Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About this message on the front of a bus?

317 replies

Iop · 12/10/2023 14:18

This morning in town a bus passed me with the phrase Mash'alla displayed on the front instead of the bus number and destination. AIBU to have found it unsettling?
We're in an area with a large Pakistani Muslim population and there were small pockets of celebration following the initial attacks on Israel (nothing violent or disruptive, just horns/cheering/Palestinian flag waving).
If I were to complain to the bus company (I won't - I don't have time) it would be on the grounds that it's unprofessional for bus drivers to be proclaiming their political or religious beliefs on the front of their busses. But if I'm honest my discomfort was about more than that - I wouldn't have felt as unsettled if the message had been "vote Tory" or "Happy Diwali" even though neither of those reflect my personal beliefs any more than Mash'alla does.
Am I being reasonable or Islamaphobic?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:30

Free2 · 12/10/2023 20:23

Christianity had already spread across Europe, at the time of Constantine the Roman stronghold was largely in the East, people weren’t forcibly converted by him, things were pretty liberal, it was Justinian who closed the Platonic academy and this was essentially about power not Christian belief.

I think that you’re deliberately misunderstanding me, and not actually reading what I’m writing, so unless you can shed light on turkey ham, I’ll bid you a good morning (yes, it’s Friday the 13th and another day of fun and frolics is about to get underway) or a good night, since I suspect you’re in Europe (because you seem to have Europe on the brain) 🙂

Free2 · 12/10/2023 20:23

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:16

So you don’t agree that when Constantine I converted to Catholicism in 312, that helped to spread Christianity through (what was left of) the Roman Empire? And then it took from there?

Christianity had already spread across Europe, at the time of Constantine the Roman stronghold was largely in the East, people weren’t forcibly converted by him, things were pretty liberal, it was Justinian who closed the Platonic academy and this was essentially about power not Christian belief.

Iop · 12/10/2023 20:23

Wow. I went away for a couple hours to do dinner and bedtime and came back to vegan cheese, the Subway business model, and assorted crusades.
Thanks to those who weighed in re the bus. Plenty of food for thought. I won't make a complaint to the company but I'll contact them to ask about the message and see what they say 🤷🏽‍♀️

OP posts:
JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:23

Can someone please tell me what the heck turkey ham is? Is it just a slice of turkey? I don’t understand how a turkey can be ham. Or is like vegetarian fakon which is supposed to be bacon? But turkey ham is a new one on me!

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:20

Free2 · 12/10/2023 20:10

You are saying stuff that doesn’t make sense. You claimed that countries only became Christian by invasion/force and I pointed out that this was not how Christianity spread through Europe and became its official religion.

When European countries started creating their own empires beyond Europe, Christianity was spread by force. But this was not the story for Europe itself.

When did I ever mention Europe? The Holy Roman Empire was a vast and well-oiled machine. And actually, Mary I, the Spanish Inquisition, and many other awful, terrible practices, were all in Europe, even though some of those countries weren’t invaded per se.

I was trying to show you, and make you think critically, how religions are spread, and how conquests, regardless of religion, are an awful and bloody thing.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:16

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:30

the Roman Empire started spreading Christianity in the 4th century CE

^^ this comment is bizarrely ahistorical.

So you don’t agree that when Constantine I converted to Catholicism in 312, that helped to spread Christianity through (what was left of) the Roman Empire? And then it took from there?

Free2 · 12/10/2023 20:10

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:06

You started this actually.

I have asked you questions about other invading forces who forcibly converted the people of whichever country to the invading forces religion and you won’t answer. Why? Because you don’t believe that any other invading force converted people?

All I wanted to do was to point out that Muslims weren’t the only conquerors that forcibly converted people. But for some reason, you disagree with that and I find it bizarre that you disagree with that!

You are saying stuff that doesn’t make sense. You claimed that countries only became Christian by invasion/force and I pointed out that this was not how Christianity spread through Europe and became its official religion.

When European countries started creating their own empires beyond Europe, Christianity was spread by force. But this was not the story for Europe itself.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 20:06

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:54

you’ve got a one track mind about Arab conquests only

🙄

Seriously, this is really annoying. I responded to someone saying ‘Muslims have been the enemy since the crusades’, I pointed out the factual inaccuracy, because it was the Islamic/Arab invasions/ conquests, led by Mohammed, that set Islamists up as ‘the enemy’ (people don’t tend to enjoy being invaded and conquered, they tend to see the people doing the invading/conquering as the enemy- it’s pretty hostile) and that the crusades were actually counter-attacks to reclaim lost territories.

I will not let this be warped into ahistorical nonsense. The fact that I won’t let you get away with it apparently means I have a one track mind. I don’t think so. I just don’t have an I’ll-informed, illogical scatterbrain.

You started this actually.

I have asked you questions about other invading forces who forcibly converted the people of whichever country to the invading forces religion and you won’t answer. Why? Because you don’t believe that any other invading force converted people?

All I wanted to do was to point out that Muslims weren’t the only conquerors that forcibly converted people. But for some reason, you disagree with that and I find it bizarre that you disagree with that!

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:54

you’ve got a one track mind about Arab conquests only

🙄

Seriously, this is really annoying. I responded to someone saying ‘Muslims have been the enemy since the crusades’, I pointed out the factual inaccuracy, because it was the Islamic/Arab invasions/ conquests, led by Mohammed, that set Islamists up as ‘the enemy’ (people don’t tend to enjoy being invaded and conquered, they tend to see the people doing the invading/conquering as the enemy- it’s pretty hostile) and that the crusades were actually counter-attacks to reclaim lost territories.

I will not let this be warped into ahistorical nonsense. The fact that I won’t let you get away with it apparently means I have a one track mind. I don’t think so. I just don’t have an I’ll-informed, illogical scatterbrain.

Glitterdavies · 12/10/2023 19:54

FloweryDrawer · 12/10/2023 19:39

I wonder how Palestinians in the UK feel right now about buildings being lit up with the Israel flag. The flag was projected onto 10 Downing St and the Palace of Westminster was covered in blue and white lights. Wembley has been criticised for not following suit.

At this time, I imagine many Palestinians will struggle when they see that and see what’s happening to people in their country. Wonder who they are complaining to.

You know what I haven't even thought about this, has anyone even asked British Palestinians how they feel right now?

A lot of the sentiment seems to be about British Jews feeling scared and how the government can do more to protect them and show their support

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:39

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:31

No, you do! You honestly think that when one nation conquers another nation, it’s not done by force?

And please answer my questions about Mary I and the Spanish Inquisition! Those weren’t forcible conversions?

Edit: I’m also not talking about religious conversions during conquests, I’m talking about the conquests themselves and then giving you some food for though, but you’re not thinking about the bigger picture, you’ve got a one track mind about Arab conquests only, as if they are the only Empire builders that used force!

Edited

If a nation following a certain belief system (in the case of Rome, pagan gods) invades other nations, it makes no sense to say that they were invading according to a belief system which they adopted much later (in the case of Rome, Christianity), during their era of collapse.

If you are going to compare the expansion of the Roman Empire to the Islamic (Arab) Invasions/conquests, then it would only make sense to call them ‘Roman Pagan invasions’ or some such thing. The Romans weren’t trying to spread their beliefs though, in a way that is comparable to the Islamic invasions led by Mohammed.

FloweryDrawer · 12/10/2023 19:39

I wonder how Palestinians in the UK feel right now about buildings being lit up with the Israel flag. The flag was projected onto 10 Downing St and the Palace of Westminster was covered in blue and white lights. Wembley has been criticised for not following suit.

At this time, I imagine many Palestinians will struggle when they see that and see what’s happening to people in their country. Wonder who they are complaining to.

SamAndEIIa · 12/10/2023 19:37

Blahbie · 12/10/2023 14:21

YNBU they would never approve of a 'Jesus saves' poster on a bus so why should they put Arabic or whatever it was on a bus. England is a Christian country believe it or not.

Wgere does it say it happened in England?

FloweryDrawer · 12/10/2023 19:35

Restaurants often use halal meat as it’s cheaper.

And places that don’t offer pork are responding to local market forces. I don’t think they have been threatened with suicide bombs for serving pork. They know their local customers don’t eat much pork so they provide other products instead. It’s about money and business. Not Muslims taking over ‘our’ country.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:31

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:28

Oh I see now! When the Romans were conquering, it was all done politely and without weapons or bloodshed!

Flippin’ ‘eck. See what I mean?

You seriously need to brush up on your history. The Roman Empire was collapsing during the rise of Christianity. It really wasn’t in any position to do any conquering. When the Romans were in their expansion phase, their gods were pagan Gods, roughly matching earlier Greek gods.

No, you do! You honestly think that when one nation conquers another nation, it’s not done by force?

And please answer my questions about Mary I and the Spanish Inquisition! Those weren’t forcible conversions?

Edit: I’m also not talking about religious conversions during conquests, I’m talking about the conquests themselves and then giving you some food for though, but you’re not thinking about the bigger picture, you’ve got a one track mind about Arab conquests only, as if they are the only Empire builders that used force!

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:31

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:30

@Free2

Read this post ^^

I am not the only one who realises that it’s not only the nasty bad Arabs that used force when conquering! Other people agree with me! Shocker, eh?

Totally missing the point.

The crusades we’re a reaction to the Arab conquests.

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:30

the Roman Empire started spreading Christianity in the 4th century CE

^^ this comment is bizarrely ahistorical.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:30

Cozzadelsol · 12/10/2023 19:12

No, they certainly did not set a good example at all, and it is a matter of opinion whether they actually improved the indegous populations way of life.

The point I was trying to make is that our British and European ancestors felt it was perfectly fine to rock up and forcefully inflict their culture, beliefs, and language on other nations. In some cases, obliterating these natives, but how dare anyone come here and practice their religion and celebrate their culture.

@Free2

Read this post ^^

I am not the only one who realises that it’s not only the nasty bad Arabs that used force when conquering! Other people agree with me! Shocker, eh?

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:28

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:24

Oh I see now! When the Romans were conquering, it was all done politely and without weapons or bloodshed!

Same with the Normans invading England - everyone was having croissants and hot chocolate - nice!

And when the British wanted to grow their Empire, it was all tea and scones.

I think I understand you now - only the Bad Horrible Muslims used force.

The Spanish Inquisition was not about forcibly converting Jews and Muslims to Catholicism but it was Rioja and paella all around, whilst watching bullfights!
Mary I of England didn’t use force to try to convert the English back to the Catholic Church at all, using quite unsavoury methods.

All that history is a lie! It was only the Arabs that did those nasty things!

And Australia really isn’t the best example either, considering there are no pure blood indigenous people left!

I think you’ll find that the Roman Empire started spreading Christianity in the 4th century CE. Islam didn’t even start until the 7th century.

Oh I see now! When the Romans were conquering, it was all done politely and without weapons or bloodshed!

Flippin’ ‘eck. See what I mean?

You seriously need to brush up on your history. The Roman Empire was collapsing during the rise of Christianity. It really wasn’t in any position to do any conquering. When the Romans were in their expansion phase, their gods were pagan Gods, roughly matching earlier Greek gods.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:26

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:16

You post doesn’t make logical sense. You make no attempt to understand what other people mean. You are waving around sweeping statements hoping others reading haven’t got time to scrutinise how your reply doesn’t properly relate to the post you are responding to.

Well, my post was very sarcastic! I took issue with your “certain kind of beard” which was ridiculous. Beards, no beards, white, black, sky blue pink, you can’t racially or socially profile what a terrorist (aka lunatic) looks like. And to say it’s a beard that alerts you to “shifty” looking people is nonsensical!

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:24

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:09

Christian countries became Christian through being conquered!

You need to brush up on your history!

The Roman Empire was collapsing, its centre moving about. This was happening at the same time Christianity was actually on the rise, word of mouth, grassroots. Christians were persecuted by the Romans. Eventually, converting the Empire to Christianity saved it. It wasn’t through invasion, it was ‘spreading the gospel’ by ordinary people which Christianised Europe, and it was later than the Arab conquests, when the Imperial Europeans forceably Christianised other nations. For example in Australia.

Oh I see now! When the Romans were conquering, it was all done politely and without weapons or bloodshed!

Same with the Normans invading England - everyone was having croissants and hot chocolate - nice!

And when the British wanted to grow their Empire, it was all tea and scones.

I think I understand you now - only the Bad Horrible Muslims used force.

The Spanish Inquisition was not about forcibly converting Jews and Muslims to Catholicism but it was Rioja and paella all around, whilst watching bullfights!
Mary I of England didn’t use force to try to convert the English back to the Catholic Church at all, using quite unsavoury methods.

All that history is a lie! It was only the Arabs that did those nasty things!

And Australia really isn’t the best example either, considering there are no pure blood indigenous people left!

I think you’ll find that the Roman Empire started spreading Christianity in the 4th century CE. Islam didn’t even start until the 7th century.

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:16

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:11

There’s an Islamic beard? I don’t think you should racially or socially profile based on beards. I remember when the IRA were bombing England - they were white people too. And that’s exactly why you shouldn’t profile based on beards, but rather try to remember that lunatics come in all shapes and sizes and facial grooming techniques 🙂

You post doesn’t make logical sense. You make no attempt to understand what other people mean. You are waving around sweeping statements hoping others reading haven’t got time to scrutinise how your reply doesn’t properly relate to the post you are responding to.

Cozzadelsol · 12/10/2023 19:12

Warum · 12/10/2023 18:52

While many (christian) white settlers definitely improved conditions/amenities in the areas they moved to, they definitely also enforced their way of life on indigenous people. They didn't really set a great example of how to move to a new country and respectfully live with those who existed there already, sadly.

No, they certainly did not set a good example at all, and it is a matter of opinion whether they actually improved the indegous populations way of life.

The point I was trying to make is that our British and European ancestors felt it was perfectly fine to rock up and forcefully inflict their culture, beliefs, and language on other nations. In some cases, obliterating these natives, but how dare anyone come here and practice their religion and celebrate their culture.

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:11

Free2 · 12/10/2023 17:41

FFS - I said ‘young men’. I know that British born men are drawn into this - apparently the criminal justice system is where many become radicalised and most of these would be ethnically European. And although I in no way feel I need to defend myself about this, it is usually young white men who scare me on the tube looking shifty like this- it is that certain kind of beard on them that is the clincher.

There’s an Islamic beard? I don’t think you should racially or socially profile based on beards. I remember when the IRA were bombing England - they were white people too. And that’s exactly why you shouldn’t profile based on beards, but rather try to remember that lunatics come in all shapes and sizes and facial grooming techniques 🙂

Free2 · 12/10/2023 19:09

JoanOfAllTrades · 12/10/2023 19:01

No, you have!

How did these Christian countries come into being? They were invaded!

And my point to you, in reply to your somewhat ridiculous one about Arabs deserving it (as that is how it came across), was that if you have a problem with Arab conquests, you should have a problem with all conquests!

But instead of admitting that perhaps your only problem is the Arab conquests, you double down, without thinking about my point - Christian countries became Christian through being conquered!

So again, do you have a problem with all Empires and conquerors, or just Muslim ones?

Do you agree with the Spanish Inquisition perhaps?

Christian countries became Christian through being conquered!

You need to brush up on your history!

The Roman Empire was collapsing, its centre moving about. This was happening at the same time Christianity was actually on the rise, word of mouth, grassroots. Christians were persecuted by the Romans. Eventually, converting the Empire to Christianity saved it. It wasn’t through invasion, it was ‘spreading the gospel’ by ordinary people which Christianised Europe, and it was later than the Arab conquests, when the Imperial Europeans forceably Christianised other nations. For example in Australia.

Swipe left for the next trending thread