Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about school transport

117 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 08:36

I’m thinking mostly about transport for pupils with disabilities- though I recognise the provision is poor all around. The fact that some counties refuse to transport the littlest reception children on the grounds that school is not compulsory, for instance, is just mean, stingy accounting at the expense of tiny children.

I’m thinking about the unreliability, about the sudden calls in the morning to say ‘no transport today’ which could leave a child stuck at home. And these are children who really can’t afford to miss a day at school, or who have a breakdown at the prospect of missing a day.

I’m thinking about the massive pressure to not be a minute late for meeting transport, applied to kids who actually deserve a medal for facing up to school at all, or to kids who have already gone through three changes of clothes and two showers trying to get ready for a 7am pick up.

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

I’m thinking about the contracts that say that involuntary behaviour, if deemed unacceptable, is cause to terminate transport arrangements. Honestly that’s not very different from saying if a baby’s crying is distressing you’ll stop feeding it.

Sigh.

OP posts:
Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 14:43

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:15

you seem to be totally unaware that it's just not the case in many places!
Tell our local parents that they should just wait for their free transport because they are more than 3 miles away 😂

Expectation or not, if you don't like or find a suitable school, you move, that's what we all had to do.

The law applies equally throughout England, with very similar provisions for Wales. If your local council isn't complying with the law, then local parents should take them to court. It's relatively easy, given that this relates to their children's rights and they would therefore get legal aid in their children's names. It's amazing what councils discover they can do when faced with a court order.

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 14:41

Quite, @Spendonsend , while in SEN world, especially were complex needs are involved, it's as much a case of a school agreeing that they have the resources for your child. The schools that might be suitable aren't a mile or two apart, they're often 10 miles apart. Or even the only one in a county. Or over several counties....

When I first viewed schools for Ds2, I visited one that was perfect on paper. In reality, the atmosphere was hushed and tense, with a high proportion of highly sensitive children in need of minimal stimulation. Ds2 is loud and bouncy and needs to move a lot. His presence there would have been disastrous for those kids and, inevitably, for him.

Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 14:38

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

Actually, your taxes do pay for the home to school transport system, because that is the law.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 14/10/2023 14:36

Here it’s a free bus pass if you’re more than three miles away IF it’s your nearest school.

Spendonsend · 14/10/2023 14:23

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:15

you seem to be totally unaware that it's just not the case in many places!
Tell our local parents that they should just wait for their free transport because they are more than 3 miles away 😂

Expectation or not, if you don't like or find a suitable school, you move, that's what we all had to do.

Does you area genuinley not have school buses or special bus passess to the closest suitable school if it is more than 3 miles. Suitable meaning a requires improvement comp not suitable as in you think its the nicest or better school in someway.

ChunkyMonkey2020 · 14/10/2023 14:18

Wow. Some of these stories are horrific and make me realise how lucky we are.

My child is currently in transport.

Her driver and PA are wonderful at keeping us updated on when they will be arriving.

She's in a mini bus with 4 other children.

Never had any issues at all with it.

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 14:16

Some challenges are bigger than others. Few parents have to provide basic personal care for their teenagers who are unable to articulate their wants and needs or make their own way to the local secondary school, whether OFSTED outstanding or otherwise. You have not taken in anything anyone has said to you, though and I am quite sure that you never intend to.

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:15

Spendonsend · 14/10/2023 14:09

You seem to be totally unaware that your tax has always paid for children to be transported to their closest suitable school if it is more than 3 miles away. There has never been an expectation for parents to move close to schools. There isnt even enough houses close to schools and people need to do rural jobs and jobs in certain locations like hospitals that arent always next to a school.

you seem to be totally unaware that it's just not the case in many places!
Tell our local parents that they should just wait for their free transport because they are more than 3 miles away 😂

Expectation or not, if you don't like or find a suitable school, you move, that's what we all had to do.

Spendonsend · 14/10/2023 14:09

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:01

where did I say it was a CHOICE? It's a fact, my tax pay for free education.

You could argue that parents should have a choice of school, which they don't. We need to move to be near a school we find suitable, or even have space.

It's also a fact that my tax don't pay for transport, for uniform or anything that's not education.

My tax don't even pay for resources, playgrounds, enrichment. That's what parents have to fundraise for.

The majority makes the choice, we vote and we only win when most people agree with us.

You seem to be totally unaware that your tax has always paid for children to be transported to their closest suitable school if it is more than 3 miles away. There has never been an expectation for parents to move close to schools. There isnt even enough houses close to schools and people need to do rural jobs and jobs in certain locations like hospitals that arent always next to a school.

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:07

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 13:44

Well some of our kids won't be getting that education , paid for by our taxes as well as yours, if they can't get to a school that they can actually learn something at.

Or do you consider some children to be more deserving of even a basic education than others?

In an ideal world, we would all have a school in our catchment that fits our needs and preferences. It's so far from the case, and ALL parents are met with a choice unfortunately.

It's not about what the children deserve, no one said it was a fair system and it's not fair to have to relocate to give our children the best we can afford. It's simply the reality, but it's the same reality for everyone.

You just cannot say an entire group is targeted or put aside while the rest is breezing through, whatever the reason and needs, all parents face their own challenges.

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 14:01

x2boys · 14/10/2023 12:37

You don't get to choose what your tax pays for

where did I say it was a CHOICE? It's a fact, my tax pay for free education.

You could argue that parents should have a choice of school, which they don't. We need to move to be near a school we find suitable, or even have space.

It's also a fact that my tax don't pay for transport, for uniform or anything that's not education.

My tax don't even pay for resources, playgrounds, enrichment. That's what parents have to fundraise for.

The majority makes the choice, we vote and we only win when most people agree with us.

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 13:44

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

Well some of our kids won't be getting that education , paid for by our taxes as well as yours, if they can't get to a school that they can actually learn something at.

Or do you consider some children to be more deserving of even a basic education than others?

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 13:37

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 10:54

It is a minefield. I’d appreciate any tips on how to build a good relationship in either department! Our council transport team are often friendly enough on the phone but never take the actions they promise. Then if you call and say ‘why’ they are full of excuses but still don’t do it. If you take a firm tone and say it’s ‘unacceptable’ or if you get upset and say ‘we’re desperate it needs to be sorted’ they say you sound ‘angry’ which is verbally abusive and so they terminate the call and still don’t do it…

Transport companies have been variable. Our current one is great but others have been opaque or downright unkind.

I always communicate by email. If it's not in writing, it never happened. <-- golden rule!

More smaller SEN units is a good model for many kids with SEN but still falls down for kids with more complex needs. Ds2 doesn't not go to the local special school because the school itself is full. He goes elsewhere because their very limited discrete autism provision was full. His school is one of the biggest SEN schools in the country and, as such, with about 15% of their intake having complex needs and/or PMLD is currently able to provide 4 such classes, just for secondary age (separate from the PMLD provision) each with about 5 or 6 kids and 3 full time staff.

Swg · 14/10/2023 13:22

It doesn’t get easier if it’s the parent with disabilities either. I’m currently trying to work out my son’s secondary school options. There’s two options with buses where he could walk to the stop but we’re at the edge of catchment for those buses and may not get in (in one case this is literally an issue of our house just edging over county lines - a street away and we would be in the next county and it would be fine).

The other school is excellent and I would love him to go - but it’s a ten minute car ride to the closest bus stop. No problems with that when I can do it but I needed three operations last year and all had a mandatory no driving period after. And as I discovered then most taxis won’t carry unaccompanied kids and anywhere near school drop off they’re all booked out by schools anyway. Our school offered no help ; I ended up paying a childminder literally to pick them up and drop them at breakfast club (and paying for breakfast club) . If I hadn’t been able to afford that I don’t know what I would have done.

And no I can’t ask a partner or family. I’m a widow with cancer and family doesn’t live close enough to do daily drop offs. Current house was purchased before widowhood and cancer. If we get into school 3 and I need another op I think we might just be fucked.

“it’s the parents job to work out” only works if there is actually a feasible option available.

londonmummy1966 · 14/10/2023 13:21

It would be the same if a parents chose a specialist school for their child, like a special music or drama school, they would have to make appropriate arrangements...

THis is not a comparator as there are hardly any schools in the MDF scheme so most going to these schools board so the transport requirements are only at Exeat weekends and the DC who get places are highly driven and intelligent individuals - not children with severe SEN difficulties.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 14/10/2023 13:00

Councils mostly provide statutory transport only now, if children are eligible, and often it is more cost-effective to provide petrol money.
Do you understand that this usually means one parent cannot work?

LoreleiG · 14/10/2023 12:54

School transport has been hit by all the same funding cuts as every other public service though, thanks for Osborne’s austerity measures. Councils mostly provide statutory transport only now, if children are eligible, and often it is more cost-effective to provide petrol money. There are many challenges to putting contracts in place such as nobody bidding for work, driver shortages, etc. Not saying it isn’t crap but it’s not all councils’ fault. Definitely write to your MP.

gotomomo · 14/10/2023 12:54

@Zzizzisnotzeproblem

You can't have a suitable school for every child in every town because needs are so diverse. My dd was recommended to a autism unit because she was struggling in mainstream but no way could she cope with the noise and violence from the other pupils - we fought and won specialist provision within mainstream school, the first student they had with this arrangement, and only worked because she was self motivated and happy to be at the back of the school office

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 14/10/2023 12:43

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.
and my child has never been to a sports tournament, can no longer have swimming lessons (private) because the local leisure centres don’t provide a disabled swimming session any more, and hasn’t done any non school ground activity for 7 years. In fact he didnt have a school for large parts of his education, and NO we are not some mythical slobs who can’t be arsed to get out of bed for school. In fact my other children are extremely successful academically. It’s NOT the case that we did it wrong, or are arsey, or lazy, or feckless. What happened is one of my children didn’t learn to talk for years and needs constant supervision to keep him safe. There’s no reason for that and it’s nothing we or he did or failed to do.

x2boys · 14/10/2023 12:37

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

You don't get to choose what your tax pays for

SpudleyLass · 14/10/2023 12:30

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

My husband's taxes pay for education too but our DD has been out of school since last December through no fault of our own.

Transport for SEN children has nothing to do with non school activities and everything to do with getting them the education that they have a right to.

Not investing in SEN children will just lead to a sizeable demographic who might have been lead relatively independent lives had they just gotten the same investment as NT kids

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 11:49

If it's all the parents' responsibility, I do hope that school you moved next to is an independent one? Otherwise you are dumping your children's education onto an LA or a state-funded academy to sort for you.

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

Passepartoute · 14/10/2023 11:49

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

If it's all the parents' responsibility, I do hope that school you moved next to is an independent one? Otherwise you are dumping your children's education onto an LA or a state-funded academy to sort for you.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 14/10/2023 11:44

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 16:49

Some of us had to MOVE to be next to a school we deemed suitable. It's not ideal, it's not cheap, but that's what being a parent means.

You could argue that children living in the wrong catchment are hugely disadvantaged not to have access to the top school either.

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

We could argue about having suitable schools accessible closer, or to have school transport for everyone, that's true.

This is so obtuse. This sentence particularly galling

I still think it's the parents responsibility, you can't dump everything on the LA to sort it for you.

What do you think I CAN reasonably expect from the LA for my child?

To be safe?
An education?
Access to dentists and healthcare?

Because NONE of that is automatic for my disabled child. My child was both numerate and literate in reception, but I have had to stand up in meetings with the LA to force them to provide maths and English lessons. How dare you sit there hogging the fucking resources my taxes pay for suggesting ANYONE with a disabled child is able to dump anything on the LA or anyone else? You should be ashamed of yourself and your “let them eat cake” attitude. WAKE UP.

Dibblydoodahdah · 14/10/2023 11:05

School transport is absolutely shocking in this country. On a recent trip to New York we were most bemused by the yellow buses dropping kids off in Manhattan at their different apartment buildings. Yes, we’d seen them in other parts of the US but we were not expecting it in a city with a subway system! We live in a rural area. The only school bus goes to the nearest school which is seven miles away but my DS1 goes to the state grammar eight miles in the other direction. There is no bus whatsoever, not even a public bus as that doesn’t start until 9.00am so we have no option but to drive him. It’s our biggest use of the car. A proper school bus system would be the easiest way to get cars off the road and would be far better for the environment.

We are currently applying for DS2’s secondary school place. He won’t be going to the grammar because it is super selective and we knew he wasn’t strong enough academically to have a chance of getting in. We would like to send him to the nearest Catholic comp (he’s at a Catholic primary school). But there’s no school bus to that school, although there is a bus to a different secondary school in the same town but he can’t get into that school because he didn’t go to our local state primary which is a feeder school for that secondary. We would have to drive him to a different village 15 minutes away to get on that school bus despite the fact that there is another school bus going from our village to that town. Unfortunately the Catholic school is a 30 min walk away from the other secondary school so he wouldn’t get to school on time if he took that bus. It’s a farce!