Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have treated children with letting dog out

239 replies

beakerclub · 12/10/2023 19:18

DH thinks I was OTT with this, I don't.

Basically as I was getting out of my car with my 2 year old child last night two kids, probably about 8 from their height, were stood right by silently in halloween masks whilst I was unclipping my son from his car seat.

I just rolled my eyes initially and completely ignored them but then as I walked toward my house and up my drive they followed me and at this point my little boy was starting to get upset. I told them to go but they didn't, literally followed me up my drive and to my door!!

In the end I said you have 3 seconds to get off my drive or I'll be letting my dog out to deal with you and you'll wish you had. They scarpered quick as I opened my door and shouted my dog outside.

Now my dog is pretty big and a bit barky and can be quite scary looking if he wanted to be, but he's actually soft as shit so there wasn't any real risk of him doing anything, still it did the trick and they ran off and my dog was confused as to what the commotion was ha.

DH thinks it was just kids messing about and I shouldn't have threatened to basically have my dog attack them (wouldn't have happened). I disagree, I think if you're going to be daft enough to make a toddler upset and follow strangers up their driveways then meeting a scary dog at the door is what you get and really all I did was just warn them I have a dog and was opening my door 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 13/10/2023 10:57

WeighDownOnMeStayTillMorning · 13/10/2023 10:15

They are also little kids though @beakerclub that's what you don't understand because you have a younger child.

Yeah, little kids that were up to no good.. I’m not sure how people can justify what they were doing to be fair.

exactly WHY are they covering their faces and WHAT were they doing following women with small children? It isn’t Halloween, they weren’t asking for sweets and they didn’t leave her alone when she asked them to.. they were purposely making her feel uncomfortable and scaring her child.. I’d have done exactly the same.

Remember James Bulgers murderers were only slightly older than that when they abducted and murdered him.. now I’m not suggesting people get hysterical, but certainly don’t just ASSUME they are sweet little 8 year olds with nothing but pure intentions.. that’s not the world we live in.

beakerclub · 13/10/2023 10:56

My dog did not chase anyone. I simply called his name when I opened my door, they'd already scarpered by the time he was at the door, he was fussed a bit and we went inside. No children were chased down the street by a vicious dog.

OP posts:
CobwebsAndCauldrons · 13/10/2023 10:54

Dogs are dangerously out of control if they cause someone to reasonably fear they may be hurt by the dog, regardless of whether or not they do hurt them and regardless of whether or not they would hurt them. This harm is not limited to deliberate aggression and includes harm such as jumping up and pushing them over. It's also not limited to public space but includes on private property, in your own home/garden.

Your dogs chasing after children (with or without real intent to harm) who fear deliberate or accidental harm if the dog catches them, are dangerously out of control.

As a fellow dog owner it saddens me to see this threat issued so casually when we have so many people who already believe dog ownership needs greater restrictions and controls because current dog owners cannot be trusted to behave responsibly. It's simply adding more fuel to that fire.

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 10:52

TheCompactPussycat · 13/10/2023 10:50

and my dog was confused as to what the commotion was ha.

What a bloody stupid thing to do. You actually thought that encouraging your dog to bark at and scare off children wearing halloween masks would be a good idea. I mean what could possibly go wrong with that tactic in the future? Utter stupidity!

She called the dog. He wouldn't have known what he was being called for 😵‍💫

TheCompactPussycat · 13/10/2023 10:50

and my dog was confused as to what the commotion was ha.

What a bloody stupid thing to do. You actually thought that encouraging your dog to bark at and scare off children wearing halloween masks would be a good idea. I mean what could possibly go wrong with that tactic in the future? Utter stupidity!

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 10:46

WeighDownOnMeStayTillMorning · 13/10/2023 08:29

You can't 'baby' children, but you can set a dog on an 8 year old if it scares a 2 year old.

Got it.

No, you haven't "got it" at all.

beakerclub · 13/10/2023 10:45

And 8 is simply my best guess given it was dark and they had masks on. They could have been 10+ for all I know. I don't know that they were exactly 8 years old. They weren't tiny kids but not lanky teens either 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie · 13/10/2023 10:45

If they’re such little kids, why were they out alone at night without a responsible adult? It really doesn’t work both ways.

All this “please will you leave”, “I’ve got to let my dog out and I’m worried it might jump at you” language is madness. If a kid is old enough to be out alone at night, trespassing and behaving obnoxiously, they’re old enough to be told to get off the OP’s land, in whatever language she sees fit.

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 10:44

I have parented 8 year olds before and I would be utterly disgusted if I found out one of them did this, especially upsetting a much younger child
Ditto.

beakerclub · 13/10/2023 10:42

Yes they are. But when do children become old enough to have consequences for shitty behaviour? They may be children but they are old enough to know you don't go round making toddlers cry and refusing to leave another person's property.

