Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for telling DS being autistic is not a good reason for smelling

109 replies

myboysmellsok · 13/10/2023 11:29

it went roughly like this:

DS 13 who has asd/adhd gets up and puts on a t-shirt he's worn twice before (my fault for not putting it in the washing machine as soon as he took it off I know).
I remind him that the t-shirt has been warn before and ask him why he didn't put a clean one one.
He says he doesn't know where the others are, that he could only see one and he didn't like that one (there's a stack of about 15, at least a few of which he liked last week).

I say that people will think I'm a bad mum if he goes out wearing dirty clothes and smelling.

He says it's because he's autistic and I say that's not a good reason, that not all autistic people have trouble with hygiene, so autism as an excuse is lazy.

He is now really angry at me and is calling me an ignorant bully. DH joining in,.

AIBU?

Does autism acceptance mean that we need to accept people have a right to set their own hygiene standards?

Instead of harrassing my son into having normal hygiene standards should I be congratulating him on ignoring judgemental people (like me) who have a problem with BO and unwashed clothes?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
napody · 14/10/2023 15:05

MardiLisa · 14/10/2023 14:30

Mainly this just seems to have turned into an argument between you, husband and son.

You say "my fault really" for not putting his clothes in the wash but is that actually your job or his? I think this whole thing would be a lot simpler if you focus on him getting dirty clothes into the wash every day. That works for you because it will naturally follow that he'll put on fresh ones, and it works for him because that is so much easier than having to pick everything up at some point and sort through what's wearable, what's dirty, and what needs to be put on and what conveyed to the basket. PP suggested basket in the bathroom and that's a good idea if you have space. Ours is right outside DS's room and he puts pants, socks and T shirt in every night as part of his bedtime routine. He is bought into this because it is much easier for him than managing piles.

You seem to have ended up wrangling about a much bigger, more abstract point about responsibility to society. Focus back on a separate, isolated task of getting used clothes into the basket. Be clear on whether it's his job ,or yours, or his with your active support. If the latter, you don't get to moan about how grim it is for him to re-wear unless you have done your bit of helping him get them into the basket. That's a more productive and positive thing to focus on, and I think cleaner clothes will naturally follow.

This is good clear advice!

napody · 14/10/2023 15:03

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 11:42

@napody you have misunderstood at least two of my comments. I was not outraged at all that people disagreed with me. I really wanted to hear from people with different points of view and was hoping to be challenged - hence post in AIBU

Also, I'm not accusing anyone of bullying me, i was just agreeing with a comment about how not someone else might find him wanting to share his BO at oppressive as he finds me for mentioning it. @Spendonsend made a similar point with nicer language - triggering other people's sensory issues. DS cares about fairness and he enjoys an argument.

Apologies- you were seeking further info from the YABUs, I see now.

I'm guessing that the 'YABU's are mostly 'he needs more support for now' or 'you're right but it sounds as if you hurt his feelings by being that blunt'. Not that you should just leave him to smell :) DH should be backing you up on that.

For teenagers, tshirts become 'like underwear' I.e. need changing daily. Would it help your son to think of it like that- 'you need to reclassify tshirts now, son'?!

Violinist64 · 14/10/2023 14:39

I have an autistic adult son and the best advice l was ever given when he was a child was the phrase "it's the rule." It's a good phrase as it takes the discussion away from the personal to the universal - we might not like it but we have to do it. In this instance I would tell your son that autism is no excuse for poor hygiene and that it is the rule that when he has worn his clothes he must put them in the laundry basket and wear clean clothes the next day. I would also make another rule that he has to have a shower every day and use deodorant.

MardiLisa · 14/10/2023 14:30

Mainly this just seems to have turned into an argument between you, husband and son.

You say "my fault really" for not putting his clothes in the wash but is that actually your job or his? I think this whole thing would be a lot simpler if you focus on him getting dirty clothes into the wash every day. That works for you because it will naturally follow that he'll put on fresh ones, and it works for him because that is so much easier than having to pick everything up at some point and sort through what's wearable, what's dirty, and what needs to be put on and what conveyed to the basket. PP suggested basket in the bathroom and that's a good idea if you have space. Ours is right outside DS's room and he puts pants, socks and T shirt in every night as part of his bedtime routine. He is bought into this because it is much easier for him than managing piles.

You seem to have ended up wrangling about a much bigger, more abstract point about responsibility to society. Focus back on a separate, isolated task of getting used clothes into the basket. Be clear on whether it's his job ,or yours, or his with your active support. If the latter, you don't get to moan about how grim it is for him to re-wear unless you have done your bit of helping him get them into the basket. That's a more productive and positive thing to focus on, and I think cleaner clothes will naturally follow.

Floofboopsnootandbork · 14/10/2023 14:09

I have autism, I don’t “struggle” with personal hygiene in the sense that I smell bad, I use deodorant and perfume everyday and shower at least every other day but aim for everyday when I can, because I know that’s what I’m supposed to do but showering and putting on clean clothes isn’t as simple as just getting in the shower and putting clean clothes on. A shower is broken into every single step from start to finish, every single thing that could go wrong, and all the sensory issues that a shower could cause, so much so that it becomes an extremely overwhelming chore for me. During stressful periods I physically can not get up and get myself into the shower. I have to wash my hair tonight, I’m already having to start to prepare myself for all the steps and how overwhelming it is going to be and when I get out I’m probably going to put back on a jumper that hasn’t been washed for at least 3 weeks because that’s “safe” clothing.

Autism isn’t an excuse but it’s a reason and if someone said to me what you said to your DS it would be more detrimental than helpful, it wouldn’t make me get into the shower and put clean clothes on, it would likely do the opposite.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 14/10/2023 13:55

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 13:15

@Username82y He's always been like this but when he was younger it was easier to tell him what to wear and tell him when it's time to wash (and literally brush his teeth for him). I remember a few terrible experiences in swimming pool showers :(

We were not aware he was autistic until a couple of years ago so i have plenty of regrets amd thoughts about how we'd have done things differently if we'd known what we know now.

I still don't know really how independent we can expect him to be. He's in a bit of a burnout situation atm, so has lost some of the independence he used to have. I don't know where we'll end up in the end.

If he's in burnout, his care needs are going to be way higher. When I'm in full autistic burnout I sometimes need my husband to come with me and chat to me when I'm in the shower otherwise all the different steps feel insurmountable and can take me hours.

Different with a teenage boy, but I wonder if going to the bathroom together, getting all the bits ready, turning the shower on for him, then retreating to the other side of the door and talking to him through it while he's showering might help?

With clothes, perhaps you could fold them into ready to grab outfits (jeans, t-shirt, pants, socks) for him until he's feeling better. Clothes worn once get washed straight away. Once he's feeling better you can start teaching him how to do it.

I wonder if he's burning out whether some of his issues are low self esteem rather than sensory? He might need help to see that he is worth taking care of, iyswim?

museumum · 14/10/2023 13:48

You are unreasonable because you asked him why he didn't put a clean one on. There’s no way he can answer that question is there? Cause there’s no excuse really.
You should have just said “that T-shirt is dirty, put it in the hamper and change into one of the clean ones in the drawer”.
Simple direct instruction without recrimination.

Createausername1970 · 14/10/2023 13:41

I haven't read the entire thread, so someone may already have suggested this.

My DS is autistic and he is very much a "out of sight, out of mind" person. We removed the doors from his wardrobe and I tend to put his pants and socks into clear boxes, rather than drawers. He is far more likely to wear clean clothes if he can see them.

He is 21 and I still have to prise him out of his favourite clothes so that they can be washed. Personal hygiene can leave a lot to be desired, but if I run a bath for him he will get in it. It's the echoey noise in the bathroom of running taps or a shower that he doesn't like.

I do tell him if he is a bit smelly. I point out that it's in his best interests to smell nice. He does know this, and will often comment if someone else is a bit smelly, but it's not high on his list of priorities.

Sprogonthetyne · 14/10/2023 13:28

I think saying autism isn't an excuse was fine, but calling in lazy wasn't. Probably better to say you understand autism makes it harder, he might not like the feel of other or by unsettled by the change/transition, but even so needs to wear clean cloths. Then offer to help him find another.

Username82y · 14/10/2023 13:26

Have a look at techniques to help with personal hygiene management for people with sensory processing issues. Sit with him and go through them together and work out together which ones to implement and how

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 13:15

@Username82y He's always been like this but when he was younger it was easier to tell him what to wear and tell him when it's time to wash (and literally brush his teeth for him). I remember a few terrible experiences in swimming pool showers :(

We were not aware he was autistic until a couple of years ago so i have plenty of regrets amd thoughts about how we'd have done things differently if we'd known what we know now.

I still don't know really how independent we can expect him to be. He's in a bit of a burnout situation atm, so has lost some of the independence he used to have. I don't know where we'll end up in the end.

OP posts:
Username82y · 14/10/2023 13:02

Has he always been like this or just since he became a grotty teenager? If he's always been adverse to personal hygiene routines id be inclined to say it's a sensory processing issue. If he hasn't had issues in the past he's just a disgusting 13 year old, many NT 13 year olds are just as foul.

TiredArse · 14/10/2023 13:01

It’s your job as a parent to make sure he’s clean. (and to support him to be clean in a way he can manage, as you do). To neglect his hygiene would be cruel. People will not treat him kindly if he reeks.

ManchesterLu · 14/10/2023 12:39

YANBU. You know him the best, and know whether his autism could actually be affecting his hygiene. If you know it doesn't then yes, he's just being a smelly teenage boy like the rest of them.

VikingLady · 14/10/2023 12:31

Also can you put a laundry bin where he usually gets undressed? That's helped hugely here. Behind almost every door is a small heap of laundry.

Tumble drying clothes makes them feel more worn in than line dried.

Also we've moved to a full change of clean clothes every single day. She's not capable of judging the cleanliness of clothes - I suspect she can't smell her own smell, so they all go in even though it's technically wasteful. I'll fish them back out if it's really necessary.

You can get a deodorant called Shower In A Can. It's brilliant, even on top of pre existing stench. Would that help? Or Mitchum?

We've gone back to spray deodorant because its immediately dry, which helps too.

Good luck.

VikingLady · 14/10/2023 12:24

I've explained to my autistic kids, repeatedly, that their neurodivergence is WHY they need to be extra careful about their hygiene.

It's a tough world out there for us NDs, and although it's now (currently) illegal to discriminate against us based on our neurotype, you'll still be sacked/excluded/bullied/generally treated badly for stinking. I've seen someone fired for it. I've not recruited several people in roles where they'd be in a small enclosed office space with others.

With my kids, I've pointed out they get treated far better in public if are look clean and tidy. They get freebies in cafes and the odd shop, people like them, and they get far more latitude on meltdowns etc.

Gwendimarco · 14/10/2023 12:24

Posted too soon. In short, you were not unreasonable in principle, but you were unreasonable in the way that you handled it.

Try a little empathy next time and you may get further.

SpringGreensPreens · 14/10/2023 12:21

Look, smelling bad is really unpleasant for other people- at home and out and about. All people just need to deal with their personal hygiene. I don’t see what it has to do with being ND. My tween is at the smelly stage and is NT - she wouldn’t care if she smells. I’ve put my foot down about daily showers and not rewearing clothes.

Gwendimarco · 14/10/2023 12:21

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 12:02

@Gwendimarco what am I supposed to learn from being called a dick? Do you want to be more specific or did you just want to make me feel bad?

I was using judgemental language towards you, like you did to your son. I am hoped that my post would encourage you to reflect on the way you communicated with him, and help you to understand why he is upset and feeling bullied, even though most people here have said YANBU.

You called him lazy and told him that he is using his autism as an excuse. That is judgemental and not a very supportive way of addressing the issue.

You are concerned about how YOU feel (embarrassed and concerned that others are judging you are a bad mother) and are responding by passing that judgement onto your son (i.e. it’s not your fault, so it must be his fault!)

Yes he still needs to take care of his personal hygeine, but his autism most likely means it is harder for him to organise himself, more unpleasant for him to wash, and it’s more difficult for him to understand why it matters and to make it a priority. That is not the same as just being lazy.

You say you have autism too, so I assume you understand what it feels like to struggle with things that others take for granted?

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 14/10/2023 12:12

Nowdontmakeamess · 13/10/2023 12:15

I voted YABU for telling him autism isn’t an excuse. Autism can severely impact executive functioning, and cause developmental delays so although he’s a teenager perhaps try scaffolding and implementing systems aimed at a younger child. Have set routines for washing every morning/night, maybe hang up his clothes so the T-shirts are easier to see and have fewer of them so it’s not so overwhelming choosing what to wear, go through all his clothes to check which ones he wants to keep and replace any which are ‘wrong’ (could be sensory - material, colour etc).

It’s a tricky balance between preparing him for independence but also needing to provide more support than other children his age. People have no idea how much autism can have an impact on day to day living and self care, even in so called ‘high functioning’ individuals. You’ve had a lifetime to develop strategies to cope, so I do think perhaps it would help to change your lens somewhat.

Yes but our jobs as mothers, is to teach them how to better handle their personal hygiene! How to better handle social situations, how to cope with losing and how to at least try to read people's behaviour etc etc. Yes their issues in these areas are absolutely due to autism, however we can’t just leave it at that! We can't just say "Oh it's Autism so that's it! And not give them any of the help, tools & guidance on how to better handle/cope with/understand/overcome these situations/things.

My 8yr old has ASD and she has learnt so so much since diagnosis at 4 and I genuinely haven't forced any of it on her! I've just gently corrected her here & there, said "thats enough now" when she's said the same thing 5 times for example. Or told her that when someone is on the phone or brushing their teeth, that they can't engage in a conversation with her at that moment in time.
None of this is ableist and i have simply followed guidance & advice i was given at diagnosis. She now has little to no issues socially or at school.

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 12:09

@NC4Obvs yes, totally, if i was smelling I would really want to hear it from a friend or family rather than someone being mean.

I guess i need to soften my delivery or something because I'm not getting thanked.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 14/10/2023 12:04

My ADHD son drives me insane with his clothes - misplacing them never having clean ones etc - he has a floorrobe. But I also have ASHD and I do explain to him that it's likely his poor exec functions so he needs to work harder at keeping on top of the clothes situation.
I suspect if your son is autistic he was being very literal and stating to you the problem was because of this autism rather than using his autism as an excuse.

delanew · 14/10/2023 12:02

I've got a 13yo autistic son and for years we've always just been very black and white about 'the rules' around personal health / care etc. I'm a HCP so he's always just listened to facts from me and luckily trusts what I say 'coz I'm qualified' 🤣

So we've always had rules around 'every person has to have a shower every day / clean teeth x 2 / flossing teeth / toileting / nutrition / eye tests / dentist visit / what to be vigilant for etc' but purely from a health perspective and nothing personal (because we reinforced it before it got to that point and touch wood - he's in full force of puberty and we've had no issues).

We've always discussed with him how he'd like to ensure it's all done and helped him find ways around the challenges in the same we have with school / friends etc.

rwalker · 14/10/2023 12:02

The fact he’s arguing about it and knows it smells proves he’s fully aware and using condition as a get out of jail free card

myboysmellsok · 14/10/2023 12:02

@Gwendimarco what am I supposed to learn from being called a dick? Do you want to be more specific or did you just want to make me feel bad?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread