Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pointless lie from friend - I'm so over it

134 replies

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 18:53

Ok this is long and over something fairly small.

Please no nasty "what a load of unnecessary drama" comments, you're welcome to not continue with the post.

Shortest version I can manage: my friend (lets call her Heidi) lied about going on holiday with other friends (who she is much closer with or related to). I am totally fine with this, like completely utterly 💯 fine. I wouldn't have been interested in this break anyway.

But the lie is so irritating and frankly, offensive. Also, similar has happened multiple times over the years and left me feeling confused and a little paranoid.

Also, I don't necessarily think the lack of information was about me but another friend (let's call her Davina) who was there. Or quite likely both of us.

Either way I'm so done with extended group politics and being lied to straight to my face.

I don't feel like being friends with Heidi anymore.

Yabu: What a massive overreaction to not being told about something you didn't even want to do.
Yanbu: being lied to is horrible and given its happened in the past, cut your losses.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stupidliefromfriend · 28/11/2023 08:39

T1Dmama · 28/11/2023 00:05

I think most of us said she was probably avoiding causing offence because you weren’t invited.. you were adamant that she knew you wouldn’t care because it was a different circle of friends that you didn’t socialise with.

A lot of posters were arguing that I did care. I didn't care but the cover up was annoying. It was frustrating to keep explaining that

Anyway it's her stuff, she's struggling and reading situations wrong a lot of the time.

OP posts:
T1Dmama · 28/11/2023 00:05

I think most of us said she was probably avoiding causing offence because you weren’t invited.. you were adamant that she knew you wouldn’t care because it was a different circle of friends that you didn’t socialise with.

Marlena1 · 27/11/2023 22:29

It does sound like a form of anxiety. She's so desperate to avoid awkwardness/hurt feelings that she creates both. It would have been nice to get your point across but it's probably not worth it, it may have put her on the spot and pushed her to the edge.

Stupidliefromfriend · 27/11/2023 15:41

Hi everyone,

This is an old thread. I wanted to give an update of sorts.

I couldn't decide what to do so did nothing. I met up with Heidi and Davina for lunch over the weekend and we caught up on lots of stuff. At one point I asked her about the holiday. I didn't bother asking her why all the secrecy because what was clear when we met was she is struggling a lot with different things. She has had fallings out with three major people in her life recently and had been keeping it to herself. She is not coping.

I know she's not malicious and my guess is that she felt awkward as we were not on the invitation list (the accommodation was free and could only fit a limited number of people) and misread the situation. She seems shaky in general and very anxious.

So I'm glad I left it.

OP posts:
WeeStyleIcon · 21/10/2023 16:35

The people who do this, ie exclude others, it enhances their own sense of belonging. The group is united by what they're not be that mothers of toddlers, women who are carrying extra weight, single mothers, mothers who aren't beautiful, women who aren't mothers, women who are mothers, women who wear dowdy clothes. There's always something about me. I am often excluded tbh, I'm one of those people who's fairly peripheral in every group. always an acquaintance. my acquaintances are often very friendly to me but I feel like I'm never at the centre of any group. Obviously that is about me not ''them''. I wonder if I'm keeping good people at a distance or something. I don't want to.

43ontherocksporfavor · 21/10/2023 08:44

Well said @JFT

43ontherocksporfavor · 21/10/2023 08:42

Yes and they’re often the same women that post #Be Kind all over their socials too.

JFT · 21/10/2023 01:22

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 20:20

You have summed up exactly how I feel about it. The covert "don't let anyone else know, it's just us" vibe. Get a life, everyone else has.

In my vast experience of dysfunctional friendship groups, I can tell you one thing as sure fact.

There are some people (who are always women, I have yet to meet men who do this) who actively enjoy knowing that when they upload their photos to FB or IG or whatever, that someone somewhere is sitting with hurt feelings.

They enjoy the superiority and powerful feeling it gives from excluding people from the group or with-holding information. It makes them feel cool, edgy, and bitchily on top form.

