Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas

632 replies

FebruaryOnMyMind · 12/10/2023 14:10

Having seen the stories of the women and girls raped at the festival (reportedly over their dead friends bodies) and the people taken off as hostage; I understand why Israel want to destroy Hamas. They have said that Hamas militants are dead men. They have said that they will go after them. The worst killing of Jewish people since the Holocaust and their 9/11 with death toll of over 1300 people.

The story of the women at the Music and Peace festival is here -

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

Yet some people celebrated when the killings of Jewish people (they were from many different countries) at the festival was announced.

I feel sadness for everything going on in the middle east and for all the people who are innocent are are dying. Terrorists need to be stopped.

Hamas 'carried out a second Holocaust' in Israel British relatives say

Two British nationals, Noam Sagi and Sharon Lifschitz (pictured), spoke of how their elderly parents were torn from their beds and forcibly deported to Gaza by Hamas along with children

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
45
Dolphin1111111111111111111111111 · 13/10/2023 09:02

Yeah, 24 hours notice to evacuate 1.1 million people isn't protecting civilians. It's giving them a time stamp on their life. Evacuation of that size just isn't possible! @Pollyputhekettleon

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas
Pollyputhekettleon · 13/10/2023 08:52

DottieMoon · 13/10/2023 08:48

Are you incapable of separating Hamas and Palestinian civilians? What Hamas did was horrendous but it just not justify Israel murdering 500 innocent children. They are just as bad a Hamas.

Murder requires intent. The Israelis are claiming, as you know, that they're doing everything they can to avoid killing civilians.

octaurpus · 13/10/2023 08:51

My comment above was for SurprisedWithAHorse

Itllbefine6 · 13/10/2023 08:50

Lastchancechica · 13/10/2023 07:35

What is obvious here is that many pp are very happy to corrupt the facts.

What did Hamas expect exactly when they ordered this massacre?

"We tried to take their land, and they took more of ours"; "We killed some of their people and they killed even more of ours"
It's like somebody saying "I borrowed some money from a Jew and they wanted to back with interest - why the interest? why are they so mean? I'm poor, I can't pay!". So be more responsible with money and stop borrowing from your neighbours!

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/10/2023 08:50

Thisisworsethananticpated · 13/10/2023 08:14

like every war ever it’s a fucking mess

What’s worse ? Gang rape versus being crushed under rubble and a hospital with no power

Anyway noones winning here

It's not really about which is a worse way to die. Although 'gang rape' is a minimization of what will be done to some of the hostages anyway. It's about the motives of those killing you.

People do win wars, all the time. I don't believe this one can be won in the long term because the Jews are completely surrounded by Islamic countries and the American empire is failing. But people can and do win wars. That's why you're not speaking German.

DottieMoon · 13/10/2023 08:48

Alexandra2001 · 13/10/2023 08:08

You ll have to show me the evidence that IDF soldiers went into Gaza, raping beheading, torturing Palestinian civilians, women, children, machine gunning babies.

The awful violence now in Gaza is as a direct response to Hamas, they choose to attack a music festival, killing over 260 young people in the most barbaric way.

Had they not attacked Israel, then all the deaths in Gaza would never have happened.

Are you incapable of separating Hamas and Palestinian civilians? What Hamas did was horrendous but it just not justify Israel murdering 500 innocent children. They are just as bad a Hamas.

octaurpus · 13/10/2023 08:47

Where did you get the impression from what I wrote that this radicalisation is 'routine'?

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/10/2023 08:45

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 08:16

So the method of killing babies is more important than the fact that they are killed on both sides?

The UN seems to believe that war crimes have been committed by Israel's soldiers - and I don't think this is the first time in recent years this has been claimed - hey they are obviously the right kind of war crime

People are saying that the motivation for it matters. You do know that. That's why in normal life, someone who accidentally hits a child with their car may not be even charged with anything. Whereas someone who intentionally kills them will hopefully be imprisoned for life. This is the same difference, applied to groups.

