Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about school transport

117 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 13/10/2023 08:36

I’m thinking mostly about transport for pupils with disabilities- though I recognise the provision is poor all around. The fact that some counties refuse to transport the littlest reception children on the grounds that school is not compulsory, for instance, is just mean, stingy accounting at the expense of tiny children.

I’m thinking about the unreliability, about the sudden calls in the morning to say ‘no transport today’ which could leave a child stuck at home. And these are children who really can’t afford to miss a day at school, or who have a breakdown at the prospect of missing a day.

I’m thinking about the massive pressure to not be a minute late for meeting transport, applied to kids who actually deserve a medal for facing up to school at all, or to kids who have already gone through three changes of clothes and two showers trying to get ready for a 7am pick up.

Im thinking about kids spending 3-4 hours a day on transport just to get to and from school.

I’m thinking about the contracts that say that involuntary behaviour, if deemed unacceptable, is cause to terminate transport arrangements. Honestly that’s not very different from saying if a baby’s crying is distressing you’ll stop feeding it.

Sigh.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Passepartoute · 19/10/2023 15:55

Good luck, OP, I hope that works!

BestOfTimesBlurstOfTimes · 19/10/2023 15:14

Passepartoute · 16/10/2023 17:29

You need to contact the transport department and the SEN department and point out that this is unlawful and directly in breach of statutory guidance. If possible, give them a full day-by-day breakdown of what has been going on. Ask them to respond to you within a week with their detailed plans for ensuring that they do comply with the law by having a reliable and safe transport arrangement in place, failing which you will have to consider judicial review action to protect your son's rights.

Also point out to the SEN department that if, as seems likely, this failure means that your son can no longer get to school, they will be in breach of their duty to ensure that he receives full time education and special educational provision, and they too will be potentially in the firing line for judicial review.

https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review/

Thanks so much for your advice @Passepartoute, I’ve emailed the SEN Transport dept and outlined what you’ve said. I’ve also contacted my MP about the lack of reply from the LA on the matter. Finger crossed something happens now!

Caffeinequeen91 · 16/10/2023 21:58

@SahliJ believe me I am not blaming LAs. It’s a ridiculous system that allows half of the high needs budget to be spent on transport not education and other support.

SahliJ · 16/10/2023 21:35

Caffeinequeen91 · 13/10/2023 16:00

And yet LAs pay a staggering sum for this transport. I know one LA where it’s half of their high needs budget. Half spent on transport not education. Bonkers.

Not a decision the LA want to make either. Budgets to LA’s are being slashed year on year by the Tory gov.

The system is broken. Too few special school places. Nothing local. Increasingly high needs pupils. LA are responsible for educating a child. LA’s can not open new schools, only Academy trusts can. Budgets are not enough to provide specialist schools ( so Academy trusts cannot take the risk). Existing special school budget are in massive deficit. ( near to £900,000) per school in my LA) and rising.
Tribunals find in favour of the SEND child. LA has to fund a place - sometimes in excess of £120,000 per year, per child, plus travel.

Bus companies and taxi companies are seeing all costs rising. Passed on to the LA. Such companies struggle to recruit. We've had bus companies go bust, leaving massive gaps in transport.

Adults are unwilling to work as transport escorts, hours aren't great - an hour each end of everyday.
My Eastern European travel escorts left due to Brexit. The LA is bringing in staff from India, who are willing to commit to the working hours.

Absolute mess by central government. My LA has another £5.5 million to save in Children’s Services alone, this year, AGAIN.

Please don't blame LA’s.

YomAsalYomBasal · 16/10/2023 21:22

Wow, I didn't realise there were people out there who resented my daughter being given transport to get to school. Yet it seems there are quite a few.
I live next to a school. Literally right next door. But they wouldn't take my child. Neither would the special school in the neighbouring town. Therefore she travels 40 minutes away to get to the only school that could accept her. I would love, LOVE for the school right next to me to have the resources to educate her along with her siblings, but they don't. So she has to travel on this bus while I take her siblings to school. This is not a lifestyle choice ffs.