You can't say anything, as if you do, you look like some unreasonably needy whiny gimp and they know that and they have an excuse like oh it was last minute and blah. But if your intuition is telling you that's what it is, then it is. I've been on the inside and the outside of these nasty performances.

I had one friend for decades who only conducted her social life in this bizarre manner of creating little cliques and groups who she'd then play off against each other and include / exclude individuals at will, toying around with people. I've seen it all. I ended my friendship with her, she was sick as heck. Over the years she had made sudden and unexpected suicide attempts which she never ever discussed and the last time she succeeded so she's no longer here. But it goes to show these people are not well and this little dysfunctional game props up the way they feel they need to live. So, let them have it hey, but not to your detriment.

JFT · 21/10/2023 01:12

I'm autistic and cannot bear this whole type of situation that you've described. I can't bear it so much that I prefer not to have to go through all the 'social' / gossip / game playing interactions that arise like office politics / friendship politics. Being lied to or deliberately deprived of information is crazy making. But here's the thing, it drives me so mad that now I've pretty much moved away from or ended most of my friendships over the years. And that can get a bit lonesome!

Anyway, my suggestion is, when these things happen, take a step back. In your mind, push these people a further to outer orbit of your social circle or activities, maybe even take up some new activities or friends. But don't cut them dead, don't create a huge conflict, drama or confrontation, or burn bridges.

The fact they behave like this means they're not capable of direct open communication and prefer to play silly games / deceits. It's not the end of the world as long you fully accept that as a fact and then deal with it accordingly. If you have different values (honesty, directness, and openness) that conflict with their behaviour, just minimise any situation to the point the way they are doesn't impact you. When I take people for how they are in reality without pondering if they've wronged me or not, it all seems a bit more manageable.

Hippomama · 21/10/2023 00:28

I would tell her/them exactly how you feel about all the sneaking and secret invites then I would cut them all out of your life to be honest. Sounds a bit toxic

Jessica3075 · 18/10/2023 23:25

Why did she feel the need to lie. Did she think you’d have taken it badly? In my experience, people don’t enjoy lying. They do it to protect someone when the truth would hurt.

if course, some people are habitual liars! Only YOU know your friend.

Grrrrdarling · 14/10/2023 15:24

@Stupidliefromfriend I would literally ask her what the problem is & why she feels she has to keep lying about things. if she comes up with a wishy washy answer, yet again, you have your answer about the friendship!

Maddy70 · 14/10/2023 11:12

Maybe she went last minute?
Maybe she was trying to spare hard feelings?

Stupidliefromfriend · 14/10/2023 09:28

I did comment below to have a great time along with loads of other people. It wasn't meant to be pas-ag and I assume it didn't look like that. Regardless I doubt Heidi will notice as the holiday will be mayhem. Her memory is not great anyway and I don't expect her to remember the conversation about holidays.

Thanks for the replies, I'm not going to do anything beyond continuing the phase out and not arrange the dinner.

For those who keep insisting I'm upset to not have been invited, that is really more about you.

OP posts:
Lollipop81 · 14/10/2023 07:31

Why would you be friends with her 😂 of course your not been unreasonable.

T1Dmama · 13/10/2023 23:58

I would have to ‘like’ the post… or write ‘have a lovely time’….
I wouldn’t say another word about it though, but I’d want her to know that you know she lied.
I would slowly just back away from her, decline her invites and she’ll soon get the hint. Just arrange to see the ones you get on with

Ryeman · 13/10/2023 23:50

My biggest take away from this thread is wow - these people seem to socialise an awful lot! That alone sounds exhausting.

Frostyloz · 13/10/2023 23:44

You are not being unreasonable. I have a friend who does this and it drives me up the wall.

I’ll casually ask if she has plans and she’ll say no, but then I speak to another friend who will tell me in conversation that they went to x place or took the kids to y. Or she’ll tell me she has plans and I’ll say, ‘oh, who are you going with?’ and she’ll mention a cousin or something, then only later do I find out that another friend was there as well as said cousin.

The other friend(s) will tell me in normal conversation because they know I’m not bothered (it’s usually something kid-related and I don’t have kids, or it’s when I’m working) but the fact she purposely hides it is baffling to me.

Or she’ll drip-feed… ‘Oh I’m going to such and such’ and I’ll ask who with and she’ll say just DP and DC. Then she’ll forget she said that and tell me who she was actually with. Then another friend might get added in the next time she tells the story. It does make me feel shit every time it happens but it’s not because I’m jealous, it’s because she feels the need to lie. I have no idea what it’s all about.

EvilElsa · 13/10/2023 23:37

I can't be arsed with liars.
Like loads of others have said, get rid. I'd cancel the lunch with her and rearrange elsewhere with Davina. I wouldn't bother with arguments or accusations, it's just a waste of your time. Just slow fade her out. Life is far too short for crap mates. I ended a long term friendship with a small group about 6 years ago -no fights or anything, it just wasn't working anymore. I didn't like the way they treated me or how they made me feel. I've never once regretted it for a minute.

Splitscreened · 13/10/2023 23:24

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 21:07

Perhaps this yes. I've heard her husband argue with her about stuff like

"In the morning, we are going to thank the hosts, pack our bags and go. Don't offer anyone lifts. My sister is expecting us at X time and we will be late if we don't go there directly."

She will agree but then be offering lifts and saying "we can squeeze you in don't worry, it's only five minutes out of the way. Much nicer than the train."

Then the person is in the car when they were perfectly happy to get the train wondering why there is tension. This exact scenario happened to a friend of mine, she was planning to get the train. She ended up going with them, they realised they were going to be late so after sitting in a car with them smoking (she was appalled)nfor forty minutes they dropped her somewhere even less accessible and she ended up getting a bus home.

This was my friend that they don't know at my party. Heidi practically wrestled her into the car then decided it wasn't convenient.

She was quite bothered by it, as if she had unreasonably asked for a favour (she hadn't).

Who has time for this stuff?

cannockcandy · 13/10/2023 23:14

I have 2 rules for being my friend. 1. Don't lie to me. 2. Don't let my son down. Imo both are perfectly reasonable to expect from grown adults.
Personally I'd be fazing Heidi out and getting closer to Davina. X

Stupidliefromfriend · 13/10/2023 22:40

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 13/10/2023 20:50

Do you think it's this? Were you quite obvious of your dislike/disapproval of them on and after the holiday to Heidi? As she's a people pleaser do you think she was worried you'd voice your disapproval of her holiday?

Nobody would have noticed.

OP posts:
helpplease01 · 13/10/2023 22:03

If I were you, I would walk away from, or. Seriously distance myself from them.
This doesn’t feel right for you.
Move on.
Good luck

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 13/10/2023 20:50

Stupidliefromfriend · 12/10/2023 21:38

Yes and they'd be right - I'm not compatible for holidaying with! That was very clear on our last very big group trip when we were on completely different schedules (basically I got up during daylight hours).

That is totally fine with me.

This holiday wasn't even Heidi's event. t was one of other woman's birthday and I'm not close with her. So there would be no expectation from me to be invited.

Do you think it's this? Were you quite obvious of your dislike/disapproval of them on and after the holiday to Heidi? As she's a people pleaser do you think she was worried you'd voice your disapproval of her holiday?

ILoveBountys · 13/10/2023 20:41

Agree with most people - I’ve had the exact same (lies over a holiday that didn’t matter to us) and I refuse to nurture a friendship with anyone that lies to me, especially over petty rubbish. Lies like that are always solely for the benefit of the person that does it; awkwardness, caught in the middle- whatever - grow tf up.

Real friendships require mutual respect; lying is the epitome of disrespect. To your face? Over something that didn’t matter? Forget it.
you’ve got some good suggestions on what you could do next - I’d let the friendship starve to death & nourish the friendships that matter.