Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What should I pay, if anything towards my partners car

88 replies

Lalalalala555 · 12/10/2023 20:35

So I just wanted some advice as to splitting car costs.

My so of 4 years has a car. They use it to drive to work, sometimes on weekends with us.
Its so's car, but only so is insured on it, has full use and decision of where/if they drives it.

Our relationship is we live together. I wfh, so works from office. We're not engaged. If so ever leaves me the car will be theirs.
They chose the car on their own, in terms of budget and what car it is.

I benefit from the car if we go away on holiday / for the weekend.
I don't get to use the car myself, if I need to get anywhere ie doctors or food shopping I use public transport /my bike. We have one parking space where we live so I couldn't get my own car.

Question is - to what extent is fair to split costs?

  1. don't pay anything, it's so's car, if I go somewhere with s.o, s.o would be going anyway/ actively wants to go
  2. pay for fuel or split fuel, for journeys we make together
  3. same as above, plus I pay for extra stuff when we have days out like food/drinks as a thanks to them driving and also using their car
  4. we split fuel, and I pay a nominal amount towards maintenance/loan/insurance costs
  5. we go halves on all costs.

I'm in a pickle what's right, because I do benefit, but I had no decision on what car it was and therefore the related expenses of insurance, maintenance and insurance. I also don't benefit in any way from independent freedom. Any journey that car makes is one s.o has decided is one s.o wants to make.

If we were living apart, I think its pretty normal someone you date you don't pay towards their car. Like people don't pay towards each others appearance costs/tv license or anything else they benefit from in a relationship.

If s.o ever did leave me, s.o would leave with a car. So any upkeep/loan costs would be towards his asset.

(not disclosing current arrangement because I'm really curious to have non biased opinions on what's right and also what others do)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OliveWah · 16/12/2023 19:33

Absolutely no way you should be paying towards maintenance costs! Would your DP pay half of the replacement cost of a new bike if yours got trashed? Would they pay 50% for your new trainers, since you need them to walk in?! Honestly, contributing towards petrol costs on shared journeys and occasionally paying for parking when you're out together are exactly what you should be doing, and no more. Your DP is a CF.

DIYandEatCake · 16/12/2023 19:04

I’d pay for petrol if it needed refuelling when you were on a journey together. Unless you take a lot from them financially already and they feel taken advantage of, I think it would be off for them to start getting the calculator out. It’s a joy to be generous in a relationship isn’t it, to help each other out?

Wednesday6 · 16/12/2023 18:56

1

kweeble · 16/12/2023 18:37

He does sound pretty awful - you’re already being far more generous. I’d hate the lack of generosity when they have a car anyway and be ready to split up.
The 45p a mile rate is high and I’d suggest using alternative transport e.g. for holidays and I’d order shopping online rather than subsidise their trips.

PeloMom · 16/12/2023 18:14

What you do is sufficient. Don’t pay for maintenance too.

Ploctopus · 16/12/2023 18:11

You pay nothing for the car. If you go on long trips together you can split the cost of fuel.

JanefromLondon1 · 16/12/2023 18:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/12/2023 18:07

Tried to remove gender so it's less biased.

If you're going to do that, and I think it's silly, don't use "so". Couple of reasons. "So" is a word, and you haven't capitalised or separated it so it's much more difficult to read. DP is an option, or OH or s.o. or SO if you must use significant other. Or just write 'partner'.

But it's also worth saying that the world is different for men and women, same sex versus mixed sex couples. So what you think of as bias may actually be realism about the world.

firef1y · 16/12/2023 18:02

I have a car, I chose it, as the only driver I drive it, I tax, insure MOT and service it. Its my car.
I think I've only asked my partner to pay for fuel once, when I'd done a lot of running around after him, other than that I'm the one that wanted a car so I'm responsible for it.
But my partner (not married, lived together for 15years), pays for ther things. We have our own money and joint money, all in all it probably works out that we share bills/outgoings 50/50

Zanatdy · 16/12/2023 17:57

In those circumstances I wouldn’t expect to pay towards it, not unless I was driving it

Ktime · 16/12/2023 17:38

You are already doing too much. Paying for all
meals, lunches , coffees and cakes because he drives is already too much.

