Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child lost soft toy. Should I get another and fake it?

107 replies

Teddybear87 · 13/10/2023 12:06

My DS is almost seven. This summer, he lost his beloved jellycat soft toy. I’m considering getting a new one, and faking it. I would need to take its arm off and stitch it back on again a bit wonky and put it through the wash a lot of times to make it look “loved”!

I don’t know if that’s not a good thing to do. It’s lying, isn’t it?

And what if he can tell the difference?

He’s still devastated about it, and I’m heartbroken for him so am v tempted to do it. Because maybe he really needs that soft toy?

What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SkySecret · 19/10/2023 11:11

I’m no psychologist, but to me buying into his sadness and confirming to him “yes it is sad” isn’t going to help him.

I’m terrible for never throwing things out because I can come up with either a reason to keep it, or an emotional attachment to it, eg piece of clothing I’ll never wear but my mum bought it me, or similar.

I find it much more comforting when my mum rationalises things a bit for me, showing me it doesn’t matter if something breaks, it’s not bad to throw things out, it’s normal and useful etc. it takes away some of that heavy irrationality that I’ve created.

Perhaps doing that here would help? “We all lose things sometimes, it’s ok” “it’s just a teddy, it won’t be sad” or something similar? Put more of a positive spin on it, show him it’s not a “bad” thing, just one of those things.

just an idea based on my own experiences

Frazzledatfifty · 16/10/2023 20:14

I lost my favourite teddy at the same age… I remember it like it was yesterday (I’m 51!)… I was horribly sad. My well meaning Mum tried to trick me into a replacement… I knew immediately that it wasn’t the original and hated it. Eventually I chose another teddy to love (it was important that I chose it) who still sits on my daughter’s bed now. The worst bit was worrying about what had happened to my lost teddy, so spinning a story for your DS about the teddy going on holidays/meeting new friends/looking after a sad child etc etc is a good idea… anything that will make your empathetic DS believe that teddy is fine and happy and not alone in the cold somewhere!

Sstitch · 16/10/2023 16:01

Maybe you could get a new one and take pictures of it in various set-ups to look like his old one's been on holiday or been to hospital to get his arm fixed or something along those lines and that's why he's come back all fixed up and clean? I've seen a few hotels find toys and do things like that and it always makes me smile!

Justagoose · 16/10/2023 12:28

In my experience he will 100% know it's not the same one whatever you do to it. My niece at 2 years old could distinguish between her beloved snuggly and the back up version even though to the adults it looked identical.
Edit: I've just seen you said it's the black and white dog. Coincidentally my 3 year old has that too. Her baby brother took a liking to it so we bought another 'identical' one to see if one of them would accept the new one. The difference is stark, I'm not sure if they have changed them slightly or ours is just very worn out but the new one is so so fluffy, I don't remember the original ever been like that! So I really do think he'll instantly know unfortunately. I think all you can so is reassure him that teddy is ok wherever he is and eventually he'll move on, very sad I know 😢
Probably a long shot but if you've any idea where he was lost check local Facebook pages, I often see teddy found posts on there, or put a post on yourself x

Apossum · 16/10/2023 11:34

Personally I wouldn’t. He’s 7 not a baby so you run the risk of him noticing quite quickly that it is, in fact, not his original toy, and knowing you’re lying to him. There’s no benefit in that situation but there are quite a few negatives! One of the solutions already on here for giving him a new toy would be better really imo.
don’t blame your husband for crying @Spencer0220 i just welled up reading that. How absolutely precious of your mother.

scarloha · 16/10/2023 11:23

Muttisays · 16/10/2023 09:07

I agree that 7 is too old to pretend- mine would have known. Not to say don’t try and get a new special one though.

The slightly elaborate solution in our house was the invention of “Teddytropolis” where all teddies live and pop in and out of the human world. Lost teddies live there, daddy’s lost Ted from when he was a child is happy in a little retirement cottage there, there’s even a special needs school for teddies with missing limbs and stuffing that works differently. Lots of this came from my daughter’s own imagination at around 7, but it meant the lost teddy was never truly lost, he was living it up at teddytropolis beach with a honey ice cream - and it helped.

This is like how adult humans cope with grief. I comfort myself like that about my recently lost loved one still doing their lovely favourite things in the afterlife, or somewhere up there looking down at me, even when I partially know that’s probably made up.

scarloha · 16/10/2023 11:20

It just seems a bit too complex for a lie. If you just had to replace it wholesale, OK, white lie and kids can cope with white lies even after they find out. But to stitch the arm back on wonky etc – if as a child I somehow found out / suspected the truth, I might get worried about the lengths my parents went to lie to me and start secretly questioning everything in my life. I was a somewhat anxious/overthinking child though so I guess it depends on your DC.

ChickpeaPie · 16/10/2023 10:55

My children of similar age would 100% know it was faked. They’d know the colour and placement of the stitches in the broken arm, the smell, the grubby patches.

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/10/2023 10:50

They def have a smell

Dd has bun bun - a small pink bunny but we have lots as seen friends kids distraught losing a toy

So when born I brought a lot of them and easily brought on eBay /Amazon

She knows she has a few but does have a particular one that is a fav which is smellier and grubbier

It gets washed weekly - end of

Yesterday she handed bun bun to me and said smelt bad as had a dark patch one corner

Which it did

I asked what it was

Dd 6 reply

My snot and bogies mummy 😂🙀

I said needs to be washed as small was rank

Weirdly enough when we go on holiday she likes a brand new bun bun 😂

She she doesn't really mind which one as long as has one. Or 5 😂

Counted 5 in bed this am

StarlightLime · 16/10/2023 10:34

Catza · 16/10/2023 10:16

When I was a kid my parents told me my parrot flew away. When I was 16 my mother confessed he died. I felt so stupid and betrayed, I surprised myself with this reaction. Do what feels right for you but if you decide to lie, don't feel compelled to tell him about it a decade later.

