Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is too much to pay for a cake???

191 replies

AmIjustreallymean · 12/10/2023 21:34

We're having a double celebration (not a wedding) but we thought we'd get one cake to celebrate both events. Cake in the shape of numbers but decorated in two different styles.

The baker was recommended to me and is consistently recommended on our local social media. I don't want to hassle them and i might not get anyone else as the event is soon. But the quote is for 3 figures, ie over £100!!!!

The last cake I bought was £65, nearly 8 years ago so I'm a bit surprised. Am I being really mean and this is a reasonable price?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PickledPurplePickle · 13/10/2023 06:35

How many people will it feed?

blanketsmell · 13/10/2023 06:32

Aylestone · 12/10/2023 22:08

Yes, qualified and insured. It’s all a matter of opinion with quality vrs price I guess. I’d rather this for £35 than what I think half of people on here are quoting and picturing. She made my son this for £55 after I got turned down by quite a few other bakers as the shape was ‘too awkward and they’d have to look into it’ (and then all blanked me)

Aw that's cute!

MariaVT65 · 13/10/2023 04:16

Another poster suggested Cakebox and I’d definitely recommend them. They taste amazing and the sponge is really light. They do national delivery. Depending on how many people you need for, this comes at £125 for 46 people as an example. https://www.cakebox.com/two-number-shape.html

It’s not something i’d pay for personally though. I think paying that much for cake is a waste, effectively for the sake of some photos.

Two Number Shape

https://www.cakebox.com/two-number-shape.html

transformandriseup · 13/10/2023 03:53

I had a similar cake for my 21st (so two cakes) which was well over 10 years ago and I am sure the cost was about £100 then.

Aria999 · 13/10/2023 03:40

It does seem a lot. Time and ingredients are expensive but you might be able to shop around and find it cheaper.

I make (amateur!) birthday cakes for my kids and it probably takes me 5 or 6 hours, then as well as the cake ingredients fondant icing is around $30 for a medium tub plus any other special stuff like toppers.

What you want doesn't sound all that complicated though so you might be able to find something nearer the 100 mark if you try.

Imjusttootired · 13/10/2023 03:05

I get your question OP- it’s kid about what the baker deserves then is it reasonable to pay for something in life that is over so quickly.
I am not on the breadline - I’m not rich but we have spare money for some luxuries - and I have never and will never spend on cakes 🤣
my children might love a certain thing but I would rather spend that on something they can keep or at least have for a period of time of what they love and they really don’t care as long as theirs some form of sugary cake !!

sunnyseed · 13/10/2023 00:15

SecondUsername4me · 12/10/2023 21:38

The last cake I bought was £65, nearly 8 years ago so I'm a bit surprised. Am I being really mean and this is a reasonable price?

I'd say in the £90s for a cake that cost you £65 nearly a decade ago (!!) is probably about right. Utilities, insurances, staff wages, delivery costs for supplies have all increased enormously in the last 3 years alone, nevermind what happened the 5 years before that.

The 90s were more than 8 years ago.

ChocolateIsntTheSameAnymore · 13/10/2023 00:15

I paid 150 for dcs birthday cake was 3 tier as party for 40 plus family and its what dc chose it was stunning and totally worth it. It must have taken hours!

Kate0902900908 · 13/10/2023 00:11

😀

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 00:09

I know there are plenty of amazingly decorated cakes cheaper but it really is only worth it if it tastes fresh and is eaten!
Yes, this is it in a nutshell.

Kate0902900908 · 13/10/2023 00:07

I’m in Manchester.
Im the child free aunt with some money and lots of nieces and nephews. We’ve had in the last 12 months 2 x 18th - x 21st 2x 16th and a 70th.
I have all the cakes made by one lady, the cakes themselves are freshly baked perfectly done, high quality and every piece is eaten (sometimes there’s fights over the last bits) all have been over £100. The cost of ingredients, overheads gas and electric, decorating and her time mean celebration cakes are a luxury BUT the quality of the cakes are that good I am happy to pay it.

last year I paid for a wedding cake. It was a 6 tier princess cake (nieces choice) it was £700. That included delinery and set up along with hours of intricate detail and icing. People are still talking about it.

I know there are plenty of amazingly decorated cakes cheaper but it really is only worth it if it tastes fresh and is eaten! X

JudgeJ · 12/10/2023 23:43

IDidntKnowMyOwnStrength · 12/10/2023 21:44

If it were that cheap and easy everyone would be making their own.
I know a lady who has recently given up her cake making business, she said she never made a penny because if she charged the correct price no one would buy them.

That applied even fifty and more years ago when my mother would sit for hours and hours creating things like the filigree corner baskets, the sheets of tracery etc and the sugar roses that almost everyone now buys ready made, cakes were much fancier and more complicated than the ones today, yet people would look and say 'but an M and S cake only costs £x, why is yours so much dearer?' No thought to her time, skill on top of the ingredients.

user1492757084 · 12/10/2023 23:39

Why don't you buy a square very large chocolate mud cake from a cheaper commercial well known establishment and then decorate it yourself?
The day before mount it on a foil cake board and you could form Chocolate Ripple Cake numbers on top and sprinkle crumbles of choc biscuits over the top. Put in fridge for at least twelve hours. Add more decorations on day ..
Ribbons around, flowers, writing (with icing tube from supermarket), anything really, either on the lower cake or the board - as you like it. You could even use small plastic toys or anything for fun.
You will be able to have a two flavoured cake, lower and upper, and you could serve with berries.

Alternatively, you could start with a large base mud cake and place a commercial baked strawberry cheese cake on top. You could decorate with standing wooden numbers from a craft shop and decorate around the circle sides of the cheesecake with real flowers,add writing or candles to the cake board etc etc

Alternatively, you could place the numbers (formed out of Cup Cakes, Sponge Kisses or Honey Joys) on a huge cake board.

Be creative with nice tasting, quality, commercial cakes and you might be surprised with what you can do.

It could save you half the cost of the cake.

FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman · 12/10/2023 23:30

@ilovemyspace sorry I can't quote you from the app.

I wasn't aware of the existence of a 18" number cake tin - a 18" tin wouldn't fit in my oven or on one of my boards (the largest board most bakers would regularly use is a 16" square).

The standard number tins are around 8" across at their longest/widest point - and as they tend to be shallower than a standard round cake the portions don't usually stretch as far.

The two options for additional servings are usually a larger number-shaped cake cut out of sheet cakes, or a number-shaped cake baked in a number tin with a sheet cake or round cake alongside to make up the extra portions.

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 12/10/2023 23:21

I remember getting a fantastic chocolate cake made for DC1's 4th birthday. Of course it would have done twenty five people instead of the ten kids it was needed for. I still remember how it tasted. I can't remember how much I paid exactly but say approx £70.

I tried in the intervening years to order more birthday cakes but the baker had stopped baking and selling cakes.

I had another cake made for their 12th birthday. it cost £100. I thought it would have piped icing with the shape of the character DC1 wanted. Instead it had some sort of paste stuck on to it. The cake itself wasn't good to eat and I think if I'd picked up a supermarket cake (as I have done many many times in the past) it would have been similar. I was annoyed because the baker was highly recommended on local FB pages.

Its difficult to compare prices because if the cake is excellent quality, it will be worth paying for. If it isn't, then obviously you will kick yourself for paying it.

A friend of mine often hosts family occasions. She orders large fresh cakes from a local, well known bakery who pipe the name of the family member onto it. Its usually a sponge and cream cake so fairly simple but its large enough to offer to a big group, its fresh and its affordable.

Wetblanket78 · 12/10/2023 23:21

Does she do them at home though or have catering premises to do them? At that price I doubt it and they won't be insured and have hygiene inspections etc.

user1492757084 · 12/10/2023 23:20

In the shape of numbers?
Does that effectively mean two cakes?

Blondeleo84 · 12/10/2023 23:20

I have used cake makers several times but once the price started increasing over £100 I couldn’t justify it any more, despite understand how expensive ingredients etc are I just didn’t think it was worth it for cake. I’ve since used cake box and although the cakes aren’t as delicious they are still yummy and fresh at less than half the price. They have 2 number cakes for £60ish!

ilovemyspace · 12/10/2023 23:19

FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman · 12/10/2023 22:57

Yes you can, but they're a standard size (pretty small) - so if the customer wants the numbers to be larger than the tin will make, a sheet cake is the only way.

How 'pretty small' are you thinking??
My daughter bakes number cakes which are baked from cake tins around 18" (maybe a wee bit bigger) and has never had any complaints about them being too small - they're certainly no smaller than a sheet cake would be .
How big are you baking your sheet cakes?

Dee00 · 12/10/2023 23:15

I wouldn’t pay that. Have a look on patisserie Valerie, I always order cakes from them for family gatherings and parties. They are around £50 each and absolutely delicious.

Maybe not as bespoke but definitely tasty.

grumpycow1 · 12/10/2023 23:11

I paid £80 for a handmade cake for my son’s birthday party to feed 40. How many people have you asked them to quote for? It sounds fine to me.

MidnightMeltdown · 12/10/2023 23:10

Spending hundreds of pounds on a cake is nuts imo. Get a giant personalised Colin the Caterpillar in M&S for £45 😂

Prescottdanni123 · 12/10/2023 23:07

Sounds like they have made two cakes. Which is understandable because if they had made 1 cake and cut two numbers out of it, they would have been quite small.

So 150 divided by two is 75. Each cake is worth £75. So the price has jumped up by £10 in eight years. Not bad really considering the increased price of eggs etc.

Wetblanket78 · 12/10/2023 23:07

8 years have passed we are going through a cost of living crisis ingredient costs have gone up massively. As well as you wanting two different designs on one cake and it shaped into numbers. That will take more of the baker's time to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread