smelt him. I have slept with it in my bed/under my pillow for 6 years. I would buy a replacement if I was you xx

MasterBeth · 15/10/2023 19:59

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 13:06

I'd do it. He's 7, not 17. He still believes in the tooth fairy and Santa Claus. Where's the harm?

The harm is, you're lying to him.

And plenty of 7 year olds don't believe in Santa.

Sjh15 · 15/10/2023 19:53

Spencer0220 · 13/10/2023 13:46

I don't agree with everyone saying he's 7 and it shouldn't be a big deal.

My husband is 34. When he was 11 his mother decided he was too old for all his teddies and got rid of every single one. It absolutely traumatised him.

He was still affected by it when I met him nearly 20 years later.

The only thing that helped? My mother (without telling either of us) set about finding him a new teddy. From her. So that no matter what happens, nobody can take it away.

Trust me when I tell you, that 33 year old sobbed like a baby on Christmas Day when he opened that package. It will never undo what happened, but it went a long way to helping

I can't tell you what to do with your son. Only you know whether to replace new or fake it.

But if he's struggling? I'd do something.

This made me sob reading it. Your mum is an angel

Sennelier1 · 15/10/2023 19:12

I would do it, absolutely. Even give the old/new toy a good workout in the garden so it looks a bit exhausted from the long time away from home ❤️‍🩹

Kazzybingbong · 15/10/2023 18:44

I don’t think I could do this knowing it wasn’t the original but having to pretend, every day that it was. I couldn’t handle it 🤣

My daughter lost her dog toy ‘Sweetie’ in New York last Christmas and she still hopes that a kid picked her up and gave her a home. They are so attached to them 😭 she also cries for her hamster that died a year ago regularly. We have had two more since but they’re not Joey. RIP Joey Jesus.

CurlewKate · 15/10/2023 18:07

My dd was 5 when she left Belle the Monkey in a London black cab. She did Lost posters about her and was so happy when she made her way home. She was 24 when she realised that her dad had been back to the Regents Park Zoo shop and replaced her.....

Casperroonie · 15/10/2023 17:57

Problem is, they have can tell!!!!!

I got my eldest 2 of the same incase one went missing, when it did I pulled out the other one, gave it a bit of rough treatment , and she was able to tell in a split second. We found the original one later and even in the dark she can tell which is which!!! This is back when she was like, 2. Now she's 7 and can still tell them apart in a split second. We now have a rule though: toy NEVER leaves the bedroom.

Maybe get him another and tell him, as he'll probably find out....!

saffronsoup · 15/10/2023 17:38

No, don't do that. One of your jobs as a parent is to support emotional development, and to help kids learn to live with difficult empotionsand cope with them. These little life lessons are what build resilience and allow kids to grow up and have better mental health due to being mentally stronger and better able to cope with what life deals to them and the negative and difficult emotions that are part of life.

It is okay for him to be sad. Help him cope with that sadness and find alternatives but don't lie and make up things.

Isthisasgoodasitis · 15/10/2023 17:38

Believe me he will know it’s better to allow him a special trip to buy a new something xx

Oysterbabe · 15/10/2023 17:37

I'd do it definitely.
My DD is 7 and would be absolutely heartbroken if she lost Doggy. I crocheted him a collar and put an airtag inside it because I couldn't bear it if he was lost.

Busyhedgehog · 15/10/2023 17:34

We lost DS's favourite toy rabbit in Belgium. I think we left it at the services. I found a replacement and had it delivered to where we were staying. Told DS the people at the services sent it over. It had a slightly different smell,...because it was new. However, DS accepted that the bunny had been travelling and he's none the wiser. We've got a second replacement in the loft.
I think he was 5 at the time and had had the bunny given to him when he was born.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 15/10/2023 17:03

DD2 lost her witch from the Julia Donaldson books. Bought a new one and popped it on the doorstep. She happily believed it had flown home.
I think he is too old to fake it but you could start a thread for people to post pics of toys they’ve found and rehomed.

any idea where he lost it?

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 13/10/2023 22:22

It’s hard. Dd lost her comforter when she was 18 months. She couldn’t sleep without it and I ordered replacements which were nearly identical to the original one, 3 of them with 2 to go away just in case. Unfortunately 2 years later she found the spare 2 and now sleeps with bloody 3 of the feckers.

She found a small squishmallow type toy in a puddle outside school this week. Took it home in a tissue and it went through my washer. She even rescues toys misplaced in Aldi and puts them back in their correct aisle. She’d melt down if she lost one of her teddies.