Every is talking as if I've no experience with 8 year olds and they are far too young to be accountable for any wrong behaviour. I have step children who I've lived with since they were small, they have been 8. I have parented 8 year olds before and I would be utterly disgusted if I found out one of them did this, especially upsetting a much younger child. I'd have absolutely no sympathy that they were scared off by talk of a dog (because despite what I said I didn't actually 'set a dog on them').

Nothing happened to them, they were acting like silly beggars and got scared off. Could have been worse, they could have gone onto someone's property who genuinely had an overprotective dog! Hopefully they won't do it again now.

OP posts:
WeighDownOnMeStayTillMorning · 13/10/2023 10:15

They are also little kids though @beakerclub that's what you don't understand because you have a younger child.

Robotalkingrubbish · 13/10/2023 10:01

It’s no wonder youngsters grow into being thugs. Bless their hearts, they were only playing. It’s this attitude from parents that is the answer to why there is so much bad behaviour in schools

My brother taught in a secondary school in a naice area. He quit because the behaviour of the kids was so bad. What was worse was the attitude of parents if their little darling was told off.

Zimunya · 13/10/2023 09:59

@beakerclub - you seem to be getting a lot of aggro on this thread, and I'm really struggling to understand why. These brats were intimidating to your toddler, didn't listen when you politely asked them to move, and followed you on to your property. I'm not sure where all the posters who think you are unreasonable draw the line, but for me, once they followed you onto your driverway, having already frightened your child, all bets were off. You have an obligation to proptect your child, and yourself, and you did. Hopefully they won't come back, now they know you have a dog.

beakerclub · 13/10/2023 09:53

Peachee · 13/10/2023 07:25

I think it would have been better to say do you mind not coming up my drive with the scary masks because it will scare my baby. Instead of rolling your eyes - however I equally get it when you have a young baby you’re in protection mode and it is instinctual.
I think YABU regarding dog but I think YANBU from protecting little one about inconsiderate children in scary masks.

I did ask them to go. I asked them politely to stop.

And I imagine if I'd simply walked in my house they'd probably have thought nothing of just knocking on my door or window. I doubt they'd just have immediately left when I closed the door.

They were purposefully trying to scare a little kid. Boohoo that they got scared in the process.

OP posts:
beakerclub · 13/10/2023 09:48

I didn't literally set a dog on them though did I. I didn't release Cujo.

I said they needed to get off my property before I let my dog out. And they did.

If you're going to go onto someone's property after being asked to leave with the intention of intimidating the people who live there (like my toddler) then sometimes you may come across a dog who also lives there.

OP posts:
WeighDownOnMeStayTillMorning · 13/10/2023 08:29

ObsidianGrape · 13/10/2023 05:54

Yanbu. If it was my child when she was 2, she would have been so scared. If the boys intentions were to scare your 2 year old, then they deserved it.

It's good for some fear to be put in them and face some repercussions for their actions. It's all this babying of children that is ridiculous. Kids need to learn right from wrong. They won't learn anything if they don't face the consequences of their actions. Let's hope they learn from this and don't do it again to someone else that might actually let dangerous dogs on them etc.

You can't 'baby' children, but you can set a dog on an 8 year old if it scares a 2 year old.

Got it.

phoenixrosehere · 13/10/2023 08:00

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 13/10/2023 07:25

That would have really freaked me out, even more so because they are so young. We’re they just silently following you 😂

I think threatening with a dog was probably OTT and maybe not sensible given the current flurry of media around dog attacks. However I can’t feel too sorry for the kids, they messed about and found out what’s happens!

I think threatening with a dog was probably OTT and maybe not sensible given the current flurry of media around dog attacks. However I can’t feel too sorry for the kids, they messed about and found out what’s happens!

Agree more with this. Maybe a bit OTT but don’t feel the least bit sorry for them.

I don't think many, if any, have excused the children's behaviour.

Some saying they’re just kids in masks fooling around imo is excusing their behaviour. Fooling around does not mean ignoring being told to leave someone’s property and following them.

NonMiDispiace · 13/10/2023 07:28

Good for you OP.
We had a gang of feral 6-9 year olds terrorise our small estate some years ago. They didn’t even live on this estate.
At Halloween they egged hoses, poured car oil and flour onto cars and set fire to bins amongst other things. The police eventually caught them but it didn’t stop them from doing the same in the village subsequently.
I loathe Halloween and dread it every year.

Peachee · 13/10/2023 07:27

Also it’s 2 weeks until Halloween! What the heck is going on!!

Peachee · 13/10/2023 07:25

I think it would have been better to say do you mind not coming up my drive with the scary masks because it will scare my baby. Instead of rolling your eyes - however I equally get it when you have a young baby you’re in protection mode and it is instinctual.
I think YABU regarding dog but I think YANBU from protecting little one about inconsiderate children in scary masks.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 13/10/2023 07:25

That would have really freaked me out, even more so because they are so young. We’re they just silently following you 😂

I think threatening with a dog was probably OTT and maybe not sensible given the current flurry of media around dog attacks. However I can’t feel too sorry for the kids, they messed about and found out what’s happens!

Hellocatshome · 13/10/2023 07:18

LolaSmiles · 13/10/2023 07:05

phoenixrosehere
I don't think many, if any, have excused the children's behaviour.

It's entirely reasonable to think the children's parents shouldn't have them out unsupervised, the children were wrong for pestering, AND that the OP was being unreasonable.

All this "but what about the neighborhood" misses the point that in the neighbourhoods that people are conjuring up to justify an adult threatening to use a dog as a weapon against some children, that's probably exactly the sort of action that is going to either escalate the situation in the moment or prompt further conflict after the event.

The OP should have been the adult in the room, not threatening children that they'll be sorry when she lets the dog out at them.

Exactly. If you truly live in a neighbourhood where the 8 year olds are so scary you have to threaten them with violence imagine what would happen when they tell their older siblings or parents?

OPs DH lives in the same neighbourhood and even he thinks she was unreasonable.

LolaSmiles · 13/10/2023 07:05

phoenixrosehere
I don't think many, if any, have excused the children's behaviour.

It's entirely reasonable to think the children's parents shouldn't have them out unsupervised, the children were wrong for pestering, AND that the OP was being unreasonable.

All this "but what about the neighborhood" misses the point that in the neighbourhoods that people are conjuring up to justify an adult threatening to use a dog as a weapon against some children, that's probably exactly the sort of action that is going to either escalate the situation in the moment or prompt further conflict after the event.

The OP should have been the adult in the room, not threatening children that they'll be sorry when she lets the dog out at them.

phoenixrosehere · 13/10/2023 06:23

Lostcotter · 13/10/2023 05:56

exactly. It’s frightening many of the people agreeing with this are parents and/or work with kids and they think this is acceptable. Threatening kids with extreme violence is not OK. And yes a dog attack is extreme violence.

From what I can see Op still hadn’t clarified if she said anything first before leaping to the threat of dogs.

What happens if the similar thing happens at a play park or shopping centre with no dog allowed.

I can’t believe I’m having to even say this but adults need to learn to be able to challenge children without falling back on the “scary dog will get you” line. aside from the fact it’s inappropriate it’s not always possible to use.

They didn't just follow me up the road, they waited by my car, right by me, purposefully whilst I was getting my son from his seat, followed me up the street to my drive, walked up my drive after being told to leave and came right up to my door whilst I was trying to settle my son and get inside. They were ABSOLUTELY trying to do it on purpose, nothing to do with sweets and they had already been told to bugger off more politely.

Literally said in one of her posts.

She told them to leave and they not only chose not to, but followed her to her door. There’s also no guarantee that they are 8. OP assumed they were by their height. She knows the type of neighbourhood she lives in. They refused to leave her be, ignored her telling them to leave her property and were following her to her door while she had her small child. She only warned them that she had a dog, didn’t let it out and that is what it took for them to finally leave.

They had no reason to be doing what they’re doing in the first place. The moment she told them to leave, that should have been the end of it. Too many adults makes excuses for children and then moan about the younger generation.

Lostcotter · 13/10/2023 05:56

BlueYonder57 · 12/10/2023 21:29

The law would disagree with you. They did NOTHING. They were 8. They had no knife. They didn't threaten. Thjey walked up a drive.

It is illegal to set a dog on people. Full stop. Whatever the breed.

And this site is still insane. If the headline in the papers had been "householder sets dog on children - child dies" you'd have been screaming for the dogs blood. Dogs are not, and should not be, weapons. If one adult cannot handle two 8 year old children by shutting the door on them, it's a pathetic adult we are talking about.

exactly. It’s frightening many of the people agreeing with this are parents and/or work with kids and they think this is acceptable. Threatening kids with extreme violence is not OK. And yes a dog attack is extreme violence.

From what I can see Op still hadn’t clarified if she said anything first before leaping to the threat of dogs.

What happens if the similar thing happens at a play park or shopping centre with no dog allowed.

I can’t believe I’m having to even say this but adults need to learn to be able to challenge children without falling back on the “scary dog will get you” line. aside from the fact it’s inappropriate it’s not always possible to use.

Swipe left for the next trending thread