Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t have a landline - what would I do in an emergency?

115 replies

Ozgirl75 · 12/10/2023 22:12

I live in the countryside, not very rural but no phone signal at all, literally zero bars. I have wifi calling and also a phone line via my broadband.
This is all fine, it works and is no problem.
But the other day we had a short powercut and I had obviously no internet and no phone and it made me think, if there was ever a fire or something like a real emergency with no power, how would I call for help?
Im young and healthy (and drive) but when all landlines are gone, how will people deal with these scenarios?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HappyHolidai · 14/10/2023 08:30

I'm worried about this too. A couple of years ago there was a big power cut in the Oxfordshire village I was living in. Mobile reception went bang too because the mast was in the power cut area.

I used my landline telephone to call the electricity supply people to report the power cut. If I hadn't been able to do that then they might not have noticed for ages (not sure how their systems work to flag this stuff) and all power and mobile signal would have been down. Not a 999 call but pretty important to be able to do this!

AtmosAtmos · 13/10/2023 23:43

myBumJuiceSmellsLikeRoses · 13/10/2023 14:33

Meanwhile, down here in sunny Devon....

My MIL has a landline, plus an emergency pull cord system which operates on a second landline. She doesn't have broadband, or a computer.
She's got dementia and can't really use her mobile phone any more but is still capable of using the old standard phone. I'm sure the authorities won't isolate her, will they?

When we were asked to change our electricity meter (apparently it was illegal 6 years ago - still there....) they came to fit a (unwanted) smart meter. The engineer left after 5 minutes because he couldn't get a strong enough signal on any mobile network from my house.

And this year Vodafone are, or already have, switched off their 3g network. 5g hasn't reached this area as yet.

Edited

I found the following on BT website Naybe register Mil now even though it looks like they should contact

As a customer with additional needs, how can I identify this to BT to get the correct equipment required?
We'll give all customers plenty of notice when we are preparing to switch you to the new service. If you identify as having additional needs or use a telecare alarm system, please let us know by calling so that we can provide a solution that works best for your needs..

Digital Voice | Digital Home Phone | BT

Experience Digital Voice from BT. With Call Diversion & Call Protect, upgrade now to get crystal clear calling, plus a free digital home phone handset.

https://www.bt.com/broadband/digital-voice#collapse8Standard1-col-parsys-3687223826717001278

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 23:04

I did not say most masts have back up

I did say there is a big program of work to make sure that the key masts have battery or generator back up

So I hope you haven't misread

ProfessorDoredumble · 13/10/2023 22:25

I’m sorry but upthread whoever said most masts have battery back up. You are talking out of your arse.

The mobile networks are not facilitated to have resilience in the form of batteries, their high income generator sites may have a battery pack or independent generator but it is not the norm. They certainly don’t last 6hours.

Adaptability for generators to mast sites only works if generators are available and not deployed elsewhere to critical infrastructure (health care, civil functions). Funnily enough the sector uses pretty similar call off contractors for generators. Which is what you found in storm Arwen and Eunice.

Im a resilience analyst in the telco sector.

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 16:51

As I , said for people with a copper line - they should be able to continue unchanged. An interim solution is being deployed that will provide the service to those who need it.

Also you can have a normal phone to plug into a fibre router that works just like it's plugged into copper and that can be protected with a battery pack in case of a power cut

But may need to tell their provider that's what they want

It's blinking hard to find links though to this - I'll keep looking

myBumJuiceSmellsLikeRoses · 13/10/2023 14:33

Meanwhile, down here in sunny Devon....

My MIL has a landline, plus an emergency pull cord system which operates on a second landline. She doesn't have broadband, or a computer.
She's got dementia and can't really use her mobile phone any more but is still capable of using the old standard phone. I'm sure the authorities won't isolate her, will they?

When we were asked to change our electricity meter (apparently it was illegal 6 years ago - still there....) they came to fit a (unwanted) smart meter. The engineer left after 5 minutes because he couldn't get a strong enough signal on any mobile network from my house.

And this year Vodafone are, or already have, switched off their 3g network. 5g hasn't reached this area as yet.

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 12:02

The widespread nature of the storms a couple of years ago did make people think / scared and there is now work to add additional resilience to the mobile phone networks - with back up power for example

rwalker · 13/10/2023 11:20

liveforsummer · 13/10/2023 07:41

They used to. I remember in the 90's having a power cut and being cut off for a week as the result of heavy snow. I was able to charge my trusty old Nokia in my car when it eventually ran low and was able to use it for about 5 days before the mast back up battery died. Looking back it's amazing I even had a signal there in rural Scotland. I wonder if there is one now - we appear to be going backwards 🙃

The don’t anymore we had no power at all for 3 days with storm Desmond
no street lights , traffic lights or mobiles

it’s all down to cost we want everything unlimited with data for £15
look at how much we just paid for calls back in the 90’s
this is why it’s cheaper lesser service

Also if you have your home phone and b band provided by sky if there’s major power cut u would lose your home phone and b band anyway after a brief time as
they have there own equipment in the openreach exchange nothing to do with openreach and don’t pay the have it connected to the back up generator again down to cost

magicmole · 13/10/2023 10:48

lljkk · 13/10/2023 10:14

I thought that corded phones, sometimes given away for free, would still work if main network went down.

Personally I'd rely on my legs to go get help. Wellies in case of snow.

I had ancestors home-steading on the North Dakota prairies in 1880s, so not really worried about English conditions now.

They used to. We get quite a few power cuts and always have an analogue corded phone in our "power cut box". But that's the network that BT are switching off. And when that happens you'll either need to have a backup power supply for your router or a (charged) phone and a decent mobile signal.

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 10:44

@lljkk

Phone plugged directly into a copper wire socket will work today but these are being phased out and I am not sure it's easy to buy a copper line anymore and if there isn't copper to the home it won't be put in

For those with a copper line you can ask to keep that functionality at least for a few years

For those without - mobile ( which may work for 999 when it doesn't for anything else ) or a home battery pack for the hub are your main options

If these don't work please raise it with your provider - there are millions of homes so even if 0.1% have problems that's a lot of problems to be resolved but you need to make your provider aware as they are not mind readers

Ozgirl75 · 13/10/2023 10:35

lljkk · 13/10/2023 10:14

I thought that corded phones, sometimes given away for free, would still work if main network went down.

Personally I'd rely on my legs to go get help. Wellies in case of snow.

I had ancestors home-steading on the North Dakota prairies in 1880s, so not really worried about English conditions now.

Lol 😃 I mean I assume I had ancestors in the Stone Age as well but it’s 2023 now and I’m not THAT rural, I’m just in the surrey countryside!

OP posts:
magicmole · 13/10/2023 10:31

We're fairly rural, the mobile signal is unreliable (although much better than it used to be) and power cuts happen regularly in winter so we've got UPS/battery backups for emergencies.

A House of Commons briefing last year said that "92% of the UK landmass had 4G coverage from at least one operator. 4% of the UK landmass had no good mobile signal at all".

The aim is for 95% to have a mobile signal by 2025, the year when BT will be switching off the analogue landline network. So it looks like a few other households will have to fork out for backups.

And I'm not sure if those figures are accurate. Ofcom has a map where you can check mobile/broadband availability for a postcode https://checker.ofcom.org.uk/ and it bears no relation to what we can actually get.

Mobile and Broadband checker - Ofcom

Webchecker

https://checker.ofcom.org.uk

ReadyForPumpkins · 13/10/2023 10:30

YANBU. When they design the new phone system to replace the existing ISDN, the backup solution is your mobile phone. They have decided not to power the old phone system.

While that work with most areas, there are pockets of rural areas in the UK without good mobile coverage.

CasperGutman · 13/10/2023 10:24

lljkk · 13/10/2023 10:14

I thought that corded phones, sometimes given away for free, would still work if main network went down.

Personally I'd rely on my legs to go get help. Wellies in case of snow.

I had ancestors home-steading on the North Dakota prairies in 1880s, so not really worried about English conditions now.

Corded phones connected to a telephone exchange by copper wire will work in a power cut (for as long as the backup power to the exchange lasts).

However, old school copper telephone lines are being phased out, meaning that corded phones will no longer work without power as they'll be connected to a VOIP service which requires a data (i.e., broadband) connection to operate. This means they will not work without the fibre modem they're plugged into (plus any wireless "landline adapter" type devices) having power.

SalmonBelongInTheWater · 13/10/2023 10:23

I don't think you could summon help. Surely you would try ensure everyone is away from danger (out of the house if it's on fire for example) and send someone with a car to the nearest place with signal? It really does suck but yeah, that's one of the consequences of living in some areas of the countryside. It's partly why I would never ever feel comfortable living in the countryside or rurally. I can't imagine being so isolated that if you needed to call for help you couldn't, or someone could come and break in or attack you and you would be left to deal with it alone. Just so scary to me.

PinkRoses1245 · 13/10/2023 10:20

I've never had a landline, and never even crossed my mind to worry about that until I saw this. But i do live in a town.

lljkk · 13/10/2023 10:14

I thought that corded phones, sometimes given away for free, would still work if main network went down.

Personally I'd rely on my legs to go get help. Wellies in case of snow.

I had ancestors home-steading on the North Dakota prairies in 1880s, so not really worried about English conditions now.

KnittedCardi · 13/10/2023 10:05

Ozgirl75 · 12/10/2023 22:26

No, sadly I get absolutely zero signal. It’s ridiculous, I’m in Surrey, only 20 minutes from Guildford! It’s not the back of beyond, but there is not a jot of signal.

Interesting. I'm also just outside Gford. I get nothing in the house, I'm with O2, but if I walk down the road a bit I get 4g. I regularly can't call from here, so always use whatsapp for calls.

CesareBorgia · 13/10/2023 10:04

rwalker · 13/10/2023 05:49

I work for them the equipment that makes the pstn ( normal dail tone )is technological that is over 50 years old it’s failing
Quite simply the cost of maintaining ,upgrading the current infrastructure to support pstn services isn financially viable as the majority of customers wouldn’t pay for it
as a massive chunk of customer don’t want or need it

But could they not keep it running just in the areas where it is needed?

Ozgirl75 · 13/10/2023 09:50

If I turn off the wifi this is the only thing my phone has at the top. It’s good to know this would pick up a 999 call anyway though.

I don’t have a landline - what would I do in an emergency?
OP posts:
MyYorkshireFarm · 13/10/2023 09:49

I’m in the exact same situation. I had a landline fitted for that exact issue

PurpleNebula84 · 13/10/2023 09:48

@Aaron95 didn't see your post until it refreshed when I posted lol

PurpleNebula84 · 13/10/2023 09:47

999 should work even when there is limited or no signal.
Have you not noticed that when there is no reception your phone usually reads "emergency calls only". This is because for a 999 call, they will piggy back on any available network signal to get the call through.

Aaron95 · 13/10/2023 09:45

Ozgirl75 · 12/10/2023 22:26

No, sadly I get absolutely zero signal. It’s ridiculous, I’m in Surrey, only 20 minutes from Guildford! It’s not the back of beyond, but there is not a jot of signal.

If you dial 999 your phone will use any available network, not just your own.

You may have no signal on say 02 but if there is a signal on any other network it will use that to put the call through.