How are the rest of the finances split? I suspect he is taking advantage of you in lots of ways.

TomatoSandwiches · 16/12/2023 17:37

Ehat you do now is more than fair, I would not be paying maintenance costs because it isn't your car and if they leave they get to take it with them.
What reason have they given for requesting this sudden change?

Ghentsummer · 16/12/2023 17:36

Do you really make your dp do all the driving to the Alps just because you don't want to go on the car insurance?

While I didn't think you should be paying for the upkeep to begin with, the fact he's happy for you to go on the insurance but you are refusing makes me think you should pay more than just petrol. You are putting the burden of driving on him to go see your family/go on holiday even though you can drive. Seems pretty selfish of you.

Greezynogreasy · 16/12/2023 17:34

Do as you’re doing and that seems fair.
Contribute fuel when you go out in the car.

Their car their costs, otherwise.

Maybe you could order some shopping online to take away some of the shopping burden.
I used to be with someone who didn’t drive and it was expected of me to drive to the supermarket on my days off to do the weekly shop.

OnlyFannys · 16/12/2023 17:29

My partner doesn't drive so we are sort of in a similar position. In our relationship the majority of driving is to pick up and drop off his daughter so I ask for a good contribution towards petrol but I don't ask for anything towards the car itself. I did consider asking slightly more as the driving to get his daughter has a huge impact on the mileage and as car is on pcp this might impact the end price/trade in value but I think I will cross that bridge if/when I come to it

GabriellaMontez · 16/12/2023 17:21

I'd do 2 or 3.

I absolutely wouldn't pay him 45p a mile. Wtf?

Is the rest of your relationship like this?

Lalalalala555 · 16/12/2023 17:07

Thanks.

Few clarifications on posts from above.
Ive never 'asked' ie been super direct because my default is.
We split petrol if its a long joint trip. I buy snacks/coffee/food on route as well, as a thanks for them driving.

Weekend days out (local), I pay for coffee/&cake, lunch, dinner. We usually go out for some food and drink but not all three. If we go a long way I'll offer a bigger meal. If its a half hour drive I'll offer coffees ect.
I pay for parking as well, especially if trip benefits me.

We are not heading for marriage, sadly, but we have been together for years.

Its got interesting because I've been asked this evening to contribute towards maintenence costs. And I'm at odds about it.
After reading this thread I don't think it is normal for a partner to expect to pay for their other half's maintenance costs.
They aslo suggested paying half of the 45p/mile whenever joint using the car.

For clarification.
We live together. Been together 4+ years. We don't have kids. We rent one bed flat.

I wfh so don't drive to work, like they do.
I get bus/cycle to doctors in week. I get train to do walks after work.

They will do some food shops using car.
We will go for weekend day trips in car.
We will visit family (mine and theirs) in the car. About once a year we take a long road trip to alps.

I don't have my own car because I don't need one because I wfh. Would quite like one but we only have room for one car where we live (the road parking is non existent being city centre and no permits allowed). I would be allowed by them to be insured on their car, but choose not to. Partly because they have the car 5 days a week anyway. They usually want to do something at the weekend, if I do something on my own I get the train or walk. We do do joint errands in the car sometimes e.g food shop. But equally I will do a food shop and carry it home on foot.

Its tricky.
I split or cover petrol depending on the trip (ie split joint interest, pay for viisitng my family, friends or medical). Also I pay for parking and food and drinks when they drive a long way and it's joint interest or my interest. And usually at weekends if we do day out together.

I don't like that I've been asked in that it feels tit for tat. But I also want to be a nice person and be fair. But I'm also not sure if it's being taken a bit too for granted.

