Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About this message on the front of a bus?

317 replies

Iop · 12/10/2023 14:18

This morning in town a bus passed me with the phrase Mash'alla displayed on the front instead of the bus number and destination. AIBU to have found it unsettling?
We're in an area with a large Pakistani Muslim population and there were small pockets of celebration following the initial attacks on Israel (nothing violent or disruptive, just horns/cheering/Palestinian flag waving).
If I were to complain to the bus company (I won't - I don't have time) it would be on the grounds that it's unprofessional for bus drivers to be proclaiming their political or religious beliefs on the front of their busses. But if I'm honest my discomfort was about more than that - I wouldn't have felt as unsettled if the message had been "vote Tory" or "Happy Diwali" even though neither of those reflect my personal beliefs any more than Mash'alla does.
Am I being reasonable or Islamaphobic?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Catlord · 12/10/2023 16:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Educate yourself... go on Instagram.

Good one.

I don't know what 5 African languages are called? Happy to send you my thesis on such if you wish. I have no interest in discussing politics with you, suffice to say you haven't picked the right person to screech 'educate yourself on geopolitics and African languages' to. I've put the time in, and a lot more hard study than looking at bloody Instagram.

This thread and my response were about messages on buses. It would not be appropriate to celebrate any death in such a way, if indeed that's what it is.

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 16:14

therealcookiemonster · 12/10/2023 15:39

I'm sorry OP but the fact that it's only because this saying is linked to arabic and Islam that makes you uncomfortable means you actually ARE islamophobic.

mash'Allah is a phrase used by arabic speakers (of all religions) all over the world to mean 'this is a blessing from God'. used very frequently in every day conversation especially when something good happens especially weddings/exam results etc.

this bus could easily have been hired for a wedding and when I have seen that word on vehicles its usually because its a wedding related transport.

or maybe the driver just had a baby and wanted to express gratitude. you have no idea as to the intention.

face it, you are judging the actions of a whole group of people based on what other people very far away did. that is the definition of discrimination.

many people world wide (Muslims and non Muslims) support the Palestinian cause in the sense that they wish the occupation to end and for Palestinians not to be bombed like rats in a cage. this does not equate to support for hamas or antisemitism. it is possible to oppose hamas and support the rights of Palestinians. in fact no one is doing more of a disservice to Palestinians right now than hamas.

It's fair enough to find Islamic messages more threatening given recent history. It's not the same as being generally fearful of Muslims, just ones that write messages on buses.

To be fair if a bus said "praise the lord" on the front the morning after Grenfell, or after the death of the queen, that would be equally distasteful although perhaps less threatening.

Gnomegnomegnome · 12/10/2023 16:12

Instead of emailing to complain you could email to ask.

It could be perfectly innocent as many posters have already explained in their examples, It may not but until you ask you won’t know.

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 16:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Modern day Christianity, maybe (although not entirely convinced). It wasn't always the case though. What about the crusades, slavery, oppression of the working class, capital punishment, divine right of kings??

Liberal democracy is a very recent invention in the history of Christianity

Free2 · 12/10/2023 16:06

People are also allowed to feel more frightened by Islamic messaging than Christian or something else. Our most recent terrorist attacks have had Islamic messaging, and although people consciously don’t want to treat ordinary innocent Muslims differently as a result of those attacks, I know that it is Islamic terrorism I am scared of when I take public transport or am in a crowded public space. The IRA no longer occupy that space for me. It is not an ‘irrational fear’/phobia that makes people jumpy, those of us who have been very close to those attacks.

Millybob · 12/10/2023 16:06

I’m going to guess a private hire/school bus for an Islamic school as there is an Islamic school in my area with MashAllah written above the main entrance door. Appreciation that Allah has provided education and safe transport for their children?

If that's true, then it's very foolish in the current climate and could be putting the children at risk.

Blueblell · 12/10/2023 16:04

Well It is open to misinterpretation and context is key. Could have been used as a school bus dropping kids at an Islamic school and it is a well intended greeting fir them then In that context it would be ok. If thought it is the bus driver displaying his personal beliefs about the conflict then that is not ok on a public bus.

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 16:04

fairgame84 · 12/10/2023 15:14

If it's returning to depot then mashallah would be appropriate to say thank God for a good shift. It's like saying inshallah if they were setting off for their shift.
It's all about context.

Really? That's a bit of a stretch. Since when do bus drivers put their own personal messages on the front of their bus?

Warum · 12/10/2023 16:04

@therealcookiemonster I will add that as much as it is your right to practice Islam and feel safe doing so, it is my right to be against all that all religions stand for and also feel safe doing so. It is not Islamophobia (or any other phobia) to refuse to allow any aspect of a religion to be part of my life. The issue with many religions is that because they believe very strongly in that religion they cannot help but try to enforce it on others, or try to normalise it being part of general daily life. The right to practice religion is important, as is the right to abstain from it.

Millybob · 12/10/2023 16:02

Why do you feel the need to complain anonymously? You have every right to complain about something like that and if I were the bus company, I'd want to know about it.

justteanbiscuits · 12/10/2023 16:00

nameoftheday · 12/10/2023 15:43

NinaBee “Sky news just came out and said they don't have any proof of Hamas beheading or killing anyone, it is all propaganda.”

Do you really believe this?

I read three entirely separate articles, from good sources, that say that only one journalist, out of a group taken to the site, claims to have seen the babies that were beheaded from a day care centre even thought the journalists were all together, all of the time. They are clear that this isn't to say it did not happen, just that no one else with the original reporting journalist saw it.