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/10/2023 08:43

pleasehelpwi3 · 13/10/2023 07:49

The whole conflict has been circular since the 1940s

No it didn't start in the 1940's. Long before that.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 13/10/2023 08:31

octaurpus · 13/10/2023 08:08

Lastchanceechia and SurprisedWithAHorse You may not be able to imagine this incident taking place in an Australian school, but that has no relevance as to whether the incident actually occurred. Apologies it was '33 years ago' - I can't help my age! I was very close to this friend at the time (as a law student in the 90s), and for many years after. She herself was extremely disturbed by the anecdote she recounted. I said in my previous post that she attended a 'conservative Jewish secondary school' - all students were Jewish, so I'm not sure where pp got the idea there would potentially have been Muslim students in attendance. All teachers were Jewish. My friend and I were discussing the conflict, and as she was a brilliantly intelligent young woman from a deeply conservative Jewish community, and I was not, I was very interested in her perspective.

Some of these young people go on to do military service in Israel, as permitted by the Australian government.

You are trying to convince us that Jews routinely radicalise their children to be murderous towards Arabs based on your second hand account: something that you didn't witness that supposedly happened 33 years ago in an obscure school somewhere in Australia.

Try harder.

FebruaryOnMyMind · 13/10/2023 08:24

StowOnTheWold · 12/10/2023 23:12

I have read a number of articles which are more sophisticated than your reasoning.

Egypt closed its main border crossing because - following Saturdays event you must understand - both Egypt and Israel carried out deeper due diligence on Hamas' tunnelling network close to the crossing. Tunnels spring up very frequently to smuggle weapons so it is natural gain intelligence updates. By mutual acceptance, Israel bombed the tunnels but in order to protect lives the crossing was closed.

You just need to replace 'because' with 'allowing'.

Indeed. Hamas tunnel and are able to get weapons in as required, shame they don't use the billions in aid on food, medicines and to make the lives of Palestinian people better. Just more and more weapons. The 5000 missiles launched into Israel on the night of their massive attack are expensive. Hamas don't care who dies they are evil.

OP posts:
andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 08:16

So the method of killing babies is more important than the fact that they are killed on both sides?

The UN seems to believe that war crimes have been committed by Israel's soldiers - and I don't think this is the first time in recent years this has been claimed - hey they are obviously the right kind of war crime

Thisisworsethananticpated · 13/10/2023 08:14

like every war ever it’s a fucking mess

What’s worse ? Gang rape versus being crushed under rubble and a hospital with no power

Anyway noones winning here

FebruaryOnMyMind · 13/10/2023 08:13

Lastchancechica · 13/10/2023 07:35

What is obvious here is that many pp are very happy to corrupt the facts.

What did Hamas expect exactly when they ordered this massacre?

Indeed I dont imagine Hamas thought that there were be no response.

Actions have consequences Hamas.

OP posts:
FebruaryOnMyMind · 13/10/2023 08:11

Alexandra2001 · 13/10/2023 08:08

You ll have to show me the evidence that IDF soldiers went into Gaza, raping beheading, torturing Palestinian civilians, women, children, machine gunning babies.

The awful violence now in Gaza is as a direct response to Hamas, they choose to attack a music festival, killing over 260 young people in the most barbaric way.

Had they not attacked Israel, then all the deaths in Gaza would never have happened.

Indeed the poster conviently forgets the points you make.

OP posts:
octaurpus · 13/10/2023 08:08

Lastchanceechia and SurprisedWithAHorse You may not be able to imagine this incident taking place in an Australian school, but that has no relevance as to whether the incident actually occurred. Apologies it was '33 years ago' - I can't help my age! I was very close to this friend at the time (as a law student in the 90s), and for many years after. She herself was extremely disturbed by the anecdote she recounted. I said in my previous post that she attended a 'conservative Jewish secondary school' - all students were Jewish, so I'm not sure where pp got the idea there would potentially have been Muslim students in attendance. All teachers were Jewish. My friend and I were discussing the conflict, and as she was a brilliantly intelligent young woman from a deeply conservative Jewish community, and I was not, I was very interested in her perspective.

Some of these young people go on to do military service in Israel, as permitted by the Australian government.

Alexandra2001 · 13/10/2023 08:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You ll have to show me the evidence that IDF soldiers went into Gaza, raping beheading, torturing Palestinian civilians, women, children, machine gunning babies.

The awful violence now in Gaza is as a direct response to Hamas, they choose to attack a music festival, killing over 260 young people in the most barbaric way.

Had they not attacked Israel, then all the deaths in Gaza would never have happened.

DottieMoon · 13/10/2023 08:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

pleasehelpwi3 · 13/10/2023 07:49

StowOnTheWold · 12/10/2023 21:58

That is what is going to happen though. Hamas will be destroyed. Maybe perhaps Hezbollah.

Then perhaps parties can sit down to look at a two state solution. Because it needs the radicals including the Iranian regime to be out of the equation before 'the lion and the lamb can sit together'.

Isn't your valid post entirely circular?

The whole conflict has been circular since the 1940s

Alexandra2001 · 13/10/2023 07:42

Lastchancechica · 13/10/2023 07:35

What is obvious here is that many pp are very happy to corrupt the facts.

What did Hamas expect exactly when they ordered this massacre?

What Hamas have done is beyond evil but i do suspect this is exactly what Hamas wanted.

The expulsion of 1.1m people within 24hrs from North to South Gaza will lead to a huge death toll, either through the exodus of peoples or when the IDF go into Gaza.

Seems to me that Israel want to remove the Palestinians from Gaza, pushing them back either into Egypt or as far south as possible.

Lastchancechica · 13/10/2023 07:35

What is obvious here is that many pp are very happy to corrupt the facts.

What did Hamas expect exactly when they ordered this massacre?

SurprisedWithAHorse · 13/10/2023 07:09

octaurpus · 13/10/2023 02:07

My mate at uni attended a very conservative Jewish secondary school, in Australia. The day after Bush invaded Iraq (in 1990) the entire student body were chanting 'Kill the Arabs!' The teachers did nothing.

I think there's been a pretty effective 'dehumanisation of the other' program operating for quite sometime among the children of both these populations.

Before I can accept that "both sides do this as much as the other", which is the clear implication, I'm going to need more than an account from octaurpus on Mumsnet whose friend in Australia claims to have seen kids shouting something in an obscure school 33 years ago.

Itllbefine6 · 13/10/2023 07:06

Also, for context, I was replying to a poster trying to claim "the British negotiated with PIRA so why can't the Israeli's negotiate?" Which is ridiculous. Nothing like the violence of what Hamas just did has happened in Ireland since the seventeenth century. I think we should save our condemnation of PIRA for the "PIRA bad" threads.

Itllbefine6 · 13/10/2023 06:46

DownNative · 13/10/2023 00:01

Wow. Just wow!

What a way to blatantly minimise PIRAs brutality! Yes, PIRA were not as efficient at murdering people as their friends Hamas are....but PIRA did shoot kids! Deliberately.

An awful, horrifying example of that is Nivruti Islania who was just six months old when she was shot in the head by the IRA while in her father's car in West Germany in 1989.

Other kids were murdered by PIRA, including via bombings. Again, deliberately.

A Catholic child called Bernard Teggart, 15-year-old boy said to have a mental age of an eight or nine-year-old, was abducted from St Patrick's Training School in west Belfast in 1973. He was shot in the head by PIRA. His father Danny had been shot dead by the Parachute Regiment in Ballymurphy in 1971, along with 10 others.

PIRA also forced people to become human bombs. In October 1990, Patsy Gillespie was abducted from his home by the IRA. His family were told he would be back soon, while being held at gunpoint. Patsy was then chained to the driver’s seat of a van filled with explosives and forced at gunpoint to drive that van to a nearby Army base. The IRA then remotely detonated the bomb, killing Patsy and five soldiers.

I don't know how you had the GALL to claim PIRA "had some standards" and that they "wouldn't shoot your kids"!

As for the British Government talking to PIRA, no they didn't find PIRA reasonable at all in 1972 or the rest of the 1970s!

In fact, talks only produced a political settlement when PIRA was defeated. PIRA rejected Sunningdale 1973 and Anglo-Irish Agreement 1985 yet accepted Belfast Agreement 1998 which had many of the SAME provisions as the earlier ones PIRA said no Republican or Nationalist could accept! They ended up accepting the same bloody conditions as available in 1973.

No, a terrorist group must be defeated before political settlements can be achieved.

I'm massively oversimplifying, of course. Don't get me wrong - I think PIRA are scumbag. But the people who wanted to terrorise had to keep predending to their recruitment pool that they were only after 'legitimate targets' or they wouldn't have had enough support amongst the local population. It's well know that the main reason for the peace process was that the various terrorist organisations had lost their grassroots support. Sure, It's frustrating to listen to deluded followers saying 'I'm so upset that bomb I was carrying went off early and killed those children', but people seem to really believe it.