OP posts:
namechange55465 · 13/10/2023 12:39

Mrsttcno1 · 13/10/2023 12:05

I dare say there must be a lot of little hypocrites hiding here on mumsnet because there was another thread about this literally a few weeks ago, but the opposite perspective, a woman who owned the car and was the only driver, and her husband was refusing to contribute towards it claiming it’s not his car. And EVERY response was that he was a joke, should be paying towards it, and in fact majority saying if he refused to then to stop taking him anywhere in it etc. Presumably on a weekend if you go somewhere you go in the car? Do you use the car to do your weekly food shop? Do you use the car for date nights?

If you are benefitting from the car, you should be paying towards it. They don’t run on fresh air, so yes as a minimum pay petrol. To be honest at the point you’re living together and presumably heading in the direction of marriage, surely these things become joint?

Yes, her husband. Who on becoming her husband signed a contract that linked their finances and who would be entitled to have the value of the car taken into account in event of a divorce.

Nowhere has OP said they are "heading in the direction of marriage", in fact they have explicitly said they're not engaged. And in any case I would counsel them against heading in the direction of marriage with someone who seemingly can't be arsed to give them a lift to the supermarket but expects them to pay towards car insurance.

namechange55465 · 13/10/2023 12:31

Somewhere around option 2 or 3, and that would be normal if you didn't live together as well. If I went on a weekend away with a friend and she drove, I'd offer half the fuel/parking and probably pay for a few drinks or something while we were away to say thanks for driving. I wouldn't pay all the fuel, and I wouldn't pay for everything on the day out/trip away - half the fuel and then something small to say "thanks" is the most I'd be willing to do.

I wouldn't be paying anything towards insurance, maintenance etc except indirectly in that by buying a meal or coffee to say "thanks for driving" I'm acknowledging that wear and tear on the car is a thing and that driving is a faff, and that I'm grateful to the other party for putting themself out in that way.

Is there a reason you're not insured on the car though? That's the weird bit to me here.

Mrsttcno1 · 13/10/2023 12:05

I dare say there must be a lot of little hypocrites hiding here on mumsnet because there was another thread about this literally a few weeks ago, but the opposite perspective, a woman who owned the car and was the only driver, and her husband was refusing to contribute towards it claiming it’s not his car. And EVERY response was that he was a joke, should be paying towards it, and in fact majority saying if he refused to then to stop taking him anywhere in it etc. Presumably on a weekend if you go somewhere you go in the car? Do you use the car to do your weekly food shop? Do you use the car for date nights?

If you are benefitting from the car, you should be paying towards it. They don’t run on fresh air, so yes as a minimum pay petrol. To be honest at the point you’re living together and presumably heading in the direction of marriage, surely these things become joint?

arethereanyleftatall · 13/10/2023 11:57

*petrol not driving

arethereanyleftatall · 13/10/2023 11:56

LouOrange · 13/10/2023 11:43

You pay nothing, maybe fill up the tank if going away. I’ve never previously asked a boyfriend to contribute anything to my cars.

I think the 'I've never previously asked' bit is the bit that many of us our finding the dynamics of this relationship so unappealing.

'Asking' wouldn't come in to it. In a normal healthy relationship where the two people actually like each other and aren't stingy
'Let me pay for the driving, you pay for everything else, so I would like to.'
'Don't be silly, I don't mind at all'

And so, at lunch;
'I absolutely insist on getting this. You keep paying for everything and I want to.'
'Lol, ok'

LouOrange · 13/10/2023 11:43

You pay nothing, maybe fill up the tank if going away. I’ve never previously asked a boyfriend to contribute anything to my cars.

RedPony1 · 13/10/2023 11:41

You pay your way with fuel costs, but that's it.

meganorks · 13/10/2023 11:26

If you go on a big trip it makes sense to pay half of fuel costs (I'm talking hour plus driving/holidays really) otherwise you pay nothing. You aren't even insured to drive the car ffs!
Myself and my (then) DP were in a similar situation where I had a car that I used for commuting etc. He was insured on the car so he could use it if needed. It never occurred to me to get him to pay for anything. It was my car! If we went on holiday one of us would probably fill up on the way, one on the way back, but that was it. If he was using it and it needed fuel he would put it in. Other than that, my car, my expense.