PickAChew · 16/10/2023 21:07

In ds2's case, a behavioural issue was caused by the escort shouting at him. Thank goodness for his echolalia so we soon realised why he was acting up at home.

FloweryName · 16/10/2023 20:10

@AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman

I think the kind of flexibility I would like is pretty minimal and reciprocal e.g. if you are given a pick up time of 7:45 to 7:55 and the taxi might arrive anywhere in that window, it should be equally acceptable for the child to be ready anywhere in that window.

In theory that should be a reasonable expectation, but throw in two or three other children with varying disabilities and levels of tolerance for waiting and that could be adding 30 minutes to a journey that is already too long.

I agree that it is necessary for the driver and passangers to be safe, but the principle of penalising involuntary behaviour is really troubling to me. If the behaviour is truly involuntary the penalty has no reforming or preventative purpose for the DC concerned. Once a DC was removed from our route for spitting as an involuntary tick. Fair?

I don’t think there is a principle of penalising involuntary behaviour, especially not for the purpose of reform. Transport providers aren’t there to hand out punishments for any reason. You say you agree that it is necessary for the others to be safe but sadly sometimes, removing a child from a transport arrangement is the only way to achieve that. Hopefully in most cases it would only be temporary. Children can involuntary do all sorts of things that are harmful to other people and in a special school environment, staff can mostly cope with it. It’s not the same in a moving vehicle because the risks become so much higher.

In your example of spitting I’d guess it would have to be assessed on an individual basis. A child spitting into their own fingers or down their chin can be cleaned quickly and easily without affecting anyone so of course it wouldn’t be fair to remove their transport. A child going through a behavioural issue that caused them to deliberately spit at people could be reasonably expected to have a different transport arrangement at the same time as being given support to redirect the behaviour.

It’s often a very difficult minefield and like many things, it all comes down to money. All of the issues that arise with getting children with disabilities to the schools they need to be at could be solved with enough money.

Some of the issues that could arise are solved by the children’s escorts/supervisors. A few of them are truly wonderful and they make all the difference to a child’s day.

Passepartoute · 16/10/2023 17:29

BestOfTimesBlurstOfTimes · 16/10/2023 10:17

My 6 year old autistic son’s SEN Transport has been awful this term. He was moved from his previous route on a minibus with a lovely driver and assistant into a mini cab. We’ve had 2 different drivers so far, 2 different assistants, one day the cab turned up with no assistant. The main assistant tried to put DS in the front passenger seat with no car seat. Pick up times have been anywhere between 7:40 and 9:00. School is a 40 min drive away, and starts at 9:00. I have to leave to take my other son to school at 8:30.
One afternoon they were 50 mins late collecting my son from school.
On 3 occasions now, my son has refused to get into the cab and had a meltdown. He is non-verbal, so he can’t tell me what the problem is. Yet LA and transport company don’t seem to think this is an issue and are not responding to my emails.

You need to contact the transport department and the SEN department and point out that this is unlawful and directly in breach of statutory guidance. If possible, give them a full day-by-day breakdown of what has been going on. Ask them to respond to you within a week with their detailed plans for ensuring that they do comply with the law by having a reliable and safe transport arrangement in place, failing which you will have to consider judicial review action to protect your son's rights.

Also point out to the SEN department that if, as seems likely, this failure means that your son can no longer get to school, they will be in breach of their duty to ensure that he receives full time education and special educational provision, and they too will be potentially in the firing line for judicial review.

https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review/

Can I seek judicial review?

https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review

x2boys · 16/10/2023 10:23

BestOfTimesBlurstOfTimes · 16/10/2023 10:17

My 6 year old autistic son’s SEN Transport has been awful this term. He was moved from his previous route on a minibus with a lovely driver and assistant into a mini cab. We’ve had 2 different drivers so far, 2 different assistants, one day the cab turned up with no assistant. The main assistant tried to put DS in the front passenger seat with no car seat. Pick up times have been anywhere between 7:40 and 9:00. School is a 40 min drive away, and starts at 9:00. I have to leave to take my other son to school at 8:30.
One afternoon they were 50 mins late collecting my son from school.
On 3 occasions now, my son has refused to get into the cab and had a meltdown. He is non-verbal, so he can’t tell me what the problem is. Yet LA and transport company don’t seem to think this is an issue and are not responding to my emails.

Fingers crossed my sons transport is quite settled at the moment ,but they change drivers and PA,s every year and its very hit and miss wether you get a good PA or not we have had some fabulous ones and some bloody hopeless ones most are mediocre
My oldest son is at college now so independent but I remember the days of ,transport being late and then that meant my oldest son was late for school too nightmare.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 16/10/2023 10:21

BestOfTimesBlurstOfTimes · 16/10/2023 10:17

My 6 year old autistic son’s SEN Transport has been awful this term. He was moved from his previous route on a minibus with a lovely driver and assistant into a mini cab. We’ve had 2 different drivers so far, 2 different assistants, one day the cab turned up with no assistant. The main assistant tried to put DS in the front passenger seat with no car seat. Pick up times have been anywhere between 7:40 and 9:00. School is a 40 min drive away, and starts at 9:00. I have to leave to take my other son to school at 8:30.
One afternoon they were 50 mins late collecting my son from school.
On 3 occasions now, my son has refused to get into the cab and had a meltdown. He is non-verbal, so he can’t tell me what the problem is. Yet LA and transport company don’t seem to think this is an issue and are not responding to my emails.

I’m so sorry, That is completely awful. Much sympathy.

OP posts:
BestOfTimesBlurstOfTimes · 16/10/2023 10:17

My 6 year old autistic son’s SEN Transport has been awful this term. He was moved from his previous route on a minibus with a lovely driver and assistant into a mini cab. We’ve had 2 different drivers so far, 2 different assistants, one day the cab turned up with no assistant. The main assistant tried to put DS in the front passenger seat with no car seat. Pick up times have been anywhere between 7:40 and 9:00. School is a 40 min drive away, and starts at 9:00. I have to leave to take my other son to school at 8:30.
One afternoon they were 50 mins late collecting my son from school.
On 3 occasions now, my son has refused to get into the cab and had a meltdown. He is non-verbal, so he can’t tell me what the problem is. Yet LA and transport company don’t seem to think this is an issue and are not responding to my emails.

Bunnycat101 · 15/10/2023 08:07

It must be so variable county by county. All of the kids in the next village along to us (less than 3 miles) get access to a minibus service that collects and drops door to door. It’s really well organised- generally same drivers every time and a teacher unloads/loads them on. Vulnerable children shouldn’t be having to deal with long journeys with dubious drivers - they deserve better than that. But it just feels like the whole sector is massively underfunded now and the cuts are causing so many problems. It just feels like education and in particular sen provision needs a huge overhaul and a ton of money pumping in.

Starseeking · 15/10/2023 06:05

Some LA's provide decent school transport. My local one does. You see all the minibuses whizzing around in the morning and evening taking all the children to school and back.

I'm a single parent, and have one DC in mainstream, and another in special school due to their additional needs. Both DC need to be at school at 9am, and the schools are 7 miles apart.

DC at the special school gets the school transport, which is a bus that picks up at a specific point a minute away from our house where a number of other DC also get on. The bus then does 2 more pickups before getting to the school.

Sounds like we're fortunate in that in the 2 years since DC has been at the school and taking school transport, the bus has not arrived on just 2 occasions (due to breakdown). Notice was very last minute, about 15 minutes before pickup.

Samcro · 14/10/2023 23:04

I’m going to hide this thread now. It reminds me why the sn topic became opt in .
hope all the sn parents get the help they deserve

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 22:06

PickAChew · 14/10/2023 13:37

I always communicate by email. If it's not in writing, it never happened. <-- golden rule!

More smaller SEN units is a good model for many kids with SEN but still falls down for kids with more complex needs. Ds2 doesn't not go to the local special school because the school itself is full. He goes elsewhere because their very limited discrete autism provision was full. His school is one of the biggest SEN schools in the country and, as such, with about 15% of their intake having complex needs and/or PMLD is currently able to provide 4 such classes, just for secondary age (separate from the PMLD provision) each with about 5 or 6 kids and 3 full time staff.

