Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for telling DS being autistic is not a good reason for smelling

109 replies

myboysmellsok · 13/10/2023 11:29

it went roughly like this:

DS 13 who has asd/adhd gets up and puts on a t-shirt he's worn twice before (my fault for not putting it in the washing machine as soon as he took it off I know).
I remind him that the t-shirt has been warn before and ask him why he didn't put a clean one one.
He says he doesn't know where the others are, that he could only see one and he didn't like that one (there's a stack of about 15, at least a few of which he liked last week).

I say that people will think I'm a bad mum if he goes out wearing dirty clothes and smelling.

He says it's because he's autistic and I say that's not a good reason, that not all autistic people have trouble with hygiene, so autism as an excuse is lazy.

He is now really angry at me and is calling me an ignorant bully. DH joining in,.

AIBU?

Does autism acceptance mean that we need to accept people have a right to set their own hygiene standards?

Instead of harrassing my son into having normal hygiene standards should I be congratulating him on ignoring judgemental people (like me) who have a problem with BO and unwashed clothes?

OP posts:
PollyPut · 13/10/2023 13:26

He may well have real problems with the smell of other people's deodorants. But some don't smell so help him find better ones

RedCrossSupporter · 13/10/2023 13:25

However as he is functioning enough to create an argument he is functioning enough to put his dirty clothing in a wash basket and locate clean items.

🤣 That isn’t how autism and ADHD work! Even the awful DWP that withholds disability benefits on a whim recognise that Autism and ADHD can severely impact self care even if the person can verbally describe how their disability affects them. These are disabilities that often do not affect intelligence.

MrsSlocombesCat · 13/10/2023 13:17

AnSolas · 13/10/2023 12:05

If you son has reached the age of 13 without ever managing to understand where his clean underwear and tshirts are stored i would go with UABU.

However as he is functioning enough to create an argument he is functioning enough to put his dirty clothing in a wash basket and locate clean items.

If he is going to wear something 2 days running i would suggest that you get colour coded hangers eg a red hanger is used to indicate clean but previously used. And on the second day he puts it into the wash basket.

You are trying to get a full functioning indedendent asult so at 13 he is old enough to learn how to use the washing machine and how to sort out laundry. So on Friday night or Saterday his job should be to collect all the washing and sort it for the washing machine. And after the wash he should be putting his clothing away.

And your husband is being an asshole. When was the last time DH too responsibility to educate your son on what is expected of him as an adult?

Have you ever lived with someone on the spectrum? My son is fortunately very hygienic but that’s because he has OCD as well. He is 32 and it would be harder for me to get him to sort his own laundry than to do it myself. I am also on the spectrum and I hate showering but make myself do it… I don’t like the feeling of water on my skin. I would be mortified if anyone thought that I smelled but a 13 year old boy is not going to be concerned with that, especially ASD. We used to go to a group where there were parents with teenagers who did smell and had poor hygiene along with others like my son who were over fastidious with it. I was thankful to be a parent of the latter. I don’t know what the answer is to be honest, but if my son refused to shower I would probably be quite insistent that he got in the shower at least twice a week. I have to go into my son’s bedroom to get his laundry so he wouldn’t get the chance to wear clothing multiple times.

BoardLikeAMirror · 13/10/2023 13:17

not all autistic people have trouble with hygiene

If you've met one autistic person ... you've met one autistic person.

There's a wide range of traits associated with autism, but we don't all have all of them, everyone has a different combination of traits. Sometimes these can be opposing - some autistic people have obsessive compulsion around hygiene, for example, whereas for others hygiene is at the bottom of the list below sensory issues which get in the way.

weebarra · 13/10/2023 13:16

DS2 is the same age and also has ASD. He needs constantly reminded about clean clothes especially.
I think it's because it's not something that matters to him, he just doesn't think about it. He's not particularly smelly, and he will go and change when I remind him, it's just something that doesn't seem to be on his radar.

Willyoujustbequiet · 13/10/2023 13:16

RedCrossSupporter · 13/10/2023 13:12

I say that's not a good reason, that not all autistic people have trouble with hygiene, so autism as an excuse is lazy.

YANBU to be concerned about his hygiene but YABU to think shaming him will work when it is clear to me that his ADHD and Autism are making self care difficult for him. Remembering and being able to shower and put on clean clothes unprompted is difficult for many people with ADHD or Autism, and he has both. It’s two of the daily living activities for DLA/PIP and why tens of thousabds of children and adults with ADHD or Autism receive due to the impact of their disability on self care.

You can’t shame someone out of the impact of their disabilities. You are being ableist.

This.

volunteersruz · 13/10/2023 13:15

I don’t think this is uncommon for any teen but i have an adhd child and this is really common in adhd, sometimes they wear certain outfits to death plus procrastination can really impact on personal hygiene .sometimes having really simple routines where prompts are used can help eg. Using a white board to make routines clear.but personally I wear a t shirt more than twice so you may need to explain why he personally needs to do it differently!!!

Willyoujustbequiet · 13/10/2023 13:15

I voted YABU as I think its his ADHD not his autism.

Dc have ADHD and short term memory is severely impacted.

Chances are he's just forgetting and/or getting distracted/not focusing on it.

Is he medicated?

RedCrossSupporter · 13/10/2023 13:12

I say that's not a good reason, that not all autistic people have trouble with hygiene, so autism as an excuse is lazy.

YANBU to be concerned about his hygiene but YABU to think shaming him will work when it is clear to me that his ADHD and Autism are making self care difficult for him. Remembering and being able to shower and put on clean clothes unprompted is difficult for many people with ADHD or Autism, and he has both. It’s two of the daily living activities for DLA/PIP and why tens of thousabds of children and adults with ADHD or Autism receive due to the impact of their disability on self care.

You can’t shame someone out of the impact of their disabilities. You are being ableist.

Unfortun8 · 13/10/2023 13:09

I think staying clean and clean clothes is non negotiable. I have an older autistic brother who never liked showers or baths, but used to have a shower every Sunday straight after my mum did. She laid out clean clothes for him each day. When she became to old to look after herself he stopped washing and showering completely. Social services used to 'ask' him to shower, but of course he didn't, and eventually the only time he got vaguely clean was when a carer took him to a Turkish barber for a shave and hair cut, about once a month. When mum died and he went into a home it had been two years since he last had a bath. Within a month the home had persuaded him to shower every other day, and he is quite ok with that now.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/10/2023 13:07

Unreasonable for suggesting you should be running around after him putting his clothes in a laundry bin!

BoardLikeAMirror · 13/10/2023 13:05

As forcing myself in the shower every day would be difficult. I mean I can do it if I have to but I wouldn't want to do it day in, day out. It would become quite stressful.

Exactly. The only time I shower is if I'm in a hotel that doesn't have a bath. The whole staying in a hotel (which I only do if I have to for work) is stressful anyway, so showering is absorbed to an extent as part of the overall wrongness. I have an ensuite shower cubicle at home that I use for storing towels in!

Marblessolveeverything · 13/10/2023 13:04

In the broader family we had this from a now great young man - but the teen years where a challenge.

We couched the hygiene issues by saying - yes you are ND and you don't have an issue with BO - however, plenty of people who are NT and ND do - so do you think you making the effort to smell clean and fresh is a reasonable accommodation for others?

That made it click - not sure why as usually he gave no cares for anyone else - at the time!

EmpressSoleil · 13/10/2023 13:01

My son can get like this refusing to shower he is autistic its the sound the shower makes that distresses him

Why can't he have a bath? I have ADHD and I hate showers as the water feels like small needles hitting my skin. I'll happily have a bath though. It's much more soothing for someone with sensory issues.

Showering seems to have become the default and I get that it's quicker and more efficient. But for those who are ND wouldn't you offer the option of a bath? If I couldn't have baths, I might well smell! As forcing myself in the shower every day would be difficult. I mean I can do it if I have to but I wouldn't want to do it day in, day out. It would become quite stressful.

It's difficult OP because while you can somewhat demand he is clean at this age, he will become an adult and he'll just please himself. I personally don't think ND people pick up "good habits" in the same way NT people do. So a routine set now will be irrelevant in future.

I mean really, people do have the right to set their own hygiene standards. It might not be pleasant for others! But there's no law that people can't be dirty/smelly. So in a way he is right. But obviously it will make his life a lot more difficult in terms of work, socialising etc as people won't want to be around him. I think all you can do is drum that aspect into him.

Merryoldgoat · 13/10/2023 13:01

sadly, a lot of (toxic) neurodiversity-affirming spaces online DO advocate for letting autistic young people do whatever the fuck they want, however anti-social

Yeah. That’s not happening here either.

