Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pointless lie from friend - I'm so over it

134 replies

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 18:53

Ok this is long and over something fairly small.

Please no nasty "what a load of unnecessary drama" comments, you're welcome to not continue with the post.

Shortest version I can manage: my friend (lets call her Heidi) lied about going on holiday with other friends (who she is much closer with or related to). I am totally fine with this, like completely utterly 💯 fine. I wouldn't have been interested in this break anyway.

But the lie is so irritating and frankly, offensive. Also, similar has happened multiple times over the years and left me feeling confused and a little paranoid.

Also, I don't necessarily think the lack of information was about me but another friend (let's call her Davina) who was there. Or quite likely both of us.

Either way I'm so done with extended group politics and being lied to straight to my face.

I don't feel like being friends with Heidi anymore.

Yabu: What a massive overreaction to not being told about something you didn't even want to do.
Yanbu: being lied to is horrible and given its happened in the past, cut your losses.

OP posts:
Janieforever · 13/10/2023 20:37

Why are you assuming it was a lie? It’s very plausible they booked a last min deal to go as they got it cheap, friends of mine just did the same.

id not have assumed a lie, just a last min booking. And as foe saying you’re not the type to throw a strop, I think this thread and your reaction proves otherwise.

Bugbabe1970 · 13/10/2023 20:20

Having lots of friends is overrated

TabsKane · 13/10/2023 19:42

Not sure why people are so insistent that you’re upset. I understand totally what the problem is. Your so called friend is a disrespectful ass. Just drop her. Don’t do anything with her, don’t accept any invites, and if you see her in your wider circle of friends just smile and offer no information on you, and if she talks about getting together just say, ‘we’ll see’ or nod and never ever do it.

This will drive her crazy. She has no info, no explanation, you just won’t make time for her ever again. And it will be extremely satisfying, for you!

Stupidliefromfriend · 13/10/2023 11:13

redribbonrose · 13/10/2023 07:44

Somebody in the wider group doesn't like you . Doesn't want you at brunch or holiday, and Heidi is caught in the middle

Phase them out

Nobody needs these teen antics in their 40s

Find some grown up friends

Yeah. These were my exact thoughts that day of the brunch.

Who was there? What was the issue? Who have I offended?

And running various scenarios through my head. It was a long time ago but I wanted to give an example as it wasn't stand alone. I felt foolish, rejected and confused.

At some stage around then I decided that I was going to focus on getting my own life in order and let other people come and go as they pleased. I did this successfully and have been much happier.

For the posters who said the friendship means more to me, she is only humouring me with lunch, I want to be more in their group than I am - that's not the case. Life moves on and people move in different directions. I probably moved more drastically than anyone.

So when I realised that a perfectly straightforward questions such as "do you have any holidays booked" was answered with a lie, I had a very strong (and yes possibly dramatic) internal reaction of FRO and then keep going please.

OP posts:
redribbonrose · 13/10/2023 07:44

Somebody in the wider group doesn't like you . Doesn't want you at brunch or holiday, and Heidi is caught in the middle

Phase them out

Nobody needs these teen antics in their 40s

Find some grown up friends

MyCircumference · 13/10/2023 06:42

oh i assumed heidi and davinia went on holiday.
how odd.
agree she sounds like she wants to fit in, or something.
odd
i wouldnt meet her, and if you do end up, then take Everything she says with a pinch of salt.

JayJayEl · 13/10/2023 00:12

Apologies, I hadn't yet read the whole thread! Sounds like you're naturally in tune with the 'Let Them' theory.

JayJayEl · 13/10/2023 00:05

Hi @Stupidliefromfriend 👋
I had a similar experience with a very close friend a long time ago (almost a decade!). We'd been friends in school, and we'd remained close as adults. Always celebrated birthdays together each year, but the year we all turned 30 she said she wasn't doing anything to celebrate. Thought this strange at the time, but whatever. Later found out she'd planned a weekend away for her 30th, and I was literally the only friend in the group that wasn't invited. Bloody hell, it HURT. Long story (slightly) short(er) it made me re-evaluate our friendship, and all the cracks suddenly appeared. So I decided to bow out. She's messaged a few times over the years, but friendship eventually fizzled out. He lack of apology made the decision easier than it may have been.

So my question is - what do you get out of the friendship? Anything good? If so, does that good outweigh the negative, or no?

I really believe that relationships work both ways (obvs) and if a relationship is only providing you with only (mainly?) negative experiences then what's the point in bothering with working at it?

P.s. Have you heard of the 'Let Them' theory, by Mel Robbins? “'Do not try to force them to change; let them be themselves because they are revealing who they are to you. Just let them – and then you get to choose what you do next.”

PyongyangKipperbang · 12/10/2023 23:55

I think she sees herself as the Ringmaster in this 3 ringed (or more!) circus of friendships. That all these friendship groups all absolutely revolve around her.

I think that if you were feeling especially cruel you could tell her that you actually dont give a shit what she does, when and with whom. That she is not certral to your life or your the particular friendship group that you are in.

Or you could be a bit kinder and say "I you seem to think that I am going to care if you go places or do stuff with anyone other than me. You are wrong. I am happy to see you live your life, just as I am living mine. What I DO care about is being lied to"

Georgeandzippyzoo · 12/10/2023 23:51

Can I say she sounds very controlling of the group ie like the 'queen bee' at secondary!

But I don't think you have a friend issue I think uou have a friends issue. I'm assuming none of these who went on holiday have mentioned it, possibly on her insistence but that's them enabling her behaviour.

I think I'd personally message them all something along the lines of
'For some reason Heidi has lied to you, youre disappointed and just dont get it?! it feels weird that as mature women they felt it necessary to do that, it feels like you're back in school....etc'

BTW had no trouble following and understanding your post.

GodDammitCecil · 12/10/2023 23:03

It sounds like her behaviour - the lying / fudging / deliberate omissions - are motivated by, if not good intentions, then at least not bad intentions. She wants to spare hurt feelings, people feeling excluded, awkwardness, etc.

But actually, that doesn’t matter.

It doesn’t matter that her behaviour may be coming from the right place. What matters is the impact it has on you.

She is hard work. You’re incompatible with her. How she handles things is not how you would handle things. You don’t like her. Or, at least, you don’t like a lot of her behaviours (which kind of boils down to the same thing).

The friendship is over, really isn’t it? I agree with pp that there’s little to be gained with having it out with her.

Just demote her. Don’t seek her out for catch-ups or include her in your stuff. And be busy when she (deigns to) invite you.

I think doing this, and focusing on your easier (low drama?) friends will result in a happier life.

Newgirls · 12/10/2023 23:02

I think she’s a not very bright, people pleaser

i dont think she wants to upset you hence going out for lunch. She massively over thinks things.

You could just decide to think of her as a bit daft and not take her very seriously. That way you can still stay in touch.

Imagwine · 12/10/2023 22:55

Yanbu

Latenightreader · 12/10/2023 22:50

She sounds like my aunt who is so desperate to be liked/seen as popular and successful she tells lies about ridiculous things. She claimed that she had argued with my cousin (her niece) that I should have been a bridesmaid at her wedding. I have barely seen my cousin since we were kids and was never close to her then - it would have been completely weird to be asked. She pushed me into a group photo at the same cousin’s wedding when I had nothing to do with the group because she decided I felt left out - I really didn’t and she spoilt the photo for them (she was making such a thing about it I joined the photo rather than have her keep going on about it). These days we have almost no contact with her - it was just exhausting…

MsRosley · 12/10/2023 22:49

The older I get, the more I see lying as an irreparable breach of trust. Once someone has lied to you, you can't trust anything they say from that moment on.

Plus Heidi is completely toxic. You're well rid, OP.

Saggypants · 12/10/2023 22:39

It's not unusual for people in my family to tag each other in FB posts even if they're not actually present. (I assume they don't really understand how FB works.) If there's no other evidence of her being away I wouldn't use that as 100% proof.

Anyway, I know you asked us not to but I do think your feelings are a bit OTT as are some of the responses. You seem quite insulted by the idea that she might assume you'd want to go and spare your feelings - there's definitely some ego involved.

She might genuinely be considerate and not wanting to cause hurt, although misguided. If you think the friendship is otherwise worth salvaging you could be honest with her, and just explain that you really do understand the friendship dynamics and you're ok with it, and she truly doesn't need to lie or cover anything up.

43ontherocksporfavor · 12/10/2023 22:38

I had a friend like this .The odd thing is she’d send me cards that said she was so glad to have a friend like me( not my style at all) but then totally leave me in the dark about quite important stuff. There was one too many and I let the friendship slide.

CaughtUpInYourWishingWell · 12/10/2023 22:33

I don't mean for this to be hurtful, only honest. I don't think she values your friendship much. I'm not sure she feels close to you at all.

I think she's using you to be honest. She likes the odd lunch with you. A bit of a catch up. But really, when it comes down to it, she hasn't got your back.

I would just rebook the lunch and tell her it's cancelled; I don't know why her and divina are having to mean anyway if they don't get along. Then just don't message her and allow it to fade away.

She's not a real friend. She's a good time girl.

Cello60 · 12/10/2023 22:32

Some people never grow up. I knew someone who did something similar for her 60th birthday/retirement party. 60!

it’s the assumption you’d be terribly offended at not getting to spend time in their august company that irritates.

and if you do cut them off/say something it just proves to them how right they are about their desirability.

Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 22:16

well there you have it I’d be pleased not to go you’d think they’d have grown out of this kind of thing at their ages

BlueEyedPeanut · 12/10/2023 22:12

For your own sanity, you need to de-prioritise this person and their importance in your life. There is no need to confront her about anything. You have seen what she is like towards you and others. This is just who she is. Stop caring and stop expecting anything different.

Lesina · 12/10/2023 22:04

Weird.

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 21:57

Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 21:51

Do they like to
booze a lot on hol?

Yes and take drugs to my surprise. I was completely left out on the last one and would have no interest in going again.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 21:51

Do they like to
booze a lot on hol?

WandaWonder · 12/10/2023 21:50

EnjoythemoneyJane · 12/10/2023 19:17

All depends where the motivation to lie has come from - is she lying because she’s been an active part of organising something that excludes you, or is she being evasive because she’s going on a trip she knows you’re not invited on but doesn’t want to hurt your feelings?

This, to actively lie there has to be a reason 'lying for the best' or 'lying because I hate you and am being mean'

Sure you don't have to get the reason but if it is important enough for the liar I would be fine with it

Swipe left for the next trending thread