Completely different scenario.

Catza · 16/10/2023 10:16

When I was a kid my parents told me my parrot flew away. When I was 16 my mother confessed he died. I felt so stupid and betrayed, I surprised myself with this reaction. Do what feels right for you but if you decide to lie, don't feel compelled to tell him about it a decade later.

GilChesterton13 · 16/10/2023 10:02

We used to keep spares of DD1's favourite Teddy for this very scenario.

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 16/10/2023 09:55

I’d be tempted to buy a second hand one off eBay or vinted so it looks worn.
although I tried this with my DS and he sniffed and gave it back and said it wasn’t his as didn’t smell right!!

June628 · 16/10/2023 09:19

Don’t do it!

sjh67 · 16/10/2023 09:09

Get him another one. I still think about my lost toy and I'm 31 years of age 😂

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 16/10/2023 09:09

This is why DD(12) now has:
Dolly
Floppy Dolly (she tumbled the spare pretty quick and adopted it)
Stiff neck Dolly (took her a few years longer to discover this)

And I still have:
Super Spare Dolly, who lives in a box in a drawer under my bed away from peeping eyes and prying fingers.

Muttisays · 16/10/2023 09:07

I agree that 7 is too old to pretend- mine would have known. Not to say don’t try and get a new special one though.

The slightly elaborate solution in our house was the invention of “Teddytropolis” where all teddies live and pop in and out of the human world. Lost teddies live there, daddy’s lost Ted from when he was a child is happy in a little retirement cottage there, there’s even a special needs school for teddies with missing limbs and stuffing that works differently. Lots of this came from my daughter’s own imagination at around 7, but it meant the lost teddy was never truly lost, he was living it up at teddytropolis beach with a honey ice cream - and it helped.

Ilikeyourdecor · 16/10/2023 08:56

I wouldn't at that age. The kids I know whose parents tried it always knew! Didn't smell the same.

JustJoinedRightNow · 16/10/2023 08:30

A PP suggested reading him JK Rowling's the Christmas Pig.
OP - DO NOT do this. That book is pretty traumatizing for young children. Yes it's on topic and explains about lost toys but there is a real sense of hopelessness to it for all the lost toys who are desperately trying to hide from a baddie. He would be distraught thinking his beloved dog was scared and frightened and trying to hide.

gettingolderbutcooler · 16/10/2023 08:14

Yes. We did it.
Look! They found snuggle and washed him and made him perfect again!

PeanutAndBanana · 16/10/2023 07:30

Danikm151 · 13/10/2023 19:09

You can try. My son lost one of his backups(3 of the same little lamb) so I got a new one. Now he declares he wants grubby lamby not the clean one. He’s 3… he knows 😂

Yup. DD at 3 handed back clean rabbit and demanded the other one which was being washed. She had no idea there were multiples. But she knew what she had been cuddling in bed for three weeks. If any parent out there is planning a rotation, do it very regularly indeed!

youveturnedupwelldone · 16/10/2023 06:33

I wouldn't try and replace in the "ooh look he's turned up!!" way, especially after all this time. If you're the kind of person that gets attached to teddies they aren't replaceable - it's genuine grief.

My DD lost a teddy earlier this year, she's 11, she was absolutely devastated. It was a very little one she took everywhere so it wasn't a surprised he got lost eventually. I found a new one but changed its name and gave it a different personality (she gives them all "feelings"!). The new one is now a very well established part of her life (secretly goes to school every day!) but she still wistfully talks about the one she lost every now and then.

BIossomtoes · 16/10/2023 06:04

Fruitbatdancer · 16/10/2023 01:50

yes. Do whatever it takes.

my 60 year old husband cried big soppy tears when he spotted a toy in an antique shop window that he lost when he was 6. Different toy obviously but same (and now a dinky toy worth $$$) but I ran straight in to buy it for him. F@ck the cost. Worth. Every. Penny.

do whatever it takes to fix his heart so you don’t have to let his wife do it when he’s 60!!!

That’s brought tears to my eyes.

Spencer0220 · 16/10/2023 05:47

Fruitbatdancer · 16/10/2023 01:50

yes. Do whatever it takes.

my 60 year old husband cried big soppy tears when he spotted a toy in an antique shop window that he lost when he was 6. Different toy obviously but same (and now a dinky toy worth $$$) but I ran straight in to buy it for him. F@ck the cost. Worth. Every. Penny.

do whatever it takes to fix his heart so you don’t have to let his wife do it when he’s 60!!!

What a wonderful wife.

Goldbar · 16/10/2023 04:26

I'd do it. Sod life lessons. I remember making my parents drive up and down a country road at night to find a small soft toy that my sibling had dropped out of the car because I hated thinking about it all alone in the dark and wet.

But I wouldn't give it to your DS outright. I'd leave the new one out in the garden on a rainy morning under a bush or in a shed (or somewhere your DS could plausibly have lost it) and 'find' it together with your DS. I'd make sure it was a bit muddy/wet/the worse for wear and needed to go in the washing-machine, which would help to explain any differences.