Ggttl · 13/10/2023 12:59

We have an autistic guy at work who smells. He would not have got the job but he was cheap so his BO was overlooked at his interview. No one wants to share a room with him, use the lift or spend too much time with him because of the smell. He won’t be able to negotiate a higher salary and I doubt he will get promoted. Most autistic people, that I know, do not smell. For his sake, keep nagging him.

Merryoldgoat · 13/10/2023 12:59

My son is younger (also has ASD) and I went through a tooth thing last month. I told him his breath was disgusting and that if he didn’t start brushing his teeth properly I’d do it for him.

I’m happy to help him and make adjustments/buy him things that make it easier but I will not tolerate a dirty smelly child no matter how old.

Totally with you @myboysmellsok

BoardLikeAMirror · 13/10/2023 12:56

I never use a shower unless there is absolutely no choice, I cannot bear them from a sensory perspective, but fortunately I get sensory satisfaction from a bath and indeed, I do not feel right if I don't have a bath at the same time every evening. I use a jug rather than a shower-head for rinsing my hair.

Stomacharmeleon · 13/10/2023 12:54

Bravo @Jellycats4life. That's my take on it too.

Jellycats4life · 13/10/2023 12:50

Mum of autistic kids here.

Personal hygiene is not up for debate for me. I understand showering can be a sensory nightmare, and demand avoidance can cause meltdowns (been there, done that) but my kids don’t get away with not washing.

As for the clothes thing, unfortunately this is someone you have to assist them with. It’s another thing to add to your mental load, and you wish you didn’t have to micromanage these things at their age but sometimes you have to. My 12yo will dump whatever she’s worn that day on the floor and put it back on the next day without a second thought - because she can’t be arsed to think of another outfit. Alternatively she’ll put something in the wash after wearing it for a couple of hours - because she can’t be arsed to hang it back in the wardrobe.

She also really struggles with the change of seasons because then the “rules” change when it comes to suitable clothes (changing from jumpers and long sleeves to t shirts etc).

Autism acceptance means helping them with the things they find tough without complaint, even when their peers have become independent.

Autism acceptance isn’t about letting them stink because they hate washing - although, sadly, a lot of (toxic) neurodiversity-affirming spaces online DO advocate for letting autistic young people do whatever the fuck they want, however anti-social.

StrawberryWater · 13/10/2023 12:50

I think all kids go through a grim and grotty teenage phase SEND or not.

That said I've found lists help with my son. He has a routine he likes to go through and having it written down that he needs to brush his teeth and wash every day is very helpful.

MardiLisa · 13/10/2023 12:45

Also I think a scuzzy phase is a normal part of teenage development. Not ubiquitous but common. I certainly rebelled against teeth brushing at one point and I'm sure it wasn't just me. That doesn't mean we just leave them to it, but try not to see it as a character flaw.

smilesup · 13/10/2023 12:42

I have one child with ASD and one with ADHD.

I have ADHD.

I often tell mine that there are things that they find harder because of their conditions but in no way is that and excuse of it just means that for them they have to work harder at that particular thing.
One of them is really good math and I point out that it's like kids at his school who struggle with mass having to work harder just to get to a basic level he has to do the same with certain aspects of his life we all have bits in life we need to work harder at

I would say hygiene is very emotive so tread carefully.

NoMor · 13/10/2023 12:41

It doesn't seem like his autism is the problem, just that he sees a t-shirt, it's close by so he puts it on or does he refuse to wash?

My son can't smell his own BO so I just make sure to remind him regularly to wash with a bar of soap, shower gel doesn't kill the bacteria as well, and not to put dirty clothes back on. And to do his washing at least once a week! We got there in the end.

What helped is explaining that it is unpleasant for others to be around a nasty smell and if you are a part of society you have to do your best not to cause harm or distress to others. I assume he would like concessions, he wants one in this instance but a concession or accommodation must never harm others. You might have to wait a few years until his empathy returns after the teenage years though.

MardiLisa · 13/10/2023 12:39

It's hard at this age. I don't approach it as a non-negotiable, it goes out of the window when DS is overloaded, but when he's OK it is an expectation and a routine.

Would having fewer than 15 help? My son absolutely won't pick any T shirt other than the one on the top of the pile. Saying he has plenty to choose from would actually be describing a barrier, whilst showing that I didn't get that it's a barrier.