Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about school transport

117 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 08:36

I’m thinking mostly about transport for pupils with disabilities- though I recognise the provision is poor all around. The fact that some counties refuse to transport the littlest reception children on the grounds that school is not compulsory, for instance, is just mean, stingy accounting at the expense of tiny children.

I’m thinking about the unreliability, about the sudden calls in the morning to say ‘no transport today’ which could leave a child stuck at home. And these are children who really can’t afford to miss a day at school, or who have a breakdown at the prospect of missing a day.

I’m thinking about the massive pressure to not be a minute late for meeting transport, applied to kids who actually deserve a medal for facing up to school at all, or to kids who have already gone through three changes of clothes and two showers trying to get ready for a 7am pick up.

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

I’m thinking about the contracts that say that involuntary behaviour, if deemed unacceptable, is cause to terminate transport arrangements. Honestly that’s not very different from saying if a baby’s crying is distressing you’ll stop feeding it.

Sigh.

OP posts:
x2boys · 14/10/2023 10:56

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

You have no clue do you🙄🙄
I didn't choose to have a disabled child I didn't choose what school.to.send him to the LEA choose the school.that could best meet his needs which is a,special school for children with severe and profound learning disabilities.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 10:54

Jakadaal · 13/10/2023 23:42

I've been through this OP and it is a minefield especially when trying to get your child to school and you to work or wherever you need to be. I found building a good relationship with both the transport company and the transport dept in the local LA was really helpful

It is a minefield. I’d appreciate any tips on how to build a good relationship in either department! Our council transport team are often friendly enough on the phone but never take the actions they promise. Then if you call and say ‘why’ they are full of excuses but still don’t do it. If you take a firm tone and say it’s ‘unacceptable’ or if you get upset and say ‘we’re desperate it needs to be sorted’ they say you sound ‘angry’ which is verbally abusive and so they terminate the call and still don’t do it…

Transport companies have been variable. Our current one is great but others have been opaque or downright unkind.

OP posts:
x2boys · 14/10/2023 10:50

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

How do you imagine that will work if you have two kids in teo.different schools
My don has always gone to.a special school ,I can't just decide to send him to the nearest school as his needs are very complex
When he and my oldest son were both in primary school the schools were several miles apart and they both had to be there at the same time
Luckily he's always been provided with transport ,but can you imagine trying to get two children too two different schools miles apart at the same time?

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 10:43

Heaviestdirtyestsoul · 13/10/2023 23:22

I think I needed this thread tonight, currently awaiting news on transport for DS10 (SEN) who, because of a change to his needs now requires an emergency health care plan. He has been off school 3 weeks so far, the school is being exceptionally wonderful- as always, making sure everybody was on the same page about my sons needs and care plan, all the chasing up paperwork and adjusting EHCP, the phone calls to anybody involved with looking after, treating or transportation of him. Kept me in the loop throughout- only to hit a blank wall with transport. Nearly 2 and a half hours each school day spent on transport, and without a medically trained escourt he can't be on the bus due to possibly needing emergency medication. Transport told school that it could take up to 4 months to sort, can I just okay it for him to come and if anything happens they will call an ambulance. I asked transport what the plan was, I was told its not their job to provide a medically trained escourt and I had to call the council. The company we had last year were good, steady, safe and agreeable, but the company this year have already changed both staff twice without notice, are unreliable and do not seem warm or friendly with the children. And now this, I don't drive and its the nearest school in our catchment ( there is a nearer school but under a different council so was rejected).

I am so sorry @Heaviestdirtyestsoul that is awful. Have you tried speaking to your MP? Getting your son’s consultant ti write a stern letter if he would? I can’t imagine either would sway my council but I’m not sure what else you could try. Sending you so much sympathy and ‘permission’ to rant about it as much as you like.

OP posts:
flustereddriver75 · 14/10/2023 07:08

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 16:30

The solution is small specialist schools in every town, rather than huge ones hours away. That’s what would help our children. That’s what would keep the. Part of our communities and seen. That’s what would save them 10plus hours a week on top of school travelling. That’s what would help @RISHI.

I'd go further than that, every school or small group of local schools have a SEND base attached so that pupils can go to a local school and still get the support that they need.
Op I completely agree with your concern having spent most of the day dealing with the fall out of children with behaviours associated with their SEND being left dysregulated and in danger/a danger to others as a result.
The main issue for us is that escorts are poorly paid, completely untrained and unwilling to use any strategies to manage behaviour.
They expect the kids to sit quietly and stare out of the window and if they don't do that the escorts shout at them...then down the track the escorts complain to us that the kids are unmanageable on the bus, the parents complain that their kids are crying about the bus, the kids behaviour deteriorates in school and we have little to no power to fix any of it.
It's incredibly frustrating.

Hatty65 · 14/10/2023 00:54

School transport round here (v rural) is crap. The minute you get over 16 you have to pay. Our nearest school is 7 miles away and DS was at it from Y7 to Y13. There was literally nowhere nearer that he could have gone - and so he had to get a bus.

For the whole of Y12 and Y13 we were expected to pay £570 per year. That's a lot of money for most families - particularly as he HAD to be in education. If he'd gone to 6th form college the nearest one is 35 miles away - and would have cost an awful lot more.

Sweetaschocolate · 14/10/2023 00:17

I must admit the sen transport for my son has mostly been amazing.
They always text if they are running late there or back (don't happen to often).
I text them if there is a problem my end as well so having that communication is important.

I do get I'm lucky (or should I say this is how it should for all children).

Heaviestdirtyestsoul · 13/10/2023 23:58

@passepartoute you utter minefield of wonderful knowledge, thank you! my to do list on Monday is this- very grateful

Jakadaal · 13/10/2023 23:42

I've been through this OP and it is a minefield especially when trying to get your child to school and you to work or wherever you need to be. I found building a good relationship with both the transport company and the transport dept in the local LA was really helpful

Passepartoute · 13/10/2023 23:42

Heaviestdirtyestsoul · 13/10/2023 23:22

I think I needed this thread tonight, currently awaiting news on transport for DS10 (SEN) who, because of a change to his needs now requires an emergency health care plan. He has been off school 3 weeks so far, the school is being exceptionally wonderful- as always, making sure everybody was on the same page about my sons needs and care plan, all the chasing up paperwork and adjusting EHCP, the phone calls to anybody involved with looking after, treating or transportation of him. Kept me in the loop throughout- only to hit a blank wall with transport. Nearly 2 and a half hours each school day spent on transport, and without a medically trained escourt he can't be on the bus due to possibly needing emergency medication. Transport told school that it could take up to 4 months to sort, can I just okay it for him to come and if anything happens they will call an ambulance. I asked transport what the plan was, I was told its not their job to provide a medically trained escourt and I had to call the council. The company we had last year were good, steady, safe and agreeable, but the company this year have already changed both staff twice without notice, are unreliable and do not seem warm or friendly with the children. And now this, I don't drive and its the nearest school in our catchment ( there is a nearer school but under a different council so was rejected).

Have you entered an appeal against their failure to arrange safe transport? You should also point out to the SEN department that if your child can't get to school because of this failure, they will also be in breach of their duty to ensure that his SEN are met and that he receives full time education. You could also ask SOS SEN to organise a formal pre-action letter threatening judicial review action.
https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review/

Can I seek judicial review?

https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review/

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 13/10/2023 23:34

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 13/10/2023 16:37

To be honest, I think it’s a parent’s responsibility to get their child to school, and it shouldn’t be the responsibility of the local authority at all.

Sure, there will be some special circumstances where it is appropriate for LA support to be given. But perhaps that support should be an enlarged Motability type funding programme, rather than coming out of the education support budget.

As someone who lives in a rural area, I really think it’s on me as a parent to work out (and pay for) how to get my kids to school, just as it’s on me to get myself to work. If I can’t get my kids to school because I live too far away, or work commitments make it difficult, that is my responsibility as a parent to resolve, not anyone else’s job.

The nearest school that could accept my DD's wheelchair is 35 minutes drive away. The one opposite my house has no classrooms on a groundfloor level and no lift facilities. She could get to the school office, the gym hall and the dining hall, but nowhere else.

The nearest school that can cope with her needs, and had space, in 50 minutes away in morning traffic. She passes 3 other nearer schools on the way. Why should that be my responsibility to get her there when I'm not the one that built a school with no accessible classrooms?

saraclara · 13/10/2023 23:28

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

Children who attend special schools (often a distance away) often have siblings attending their local schools. Which child/children is the parent supposed to take to school?

funbags3 · 13/10/2023 23:24

@SacAMain
My daughter has DS. The only school that would accept her is 1 hr away by car.
Most children are able to go to the catchment school, which is usually close by.
Would I love my child to be able to go to mainstream like her peers? Of course I would but I do not have that choice.
We are also rural and there's also a bus put on for non-sen students.

Heaviestdirtyestsoul · 13/10/2023 23:22

I think I needed this thread tonight, currently awaiting news on transport for DS10 (SEN) who, because of a change to his needs now requires an emergency health care plan. He has been off school 3 weeks so far, the school is being exceptionally wonderful- as always, making sure everybody was on the same page about my sons needs and care plan, all the chasing up paperwork and adjusting EHCP, the phone calls to anybody involved with looking after, treating or transportation of him. Kept me in the loop throughout- only to hit a blank wall with transport. Nearly 2 and a half hours each school day spent on transport, and without a medically trained escourt he can't be on the bus due to possibly needing emergency medication. Transport told school that it could take up to 4 months to sort, can I just okay it for him to come and if anything happens they will call an ambulance. I asked transport what the plan was, I was told its not their job to provide a medically trained escourt and I had to call the council. The company we had last year were good, steady, safe and agreeable, but the company this year have already changed both staff twice without notice, are unreliable and do not seem warm or friendly with the children. And now this, I don't drive and its the nearest school in our catchment ( there is a nearer school but under a different council so was rejected).