I think at this point in time, it would be prudent to not believe everything coming from the Israeli government too.

MollyMarples · 12/10/2023 16:00

It’s the different language that I would find unsettling. And the timing/support this is showing to the Palestinians.

Bromptotoo · 12/10/2023 15:59

fioritura · 12/10/2023 15:58

I’m going to guess a private hire/school bus for an Islamic school as there is an Islamic school in my area with MashAllah written above the main entrance door. Appreciation that Allah has provided education and safe transport for their children?

That sort of thing.

Exactly.

fioritura · 12/10/2023 15:58

I’m going to guess a private hire/school bus for an Islamic school as there is an Islamic school in my area with MashAllah written above the main entrance door. Appreciation that Allah has provided education and safe transport for their children?

Gothambutnotahamster · 12/10/2023 15:57

Warum · 12/10/2023 15:36

I think this needs flagging up for two reasons:

  1. The meaning is unclear, even if you do know it means something along the lines of 'to give thanks' it is not obvious what we are supposed to be giving thanks for.
  2. The person, presumably the driver but possibly someone else in the company, should not be using buses to make any sort of statement (including religious ones), especially not in a language which the bus display would not usually be in!

This!

Warum · 12/10/2023 15:57

therealcookiemonster · 12/10/2023 15:50

@Warum well as a Muslim who faces islamophobia every day, I think we are allowed to say when we feel discriminated against?

I am not referring to any other incidents. as a Muslim I am saying that if someone says they are happy to see 'vote tory' or 'Happy diwali' but feel uncomfortable to see an innocuous arabic phrase 'mash'Allah' which they didn't even initially know the meaning of - then this is a response which comes from a discomfort around Muslims or Islam hence its islamophobic.

I didn't say you weren't allowed to express how you feel or talk about your experiences, I simply stated that any concern over anything which is remotely linked to Islam can be labelled 'Islamophobia' and it isn't always actually the case. If anything it muddies the water and perhaps makes people discount actual islamophobia (or phobia of any other religion).
As it stands, I am not happy to see anything on the front of a bus other than a destination/private hire/out of service etc, buses are no place for religious or political propaganda of any sort.

Free2 · 12/10/2023 15:56

I would have thought there would be caution even if it had been planned a while back. Someone should have said, before leaving - is this a good idea to do this today? Shall we put something else up? This is going to give the wrong impression.

Bromptotoo · 12/10/2023 15:55

Get over it.

A few years ago I flew with Biman, the airline of Bangla Desh. Inshallah we will be landing in Birmingham in five minutes, please ensure your seat is upright, table stowed etc.

It's a simple religious blessing in Islam referring things being willed by Allah (God).

Why should it bother you other than perhaps offending against one's atheism?

Iop · 12/10/2023 15:55

@therealcookiemonster FWIW I wholeheartedly support the Palestinian cause, and I think the way the Palestinian people have been treated by Israel, with the backing of the West, for decades, is appalling. But like most people I know (and like yourself, I believe), I think the recent actions of Hamas are absolutely unjustifiable.

My question was less about that, though, and more about the message on the bus. You're right that I did view it through the lens of the events in Gaza, and didn't consider that it might have referred to a personal event, and I'll reflect on what that says about me. But it still seems a little tone deaf at best. The driver must have considered that people wouldn't automatically assume it related to his new grandchild that nobody knows about, and would relate it to events of global significance that are currently at the forefront of many people's minds.

@Lookright, it wasn't an advert on the side of the bus, it was on the front where it normally says 73 Kings Cross or whatever. Which I think can be changed pretty easily without much advance planning or funding.

OP posts:
Graciebobcat · 12/10/2023 15:54

I'm sure I've seen Christian adverts on a bus!

NinaBeee · 12/10/2023 15:54

nameoftheday · 12/10/2023 15:50

“what's an active islamist area? Muslims live all over the UK. or do you think we should live in ghettos? or maybe not be here at all?”

That’s quite the extrapolation, Cookiemonster.
The fact is that there are/have been cells operating from certain places - e.g. Luton where the 7/7 bombers came from. And if the bus had been in one of these places, that adds to the “context”.

So if there were white murderers and rapists from Luton means I should be wary of all white people too?

Jellycats4life · 12/10/2023 15:53

fairgame84 · 12/10/2023 15:14

If it's returning to depot then mashallah would be appropriate to say thank God for a good shift. It's like saying inshallah if they were setting off for their shift.
It's all about context.

I can’t imagine it being common practice for bus drivers to change their digital displays to give thanks to God for a good shift though, can you?

Having said that, I’ve no idea why a bus would say mashallah, other than being a private hire.

NinaBeee · 12/10/2023 15:52

nameoftheday · 12/10/2023 15:43

NinaBee “Sky news just came out and said they don't have any proof of Hamas beheading or killing anyone, it is all propaganda.”

Do you really believe this?

Do I believe that? Sky news said it themselves! Please do your research and find out things for yourself. Here is some proof www.instagram.com/p/CyRmy7Ar7WH/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA== and www.instagram.com/p/CyQgHL6Mur9/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA== please do some research.

nameoftheday · 12/10/2023 15:52

Iop · 12/10/2023 15:46

To be fair to @nameoftheday, she did clarify that she was talking about Islamists, not Muslims. Not all Muslims are Islamists, and in fact most of the Muslims I know would strongly object to being lumped in with Islamists.

Yes, thank you

therealcookiemonster · 12/10/2023 15:51

@Iop saying islamists doesn't make it clear no as a lot of islamophobic or racist individuals refer to all Muslims as islamists