It's a good point about writing things down. Unfortunately ours 'didn't realise the email required a response' or they have 'discussed the issue with the chaperone for the chaperone to report back' and nothing gets done, which is why I always seem to end up on the phone. I'm realising that they really are totally rubbish! I think their policy is to just wear you down and/or run out the clock for the term/school year.

I hear what you're saying about more complex needs and the difficulties there.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 21:54

FloweryName · 13/10/2023 18:06

There are a lot of problems with school transport for children at special schools but I don’t think everything you’ve said is entirely fair.

They have to try and make sure the children are on time for pick up because they often have more than one child to collect, it’s not fair to keep others waiting, especially if their disability makes waiting difficult. The escorts don’t get paid overtime if they work extra hours to cover lateness.

It’s also fair if unacceptable behaviour, even if involuntary, means that a contract has to be terminated. The safety of the other people in the bus or taxi has to take priority over anything else.

@FloweryName I wanted to come back and reply to your points.

I do agree with the general principle of timeliness, and I do have concern for the DC who would struggle with waiting, either for physical reasons or because they are fixated on precise timings. However, I think the kind of flexibility I would like is pretty minimal and reciprocal e.g. if you are given a pick up time of 7:45 to 7:55 and the taxi might arrive anywhere in that window, it should be equally acceptable for the child to be ready anywhere in that window. Most human drivers I've dealt with have kept that sort of rule in practice and I don't think that would lead to insurmountable waiting beyond that intrinsic in using a taxi for the DC who struggle with waiting.

Our experience was that we were given an 8:00am pick up time for a school 30 minutes' drive away in morning traffic that opened at 9:00am. So a 30 minute cushion of extra time and no DC to pick up after us. Still we were threatened quite nastily with being left if took more than 2 minutes for DC to get settled in the car after it arrived. What harm could it have done if it took 12 extra minutes as a one-off? Isn't that part of what the cushion is for?

As much as some DC struggle with waiting others really struggle with time keeping and organisation as part of their disability and I'm not sure why it's fairer to meet the needs of those who struggle to wait over and above those who struggle to be ready?

I agree that it is necessary for the driver and passangers to be safe, but the principle of penalising involuntary behaviour is really troubling to me. If the behaviour is truly involuntary the penalty has no reforming or preventative purpose for the DC concerned. Once a DC was removed from our route for spitting as an involuntary tick. Fair? Spitting is disgusting. But last week, a tradesman appeared to spit twice in my home. When challenged - 'did you just spit?' - he replied 'No. I have Tourettes. It's involuntary.' He was quite offended that I considered it spitting and quite certain that it was not a problem because it was related to a disability. Why should it be ok in his case, but not for the DC? Just because the DC is non-verbal and unable to defend their actions?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 14/10/2023 21:48

danni0509 · 14/10/2023 21:25

You’re joking right? Obviously you have no disabled children. Lucky you.

Ds travels 22 miles, twice a day, he can’t go to a local sen school, they can’t meet his needs, the one he’s at barely can.

Why is that my responsibility to take him. The local authority placed him that far, it wasn’t my choice.

SEN provision is a fucking joke. One friend's autistic son was placed in a school out of county and so far away that he had to board Monday-Friday.

LakieLady · 14/10/2023 21:37

My town has outgrown its only secondary school and it can't be extended any further, so kids have to go to the next nearest secondary school. Those on one side of town go to a school that's on a bus route, so can travel independently. Those on my side of town go to a school that's nowhere near public transport, so get a school bus.

Unless they have a parent who can pick them up, they can't participate in after school activities as they have no way of getting home afterwards. I think that's really sad.

Kids with additional needs get accompanied transport if they have to go to a special school though. It's by taxi, or minibus if there are enough kids.

danni0509 · 14/10/2023 21:25

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 15:45

I do feel for the children, but surely the transport should be the parents responsibility?

You’re joking right? Obviously you have no disabled children. Lucky you.

Ds travels 22 miles, twice a day, he can’t go to a local sen school, they can’t meet his needs, the one he’s at barely can.

Why is that my responsibility to take him. The local authority placed him that far, it wasn’t my choice.

JessicaBrassica · 14/10/2023 17:03

I've seen kids unable to attend school because there was no available transport.
I've seen kids unable to attend school because even though there was a wheelchair accessible vehicle, there was no driver.
I've seen school transport refuse to transport a folded wheelchair. Parents could manage without it overnight but had to take in on Monday morning to ensure the chair was in school for the week... And then pick up on Friday so they could have the chair at home for the weekend. When school unexpectedly shut mid wee, he didn't have his chair for the weekend, parent unable to leave the house and dog not walked because school transport wouldn't accommodate the chair.
I've seen 4yos getting picked to at 7 because that's how long the journey takes from home with stops
I've seen parents offer to drive because they can make more money in payments for fuel than they can as a school cook.

I've also seen kids with such a strong relationship with the bus staff that the hour on the bus is the best but of their day!

We live in a very rural area. School transport is the only way many of these kids can get to school.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 14/10/2023 16:25

SacAMain · 14/10/2023 11:58

The schools are not arranging transport for my children?

The schools are not even arranging transports for sports tournament, mandatory swimming lessons or any non-school ground activity... which is a non-issue and no-one is complaining, but bringing children to anything is the parents responsibility.

My tax pay for free education, which we have, not for free transport, free food, free activities or free uniform.

The lack of trained teachers is getting a worry, the lack of school coaches not the priority. Private schools supply them for those who think that's an important element.

You’ve not engaged with my comments about choice or lack of it, but regarding entitlement to free education: would you agree that if the free education is provided so far away that it would cost hundreds per month in transport costs to get there, and is the only option, that it no longer constitutes free education?

OP posts:
higgledypup · 14/10/2023 16:24

@SacAMain
The criteria for free school transport is very simple. If your child has no SEN, then you apply for your allocated catchment school and if that meets the criteria, you are entitled to transport for free.
Whether that is bus, taxi or a mileage allowance.
If there are multiple families at your school not getting a bus, a taxi or a mileage allowance, it's because they are not entitled to it. Probably because they've picked a school which is their preference, as opposed to their catchment school.

SEN is a whole different ball game. Parents don't have the easy option of just picking the catchment school, or even a preferred school, they are often told that is the nearest available school and that is the end of it. These children absolutely need the transport providing for their schooling.

All of our taxes pay for school transport, not sure why you think they don't, unless you don't pay tax, then yes, you don't pay.

To feel hopeless about school transport
Zippedydoodahday · 14/10/2023 14:54

@Bellasbeau If the driver is speeding and putting children at risk and no-one is prepared to sort it , I would call the police. It will help if you know the bits of the route and times that they speed.

missfliss · 14/10/2023 14:47

I get that many folks don't really understand the particular issues around finding SUITABLE provision for SEND kids. If only that was all there is to it. Oh no, then you have to hope there is space. You also have to hope they will cater to your age range and that it will be specified in your EHCP. And that's all if you are lucky. Even if your kiddo gets in you then have to hope that the placement works and also hope that it doesn't shut down through underfunding....

What does surprise me is the utter refusal by some posters on here to allow themselves to be educated as to why 'move closer to the SEND school' is not an appropriate suggestion in so many cases.

Blissful ignorance and willful stupidity

Spendonsend · 14/10/2023 14:46

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 14/10/2023 14:36

Here it’s a free bus pass if you’re more than three miles away IF it’s your nearest school.

Yes. The criteria are that your closest school is more than 3 miles. But they dont include schools that wouldnt let you in? Like if an infant school is 1 mile from your house and you are 13, they dont say there is a school closer. With sen the closest physical school might refuse entry by saying 'cant meet needs' which is a totally diffferent scenario than a parent saying 'i prefer the sports field at this one which is further away"