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 22:49

I think it’s totally unacceptable for children to spend 3 hours a day in a taxi 5 days a week. Most adults would struggle with that commute. These are our most vulnerable children. The weakest and most disadvantaged. And who will help us? We are the ones up hours before school to “make it work” and who deal with the aftermath for hours after school.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 22:18

Passepartoute · 13/10/2023 19:43

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

Unless that is unavoidable (which is unlikely) any council that has transport arrangements that entail children spending 3-4 hours a day travelling to and from school is acting unlawfully. The statutory guidance says that the maximum journey time for primary aged children should be 45 minutes each way, and for secondary aged 75 minutes each way.

Longer journeys tend to happen when councils make children share minibuses or taxis, and arrange long journeys picking them up and dropping them off. If that takes them over the maximum time limits, they should split the route and put two vehicles onto it.

My understanding was that, unfortunately, the recommended maximum journey times are merely recommendations and thus not unlawful if the council can claim that a particular journey length is unavoidable. At any rate, I got no joy when my primary aged child had a 90 minute journey plus a 75-90 minute return journey, even though the other passengers were secondary aged and the pick up order could have been reversed to mostly solve the problem.

I also had the council prefer to give my child a 90+ minute return journey so that the other passenger’s journey was kept to 40 minutes, rather than give my child a 30-35 minute journey and the other passenger 45-50 minutes, which would have been a shorter route overall. 10 minutes’ gain for one child at the expense of nearly an hour lost to the other 🤷‍♀️

Perhaps our council is just exceptionally bad at this.

OP posts:
Lougle · 13/10/2023 20:02

Last year was awful for us. I had DD1 in a special college 12 miles away. I had DD2 in a special school 20 miles away, but in the opposite direction. The transport for DD1 was unsafe but the LA couldn't offer safe transport. They wouldn't take DD2 because she was too anxious to attend full time.

The LA's 'solution' was to give me a mileage allowance. The fact that it meant that I was driving for 5 hours per day, didn't matter to them.

Passepartoute · 13/10/2023 19:43

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

Unless that is unavoidable (which is unlikely) any council that has transport arrangements that entail children spending 3-4 hours a day travelling to and from school is acting unlawfully. The statutory guidance says that the maximum journey time for primary aged children should be 45 minutes each way, and for secondary aged 75 minutes each way.

Longer journeys tend to happen when councils make children share minibuses or taxis, and arrange long journeys picking them up and dropping them off. If that takes them over the maximum time limits, they should split the route and put two vehicles onto it.

SpudleyLass · 13/10/2023 19:32

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

I did move. Back to my home county for more family support and more SEN schools generally. The school is still out of county.

Making more expensive choices just to get 1 school that can meet needs which will even offer her a place is in no way the same as parents of NT children moving to be in the catchment area of a school considered advantageous for NT children. It just isn't.

It was also the LA who approached my DD's school and consulted with them, therefore absolutely it's on them to sort transport. Of course I'm grateful but my preference, funnily enough, would have been to do the school run myself. It just isn't feasible.

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 18:12

wizzywig · 13/10/2023 18:00

We're supposed to be grateful for the crumbs we get. It's shocking. No way would parents in mainstream school put up with this

have you seen the state of the "mainstream" education? What funding do you think exist today, having a qualified teacher is becoming a luxury.

"mainstream" gets the same crumbs.

It's not an excuse, but it's not a suitable or acceptable situation for anyone.

firef1y · 13/10/2023 18:08

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

My son is in a special school, it's an hour drive to get there, he has a younger brother in the local mainstream. It's not my fault that the only suitable school involves 4hours of driving. I cam drive if necessary, but would literally be spending half my day going back and forth and would have no-one to take the younger child to/from school

FloweryName · 13/10/2023 18:06

There are a lot of problems with school transport for children at special schools but I don’t think everything you’ve said is entirely fair.

They have to try and make sure the children are on time for pick up because they often have more than one child to collect, it’s not fair to keep others waiting, especially if their disability makes waiting difficult. The escorts don’t get paid overtime if they work extra hours to cover lateness.

It’s also fair if unacceptable behaviour, even if involuntary, means that a contract has to be terminated. The safety of the other people in the bus or taxi has to take priority over anything else.

wizzywig · 13/10/2023 18:00

We're supposed to be grateful for the crumbs we get. It's shocking. No way would parents in mainstream school put up with this

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 17:55

Flufferblub · 13/10/2023 17:16

I didn't realise this was a widespread issue. We've had problems with the school transport this year. The bus of kids doesn't get to school until 9.30, so they've been missing their first lessons since September. There are too many kids on each bus, and some children are on the bus for 5 hours a day. It's really not acceptable for children with SEN to have to endure sitting on school transport for that amount of time, and arrive to school late every day. I've written to the council and the MP. I don't know what more I can do.

I’m so sorry to hear that @Flufferblub, it’s really not ok for kids who are going to struggle more to access education anyway to be subjected to the extra fatigue of a journey like that and to be missing lessons. I hope you get a useful reply.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 13/10/2023 17:32

Local authority budgets are stretched, there is usually an obligation to go for the cheapest tender, and driving be it a taxi, bus or indeed a lorry is not seen as a high value career. Indeed it's probably a second or even lower choice for those who do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread