Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about school transport

117 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 08:36

I’m thinking mostly about transport for pupils with disabilities- though I recognise the provision is poor all around. The fact that some counties refuse to transport the littlest reception children on the grounds that school is not compulsory, for instance, is just mean, stingy accounting at the expense of tiny children.

I’m thinking about the unreliability, about the sudden calls in the morning to say ‘no transport today’ which could leave a child stuck at home. And these are children who really can’t afford to miss a day at school, or who have a breakdown at the prospect of missing a day.

I’m thinking about the massive pressure to not be a minute late for meeting transport, applied to kids who actually deserve a medal for facing up to school at all, or to kids who have already gone through three changes of clothes and two showers trying to get ready for a 7am pick up.

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

I’m thinking about the contracts that say that involuntary behaviour, if deemed unacceptable, is cause to terminate transport arrangements. Honestly that’s not very different from saying if a baby’s crying is distressing you’ll stop feeding it.

Sigh.

OP posts:
berksandbeyond · 13/10/2023 17:29

Yes, the US has school buses but they also have barely any pavements, it’s very unusual to live within walking distance of school, and plus the whole your kid getting shot dead once they get to school thing.. let’s not rush to wish we were like them 😳

PickAChew · 13/10/2023 17:23

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

I live 10 minutes walk from a special school. It didn't have a place in suitable provision for Ds2 either in year 7 or in 6th form, so he goes to the second nearest special school, which, to be honest, we preferred so we're not sad about it.

Even if we moved right next door to his current school, that would have done nothing to reduce DS1's 50 mile journey to the closest school to meet his particular needs. We would now also be in a position where Ds1 would be less able to take advantage of opportunities available to help him to become a little more independent as a young adult, as where we are is very central with good transport links.

At no point, when we were starting a family, did we decide that it would be nice to be a bit different and have children with disabilities. We already have to deal with a shit ton of stuff that parents of children without disabilities don't without still being expected to take our teenagers to school because they cannot safely travel alone.

Flufferblub · 13/10/2023 17:16

I didn't realise this was a widespread issue. We've had problems with the school transport this year. The bus of kids doesn't get to school until 9.30, so they've been missing their first lessons since September. There are too many kids on each bus, and some children are on the bus for 5 hours a day. It's really not acceptable for children with SEN to have to endure sitting on school transport for that amount of time, and arrive to school late every day. I've written to the council and the MP. I don't know what more I can do.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 17:15

cansu · 13/10/2023 17:10

Tbh I am incredibly grateful for school transport.my dd who has sen has been transported to her specialist school twice a day for nearly ten years. A journey of about 45 mins and I didn't pay until she was 16. I think that is pretty good. There has been one occasion in those ten years where transport has not arrived.

That sounds like a good run @cansu. We are just over two years in and already there have been two weeks’ worth of missed journeys, sometimes with only 15 minutes notice.

OP posts:
cansu · 13/10/2023 17:10

Tbh I am incredibly grateful for school transport.my dd who has sen has been transported to her specialist school twice a day for nearly ten years. A journey of about 45 mins and I didn't pay until she was 16. I think that is pretty good. There has been one occasion in those ten years where transport has not arrived.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 17:07

I’ll happily agree that transport, like most of education, in underfunded and more or less broken. It does feel like such a stitch up though, a weird kind of bait and switch. Because people on the outside will say ‘wow! You get free transport to a special school for your disabled DC. That’s extraordinary! That’s so generous!’ Especially people from elsewhere in Europe. And the you feel like an ingrate for complaining at all. “My child has the opportunity to go to school after all! The transport is free! How could I be upset about that?!” When the truth is, the provision maybe available, it may be free, but that doesn’t mean it’s actually safely meeting the child’s needs.

OP posts:
dontbenastyhaveapasty · 13/10/2023 17:00

Everything local authorities do is hopelessly underfunded, thanks to 14 years of central gov cutting budgets. I totally understand that SEN provision is hopeless and inadequate, and that has knock-on impacts such as the need to transport children long distances.

But, perhaps better funding for SEN transport might be possible if parents of non-SEN children were expected to step up and take responsibility for getting their kids to school?

fearfuloffluff · 13/10/2023 16:51

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

I think op is talking about SEN transport. SEN schools have much bigger catchment areas and it's not so simple to move, especially if you have other kids in other schools.

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:50

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 16:30

The solution is small specialist schools in every town, rather than huge ones hours away. That’s what would help our children. That’s what would keep the. Part of our communities and seen. That’s what would save them 10plus hours a week on top of school travelling. That’s what would help @RISHI.

that's a better way to express what I was also trying to say!

fearfuloffluff · 13/10/2023 16:50

It's mad. I went to a Catholic school in the 90s with a large catchment area, council used to provide transport for free.

I know kids who go to the same school from the same town now. First council reduced funding, then cut it so parents would pay the whole cost (making the school de facto less inclusive).

Then council said they not only wouldn't fund it, they wouldn't manage the coach contract. No parent wanted to take that on so what had been a coach load of children turned into about 20 extra cars on the road, impacting parents' ability to work etc.

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

Spendonsend · 13/10/2023 16:49

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

School transport exists for all children, not just sen children, if their nearest suitable school is over a certain distance. Rurally lots of children are on a school bus/coach.

Its just for sen children that is more likely to happen as there are less SEN schools and they also have a cant walk/use public transport extra category that might apply.

The reason it ends up taxis is you dont get a whole coach load from one village travelling to the school as SEN is more spread out.

Its very unlikely picking a specialist sport of music school would be considered the closest suitable school as suitable doesnt mean 'best' it means adequete. Very often the closest mainstream would mean no education for a child with sen, wheras for someone good at music it would still provide a normal education just not stretch in one area. Which isnt a basic right in the same way.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 16:48

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 16:30

The solution is small specialist schools in every town, rather than huge ones hours away. That’s what would help our children. That’s what would keep the. Part of our communities and seen. That’s what would save them 10plus hours a week on top of school travelling. That’s what would help @RISHI.

I’m inclined to agree with this

OP posts:
Bobbybobbins · 13/10/2023 16:47

I have two children in different special schools. We used to go transport ourselves when we just had one child in school- this involved 2 hour long round trips every day. Now it is impossible so we are lucky to have fairly functional transport from the LEA.

I would love to be able to take my kids to school and for them to go to mainstream school. Try putting yourself in the position of parents with disabled children.

Bellasbeau · 13/10/2023 16:45

I chose to live within walking distance of outstanding schools, I chose to live within walking distance of a train station to make commuting easy.

I didn’t choose to have a disabled child. I didn’t choose for the nearest suitable school to be 30+ miles away.
Our situations are completely different as with a disabled child the element of choice is taken away.

OhmygodDont · 13/10/2023 16:44

We fortunately have a couple or primary’s and secondary’s here and a half decent bus service so I do think those parents should be getting their own children to school. Especially when they then move further away from the school.

Some of the behaviour however my friends child had witnessed on the little minibus is terrible. The police have had to be called out multiple times and then mum kicked off because the minibus drivers refused to pick up that child as it wasn’t safe. They even gave the parent and child free bus passes to use, continued to kick off till the bus company backed down. Second pick up child assaulted the supervisor adult and two children. Child now has to go in a taxi with parent and parent is still kicking off because she has to go as supervisor as the taxi staff wouldn’t take her alone due to threats.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 13/10/2023 16:37

To be honest, I think it’s a parent’s responsibility to get their child to school, and it shouldn’t be the responsibility of the local authority at all.

Sure, there will be some special circumstances where it is appropriate for LA support to be given. But perhaps that support should be an enlarged Motability type funding programme, rather than coming out of the education support budget.

As someone who lives in a rural area, I really think it’s on me as a parent to work out (and pay for) how to get my kids to school, just as it’s on me to get myself to work. If I can’t get my kids to school because I live too far away, or work commitments make it difficult, that is my responsibility as a parent to resolve, not anyone else’s job.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 16:35

Thanks @SENteacher12 - I haven’t seen it from your perspective but I would have guessed that’s what it looked like. Scary thought.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 16:32

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

I guess that depends. If the only possible space in a suitable school is a 90 minute round trip, should that be the parents’ responsibility? Maybe if it’s a private school or a conservatoire or a space that represents a meaningful choice of some sort? But just an accident of birth that means the child has a disability and the provision is scant? Should the family be disadvantaged or impoverished for something that they didn’t choose? And no, before it’s suggested, not all disabilities, not even all congenital ones, are identifiable in utero.

OP posts:
Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 16:30

The solution is small specialist schools in every town, rather than huge ones hours away. That’s what would help our children. That’s what would keep the. Part of our communities and seen. That’s what would save them 10plus hours a week on top of school travelling. That’s what would help @RISHI.

ohtowinthelottery · 13/10/2023 16:26

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

@SacAMain My DD started at nursery based at an SEN school at the age of 2 1/2. It was 15 miles away - there were no other options. Thankfully back in the day the LA provided the transport and continued to do so through school and 6th form until she was 19.
Our DS (2 years younger) went to the local nursery and primary school. It would have been impossible to get DD to nursery/school (a 30 mile round trip and DS to the local nursery/school. I had no family to help out and as he was later diagnosed with ASD, expecting someone else to take him was not a option. I suppose my DH could always have given up work - like I'd already had to do - and we could have claimed benefits and lived off the state instead!

DrumKittyKat · 13/10/2023 16:24

ladykale · 13/10/2023 16:04

@Bellasbeau but what are you suggesting as an alternative? Due to your children's needs they have to go to a special school.

Surely parents should be happy that they aren't left footing the full bill for transport to and from school?

It would be the same if a parents chose a specialist school for their child, like a special music or drama school, they would have to make appropriate arrangements...

The special school is not a ‘choice’ for those parents. It is a necessity.

I am sure they would love an appropriate school on their doorstep.

PickAChew · 13/10/2023 16:22

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

At one point I had one child in a specialist school 50 miles away and another in a different special school 10 miles in another direction. These were their closest suitable schoolsfor their respective needs. How was I supposed to get them to school myself?

Samcro · 13/10/2023 16:17

there was only one school that would meet my dc needs, it was miles away. so I then had to take her there and back till she was 5. school transport was a nightmare until she was a teen and got a taxi as she was then the only child in our area going there . that was brilliant.

you can not compare sen schools to "It would be the same if a parents chose a specialist school for their child, like a special music or drama school, they would have to make appropriate arrangements..."
to do so is ableist in the extreme.

BlueIgIoo · 13/10/2023 16:12

BCCoach · 13/10/2023 16:08

@PuttingDownRoots I'm aware that lots of areas do, but the network is often extremely flakey and often only links bigger villages together. In the US (although I imagine it varies by school district) school buses pick up every child who goes to a specific school, either from their home, or from a common pick up point if there are several children living in the same area. There are literally dozens of taxis queueing to drop off at our secondary every morning, most of them with only one child in, and all paid for by the LA. It's insane.

This is exactly the case in areas like rural Scotland and I'm sure some others. You don't travel to the nearest village - the bus stops outside your house to pick you up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread